Election in Spain

OK

seven said:
Don't be an idiot.

I don't have that problem but I can see why you are concerned.

seven said:
It is common knowledge that Bush lied about the WMD angle so he could justify the war.

Perhaps in liberal knee-jerk communities it's "common knowledge" but in the real world it is not. He, and much of the world, was wrong. Which is different from lying - a differentiation that democrats down here can't seem to grasp.

seven said:

You do know about that state of the union address where he lied his ass off, right?

I watched it.

OTB
 
Re: OK

onthebottom said:
Perhaps in liberal knee-jerk communities it's "common knowledge" but in the real world it is not. He, and much of the world, was wrong. Which is different from lying - a differentiation that democrats down here can't seem to grasp.

Is Fox News the only channel your TV hauls in? Like I said, you really need to inform yourself.


http://www.progressive.org/sept03/comm0903.html

Highlight:

There was the lie about aluminum tubes, which Condoleezza Rice said were "only really suited for nuclear weapons programs, centrifuge programs." Actually, many intelligence experts, including the International Atomic Energy Agency, concluded that the tubes were more likely to be used for artillery rockets.


See State of Union Address 2003 : http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/01/20030128-19.html. So how was most of the world wrong, as you say? Bush jumped the gun and lied to justify his actions.

Also, this part of the speech was a lie:

The International Atomic Energy Agency confirmed in the 1990s that Saddam Hussein had an advanced nuclear weapons development program, had a design for a nuclear weapon and was working on five different methods of enriching uranium for a bomb.


The IAEA never confirmed that.
 
Re: Re: OK

seven said:
Is Fox News the only channel your TV hauls in? Like I said, you really need to inform yourself.


[

You forgot about the Libya connection on Uranium (or was it Plutonium I always get them mixed up). That's a far cry from "it's common knowledge that Bush Lied about WMD" these were sub points under the main point of Saddam had skirted 14 years of UN resolutions.

I don't watch much television, and almost never FOX or CNN (CNBC is good in the morning for corporate and economic news) I read the economist and listen to NPR for my news intake. I suggest you move away from the TV and stop hanging out at Progressive.Org and MoveOn.org. I love the word progressive, it's how you describe yourself if you're a liberal but too chicken shit to say liberal!

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: OK

onthebottom said:
You forgot about the Libya connection on Uranium (or was it Plutonium I always get them mixed up). That's a far cry from "it's common knowledge that Bush Lied about WMD" <blah,blah,blah>

You have to learn how to read. This is what the president said during his State of the Union Address 2003:


The International Atomic Energy Agency confirmed in the 1990s that Saddam Hussein had an advanced nuclear weapons development program, had a design for a nuclear weapon and was working on five different methods of enriching uranium for a bomb.


The IAEA never confirmed that. How is that not a lie regarding WMD? Do you not know what a lie is???

Bush also was willfully ignorant regarding the aluminum tubes and what their purpose and design was according to the scientific community. Being willfully ignorant in an attempt to deceive is immoral and dishonest.

If that is not enough check out all the lies Bush has said to justify the war on Iraq:

http://www.winwithoutwarus.org/html/new_censure.claims.html

Highlight:

“I would remind you that when the inspectors first went into Iraq and were denied – finally denied access—a report came out of the IAEA that they were six months away from developing a nuclear weapon. I don’t know how much more evidence we need.”

President Bush, September 6 2002 news conference

“The International Atomic Energy Agency says that a report cited by President Bush as evidence that Iraq in 1998 was ‘six months away’ from developing a nuclear weapon does not exist. ‘There's never been a report like that issued from this agency, Mark Gwozdecky, the IAEA's chief spokesman, said.”

The Washington Times, September 27, 2002


Can you say "liar, liar pants on fire"? Bush is a liar and you'd have to be stupid not to believe that.

PS - Can you give me any evidence from right-wing media to deny what I have said? Yeah, that's what I thought.
 
Why

Don’t you try balanced media, and I wouldn't consider either The Economist or NPR as right wing media.

My Libya comment was about a comment in Bush’s SOTU about material being shipped to Iraq from Libya, he used the British as the source. It turned out to be incorrect. Again, read THEN respond. You can even add think (as opposed to copy / paste) to the process if you can.

You are missing the point, as is usual for rabid Bush haters.

OTB
 
Credible News Source

Seven,

Here, try reading some real analysis from a real news organization:

Economist January 29, 2004

George Bush and Tony Blair exaggerated, but they did not lie






BEFORE going to war against Saddam Hussein last March, George Bush and Tony Blair told the world they were certain that the Iraqi dictator possessed chemical and biological weapons, and long-range missiles, and was actively seeking an atomic bomb. This was the basis on which millions of Americans, Britons and others, including The Economist, supported the war. But ten months after the invasion, and despite the interrogation of hundreds of captured Iraqi officials, none of these weapons has been discovered. Even David Kay, the hardline inspector America had put in charge of the post-war weapons hunt, expects now that none will be (see article). After resigning from his job last week, he said that Iraq seemed to have got rid of them in the 1990s.

The absence of these weapons is more than just an embarrassment. It raises the question of whether this war was fought on a false prospectus. Above all, did the president of the United States and the British prime minister lie?

So far, the answer seems to be no. Not a scrap of evidence has emerged since the war to suggest that Mr Bush or Mr Blair doubted the truth of their central claim. Moreover, given the evidence available to them at the time, they were entitled to their pre-war confidence.

.......

If you want to read the rest of the article I suggest subscribing, it will have a remarkable effect on your ability to think.

OTB
 
OTB,

Do you deny that Bush lied about WMD? Yes or no? Cause that was your initial point of contention. Proving that Bush received bad intel from the British does not prove he didn't lie regarding other stuff he said. That's mickey mouse spin and you know it.
 
OK

Let's make this real simple. I believe that Bush believed that Iraq had WMD period. Blair believed it, the US and UK intelligence community believed it and that back stabbing wimp in Paris believed it as well.

Bush (and Blair) sold this line hard; they exaggerated, drew conclusions (aluminum tubes), and didn't vet intelligence (Libya) well enough. At the end of the day they were not lying, because they believed what they were saying. You are lying when you are saying something that you know to be false ("I never had sexual relations with THAT woman"), see Martha Stewart for latest example.

Now Liberals (oh I'm sorry, progressives) want to paint this with a very wide brush and say that Bush is a Lying Liar (good name for a book don't you think) because the people who get all their news from TV will understand it.

OTB
 
And back to the point

The Spanish are still retreating appeasement monkeys.

May they get the slower economy and higher unemployment that accompanies all socialist governments!

OTB
 
This is a lie.

Originally posted by OTB
Bush (and Blair) sold this line hard; they exaggerated, drew conclusions (aluminum tubes), and didn't vet intelligence (Libya) well enough. At the end of the day they were not lying, because they believed what they were saying. You are lying when you are saying something that you know to be false ("I never had sexual relations with THAT woman"), see Martha Stewart for latest example.

Maybe it will sink in this time...


“I would remind you that when the inspectors first went into Iraq and were denied – finally denied access—a report came out of the IAEA that they were six months away from developing a nuclear weapon. I don’t know how much more evidence we need.”

President Bush, September 6 2002 news conference

“The International Atomic Energy Agency says that a report cited by President Bush as evidence that Iraq in 1998 was ‘six months away’ from developing a nuclear weapon does not exist. ‘There's never been a report like that issued from this agency, Mark Gwozdecky, the IAEA's chief spokesman, said.”

The Washington Times, September 27, 2002


How is that not a lie according to your definition? Let me guess... it isn't a lie it's an exaggeration of reality past the truth. Yeah that's it.
 
ocean976124 said:
IMO, thats like blaming the woman for being raped because she was "dressed like a slut" or "led the guy on." Nothing excuses rape, nothing excuses terrorism.

That's one of the dumbest analogies i've ever heard. The Spanish people voted out a government that exposed them to a greatly increased risk of attack.....in spite of their demands to the government not to do so. Al Qaeda is the evil one in this scenario, but the Spanish government (with a big assist from George Bush) was the stupid one in this scenario.

If you and i are roommates, and you demand that we lock the door at night, but i demand that we leave it open and so we leave it open.....and someone breaks in and beats the bejeesus out of both of us with a baseball bat, are you going to hold me completely blameless? Or are you going to find a new roommate?
 
ocean976124 said:
Terrorism has no justification and the US and British forces are probably the most moral military forces that have ever existed. Does shit happen? Yes, but thats a far cry from actual national or military policy.

How moral they may be is irrelevant. What's relevant is what their actions cause in spite of their morality. Tell me, the military drops a bomb on a restaurant trying to kill a military leader who isn't there knowing that at least 10 innocent civilians will probably be killed in the effort. OBL sends a suicide bomber to downtown Baghdad to blow up a hotel and kills 10 innocent civilians. I'm one of the dead innocent civilians in the restaurant. Convince me i was killed by a more moral bomb.
 
ocean976124 said:
In a certain sense, yes. Look the world is crazy place. Not every nation sees eye to eye on almost anything. You have to pick your spots and choose your fights.
To pretend that France is some begnin peace maker is silly. They had their own interests at heart, which is fine but lets not make them out to be peace loving pacificists.

"For sale, French military rifle. Never fired, droped once."

And maybe if Spain supported us in a war against Saudi Arabia, backed up with evidence of how that actually fights terrorism as opposed to the joke in Iraq backed up by nothing but Bush's lies, perhaps they are more resolute in the face of the bombing last week.
 
Re: Credible News Source

onthebottom said:
So far, the answer seems to be no. Not a scrap of evidence has emerged since the war to suggest that Mr Bush or Mr Blair doubted the truth of their central claim.
OTB

You give what is nothing more than an opinion of one writer. But nonetheless, one could just as easily say there is no evidence that has come out to indicate they actually believed what they were saying either. The fact that they were wrong doesn't exactly prove they believed it. But more to my point - the best evidence that suggests they were lying is the fact that nobody seems to have lost their job over the intelligence fiasco. They say a war was started because of bad intelligence. Good grief, if that's not reason enough to roll some heads, then i don't know what is. If Tenet had his sorry ass thrown out on the street, i'd still say Bush was a lying piece of garbage, but at least you'd have something to hang your hat on to indicate he was simply given bad information.
 
Re: Everyone Forgets

onthebottom said:
In a post 9/11 world Bush was faced with a choice, allow Saddam out of his box (sanctions) or take him out. He made his choice (the right one) because he was the only person who could make that decision and enforce it OTB

So let me see if i got this straight. Because of what Saddam might do if we lifted the sanctions, we have to invade. Is that your story? Sounds to me like you're just heaving another piece of s**t at the wall hoping this one sticks. If we lift the sanctions, Saddam is gonna do something dastardly, so rather than just not lift the sanctions, we invade. Good one.

It's actually becoming good sport watching you people try to defend this fiasco. So keep 'em coming.
 
The_Jaded_One said:
It doesn't give him the moral high ground but his passive actions don't put him in the wrong. Notice the key difference...
If it was an immoral war then France should have called to arms to defend Iraq...
Question: How many country leaders want GWB ousted?

Answer: Every country leader except for three. Bush's foreign policy and decision to go to war against Iraq was/is a total disaster not to mention unethical.
Not really.
The USA had no right to attack Iraq, and as you say, did it in accordance with its own best (economic) interests. It was an immoral decision. We are not talking about the lesser of two evils here...
It was not in economic best interests. Our economic best interest would have been to secretly strike some sort of deal with Saddam...
 
Winston said:
I'm sorry, but I don't see OBL out marking the gypsies, the homosexuals and the Jews for death. I don't see OBL trying to create/extend an Empire, I don't see OBL marching a significant percentage of his own population to the gas chambers.
OBL most certainly has maked Jews for death. Just ask Daniel Pearl...
The greater question is "why do we need to engage OBL at all?" The reality is, if you understand what is driving him, and turn it around, does what he is asking for really seem outlandish?

He wants: Foreign armies out of the middle east
Foreign influence out of middle eastern politics
foreign rule out of the middle east.
Lets see, why did the armies go to Saudi Arabia to begin with? Oh ya, because Saddam had invaded Kuwait and no international force will do anything without the USA's troops!
Why does the USA support Israel? Hmmm, maybe because its a functioning democracy that has continously been invaded throughout its history by nations that seek to wipe it off the face of the earth...
So, just how do you see compare OBL to Hitler again? [/B]
Did you miss what the Tailban, which are aligned with OSL, were doing in Afghanistan? OBL hates Jews and Infidels, apparently that kind of language doesn't scare you. Well, it didn't scare me either until two towers collapsed and 3000 people died.
 
seven said:
Don't be an idiot. It is common knowledge that Bush lied about the WMD angle so he could justify the war. You do know about that state of the union address where he lied his ass off, right?
Even Hans Blix has said he does not believe Bush was lying about WMD, he was mistaken but not lying. Bush did exaggerate the evidence greatly but anyone who was paying attention all along knew that. Thats what politicians do. The left does it as well as the right.
 
Ickabod said:
That's one of the dumbest analogies i've ever heard. The Spanish people voted out a government that exposed them to a greatly increased risk of attack.....in spite of their demands to the government not to do so. Al Qaeda is the evil one in this scenario, but the Spanish government (with a big assist from George Bush) was the stupid one in this scenario.
Its only dumb if you think terrorism can be justified.
If you and i are roommates, and you demand that we lock the door at night, but i demand that we leave it open and so we leave it open.....and someone breaks in and beats the bejeesus out of both of us with a baseball bat, are you going to hold me completely blameless? Or are you going to find a new roommate? [/B]
Well I certainly wouldn't "blame" you. But in your analogy me locking the door from now on will prevent, to a certain extent, future break-ins. Giving in to terrorists does not end terrorism, it spreads it...
 
Ickabod said:
How moral they may be is irrelevant. What's relevant is what their actions cause in spite of their morality. Tell me, the military drops a bomb on a restaurant trying to kill a military leader who isn't there knowing that at least 10 innocent civilians will probably be killed in the effort. OBL sends a suicide bomber to downtown Baghdad to blow up a hotel and kills 10 innocent civilians. I'm one of the dead innocent civilians in the restaurant. Convince me i was killed by a more moral bomb.
And you've fallen for what Saddam wanted you to fall for. He used human shields when he could so that any attempt on him would be seen as killing innocent people. OBL does the same thing. They make sure to hide with the innocent. But you don't seem to be questioning the morality of that decision.