F-35 II Lightning

F-35 purchase

  • YES, I support the deal

    Votes: 53 64.6%
  • NO, the deal must be cancelled

    Votes: 29 35.4%

  • Total voters
    82
Absolutely, the Ruskies and a few silly Danes are already laying claims to the CANADIAN ARCTIC. Tough words are only good to a point and then you must be able to back it up with a "big stick". The riches of the Canadian Arctic are our children's inheritance.

You got it Cadillac!
 
What good is dog-fight-ability? There hasn't been a dog fight between fighter aircraft, anywhere, since the fifties. It's all done with missiles these days. We use fighter aircraft to support ground and sea operations, not to participate in dogfights.

How can any fighter aircraft establish sovereignty? You need vehicles on the ground, and ships on (the surface of) the sea, to establish sovereignty. Fighters are about as much use as submarines, for establishing sovereignty.

To show the flag in the Arctic, we should be developing amphibious go-anywhere long-range vehicles for prowling round the Arctic. Nobody makes anything like that, at present. They could be a Canadian speciality.

We should do what you say too but before they launch a missile to destroy a foreign aircraft entering our airspace, they send one of these babies to intercept and if need be, escort it away or take it down, therefore, the potential dogfight.

BTW, are you referring to dogfights by the Cdn airforce or in global terms (there were dogfights during the Vietnam War and many in M.E. conflicts, to name a few)?
 
What good is dog-fight-ability? There hasn't been a dog fight between fighter aircraft, anywhere, since the fifties.
Buttercup you are very much mistaken. Indeed the F-4 Phantom II had to be retrofitted with a cannon because the designers very much believed your statement "It's all done with missiles these days" the only problem was that the North Vietnamese didn't believe that and didn't fight like that.

This has subsequently been shown time and again including in the middle east.
 
The F-35 is useless in the artic. We would be much better off purchasing a bunch of the latest F-18 Super-Hornets before they shut down the production line. For arctic and wide open ocean use, it is necessary to have two engines. It is not even clear if the F-35 will operate cost-effectively in the Arctic. Besides, why would we send stealth aircraft up to Soviet Bombers? To give the Soviet's nice clear radar signatures on our aircraft?

The F-35 is a great plane for backing up the Americans in the Middle East.

Personally, if we have to purchase one plane, I'm not clear why it is not the F-22. The F-22 is a much more useful and capable plane for the Arctic, and any other combat mission the government dreams up. As other commentators have pointed out, the F-22 is not that much more expensive, and is available now.
 
The F22 is not available for export.
 
The F22 is not available for export.

The F-22 might be available for export if Canada asked. The head of the defence department indicated the U.S. was willing to consider it for Australia.

You can still purchase 5 F-18E/F SuperHornets for every 2 F-22 fighters. Personally, I can't see using stealth aircraft for intercepting soviet bombers in the arctic. It is an extremely expensive way of solving the problem. Save stealth technology for when and where it is needed.
 
Canada can also purchase 10 F-18E/F SuperHornets for 3 F-35 aircraft.

This is a big improvement, the F-18E/F is a two engine aircraft, and can fly with one engine out. The F-35 would need to be paired with a jet rescue craft if the pilot was to be saved, and Canada doesn't have any jet rescue aircraft.
 
What good is dog-fight-ability? There hasn't been a dog fight between fighter aircraft, anywhere, since the fifties. It's all done with missiles these days. We use fighter aircraft to support ground and sea operations, not to participate in dogfights.

Yeah, thats what the US thought in Viet-Nam. The Phantom II was a missile only bird at first, but the US found that a 20mm gun was necessary and added one.

Although some think that it will all be done with missiles, the reality is that there has not been a direct competition between major powers in a long time. Taking on the Russians or the Chinese will certain need a different strategy than trying to catch the fleeing Iraqi airforce as it fled to Iran.
 
The F-22 might be available for export if Canada asked. The head of the defence department indicated the U.S. was willing to consider it for Australia.

You can still purchase 5 F-18E/F SuperHornets for every 2 F-22 fighters. Personally, I can't see using stealth aircraft for intercepting soviet bombers in the arctic. It is an extremely expensive way of solving the problem. Save stealth technology for when and where it is needed.

Just wondering have you looked at the price tag on a Raptor?
 
Canada can also purchase 10 F-18E/F SuperHornets for 3 F-35 aircraft.

This is a big improvement, the F-18E/F is a two engine aircraft, and can fly with one engine out. The F-35 would need to be paired with a jet rescue craft if the pilot was to be saved, and Canada doesn't have any jet rescue aircraft.

Please define a jet rescue aircraft?
 
the navy has its own ship building program in the works somewhere near 100 ships over the next 23 odd years.
The F35 is a usable aircraft for air to air service and it is usable for ground support. It does not have the avionics package that the F22 does but it has the same radar stealth package, actually it is a genration ahead of the F22 in that regard. The super hornet is a stopgap until the F35 comes into naval service it will be retired over time

It is not really better then the F-22 at anything except ground attack. In fact, it is significantly inferior in stealth but I do believe it has similar radar capabilities to F-22.
 
Canada may need new planes, but Canada does NOT need F-35's. They are next to useless here!

For one thing they can't even fly far enough to get up into the arctic--that alone should rule them out. Canada's a big country and we need fighters with RANGE, we should be increasing the range over the CF-18 not cutting it practically in half. To fly far enough to be useful in the North the F-35 would require mid-air refuelling, but at some of those locations it would take EIGHT HOURS for a refuelling jet to arrive, more or less ruling out scrambling F-35's and sending them off to the arctic on a moment's notice.

It gets worse: The F-35 is a single engine fighter, but we need a jet that can be deployed to hostile and remote environments. Survivability under such circumstances demands a multi-engine jet, something that can take a few knocks and still get home. In a sparse country with hostile remote areas such as Canada has you want a highly reliable vehicle with redundant systems.

For another thing it isn't clear at ALL why we would want stealth technology. It makes the planes very expensive and it is simply not necessary for an interceptor plane, it's the sort of thing you need if you are planning to invade another country and you want to take out their air defenses. Not what Canada is likely to do. For an interceptor it doesn't matter if the enemy sees you coming, the enemy is likely a heavy bomber that can be taken out at great range. If it sees you and turns back before you get there so much the better.

The F-35's also expensive because it was designed to fly off of aircraft carriers so it has made all sorts of design compromises to achieve that goal. Guess what Canada does not have any of?

Canada needs a presence up in the North. We need planes that can fly far enough and fast enough to challenge anyone who questions our sovereignty.

That's not the F-35, it does not meet that requirement.

The F-35 is a multi-role strike fighter that would be suitable if Canada were to participate in the invasion of some other country. In that case the short range would be irrelevant, the ability to fly off carriers or converted operational runways near an AO key, and the stealth technology absolutely critical for avoiding enemy air defenses. That is not the role we need, but it appears to be what Harper is hoping we will be doing more of.

Basically Harper seems to be selling out Canadian sovereignty in order to buy expensive military hardware suitable for joining more overseas invasions.
 
What good is dog-fight-ability? There hasn't been a dog fight between fighter aircraft, anywhere, since the fifties. It's all done with missiles these days. We use fighter aircraft to support ground and sea operations, not to participate in dogfights.

How can any fighter aircraft establish sovereignty? You need vehicles on the ground, and ships on (the surface of) the sea, to establish sovereignty. Fighters are about as much use as submarines, for establishing sovereignty.

To show the flag in the Arctic, we should be developing amphibious go-anywhere long-range vehicles for prowling round the Arctic. Nobody makes anything like that, at present. They could be a Canadian speciality.

Hate to burst your bubble but there have been many dogfights...and yes dogfights are done with missles these days. You just havent heard much about the dogfights because really? Out side of the Soviets, North American pilots dominate... I would hate to be an under trained Iraqui pilot during the hieght of the Iraqui war and have to step to some top gun alumni

Fighter jets are indeed primarliy there for ground support but they also escort air transport and bombers... wouldnt be much support or much of an escort when the other guys jets show up and have something to say about it all
 
During the Vietnam war, the kill ratio for f4s was less than 1 to 1 because the inferior MiGs the Vietnamese were using had guns on them and they were better at dog fighting.
That's when Top Gun schools were started.
 
During the Vietnam war, the kill ratio for f4s was less than 1 to 1 because the inferior MiGs the Vietnamese were using had guns on them and they were better at dog fighting.
That's when Top Gun schools were started.

Yeah we all watched Top Gun and heard Micheal Ironside say that in the briefing scene.
Now the F14 TomCat - THAT was an interceptor!

 
Canada may need new planes, but Canada does NOT need F-35's. They are next to useless here!

For one thing they can't even fly far enough to get up into the arctic--that alone should rule them out. Canada's a big country and we need fighters with RANGE, we should be increasing the range over the CF-18 not cutting it practically in half. To fly far enough to be useful in the North the F-35 would require mid-air refuelling, but at some of those locations it would take EIGHT HOURS for a refuelling jet to arrive, more or less ruling out scrambling F-35's and sending them off to the arctic on a moment's notice.

It gets worse: The F-35 is a single engine fighter, but we need a jet that can be deployed to hostile and remote environments. Survivability under such circumstances demands a multi-engine jet, something that can take a few knocks and still get home. In a sparse country with hostile remote areas such as Canada has you want a highly reliable vehicle with redundant systems.

For another thing it isn't clear at ALL why we would want stealth technology. It makes the planes very expensive and it is simply not necessary for an interceptor plane, it's the sort of thing you need if you are planning to invade another country and you want to take out their air defenses. Not what Canada is likely to do. For an interceptor it doesn't matter if the enemy sees you coming, the enemy is likely a heavy bomber that can be taken out at great range. If it sees you and turns back before you get there so much the better.

The F-35's also expensive because it was designed to fly off of aircraft carriers so it has made all sorts of design compromises to achieve that goal. Guess what Canada does not have any of?

Canada needs a presence up in the North. We need planes that can fly far enough and fast enough to challenge anyone who questions our sovereignty.

That's not the F-35, it does not meet that requirement.

The F-35 is a multi-role strike fighter that would be suitable if Canada were to participate in the invasion of some other country. In that case the short range would be irrelevant, the ability to fly off carriers or converted operational runways near an AO key, and the stealth technology absolutely critical for avoiding enemy air defenses. That is not the role we need, but it appears to be what Harper is hoping we will be doing more of.

Basically Harper seems to be selling out Canadian sovereignty in order to buy expensive military hardware suitable for joining more overseas invasions.

Simple - Buy 65 F18 Superhornets in addition to the F35's.
 
It would be pretty funny if they tried to intercept a TU-160 with an F-35 and end up chasing it all over Canada with little success.
 
I haven't seen one knowledgable arguement in here that made a real case for not buying the F-35. Frankly we cannot simply stick our heads in the sand and relinquish our sovereignty to the US every time we need to upgrade our military hardware. The Super Hornet is a great aircraft BUT it is an upgrade of a 1970's design, it is not a next-generation aircraft. Canada has made the mistake time and again of trying to make our military hardware last beyond its service life. Sooner or later you have to buy new, that's just the way it works.
 
Can someone say "AVRO Arrow"

If it doesn't have the legs or two engines its not suited to Canada's needs.
How come it everytime we need new jets it the PC goverment in power.
They should folllow "Def the chief" role and just buy missiles. Because Jet are so last century.

Unmaned drones are the way to go, they are cheaper, faster and you can swarm a fighter with them.
But that still in the future. We should buy chinese copies of russian jet. (very cheap).