You are both correct.
Biden gave a very good speech. However, it was a campaign speech and not a State of the Union address. I also suspect they juice him up with something for an event like this. It would be crazy to think he could do this several nights a week for several months during a campaign.
As far as a campaign speech, a Democratic President's SOTU has become a progressive wish list. It is a litany of government proposals. A Politician declaring a war on cancer? I'm sure a lot of folks at home including independents were like me. Yeah Joe. You're going to end cancer! And, and............don't forget world peace!
On the flip side, I thought Katie Britt was nice to look at. I think I can still say MILF on this site. Southern MILF I might add. Leave the Cross on around your neck Katie. For some impulse I can't explain, that's a hot look in porn.
However as KD noted, she was overscripted and overprepared. I blame the handlers. Let her have some immediate and natural reactions to Biden's speech to get started. I don't necessarily agree with throwing relative newcomers on to the national stage. I would say she was a lot better than Bobby Jindal delivering the Republican response years ago.
Anyway, what the Republicans wanted to do was present a young woman and mother as spokesperson. So they accomplished that aspect.