Fraudulent Conservative Election!

Some groups do have privilege, putting up signs during a campaign does not require consent from the city, the only other group allowed to do this is Realtors. So allowing any political party to use any available material and be permitted to air such ensures that media outlets do not control politics.
The courts can still protect the persons from slander.
 
What happens if media outlets refuse certain parties clips but happily supply to others? Do we want a media(other than in its editorial pages etc) doing that. If a media outlet did do that it would be fair for politicians to start denying access to certain media as clearly biased?

At what point does the media lose its "objectivity" standing? We all accuse certain outlets of a slant but this is a very real possibility. And as we've seen from JT and Quebecor recently no party/politician is immune from denying access. Same with the Fords on the other end.

I personally don't see the media being able to maintain the fairness.
 
I can see your point , we just have to look to Sun Media!

A better example would be to look at the networks that ran stories about this issue.

In a column today, Ezra Levant makes the same point I made yesterday -- why was there no mention of the broadcast "consortium" and the April letter in the networks' coverage of this issue?

It's possible, I suppose, that the reporters didn't know about the letter. But the bigwigs who oversee the coverage knew about it. Yet nothing was reported. As Levant said, "That's the first rule of the Consortium: You don't talk about the Consortium."

http://www.torontosun.com/2014/10/19/media-consortium-takes-on-tories

As a result, the stories were completely misleading. So much for "journalistic integrity."

Clarifying the rules around fair dealing could help promote "journalistic integrity."

It would confirm what the CBC already knows from its lawyers -- that journalists do not have the authority to decide what goes into political parties' ads. Nor should they.
 
I can see your point , we just have to look to Sun Media!

The Star is also well known as a regular and staunch supporter of the Liberal Party of Canada. For Decades.

It doesn't mean I don't read them. But I take certain things written with a grain of salt. The Sun, National post and G+M as well.

By the same token I don't think you can say the CBC is unbiased in its political leanings with a straight face.

But untimately its about what is legal. Looks like it is. If the media wants to be considered "free" then that also includes its disemination after the fact within limits. Many on this site will use partial quotes in arguments. I'm intelligent enough to parse them. I expect the same of the populace.
 
But untimately its about what is legal. Looks like it is.

It's also quite ethical.

An informed citizenry is a good thing, as the courts have recognized. As you say, all sources must be taken with a grain of salt (including the news media). That is why more information is better.
 
No, because up until now, the parties have not sought such permission. Since they weren't seeking permission, there was no need to pay anything.

Permission and copyright was always required, they just didn't do it and the media didn't call them on it until they started using it unfairly.

By the way, I don't disagree with the quote you cited from Chris Selley's column. If the rules around fair dealing need to be clarified, they should be clarified for all players, not just politicians. I'm actually sympathetic to Michael Geist's point that the rules should more closely resemble the fair use provisions in the U.S.

The CBC might have some issues with clips being used in ads by political parties that don't share the CBC's political biases. But there are five big media players that signed the letter.

For the other four, the issue is really about money. Actually, for the CBC -- which has had its budget cut under the Conservatives -- the issue is really about money, too.

It should be the same rules for everyone, no exclusions for political uses.
But again, as you admit, no money has ever changed hands and none has yet to be requested.
Its only been really about unfair use and journalistic integrity.

The con's want to frame it around money, to sell to the sheople, but its not the issue.
 
Permission and copyright was always required, they just didn't do it and the media didn't call them on it until they started using it unfairly.

According to the CBC's lawyers, it is unlikely the media companies will be able to establish that permission is required.

As for money being requested, the media organizations sent a letter saying they wanted the political parties to seek permission to use the clips. As in all things involving copyright, you can safely conclude that involves money. It always does.
 
According to the CBC's lawyers, it is unlikely the media companies will be able to establish that permission is required.

As for money being requested, the media organizations sent a letter saying they wanted the political parties to seek permission to use the clips. As in all things involving copyright, you can safely conclude that involves money. It always does.

No you can't, unless you can prove they want money, then you are just making things up.
They just want fair representation of their work and the right to approve where and when its re-used.
 
No you can't, unless you can prove they want money, then you are just making things up.
They just want fair representation of their work and the right to approve where and when its re-used.

So in other words the media will be able to deny a party access to a news item if they disagree with the policies of the party? I prefer open information thanks. If a public figure makes a public statement over the airwaves and its broadcast it should be fair game. Period.

Anything else is in effect censorship.
 
So in other words the media will be able to deny a party access to a news item if they disagree with the policies of the party? I prefer open information thanks. If a public figure makes a public statement over the airwaves and its broadcast it should be fair game. Period.

Anything else is in effect censorship.

That would be major news were that to happen.
No, what they say is that the networks will have the right to say how their products are used for political means.
That means they can stop dishonest use of clips by political parties.

Do you support the dishonest use of media by political parties?
 
That would be major news were that to happen.
No, what they say is that the networks will have the right to say how their products are used for political means.
That means they can stop dishonest use of clips by political parties.

Do you support the dishonest use of media by political parties?

Nope. Just as don't "support" columnists and talking heads spouting half-truths and slanted opinion on what passes for 24 news stations of all types. But support isn't the issue. Its one, if its legal under our laws and two, considering how it could prevent information publicly broadcast from being re-diseminated.

If the law states its ok, then the only thing left is the "morality". I prefer its used and let the courts decide what's false and libelous, not the media.
 
I'm still waiting for grog to explain how the rules are undemocratic. I get the argument about slimy but they seem to apply to all and still allow voters to make their choices.
 
I'm still waiting for grog to explain how the rules are undemocratic. I get the argument about slimy but they seem to apply to all and still allow voters to make their choices.

Can't you hear the pin drop?

Alls I want is for him to persuade jt to publically state his intention to repeal c36, then all you have to do is hope the liberals actually keep an election promise.
 
Here is Cision's page for CBC content. If you want authorization to broadcast something, you are directed to CBC sales departments.

http://www.cision.com/ca-en/resources/consumer-recordings/

Sales departments want money.

You aren't very smart, are you moviefan?
That's the consumer page, as in, if you want to buy a copy of a show you go there.
So yeah, you are supposed to buy a copy of the show if you want to fap to it at home, not just download it.

Do you want to just give up now and admit you don't know what you're talking about?
Or do we need to get back into establishing your total lack of intelligence with a refresher on your climate change stance?

As for the free speech argument, this in no way imposes on free speech.
Harper is free to say what he wants in any ad now, as he was before.
 
Nice try. The web page says "content", not "shows".

http://www.cision.com/ca-en/resources/consumer-recordings/

You have received the evidence you wanted.


Wow.
I mean I know you're stupid, but are you really that stupid?

Do you know the difference between a site that sells copies of shows to 'consumers' versus an office that licenses shows and clips for rebroadcast?

Are you so very stupid that you still think that site is where you go to license content for reuse?
 
Are you so very stupid that you still think that site is where you go to license content for reuse?

As I already explained to you, the site directs you to the "sales" offices where you license content for reuse, including for broadcast.

To license CBC content for broadcast please contact:

CBC Program Sales at 416.205.3506

To license CBC content for inclusion in other productions please contact:

CBC Archive Sales at 416.205.6361 or 416.205.3696

Since you apparently don't know what the word "sales" means, let me help you out:

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sale