My luck hasn't run out yet.
Had sex with another girl last night. Messaged her yesterday morning on POF asking to meet. After a minor shit test that I passed with ease, she said she'd be glad to. Went for coffee, brought her back after an hour, escalated kino for a while, and then banged her. Afterward, she has this "Oh God, what have I just done?" look on her face.
That's three girls in six days. I guess it's all about being really aggressive.
This is getting old fast though. Now I don't just want any girls, but hot girls, which seems to be a whole different ball game.