F-35 II Lightning

F-35 purchase

  • YES, I support the deal

    Votes: 53 64.6%
  • NO, the deal must be cancelled

    Votes: 29 35.4%

  • Total voters
    82
I haven't seen one knowledgable arguement in here that made a real case for not buying the F-35. Frankly we cannot simply stick our heads in the sand and relinquish our sovereignty to the US every time we need to upgrade our military hardware. The Super Hornet is a great aircraft BUT it is an upgrade of a 1970's design, it is not a next-generation aircraft. Canada has made the mistake time and again of trying to make our military hardware last beyond its service life. Sooner or later you have to buy new, that's just the way it works.

The F-18E/F Super Hornet is still in production, and the US Navy is getting a new EA-18G variant. It is not the same plane as our current F-18's. The US Navy is planning on standardizing almost all of its capabilities on the F-18 E/F/G variants, such that parts and platforms are common for many different roles.

In any case, for interception roles in the arctic, the F-35 is the wrong plane. An F-18 can beat it. You need range, dual engines, cheap to operate, and capable of catching a Soviet Bomber. It doesn't need surprise, or the ability to dogfight. In fact, just scrambling the jets is often sufficient to show your sovereignty and readiness to act.

Stealth aircraft doesn't work well in the "let them know you are there and are ready" role. Stealth aircraft are for attacking the enemy and not letting them know you are coming. The opposite of creating a visible presence. Also, the F-35 is a really unlikely aircraft for Arctic operations. It really wasn't designed for it. Sometimes the older technology is better.

Australia had some of these same issues. Eventually, they bought the F-18 Super Hornets. The may purchase F-35's later, but they are unlikely to completely replace the F-18 Super Hornets.
 
Can someone say "AVRO Arrow".
Indeed I can. However, as unpopular as it may be. One also needs to remember the limitations of the Arrow and that both the USAF and the RAF cancelled similar projects at roughly the same time.

There is national myth and there is history.
 
Indeed I can. However, as unpopular as it may be. One also needs to remember the limitations of the Arrow and that both the USAF and the RAF cancelled similar projects at roughly the same time.

There is national myth and there is history.

Come on now.
The Avro Arrow was before it's time and a true high altitude interceptor.
It was a very one dimensional aircraft. It was designed to seek out Soviet bombers at high altitude and kill them. Period.
 
It was a very one dimensional aircraft. It was designed to seek out Soviet bombers at high altitude and kill them. Period.
Exactly its problem.

Particularly when improvements to AA missiles such as the S-75 and Nike Zeus made high altitude bombers such as the XB-70 and similar Soviet plans obsolete.
 
The Super Hornet is a great aircraft BUT it is an upgrade of a 1970's design, it is not a next-generation aircraft.

The Super Hornet is more a new aircraft than simply an upgrade of a 1970's aircraft. While I have no objection to Canada having some of the F-35, it is not a good choice for what we need it to do.
 
I haven't seen one knowledgable arguement in here that made a real case for not buying the F-35.

Care to respond to the problem of its range? How is it supposed to do any good for us if it can't even get to the AO?

To fight, you first have to show up.
 
Part of the draw of the F35 for Canadian politicians is the fact that many parts are made in Canada and it was developed, in part, by Canadian designers and manufacturers. By purchasing this aircraft some jobs in Canada will be assured. Remember it's not just about the capability of the plane itself. Many other factors go into the purchase of a military weapon by governments.

In particular, the current purchase of several hundred Leopard 2A6 main battle tanks from Germany to replace the really old Leopard 1 that Canada has been using since the 60's. Part of this deal was a joint training regime in Alberta for the German military.

Also, remember the purchase of the CF101 VooDoo back in the 60's. Many people complained that the Canadian government should have purchased the F4 Phantom or continued the Arrow program. It was the CF18 Hornet that replaced the VooDoo. The main reason for the VooDoo purchase was cost.
 
Part of the draw of the F35 for Canadian politicians is the fact that many parts are made in Canada and it was developed, in part, by Canadian designers and manufacturers. By purchasing this aircraft some jobs in Canada will be assured.

Two separate issues here. You are talking about our investment of $100 million in the JSF program and other expenditures that were undertaken to ensure that Canada was part of the program and that Canadian firms would be able to bid on the subcontracts. In fact it turned out to be a great investment--our $100 million generated something nearer $500 million in contract value. So, a win.

However we don't need to purchase the fighters to retain those benefits. The contracts have already been awarded, the jobs are already coming here, and the Canadian order is a fairly insignificant one versus the total production run for the F-35 (the US's 1000's).

We can feel good about our $100 million investment and the jobs it brought to Canada and still purchase a different plane for our own air defense. The F-35 is a great plane for its role--but we require a different role.
 
Two separate issues here. You are talking about our investment of $100 million in the JSF program and other expenditures that were undertaken to ensure that Canada was part of the program and that Canadian firms would be able to bid on the subcontracts. In fact it turned out to be a great investment--our $100 million generated something nearer $500 million in contract value. So, a win.

However we don't need to purchase the fighters to retain those benefits. The contracts have already been awarded, the jobs are already coming here, and the Canadian order is a fairly insignificant one versus the total production run for the F-35 (the US's 1000's).

We can feel good about our $100 million investment and the jobs it brought to Canada and still purchase a different plane for our own air defense. The F-35 is a great plane for its role--but we require a different role.

It's not just about the initial investment but the millions of dollars in maintenance and repairs over the next 30 years. If we buy the F35 we assure Canadian manufacturers as opposed to, for example, if we bought the Mirage most of those dollars for the next 30 years would go straight to France with Canadians recieving nothing in futrure investment.
 
It's not just about the initial investment but the millions of dollars in maintenance and repairs over the next 30 years. If we buy the F35 we assure Canadian manufacturers as opposed to, for example, if we bought the Mirage most of those dollars for the next 30 years would go straight to France with Canadians recieving nothing in futrure investment.

Our 65 jets represent a tiny fraction of the maintenance costs for the F-35 worldwide, so I don't think it'd make that much of a difference.

Also if Canada decided to go with something like the superhornet then we could probably negotiate some deals there too.

Hell, if we got serious about investing in the Eurofighter we could probably negotiate some nice subcontracts for Canadian suppliers there as well.
 
Our 65 jets represent a tiny fraction of the maintenance costs for the F-35 worldwide, so I don't think it'd make that much of a difference.

Also if Canada decided to go with something like the superhornet then we could probably negotiate some deals there too.

Hell, if we got serious about investing in the Eurofighter we could probably negotiate some nice subcontracts for Canadian suppliers there as well.

I would be AMAZED if the Americans follow through and order 3,400 F35's frankly. They simply don't have the money. There are also rumblings that the entire F22 program may be shelved (at 145 million per unit it's not hard to see why.)
 
Our 65 jets represent a tiny fraction of the maintenance costs for the F-35 worldwide, so I don't think it'd make that much of a difference.

Also if Canada decided to go with something like the superhornet then we could probably negotiate some deals there too.

Hell, if we got serious about investing in the Eurofighter we could probably negotiate some nice subcontracts for Canadian suppliers there as well.

Agreed.
But my grandad always told me that even if you want to be a millionaire and can't do it then a few dollars is better than none.
 
Every time I hear about trying to buy 1 plane to do all the different tasks that are required... air-to-air and bombing chiefly I think of a pilot's comment I read once when he was asked about the role of multi-use planes.... "If I had a bomber that turned into a fighter as soon as I lost my bombs, there'd be a lot of quick jettisons when the bad guys showed up."
 
Israel Reaps Work Share Bonanza for F-35
MoD Pushes for $5B Buyback on $2.75B Deal
By BARBARA OPALL-ROME
Published: 23 August 2010 TEL AVIV - In attempts to clinch its first F-35 foreign military sale, Lockheed Martin has pledged $4 billion in F-35-related work for Israeli industry, with prospects of upping that amount by at least another $1 billion over the next decade, defense officials here said - a much higher return on investment than currently planned for other Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) customers.

Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak announced his approval in principal to the pending F-35I deal Aug. 15, noting that beyond performance capabilities, his decision was based on "agreements reached until now ... for offsets in the amount of $4 billion."

The Barak statement intentionally omitted details of prospective offset awards, which must be negotiated directly between Israeli firms and Lockheed Martin once the Israeli government formally approves the deal, and the United States and Israel sign a government-to-government contract.

Nevertheless, the Aug. 15 statement lauded agreements in hand "to integrate the Israeli industry in the aircraft's production [for the Israel Air Force and] also for additional customers." The MoD said procurement officials were continuing contacts with involved parties with an eye toward reaching $5 billion in JSF buybacks for Israeli firms.

Israel's extraordinary buyback commitment from Lockheed is unprecedented in the percentage of pledged work relative to the value of the planned procurement. According to U.S. Commerce Department data, offsets, or so-called industrial participation, associated with major defense and aerospace deals in recent years have averaged about 100 percent for European and advanced Western countries including Canada, Australia and South Korea. In less developed countries of the Asia Pacific, Eastern Europe and Latin America, offsets rarely exceed 50 percent.

But under Israel's planned 20-aircraft, $2.75 billion package, work pledged by Lockheed will reach roughly 150 percent. And if, as expected here, Israel's share of JSF-related work exceeds $5 billion, buybacks will figure closer to 180 percent.

In contrast, as part of Israel's $4.5 billion deal for 102 F-16Is struck earlier this decade, Lockheed pledged a 10-year, $1.45 billion buyback package. Since then, industry sources said Lockheed has renewed F-16I-related awards to Israeli firms, with overall industrial participation exceeding $2.2 billion, or about 50 percent of the value of the package buy.

"Offsets to Israel have always been high, and in this case, it's way off the charts," said Joel Johnson, a former vice president for international programs at the Aerospace Industries Association, Washington. Johnson said any Israeli claim to offsets is a form of "double dipping," given the fact that major Israeli weapon deals are funded through U.S. grant aid.

"The U.S. defense industry has always understood offsets as the price of doing business when you sell expensive products to a government that is spending taxpayer's money," he said. "But only the Israelis have had the chutzpah to demand offsets for selling our products to them with our taxpayer's money. A 150 percent or 200 percent offset is actually triple dipping; it's chutzpah on steroids."

Lockheed declined comment on MoD claims of $4 billion in pledged offsets, saying it was inappropriate to discuss the Israeli case before a government-to-government accord is finalized. But in a statement earlier this summer, Lockheed spokesman Christian Geisel said, "I can tell you the [industrial participation] package includes several billions of dollars of strategic and competitive work for many Israeli companies."

Investments and expected return vary among major JSF partners:

Canada: In 2002, Canada joined the JSF's System Development and Demonstration Phase with an investment of $150 million. In 2006, it decided to participate in the Production, Sustainment and Follow-On Development phase at a cost of about $500 million spread over 45 years. That money would go for tooling for aircraft production.

The government intends to spend 9 billion Canadian dollars ($8.5 billion) on purchasing the planes as well as acquiring associated weapons and infrastructure. Delivery of the 65 aircraft is expected to start in 2016.

A long-term in-service support contract, with some estimates putting that at 7 billion Canadian dollars or higher, would also be negotiated with Lockheed Martin. In return, the Canadian government is expecting at least $12 billion in work for domestic firms.
 
Canadian government officials say they are happy with the rate of work that domestic firms have received, noting that 85 companies, research laboratories and universities have obtained about 350 million Canadian dollars in contracts.

Denmark: The defense industry has been very critical on offset, and the range and value of subcontracts flowing to Danish companies.

"There are problems with JSF and offset. There is a feeling that we could have done better as a country and an industry, but then again we are a small player in this program and the subcontracts that we have received, and will receive, may not be what we had expected or wanted originally," said Michael Holm, CEO of Danish company Systematic.

The sharpest criticism has come from the Confederation of Danish Industries (DI), which represents the defense industry.

"We want to see Lockheed Martin contractually agree to ensure Danish industrial participation at a level that at least corresponds to the total purchase price of the aircraft we may one day buy. We are very disappointed at the level of orders obtained since Denmark joined the JSF development program in 2002," said Anders Ladefoged, DI's vice president and the head of the organization's defense segment.

Danish industry wants the government to renegotiate its cooperation pact with JSF, signed in 2007, and which exempts Lockheed Martin from signing contractual guarantees on offset.

"This exemption needs to be looked at. What we need is a level field of play where the potential for real offset that benefits the Danish industry sectors is heightened. This was one of the original reasons we joined the JSF-program," Ladefoged said.

Italy: Politicians and industrial officials have long lamented what they consider the limited amount of work that Italian firms have received on the JSF program.

Speaking in July, Finmeccanica CEO Pierfrancesco Guarguaglini said, "I agree with the criticisms leveled not only by the Italian government, but also by the U.K. and the Norwegians," adding, "The Italian investment in this program at this difficult time is significant and it is in the interest of Lockheed Martin and the other Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) partners to not create difficulties."

Italian Defense Undersecretary Guido Grosetto told Defense News on Aug. 19 that agreed Italian work on the program now amounted to 70 percent of Italy's total planned investment in the program, including its eventual aircraft purchases.

"This is a discussion which will continue, and in any case, it is a vast improvement on when the current Italian government took office," he said.

Reacting to news of the much-higher Israeli work share, he said, "I know that the U.S.-Israeli relationship is particular."

Norway: Industry had criticized the trickle in subcontract work flowing from the country's Tier-3 involvement in the JSF program up to mid-2008. However, criticism has waned considerably since the government issued its commitment, in December 2008, that the country's defense and nondefense sectors would benefit "significantly" from offset.

This confidence is based on the government's position that it will not enter into any contractual arrangement to acquire the F-35 until it can purchase the fighter at the lowest price and achieve a minimum of 100 percent offset.

"The government is rigid on the point of offset. Not alone do we want 100 percent, but we want offset that has a high technology value, and that can be used to internationalize our defense industry sector," said Ine Eriksen Soreide, chairperson of The Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defense in Norway's parliament, the Storting.

"Obtaining optimum offset in this purchase has always been a critical point. We will see a good deal of activity and deals over the next two to three years," said Ivar Kristiansen, the Hoyre conservative party's High North Industry and Defense spokesman.

The Norwegian government's agreement with Lockheed is based on a price offer of $3 billion for delivery of up to 48 F-35s; 100 percent offset is expected by Norway on this value by 2018.

United Kingdom: America's only Tier 1 partner on the JSF program contributed 2 billion pounds ($3.1 billion) to the System Development and Demonstration (SDD) phase. That's been good news for industry there. U.K. participants read like a roll-call of the leading local aerospace companies.

BAE Systems and Rolls-Royce are partners in the Lockheed Martin-led JSF team, while other companies like GKN Aerospace, Cobham and Martin Baker all have work on the program. Some of the work is sourced from the U.K., some from their U.S. subsidiaries, and in the case of BAE, even its Australian operation has a share of the action.

Estimates put British companies as holding about 15 percent of the work on the program. Lockheed Martin estimates the SDD, production and support phase for partner nations will earn U.K. industry more than 20 billion pounds. Export projections of up to an additional 3,000 machines could generate a further 24 billion pounds over the life of the program, Lockheed says on its website.

These figures could go higher as they do not include the propulsions system, which includes Rolls-Royce involvement.

The British originally committed to buying 150 short-takeoff and vertical-landing variants but subsequently trimmed that to 138. An upcoming strategic defense and security review could halve that amount, analysts and others speculate.

In Israel, sources are generally satisfied about the technology-transfer and industrial-participation concessions MoD managed to extract over the past two years of tense government-to-government and government-to-industry negotiations. When compared with the mere $20 million that Israel paid back in 2003 for its sideline status in the three-tiered, nine-nation international program, Lockheed pledges of $4 billion in offsets is a veritable bonanza - a 200-fold return on investment, a source here crowed.

"We were never a full partner, we never had a seat at the table with the others," an Israeli government source said. "But in the end, we stand to gain as much or more than all the partners."

The source was referring to Israel's Security Cooperation Participant status in the program, which formally provided limited development, industrial participation and preferential deliveries before other non-partner JSF customer countries.

In contrast, Britain, a first-tier partner, pledged $2 billion to the program, followed by second-tier partners Italy and the Netherlands with respective investments of $1 billion and $800 million.

Of third-tier partners Canada, Denmark, Norway and Turkey, none committed less than $200 million to the program.

Johnson disputes Pentagon claims that the JSF is a new breed of program in which formulaic offset and work-share agreements are replaced by so-called value-for-money-based production awards.

"The Norwegians, the Dutch and others are screaming about not getting enough work-share," he said. "These governments are seeing they're not getting back at least in proportion to what they're putting in ... and keep in mind, these governments want a return on their own taxpayers' money, not ours."

A veteran Capitol Hill aide acknowledged that under the value-for-money benchmark, Israel leads countries capable of doing high-quality technical work.

"But then again, when put in context, they're demanding offsets disconnected to the rest of the world at a time when we're cutting our own defense budget and losing jobs here in America," he said.

At some point, Johnson said, U.S. lawmakers championing the Buy America Act and other initiatives aimed at preserving the domestic industrial base may seek to limit the amount of buyback Israel receives on U.S.-funded procurement packages.

"If it were Saudi Arabia asking for a 50 percent or 60 percent offset, there would be uproar on the Hill," he said. "But Israel on steroids can get away with it. There must be a break point where members start to realize they're losing work in their districts due to packages they authorized and appropriated."

Big Deals in the Offing

Under strict MoD orders, Israeli firms declined to discuss potential F-35-related awards in the offing. Privately, however, industry sources said they expect more than $1 billion to go to state-owned Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) and close to $2 billion to Elbit Systems, both of which have long and productive experience with Lockheed as F-16I subcontractors.

IAI's Bedek Aviation Group is expected to receive a significant portion of production work on F-35 wings, while Elbit's Cyclone Aviation Products subsidiary is expected to provide structural components and fuel tanks, sources here said. Additionally, Tadiran, Elop, Elisra and other firms owned wholly or in majority part by Elbit are likely to reap F-35-related awards, Israeli and U.S. industry sources said.

It is not clear whether the Elbit-developed Second Generation Helmet Mounted Display System, now in low-rate production to support the JSF program, will be counted in the prospective buyback contracts to Israeli industry. The system is produced by San Jose, Calif.-based VSI, a subsidiary of Elbit Systems of America and Rockwell Collins, and was selected by Lockheed irrespective of the pending F-35 buy for the Israel Air Force.

The remaining billion or more is expected to be dispersed among nearly a dozen smaller firms, including Simigon, a simulation software firm; Rada, an established provider of avionics, recording and debriefing systems; and Ashot Ashkelon, an Israel Military Industries unit specializing in gear systems and jet engine shafts.

-- Andrew Chuter in London, Umit Enginsoy in Ankara, Tom Kington in Rome, Gerard O'Dwyer in Helsinki and David Pugliese in Ottawa contributed to this report.
 
Are u guys serious about all of this? It's pure stupidity as to support war. Puttin up such a defense goes agaist our peace codes of our country yet we are trying to buy some type of weapon of destruction only to "quote" "protect" ourselves?!?!? If someone wants to prove that we will be attacked some time, it's only going to happen because some idiot government wants to prove this inhumane point of self destruction. Create peace, not war... Use ur stupid heads think harder for peace... Not create it to go to create fake wars in Afghanistan then show the world how great they were at taking Someones life just because Ottawa/USA said so... They aren't human... They only run under a program similar to our way of inputting command lines into a computer. Politics? Their just shows to mold ur minds dull. Honeslty... Why result to war. Do u want to fight still? I wouldn't, I'm Canadian... I am peaceful canadians influnece peace and don't need weapons. We aren't Americans where they brain wash their country into teaching to relive hell on earth everyday of their lives... The states system is screwed up and has been for a long time and yet we are going with their ways? That's pure stupidity. We are our pun country... If we don't want to do shit, don't do it... We don't want to start wars like vietname again where it started over nothing and to be honest... Ask them what happened. They will tell you they don't know, or just some rubbish lie to just make themselves feel better about themselves for surviving it all... Oh and Hiroshima was a just a bomb the states intentionally sent out and they said they were scared?!?! Come on... Don't try to use these toys as to keep any peace... It's pretty silly itself when it was meant to kill
 
Are u guys serious about all of this? It's pure stupidity as to support war. Puttin up such a defense goes agaist our peace codes of our country yet we are trying to buy some type of weapon of destruction only to "quote" "protect" ourselves?!?!? If someone wants to prove that we will be attacked some time, it's only going to happen because some idiot government wants to prove this inhumane point of self destruction. Create peace, not war... Use ur stupid heads think harder for peace... Not create it to go to create fake wars in Afghanistan then show the world how great they were at taking Someones life just because Ottawa/USA said so... They aren't human... They only run under a program similar to our way of inputting command lines into a computer. Politics? Their just shows to mold ur minds dull. Honeslty... Why result to war. Do u want to fight still? I wouldn't, I'm Canadian... I am peaceful canadians influnece peace and don't need weapons. We aren't Americans where they brain wash their country into teaching to relive hell on earth everyday of their lives... The states system is screwed up and has been for a long time and yet we are going with their ways? That's pure stupidity. We are our pun country... If we don't want to do shit, don't do it... We don't want to start wars like vietname again where it started over nothing and to be honest... Ask them what happened. They will tell you they don't know, or just some rubbish lie to just make themselves feel better about themselves for surviving it all... Oh and Hiroshima was a just a bomb the states intentionally sent out and they said they were scared?!?! Come on... Don't try to use these toys as to keep any peace... It's pretty silly itself when it was meant to kill

Please go back to school or stop posting while drunk.