Election Prediction

In both 2004 and 2008 Intrade correctly predicted the vote in all 50 states. I don't know that it was around or had enough volume in 2000
Wow, thats a great record.

The smart money is on Obama then. Even though I want Romney to win
 
The smart money is on Obama then. Even though I want Romney to win

That's the thing, it's actually money. Intrade does not ask "who would you vote for", it asks "who do you think will win", and requires you to back up your answer with cash.

Still the predicting it is making is not a certainty, it's still giving Romney a 1 in 3 chance of winning the election and there is a week to go. I believe in 2008 at this point its prediction for Obama was in the 80% range so obviously it's a closer race this time out.
 
That's the thing, it's actually money. Intrade does not ask "who would you vote for", it asks "who do you think will win", and requires you to back up your answer with cash.

Still the predicting it is making is not a certainty, it's still giving Romney a 1 in 3 chance of winning the election and there is a week to go. I believe in 2008 at this point its prediction for Obama was in the 80% range so obviously it's a closer race this time out
Yup.

Even at 1.68 that still means very little. At least to those who know "gambling"
 
Supposedly (and I mean ALLEGEDLY) the main stream media is stacked against Romney so badly that the polls arent even close to being accurate.

These are not my words, thats just what I heard.

If the election turns out to be close, or slightly in favor of Romney, I will never trust another MSM poll again!! Its time to start storming capitol hill, dammit!!!
 
Blaming the mainstream media is part of the Republican playbook. It is their #1 way of pretending to be the political outsider, despite the fact that they represent fundamentally insider interests, and despite the fact that they are backed by people who own huge swaths of the American media properties.

I don't think they allow you to be a member of the Republican party unless you say a few suitably critical things about the "Liberal media".

In reality I think the media, overall, if you averaged it, sits squarely in the middle between the two parties, with some outlets plainly leaning left (the NYT, CNN) and some plainly leaning right (anything owned by Murdoch). As such both parties are able to point to the media and say it is biased against them, because it is! It's left of the R's and right of the D's, because the nation is, and the media reflects the nation (i.e., seeks to appeal to its audience).
 
Supposedly (and I mean ALLEGEDLY) the main stream media is stacked against Romney so badly that the polls arent even close to being accurate.

These are not my words, thats just what I heard.

If the election turns out to be close, or slightly in favor of Romney, I will never trust another MSM poll again!! Its time to start storming capitol hill, dammit!!!

When you hear (or see) a poll result, you have to ask what their skew was.

For example, a poll will ask whether an individual is a Voter, a Registered Voter, or a Likely Voter (each being a subset of the prior set). They will ask if the individual is a registered Democrat, Republican, or Independent. And they will ask whether the individual is committed to Romney (R) or Obama (O), is leaning R or O, or is undecided.

That leaves a lot of "quadrants" for the pollster to analyze.

But the pollsters know, for example, that a particular State had, say, 4 percent more D voters than R voters in 2008 (and maybe only D+1 in 2004).

So when they announce that their poll says O+3 (D+7), they're saying that Obama will lead by 3 points if the Democrats improve their turnout by 3 points (more than R's) over their 2008 turnout (for this particular example).

Nobody expects the Democrats to actually improve their turnout over 2008, except a few pollsters.

Some of the recent polls have moved from O+1 to O+2 while shifting from D+3 to D+6. In other words, over the course of just a few days, they're expecting 3 percent higher Dem turnout, but translating that to only a one point gain for Obama.

And some people think that the Vegas line determines the outcome of NFL games. Err, that InTrade predicts the outcome of elections.

HA!
 
Hey, Anynym, if you figure intrade has it wrong , why not put a few grand down on Romney? They are paying out 2 to 1 if he wins. You could make some good money in just six days.
 
Hey, Anynym, if you figure intrade has it wrong , why not put a few grand down on Romney? They are paying out 2 to 1 if he wins. You could make some good money in just six days.

Who says I won't? Who says I haven't?
 
When you hear (or see) a poll result, you have to ask what their skew was.

For example, a poll will ask whether an individual is a Voter, a Registered Voter, or a Likely Voter (each being a subset of the prior set). They will ask if the individual is a registered Democrat, Republican, or Independent. And they will ask whether the individual is committed to Romney (R) or Obama (O), is leaning R or O, or is undecided.

That leaves a lot of "quadrants" for the pollster to analyze.

But the pollsters know, for example, that a particular State had, say, 4 percent more D voters than R voters in 2008 (and maybe only D+1 in 2004).

So when they announce that their poll says O+3 (D+7), they're saying that Obama will lead by 3 points if the Democrats improve their turnout by 3 points (more than R's) over their 2008 turnout (for this particular example).

Nobody expects the Democrats to actually improve their turnout over 2008, except a few pollsters.

Some of the recent polls have moved from O+1 to O+2 while shifting from D+3 to D+6. In other words, over the course of just a few days, they're expecting 3 percent higher Dem turnout, but translating that to only a one point gain for Obama.

And some people think that the Vegas line determines the outcome of NFL games. Err, that InTrade predicts the outcome of elections.

HA!

538 actually does a far more sophisticated analysis than yours and their numbers are pretty clear. And the vast majority of pollsters don't actually report the way you say they do. There is no "if" statement like you propose. In fact they report their numbers categorized as "likely voters" or "registered voters" and ask questions about how likely the people are going to vote, and how strongly they feel about their convictions.

I can't remember the last time I saw a poll report the way you suggest they do. Where do you get this stuff?
 
Right, the facts are nonsense to you. I will take note that your views are based on something else.

The Quebec election showed us how reliable polls can be, I suspect you post this because in some odd way it gives you comfort, the way fred posts everytime some hayseed Republican says something stupid in public - as if it represents the whole party.

Hey if makes you all feel better go ahead, I think I will wait for the results of Florida and Ohio.
 
The Quebec election showed us how reliable polls can be, I suspect you post this because in some odd way it gives you comfort, the way fred posts everytime some hayseed Republican says something stupid in public - as if it represents the whole party.

Hey if makes you all feel better go ahead, I think I will wait for the results of Florida and Ohio.

So you think a single outlier means that the science is unreliable?

That really makes no sense. The whole idea of a large data set is to take account for those. It would be irrational to assume rare events are common now wouldn't it?
 
Dick Morris is one of the people who says some of the polls are being weighted too much in Obama's favour:

http://www.dickmorris.com/why-the-ny-times-poll-is-wrong/

I don't believe he is at all correct on how the Times uses its data. Not even close. In fact the NYT has full transparency on its poll procedure and analysis and it does not do what Dick says it does:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/31/us/politics/how-the-polls-were-conducted.html?_r=0

Even if he was, the 538 model uses hundreds and thousands of polls, not a single poll.

So do you believe Dick is correct and Romney will win by a landslide?
 
Supposedly (and I mean ALLEGEDLY) the main stream media is stacked against Romney so badly that the polls arent even close to being accurate.

These are not my words, thats just what I heard.

If the election turns out to be close, or slightly in favor of Romney, I will never trust another MSM poll again!! Its time to start storming capitol hill, dammit!!!


Where did you hear that?
What I've heard is the opposite, that Obama should be well above Romney, but that the very, very right wing media in the US is pushing this fantasy that Romney is competing to cover up the expected electronic voter manipulation that might let him win like Bush did.
http://www.themoneyparty.org/main/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Republican-Primary-Election-Results-Amazing-Statistical-Anomalies_V2.1.pdf
 
the very, very right wing media in the US is pushing this fantasy that Romney is competing to cover up the expected electronic voter manipulation that might let him win like Bush did
Thanks for proving once again you're delusional (as if we needed further proof)
 
Last edited:
Here's an analysis of Intrade's 2008 performance:

http://electoralmap.net/2012/2008_election.php

So I was wrong, it got its predictions for two states wrong and did not predict a split vote in Nebraska. Net effect is its prediction for the electoral college was wrong by 1 elector
Still though, getting 48 States out of 50 right is pretty good.

Also interesting to note, Intrade gives Rasmussen an A- grade (91% accuracy):
Rasmussen Reports 91% A-

And Rasmussen has Romney winning the election :confused: