Election Prediction

I dunno, its gonna be a lot closer than those 2 oddsmakers predict I think.

I want Romney to win, because Obama is absolutely useless when it comes to running a lemonade stand (hyperbole for US economy)
 
I dunno, its gonna be a lot closer than those 2 oddsmakers predict I think.

I want Romney to win, because Obama is absolutely useless when it comes to running a lemonade stand (hyperbole for US economy)

Hey don't knock it, even by 538 odds, Romney has a 23% chance of being the next President of the United States. Neither of us have even a 1% chance of being the next El Presidente of even the crappiest banana republic. 23% is pretty good!
 
Hey don't knock it, even by 538 odds, Romney has a 23% chance of being the next President of the United States. Neither of us have even a 1% chance of being the next El Presidente of even the crappiest banana republic. 23% is pretty good!
I tell you what, if US polls are as skewed as they say they are, Romney is walking away with this baby next week! Like 52% vs. Obama 49% (total vote)
 
fuji, why do you keep posting this nonsense?
 
Dick Morris, remember the Clinton Campaign "genius," is calling it for Governor Romney.

Indeed. He's actually predicting a Republican landslide: http://thehill.com/opinion/columnists/dick-morris/264935-here-comes-the-landslide

Morris has also said Romney can win without Ohio, although he predicts Romney will win Ohio.

http://www.dickmorris.com/the-ohio-illusion-dick-morris-tv-lunch-alert/

Karl Rove is also calling it for Romney:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB100...20229096046.html?mod=WSJ_hps_sections_opinion
 
Right, the facts are nonsense to you. I will take note that your views are based on something else.

What facts? That less than a thousand people gambling a couple of bucks here and there will determine the presidency.
 
You have a link to a prediction you think is based on something stronger?

Oh wait I forgot--your opinion, not based on facts. Gonna take some time for me to digest that one, it's so unusual--but I respect your anti-factual ideology!
 
Kraft Dinner would prefer wishing on a star as opposing to what the people think. Or what a statistician who predicted 49 out of 50 state outcomes and all 35 senate races 100%. But statistics is witchcraft so you have 6 on one 1/2 dozen on the other.
 
Obama's over 68% on Intrade now.

HEY KD: You know if the Intrade prediction is a load of bunk, as you so firmly believe, you could make yourself some real cash opening up a position there right now. Not small dollars either--a total of about $1.2 million in shares traded today alone on Intrade. If you are so sure you are right, why not bet a few $100k that Intrade has got it wrong?

If you haven't been able to save up that much from your paper route, well, you can trade amounts as low as $10, but the market could clear a $100k order if you had one.
 
And how relaible has such betting speculation been historically fugi? I have no idea, I'm just asking the question.
 
And how relaible has such betting speculation been historically fugi? I have no idea, I'm just asking the question.

The Iowa Electronic Market, run by U of Iowa, has been extensively studied and has generally performed better than raw polls. Polls are an input to the market, in the sense that people trading in the market base their decisions on all the information available to them, which plainly is mostly the polling data plus whatever intuition they have about momentum. However--polls themselves are famously inaccurate sometimes, so take "better than polls" with a grain of salt, since the polls aren't always very good.

Sites like 538 attempt to integrate all the polling data in a different way, by using a formalized statistical model that the sites author attempts to back test. This takes the raw data and translates it into a prediction using all the available historic data the author was able to build into the model. In a sense, this is also an input to Intrade, as Intrade participants can view 538 predictions in making their trades--and probably do. There are probably a bunch of people who arbitrage the difference between the 538 prediction and Intrade's.

Whether a formal, professional, back-tested statistical model that integrates polls using formal methods is better, or whether an organic market is better at integrating polls, is a contentious topic that can probably be debated until economists give up on their profession and go home. I am certain there is no research out there stating that 538 is better than a prediction market or vise versa, but I believe that there is research demonstrating that both approaches are superior to raw, uninterpreted polling data.

However, again, polls themselves are not all that accurate, and so if all the polling is wrong--and that has happened before--then perhaps garbage in, garbage out.

As the famous saying goes the only really accurate poll will be conducted on election day.

Also note that even the most aggressive prediction, on 538, giving Obama a roughly 75% chance still has Romney winning one coin toss in four and with Intrade's odds he is winning one coin toss in three. Unless the markets were reporting Obama with over 90% certainty that is still a lot of leeway for inaccurate polls, voter shifts between now and election day, etc.
 
OK, but how did these betting sites perform in the weekend before the presidential election in 2000 and 2004? I won't ask about 2008 because by then it was a forgone conclusion. Again, just asking. You seem to rely on this sort of thing so I assume you know.
 
OK, but how did these betting sites perform in the weekend before the presidential election in 2000 and 2004? I won't ask about 2008 because by then it was a forgone conclusion. Again, just asking. You seem to rely on this sort of thing so I assume you know.

In both 2004 and 2008 Intrade correctly predicted the vote in all 50 states. I don't know that it was around or had enough volume in 2000.(*)

That is a statement about where its predictions sat when the polls opened in each state on election day. If you view the historic data on their sites, you can see a lot of volatility in its predictions leading up to election day, so it's fair to ask how far in advance Intrade can accurately forecast elections, but it is appears to be a very good forecast by the time the polls open.



(*) Edit: I have been looking for the answer, and just found that Intrade started in 2001, so it was not around for the 2000 election cycle.
 
I wouldn't say I "rely" on this information. I think that Intrade and 538 are the best predictions that we have about what is going to happen on election day, with an unsettled philosophical debate about which approach generates better predictions. I don't know how good the "best" really is, as I said, if the polling that feeds these things is all garbage, or if there is a major shift in voter sentiment between the time the last poll is taken, and when people show up at the polls, then we are probably talking garbage in, garbage out for ANY method of predicting elections.
 
More -- in the 2004 election, Intrade was correctly predicting a Bush win from August all the way through to election day.
 
Another data point, Intrade made 95 predictions for the most recent Academy Awards, and got 93 of them right.