F-35 II Lightning

F-35 purchase

  • YES, I support the deal

    Votes: 53 64.6%
  • NO, the deal must be cancelled

    Votes: 29 35.4%

  • Total voters
    82

dj1470

Banned
Apr 7, 2005
7,701
0
0
Lots of prattling right now in Ottawa about the purchase of these planes to replace the aging CF-18 Hornets for the Canadian military. I really don't care about how the contract was awarded - our pilots need the new plane and this seems to fit the bill since some of it was designed in Canada and many parts are manufactured in Canada. I don't think Canada is purchasing the standing takeoff or carrier variants but just the regular long take off variant.

Canada can't be anything but better off with these planes guarding us, our security, and our soverignty.

 
This looks like the Raptor stealth aircraft. Does it have stealth technology and does it have the same aerodynamic manoeuverability?
 
Shouldn't this be in the Politics and International Affairs section ?
 
Capabilities and tech for the F35
http://www.lockheedmartin.com/products/f35/
I just found out Canada is purchasing the F35A version
F35B is the vertical takeoff version
F35C is the carrier/naval version

Shouldn't this be in the Politics and International Affairs section ?

Possibly but I thought polls were supposed to be in the Lounge, but thanks for coming out from under your rock Mr. Troll
 
This would be a good ADDITION to the RCAF, but alas it is replacing the RCAF. While the F-18E/F Super Hornet is not a perfect aircraft, it is a much better pick for the role that Canada wants the multi-role aircraft to play. The Lightning II is really a vehicle to deliver a ground attack. It simply cannot dogfight. It has only one engine. It would suck at showing our sovereignty over the Arctic.

And in a shooting war, how can 35 aircraft replace 183? Can't.

Sorry, but in my view the Harper government is shitting us again and is kissing ass to the US.

If he had said we could afford only 30 of these aircraft, and would be able to buy only 80 Super Hornets, I would have been happier.

But the F-35 on its own is a terrible mistake.

And while we are on the subject, I understand that the last of the destroyers are going to be scrapped soon. When that happens, Canada will no longer have a blue water navy. The City class ships simply do not have enough air cover.
 
the navy has its own ship building program in the works somewhere near 100 ships over the next 23 odd years.
The F35 is a usable aircraft for air to air service and it is usable for ground support. It does not have the avionics package that the F22 does but it has the same radar stealth package, actually it is a genration ahead of the F22 in that regard. The super hornet is a stopgap until the F35 comes into naval service it will be retired over time
 
For the cost of these planes, Canada could give 1 million students a university education.
 
Last edited:
To my mind a mix of the F-35 and the Eurofighter Typhoon would be better. Then again probably the F-22 Raptor would be even better than the Typhoon but the U.S. is not selling it.

However, no one elected me to Parliament nor as Secretary of State for Defence!
 
This would be a good ADDITION to the RCAF, but alas it is replacing the RCAF. While the F-18E/F Super Hornet is not a perfect aircraft, it is a much better pick for the role that Canada wants the multi-role aircraft to play. The Lightning II is really a vehicle to deliver a ground attack. It simply cannot dogfight. It has only one engine. It would suck at showing our sovereignty over the Arctic.

And in a shooting war, how can 35 aircraft replace 183? Can't.

Sorry, but in my view the Harper government is shitting us again and is kissing ass to the US.

If he had said we could afford only 30 of these aircraft, and would be able to buy only 80 Super Hornets, I would have been happier.

But the F-35 on its own is a terrible mistake.

And while we are on the subject, I understand that the last of the destroyers are going to be scrapped soon. When that happens, Canada will no longer have a blue water navy. The City class ships simply do not have enough air cover.

Actually, they are buying 65, not 30.

Though I believe the original F18 order under Trudeau was about 130 planes, so they have halved the number of F18's that we originally bought (though I seem to remeber that the number flying was reduced to 70 or so in later years with the others being caniblized for parts, crashes, etc.)

The existing F18's were also overhauled along the way a couple of times, adding new weaponry and avionics and most of all computers since the original computers were so outdated that our F18's could communicate with other NATO country's F18's. I believe the comparison was "it was like the Vic20 of computers"

Too bad they scrapped the ARROW. We could have been making our own fighter air craft.

BTW, apparently the Americans are ordering 2,500 to 3,400 F35s (depending on who you listen to). Now that's an insane number of aircraft, but the Americans definitely love things that go boom.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ered-deal-to-buy-fighter-jets/article1684112/
 
We need these planes defending our skies so that we don't wind up with American planes defending our skies. Canada is a country, like it or not, and we have to act like one. Countries maintain their own abilities to defend themselves, like it or not. By contributing to a continental defense structure (NORAD, in this case), we ensure that we as Canadians have a say over what happens over our skies.
 
Countries maintain their own abilities to defend themselves, like it or not.

Absolutely, the Ruskies and a few silly Danes are already laying claims to the CANADIAN ARCTIC. Tough words are only good to a point and then you must be able to back it up with a "big stick". The riches of the Canadian Arctic are our children's inheritance.
 
Possibly but I thought polls were supposed to be in the Lounge, but thanks for coming out from under your rock Mr. Troll



Any time, Mr. Asshat.
 
The Lightning II is really a vehicle to deliver a ground attack. It simply cannot dogfight. It has only one engine. It would suck at showing our sovereignty over the Arctic.

What good is dog-fight-ability? There hasn't been a dog fight between fighter aircraft, anywhere, since the fifties. It's all done with missiles these days. We use fighter aircraft to support ground and sea operations, not to participate in dogfights.

How can any fighter aircraft establish sovereignty? You need vehicles on the ground, and ships on (the surface of) the sea, to establish sovereignty. Fighters are about as much use as submarines, for establishing sovereignty.

To show the flag in the Arctic, we should be developing amphibious go-anywhere long-range vehicles for prowling round the Arctic. Nobody makes anything like that, at present. They could be a Canadian speciality.