Fraudulent Conservative Election!

As I already explained to you, the site directs you to the "sales" offices where you license content for reuse, including for broadcast.

In other words, if you're at that page looking for licensing for broadcast, please go elsewhere.
As in, there is no licensing or licensing information here at this page!




Now, just because I can see where this is headed, I will take the time to head off what is a very stupid and literary argument.
First off, when you use baby oil do you feel guilty about all the dead babies killed for that oil?
Do you feel disgusted when you use a toothbrush, since its made from teeth?
Do you take your hands off the steeringwheel when you drive since its an 'automobile'?
And finally, because the word sales is in the name of the office do you assume that every licensing use must be paid?

Is your entire argument now down to assuming that since you have now found the word 'sales' in the office that deals with licensing that you must pay for every use in all situations?
Is that your entire argument?
 
Is your entire argument now down to assuming that since you have now found the word 'sales' in the office that deals with licensing that you must pay for every use in all situations?

If you're looking to broadcast the content -- yes, that's exactly what I'm saying.
 
If you're looking to broadcast the content -- yes, that's exactly what I'm saying.

Ok, so you talk to program sales for licensing.
Great.

Now, can you prove that they charge for use for political ads?
Is your entire argument based on their use of the word 'sales'?


(and yes, it should have been 'literal', one glass wine more then I should have had today....)
 
Now, can you prove that they charge for use for political ads?
Is your entire argument based on their use of the word 'sales'?

I have proven that they charge for all situations where the parties acquiring the content intend to broadcast the content.
 
I have proven that they charge for all situations where the parties acquiring the content intend to broadcast the content.

When did you do that?
Is it when you saw the word 'sales'?

Or is it when you fully researched the subject by finding the page where they sell videos to consumers?

That is the sum total of your 'research' isn't it?
 
Yup. The fact that they sell the content means the people acquiring the content have to pay for it.

Ok, we're back to the earlier statement, as in:

Wow, are you really that stupid?


You didn't look into the issue other then a five second google search. You don't understand copyright law and you don't understand the reality or the issues.
But you did find the word 'sales' in the title of the office that licenses work for rebroadcast.

In other words you've failed totally in proving your point.
You haven't found any evidence that any political party has ever paid for licensing of use for political ads or any evidence they might start doing so.

You lose.
 
Ok, we're back to the earlier statement, as in:

Wow, are you really that stupid?


You didn't look into the issue other then a five second google search. You don't understand copyright law and you don't understand the reality or the issues.
But you did find the word 'sales' in the title of the office that licenses work for rebroadcast.

In other words you've failed totally in proving your point.
You haven't found any evidence that any political party has ever paid for licensing of use for political ads or any evidence they might start doing so.

You lose.

I didn't need to spend a lot of time looking for the evidence because I knew what I was looking for.

The evidence is quite clear: The networks expect any person or party looking to broadcast their content to pay for it. There is nothing indicating that they make any exceptions.

You seem to think they make exceptions for political parties. Perhaps you could direct us to the exhaustive research you have done to support that point.

I produced the evidence. Now, it's your turn. Show us what evidence you have that the networks would make an exception for the political parties.
 
I didn't need to spend a lot of time looking for the evidence because I knew what I was looking for.

The evidence is quite clear: The networks expect any person or party looking to broadcast their content to pay for it. There is nothing indicating that they make any exceptions.

You seem to think they make exceptions for political parties. Perhaps you could direct us to the exhaustive research you have done to support that point.

I produced the evidence. Now, it's your turn. Show us what evidence you have that the networks would make an exception for the political parties.

Easy.
No political party has paid for use of clips in political ads in the past.

Harper has been in trouble in the past for using clips unauthorized in fact.
That is the issue.

Up until now political ads have used media under 'fair use' provisions and never paid for them, even after this bill they will not pay for them.
What they want with this bill is the chance to use whatever clip in whatever context and force networks to broadcast them.
 
No political party has paid for use of clips in political ads in the past.

Harper has been in trouble in the past for using clips unauthorized in fact.

The sentences above are a total evasion. According to Groggy, no political party has ever paid for authorization to use media content because no political party has ever sought authorization to use media content.

Fine.

But the issue in question is the letter sent by five of the broadcast media organizations telling the parties they will now have to seek authorization. My question was straight-forward: Is there any evidence that the media will make an exception for the political parties and waive their standard requirement for payment.

Given Groggy's total evasion, I will assume the answer is no, he doesn't have any evidence to support that belief.

The evidence clearly shows the media expect to be paid. This issue is all about money, which is what I have said all along.
 
The sentences above are a total evasion. According to Groggy, no political party has ever paid for authorization to use media content because no political party has ever sought authorization to use media content.

Fine.

And what the broadcasters said:
Last May, representatives from Canada's major broadcasters, including CBC, Radio-Canada, CTV, Rogers and Shaw, served notice that they would no longer air political advertisements that include material taken from their airwaves without their express authorization.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/cop...litical-ads-mulled-by-conservatives-1.2793758
They didn't say they wouldn't air those ads unless the parties paid for fair use, only that they wouldn't air them without authorization, to check that the use is fair and accurate representation.

There is no mention of money in any of the demands.
You lose.
 
They didn't say they wouldn't air those ads unless the parties paid for fair use, only that they wouldn't air them without authorization, to check that the use is fair and accurate representation.

You don't know what you're talking about. You don't have to pay for "fair use." In fact, you don't need authorization for fair use.

The media said they wouldn't air the ads unless the parties had attained authorization, which always has to be purchased. There is no evidence the media are prepared to waive the required payments for authorization if the political parties agree to seek authorization. This is about money.

Meanwhile, if Trudeau wants to prove he isn't soft on terrorism, it looks like he'll get his chance in the coming days.
 
You don't know what you're talking about. You don't have to pay for "fair use." In fact, you don't need authorization for fair use.

The media said they wouldn't air the ads unless the parties had attained authorization, which always has to be purchased. There is no evidence the media are prepared to waive the required payments for the political parties. This is about money.

Authorization doesn't mean payment.
You have no idea what you are talking about.

Authorization is just legal permission. You can sell it or give it away, your choice.
You've never dealt with copyright before, have you?

Are you still going to make this really, really stupid and really, really uninformed claim?

And here's a hint.
http://www.cbc.ca/aboutcbc/discover/termsofuse.html
(this is just the page on digital rights issues)

Note that the terms are all to make sure that people don't:
try to make profit off of CBC's work
try to claim CBC's work as their own
try to misrepresent CBC's work

There is no mention of fees or rates for licenses.

As for 'fair use', that's exactly the point. Ads have previously used clips under a 'fair use' provision (though its not specifically part of our copyright law). They didn't pay for use before and won't in the future with or without this change to the copyright law. The 'fair' part of the 'fair use' allows for copyright holders to say 'that's not fair use, its a quote out of context' and request the usage stop.
What the con's are demanding is that they take that right away from the networks, so they can use whatever they want in any form and the networks will be denied to right to even say 'that's not what we said' and refuse to show it. That is what this is about.
 
Authorization is just legal permission. You can sell it or give it away, your choice.

To get authorization from the CBC for content you wish to broadcast, you have to go to the sales offices. That means the CBC has chosen to sell it.

There is no evidence that the CBC or any other media outlet has agreed to waive the charges for the political parties.
 
To get authorization from the CBC for content you wish to broadcast, you have to go to the sales offices. That means the CBC has chosen to sell it.

There is no evidence that the CBC or any other media outlet has agreed to waive the charges for the political parties.

That's the same office the con's should have gone through for every other use up to now.
Same with the liberals and the NDP.
Have they paid for those clips?
Nope.

Its just the name of the office that deals with copyright use and licensing.
Do you really think that the CBC wanted to charge politicians to use clips broadcast from the publicly funded network?
Do you really think that the CBC was after more money from political parties for licensing?

I have to keep asking, are you really that stupid?
 
So, it's your contention that the CBC's sales offices aren't actually involved in any sales.

Wow.

CBC's licensing department will sell rights to Canadian shows and products internationally, license clips for use in other media for fees and grant permission for use in schools, political ads and other fair use type situations where fees aren't necessary.

I know you are really stupid and live in a black and white world, but try to imagine that there are a range of possibilities, not just everything must be paid because the word 'sales' is on the door to the office.

Think of it this way.
When you sit in a restaurant (ok, lets make this realistic - when you sit down at McDonald's) you buy a meal. Do you also buy a glass of water or is it offered free?
Why don't they charge you for that glass of water, its a restaurant after all, where you pay for food?

If you can answer that question, you might start understanding.

Take your time, it may be very hard for you....
 
CBC's licensing department will sell rights to Canadian shows and products internationally, license clips for use in other media for fees and grant permission for use in schools, political ads and other fair use type situations where fees aren't necessary.

Once again, you've tried to sound clever by using language and concepts that you actually don't understand.

The media will "grant permission" for "fair-use type situations"? I don't think so.

If it's a "fair-use type situation," the person using the content doesn't need permission.

Furthermore, the CBC has a different office (not the "sales" offices) to handle requests for the use of content for educational purposes. Those requests do not involve the rebroadcast of content.

The evidence is irrefutable: You don't know what you're talking about.

I know this is a waste of time, but I'll repeat my challenge again (and watch you avert it): Produce the evidence that the media are prepared to "grant permission" to the political parties to use their content for free.