Free speech or hate speech??

I'm the second least racist person on earth. The least racist person is Donald J. Trump.
 
Yes another slippery slope indeed. A major part of public discourse is on social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, Youtube & Google. These media platforms have been granted legal immunity from the content on their platform under the assumption that they are merely providing a public square and that those who use it should be held accountable for their own statements; which is appropriate, as long as these platforms aren't practicing any forms of censorship or political favoritism other than the obvious censoring of explicit incitement of violence which we all expect. But they are practicing in censorship and political favoritism, which as you mentioned is their right as a private corporation yes, BUT, once they begin to do this they cease to be neutral platforms and instead become publishers who are responsible for their content and subject to action of incitement or defamation.

These sites were never were created or meant to be "neutral" platforms as you put it. Further, there is no such thing as a "neutral" platform. Any article, web-sites, newspaper, etc regardless of size are biased in some way to the creator's experiences. Human beings are simply not capable of being 100% unbiased. All of these sites were started in someone's basement without any real thought of how they would monetize them. Regardless of how they started, all these sites are now businesses that are not and never will be neutral platforms no matter their popularity. They serve the needs of their shareholders and advertisers first and foremost.

If your argument is that there is too much censorship on-line, content that incites violence, child porn, animal cruelty and others should not be censored. Yet you agree that there are some limits on freedom of speech just as there are limits on all rights.
 
These sites were never were created or meant to be "neutral" platforms as you put it. Further, there is no such thing as a "neutral" platform. Any article, web-sites, newspaper, etc regardless of size are biased in some way to the creator's experiences. Human beings are simply not capable of being 100% unbiased. All of these sites were started in someone's basement without any real thought of how they would monetize them. Regardless of how they started, all these sites are now businesses that are not and never will be neutral platforms no matter their popularity. They serve the needs of their shareholders and advertisers first and foremost.

If your argument is that there is too much censorship on-line, content that incites violence, child porn, animal cruelty and others should not be censored. Yet you agree that there are some limits on freedom of speech just as there are limits on all rights.

Which is why they are being sued from many different entities as well as their own advertisers for discrimination and targeted censorship. This kind of power of Big Tech to regulate speech based on political affiliation on the worlds largest online public square can be dangerously abused (and is) and will end up being regulated if they aren't sued into oblivion by enough people before that.

As I previously stated there are exceptions such as you can't yell FIRE in a crowded theater, or publishing that you are going to be at a certain location to harass someone and recruit people to join you and then a violent crime ensues do to your statements, you have 'incited violence'. That is something we both agree on.
 
Which is why they are being sued from many different entities as well as their own advertisers for discrimination and targeted censorship. This kind of power of Big Tech to regulate speech based on political affiliation on the worlds largest online public square can be dangerously abused (and is) and will end up being regulated if they aren't sued into oblivion by enough people before that.

As I previously stated there are exceptions such as you can't yell FIRE in a crowded theater, or publishing that you are going to be at a certain location to harass someone and recruit people to join you and then a violent crime ensues do to your statements, you have 'incited violence'. That is something we both agree on.

That is certainly your personal opinion.
But majority of people believe what should not be done online also is the spread of hate, and the spread of discrimination of any person based on the colour of their skin, their race, their culture, their religion.
Again your right to be online and use social media outlets does not include you discriminating or spreading hate against others and stepping on their rights. There are many blogs, social media outlets like GAB you can use that allows your nationalist, right wing views to be spoken. Feel free to join them.
 
If people feel they have been mistreated by a parking officer, they can complain about what happened, and the interaction can be reviewed on the facts of the interaction, not based on the thoughts in the officers mind. If such "slings and arrows of outrageous fortune" are too trivial for the victim to follow up on, I'd say they're also not worth worrying about as a matter of police policy.

When a person encounters a parking officer, and has some misgivings about what happened, they don't need to start a search on the internet to find out what views may have influenced what happened. They can simply complain about what happened. If the officer chooses to tell the citizen that he's getting a ticket because he's an immigrant, black, gay, short, ugly, etc, then the officer is showing poor judgment, because those are not reasons to hand out tickets. Likewise, choosing to talk about such views in an interview about policing is demonstrating a lack of appreciation for the relevant policing principles. No one should be hired who doesn't appreciate that. However, no one should be doing the hiring who, similarly, believes that such views should be relevant to policing or choosing police officers. The interview process can achieve everything it needs to by exploring what the prospective officer would say are the correct criteria for exercising discretion.

However, social media posts are not a job interview, or actual job performance.
If "such views" have enough relevance to "policing principles" that a prudent and wise interviewee keeps them private when seeking the job, how do they become irrelevant to performing it, and acceptable to be publicized and boasted of after they get the post?
 
Actually you don't understand the law. Simply saying you don't like some group does not qualify as inciting hatred.

As distasteful as it is to appear to defend such people, you can check the wikipedia article on hate speech in Canada, which cites cases where some pretty discreditable types have been charged for communicating hateful views. The law took these to be incitement.

from the Criminal Code...
"Section 319(2): Promoting hatred
Section 319(2) makes it an offence to wilfully promote hatred against any identifiable group, by making statements (other than in private conversation). "
 
If "such views" have enough relevance to "policing principles" that a prudent and wise interviewee keeps them private when seeking the job, how do they become irrelevant to performing it, and acceptable to be publicized and boasted of after they get the post?

If I go to a job interview for a position as a chef, and start talking about the importance of the color of the cookware, I am revealing that I might not understand what cooking is all about. My prospective employer shouldn't take a chance on hiring me. If I am interviewing cooks, and asking for their views on the color of cookware, I am making the same error. However, if the best cook at my restaurant (as demonstrated by their actual cooking) writes a blog talking about how he thinks that the color of the cookware at my restaurant is an important part of his cooking, I could not care less - as long as his cooking continues to be good.
 
Last edited:
You can read what I post again if it helps. Undermining public trust in law enforcement is a fire-able offence. Malata quoted the relevant part of their duty.

I read the policy he quoted. However, the policy begs the question as to what actions undermine public trust in law enforcement. The policy refers to upholding the rights of all individuals under the Charter. I have to assume that includes the free speech rights of police officers as well. A police force has to consider the reasonable concerns of citizens that officers might misuse their authority. A claim that officers who hold unpopular political views would be likely to misuse their power is not reasonable. It is a thinly viewed attempt to squelch political discourse.

Police forces should be concerning themselves with officers that aren't doing their job properly, or who are breaking the law themselves (thereby undermining public confidence in law enforcement). On what has been reported, it would appear that this officer hasn't failed in either respect.
 
If I go to a job interview for a position as a chef, and start talking about the importance of the color of the cookware, I am revealing that I might not understand what cooking is all about. My prospective employer shouldn't take a chance on hiring me. If I am interviewing cooks, and asking for their views on the color of cookware, I am making the same error. However, if the best cook at my restaurant (as demonstrated by their actual cooking) writes a blog talking about how he thinks that the color of the cookware at my restaurant is an important parting of his cooking, I could not care less - as long as his cooking continues to be good.
And if you are indeed so lacking in understanding of what real cooking is about as you describe, then for your employer to find out later later (and protect the customers and public when you do reveal your mistaken thinking) is better than leaving you in place. Particularly relevant to terminating you, would be your devious and misguided effort to conceal your ideas about what really matters when making food for people, at the very time when such things are properly assessed. It certainly wouldn't help your case for continued employment, if you blogged to the world that the restaurant's cooking problems are due to it's nastily coloured pots.

However, your analogy is not appropriate to the matter at hand; it would be only if we were discussing the PKO's views on the virtuous and evil colours of Parking tags. In your fable, if you had eventually revealed you despise customers of other races than your own, and think they have no rightful place in your country, or in the restaurants where you cook, then you'd have a similar situation. And as the owner I'd be rightfully worried about the likelihood of you spitting in the entrees for certain customers.

BTW: We have gotten well into fantasy-land here; the matter of the PKO and his bigoted tweets is only being "looked into" by TPS, because of just the sort of complaints from the public as you mentioned. He hasn't, to my knowledge, been disciplined in any way other than by that self-invited attention.
 
And if you are indeed so lacking in understanding of what cooking is about as you describe, for your employer to find out later later — and protect the customers and public — when you reveal your mistaken thinking is better than leaving you in place. Particularly relevant to terminating you, would be your devious and misguided effort to conceal your ideas about what matters in making food for people, at the very time when such things are assessed.

I think a more reasoned approach would be to actually review the cook's work. If he is truly relying upon the color of the cookware alone, and his fabulous cooking is just pure luck on a miraculous scale, I think even a cursory review would reveal that. If it's just luck that he hasn't made a bad meal yet, then yes, he should be let go. I don't see that on the facts of this case. No complaints concerning his work as an officer have been reported.

However, your analogy is not appropriate to the matter at hand; it would be only if we were discussing the PKO's views on the virtuous and evil colours of Parking tags. If in your fable, you had revealed you despise customers of other races than your own, and think they have no rightful place in your country, or the restaurants you cook in, then you'd have a similar situation. And as the owner I'd be seriously worried about the possibility of you spitting in the entrees for certain customers.

Your criticism only begs the question of what is relevant. I say his views on immigration and cultural integration have not much bearing on deciding whether a car is parked in the wrong spot at the wrong time. Could you explain why you think he's more likely to ticket a car that he suspects is being driven by a person who was born outside Canada (as suspicion it will have to be, given the circumstance under which most parking tickets are given (the driver is not with the vehicle))?

Your example, set in the world of cooking and then applied to world of policing, seems less apt. A restaurant (presumably) is trying to attract as many customers as possible. Any public statements associated with the business that would discourage clientele from patronizing the business would be at direct odds with the legitimate interests of his employer. Harder to apply that principle to the world of policing. The police aren't looking for customers. They would, however, have a legitimate interest in reducing any reasonable suspicions that citizens might be ticketed for reasons other than violation of the law. I just can't draw a reasonable connection between this guy's views on immigration and how he hands out tickets, particularly since he has a track record of handing out tickets with no history of complaints that he's misusing that power.

The most interesting aspect of this discussion is that what has to be focused on are the consequences of his communication of his views, because, as of yet, no government has risked the political consequences of trying to enact and enforce thought crimes. If he agreed to take down his social media posts, but held the same views privately, would you still be calling for his dismissal, even in the absence of any evidence that he has abused his authority?
 
I had commented on this post and I’m sure my opinions are not popular which is fine .,
Also I have received some pretty hateful PM’s which is also fine my skin is thick lol
But , why is this kind of post even on here ? This is a website to talk about escorts and MPA’s
Don’t we get enough politics shoved down our throats ? I use these services to escape the real world
For a short time lol
 
...We see examples of this today in legitimate speech being suppressed on college campuses, ...

What we see is people using their right of free speech to counter others right of free speech. I don't support disrupting events but a crowd protesting outside a speech is exactly the kind of free speech you claim to be defending.

Again, you (and the parking cop) have a right to free speech but you don't have a right protecting you from accountability.
 
Yes another slippery slope indeed. A major part of public discourse is on social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, Youtube & Google. ....

What you miss is under US law, corporations have the same legal status as individuals so they have the complete right to decide what can or can not appear on their platforms. It is also worth noting that their decision is not based on any leftist agenda but rather pure capitalism and deciding that banning hateful trolls is good for business.
 
As distasteful as it is to appear to defend such people, you can check the wikipedia article on hate speech in Canada, which cites cases where some pretty discreditable types have been charged for communicating hateful views. The law took these to be incitement.

from the Criminal Code...
"Section 319(2): Promoting hatred
Section 319(2) makes it an offence to wilfully promote hatred against any identifiable group, by making statements (other than in private conversation). "

Perhaps you should actually read the legal statements included in the wiki you linked. Saying you don't like a group in a private conversation spreading is not considered incitement.

Hatred is predicated on destruction, and hatred against identifiable groups therefore thrives on insensitivity, bigotry and destruction of both the target group and of the values of our society. Hatred in this sense is a most extreme emotion that belies reason; an emotion that, if exercised against members of an identifiable group, implies that those individuals are to be despised, scorned, denied respect and made subject to ill-treatment on the basis of group affiliation.[2]

In my view, "detestation" and "vilification" aptly describe the harmful effect that the Code seeks to eliminate. Representations that expose a target group to detestation tend to inspire enmity and extreme ill-will against them, which goes beyond mere disdain or dislike. Representations vilifying a person or group will seek to abuse, denigrate or delegitimize them, to render them lawless, dangerous, unworthy or unacceptable in the eyes of the audience. Expression exposing vulnerable groups to detestation and vilification goes far beyond merely discrediting, humiliating or offending the victims.[3]
 
I read the policy he quoted. However, the policy begs the question as to what actions undermine public trust in law enforcement. ....

And the TPS decided it did. Considering how strong the police union is, I'm pretty sure they have completely covered their bases.


BTW. It is reasonable to be concerned that a person in an authority position who publicly expressed xenophobic views might be influenced by those views while enforcing laws.
 
If I go to a job interview for a position as a chef, and start talking about the importance of the color of the cookware, I am revealing that I might not understand what cooking is all about. My prospective employer shouldn't take a chance on hiring me. If I am interviewing cooks, and asking for their views on the color of cookware, I am making the same error. However, if the best cook at my restaurant (as demonstrated by their actual cooking) writes a blog talking about how he thinks that the color of the cookware at my restaurant is an important parting of his cooking, I could not care less - as long as his cooking continues to be good.

A chef stating that cooking with copper, cast iron, or coated cookware is different has their opinions based in scientific fact about how the heat is transferred and how much food sticks. Someone who thinks that different colour people have different abilities is just a racist.


What a stupid analogy.
 
What we see is people using their right of free speech to counter others right of free speech. I don't support disrupting events but a crowd protesting outside a speech is exactly the kind of free speech you claim to be defending.

I don't think you understand. I'm not talking about people's right to oppose other's free speech or their right to peaceful assembly, we're talking about suppression of free speech on college campuses to which there are ample examples of and a litany of cases that are being settled as we speak ie: Berkeley.

What you miss is under US law, corporations have the same legal status as individuals so they have the complete right to decide what can or can not appear on their platforms. It is also worth noting that their decision is not based on any leftist agenda but rather pure capitalism and deciding that banning hateful trolls is good for business.

Again, you're not comprehending and missing the point
These media platforms have been granted legal immunity from the content on their platform under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act under the assumption that they are merely providing a public square & that those who use it should be held accountable for their own statements; which is appropriate, as long as these platforms aren't practicing any forms of censorship or political favoritism besides the obvious censoring of explicit incitement of violence which we all expect. But they are practicing in censorship and political favoritism, which as you mentioned is their right as a private corporation yes, BUT, once they begin to do this they cease to be neutral platforms and instead become publishers and AS PUBLISHERS are responsible for their content and subject to legal action for incitement or defamation.

They can't have it both ways. Either they are a platform which they purport to be or they're publishers; but they cannot be both
 
A chef stating that cooking with copper, cast iron, or coated cookware is different has their opinions based in scientific fact

I don't think there are any scientific facts about whether a society is better off receiving immigrants from particular groups, or not. There is just opinion. Political opinion.
 
I think a more reasoned approach would be to actually review the cook's work. If he is truly relying upon the color of the cookware alone, and his fabulous cooking is just pure luck on a miraculous scale, I think even a cursory review would reveal that. If it's just luck that he hasn't made a bad meal yet, then yes, he should be let go. I don't see that on the facts of this case. No complaints concerning his work as an officer have been reported.



Your criticism only begs the question of what is relevant. I say his views on immigration and cultural integration have not much bearing on deciding whether a car is parked in the wrong spot at the wrong time. Could you explain why you think he's more likely to ticket a car that he suspects is being driven by a person who was born outside Canada (as suspicion it will have to be, given the circumstance under which most parking tickets are given (the driver is not with the vehicle))?

Your example, set in the world of cooking and then applied to world of policing, seems less apt. A restaurant (presumably) is trying to attract as many customers as possible. Any public statements associated with the business that would discourage clientele from patronizing the business would be at direct odds with the legitimate interests of his employer. Harder to apply that principle to the world of policing. The police aren't looking for customers. They would, however, have a legitimate interest in reducing any reasonable suspicions that citizens might be ticketed for reasons other than violation of the law. I just can't draw a reasonable connection between this guy's views on immigration and how he hands out tickets, particularly since he has a track record of handing out tickets with no history of complaints that he's misusing that power.

The most interesting aspect of this discussion is that what has to be focused on are the consequences of his communication of his views, because, as of yet, no government has risked the political consequences of trying to enact and enforce thought crimes. If he agreed to take down his social media posts, but held the same views privately, would you still be calling for his dismissal, even in the absence of any evidence that he has abused his authority?
Your faulty cooking analogy was already sent back to the kitchen, before you changed the chef from yourself to some new and fabulous cook. Whatever his results, concealing when he was hired that he relies on cookware-color alone is misrepresentation of his knowledge and skills, and would endanger the restaurant's license, not to mention the health of its patrons. It's a matter of whether a chef — you or François le fabuleux — can be trusted to do on the job.

I'm glad you seem to see a reasonable connection might indeed be made between an officer's public statements on 'political' matters and the possibility that he might apply the same warped thinking to his work, and so enforce the laws less than fairly. I certainly have not called for his dismissal, and in fact made the point above, that he and his postings are only being looked at (the sort of thing you might call "a cursory review"). In fact, according to the OP, the PKO closed the Twitter account in question as soon as it attracted attention. We can debate a hypothetical whether someone that ashamed/embarrassed/regretful/scared about what they once saw fit to broadcast to the Universe, however hurtful or dangerous to those their words attacked, could ever be a worthy hire for a position of public trust and power any time you wish.

But no more cooks please, even if you have a handle on the cookware thing.
--------
PS: Your debating style reminds me of another TERBian, sadly departed. He too would shift his argument to a new position as if he'd always been there, and represent his personal inferences to others as their stated positions. All fun 'til someone gets poked in the eye.
 
Frankly, I am getting sick and tired of hearing "Alt Right"-type fuckwads complaining that their "free speech" is infringed upon because they're not allowed to make public comments that are basically aimed at making certain people feel unwelcome in this country.

Fuck those people.

I say this is a 40-something WASPish male, born and bred in Canada. Civilized countries put limits on how "freely" you can speak. Canada's "free speech" laws are no different from those of other socially-like-minded countries like the UK, France, Germany, Sweden, the Netherlands, etc.

All you need to do is look south the Republic of Yankland to see the racial tension and constant polarization they have in that country because of their rather soft stance on hate speech. Allowing "Nazis" to march around brandishing the swastika -- the symbol of a vanquished enemy, no less -- is repulsive.

As I said, fuck those people and fuck their free speech.