Famous case from a few years ago.
Toronto McDonald's shooting: Security guard won't be charged after 2 die | CBC News
Toronto McDonald's shooting: Security guard won't be charged after 2 die | CBC News
Agreed
There are a number of laws where I like the fact it’s grey. As opposed to blackwhite, rule of the law. It gives cops some discretion whether or not to proceed.
Too often though in Canada, when someone defends themselves or their property (houses). They just have the book thrown at them. When some common sense might have prevailed.
Don’t have to search hard on Google to find way too many. I think there was one in NB or NB last year. Certainly one I recall out West where the judge finally tore strips out the crowns. Blasted them.
And some years ago in Hamilton a guy that had his house firebombed. I think he fired twice. Cops lost their minds. Acted like apes. In the end charges dropped some years later. The guy spent a fortune having to defend himself twice.
Yup. I think the only other way you could do it, is to just give the benefit of the doubt to the home owner. Which is how I think it should be.
So if a guy trespasses and you end up shooting him or killing him inside your property, you should face no charges. If the guy is running away and you shoot him in the back, then yes you should be prosecuted.
The way the law is written in Canada, you are fucked either way. Either by the criminal if you hesitate thinking about the law and its ramifications. Or by the law should you successfully defend that leaves you broke.
It just means there is nothing much a mayor can do in these situations. These crimes are still outliers. Only other thing you can do is scan everyone and their baggages using TTC like at the airport. More policing wont work either. I mean how many police officers per train?
Reality is that although we hear about these things every once in a while, if you pull back and think about it, the TTC is still one of the safest transit systems in the world.
It just means there is nothing much a mayor can do in these situations. These crimes are still outliers. Only other thing you can do is scan everyone and their baggages using TTC like at the airport. More policing wont work either. I mean how many police officers per train?
Reality is that although we hear about these things every once in a while, if you pull back and think about it, the TTC is still one of the safest transit systems in the world.
Not asking for a list. Just saying what I might find justified, others may not.
It's unfortunate that a person would have to spend lots of $$$ to prove his/her point.
So let's do some math. Let's multiply the # of TTC vehicles by the number of runs made by thise vehicles each day. And then we consider that there were two serious violent assaults on the TTC yesterday. Clearly we don't need special constables, security checkpoints or social workers.It’s been many years since I’ve ridden on the TTC. Things have changed, the city’s population being one. Adding more special constables is I’m sure overdue. Don’t need them on every car. Need enough for a visible presence as they patrol. Won’t stop everything ( nothing ever does) but it will help reduce the number of incidents. And they are “nearby” to assist with a lot of things. Kind of like old school but effective policing when beat cops wore out boots..
Problem is, that takes money. Something the city doesn’t have, and residents don’t want to pony up.
Let me see. A guy disarms an assailant and then takes the knife and stabs the assailant 13 times. He was lucky to only get 5 years. "Self defence" ended after the first stab, the second at best.It’s going to take a decade or two and a few dozen very high profile, with lots of headlines and controversy incidents. We can hope that police and crowns find their common sense again. The one I linked from this past winter a perfect example of how they should apply the new law.
Elderly man vs home invader. There’s a nuance ( contributing factor ) there. Some or similar situation say you…a big strapping man in his prime vs a scrawny teen that’s drunk or high and enters the wrong house. Green light to pull the trigger?
Presently, many Canadians are under the misconception they can’t defend themselves. Largely because cops and crowns haven’t used common sense for decades. Or the judge that sentenced a guy to 5 years for taking a knife off an armed invader and stabbing him 13,times. Obviously the cops involved, the crown involved and that judge. Have never, ever been in a situation when their lives were in danger and on the table…would have probably pissed themselves in fright instead of fight.
That should change, and hopefully people will have a sense of what is “acceptable” and what isn’t….So long as cops and crowns use their brains instead of just throwing the book at people.
Let me see. A guy disarms an assailant and then takes the knife and stabs the assailant 13 times. He was lucky to only get 5 years. "Self defence" ended after the first stab, the second at best.
This is standard self-defence law that happens 100 times a day in the courts. Here you go - s.34 of the Criminal Code.
Defence — use or threat of force
- 34(1) A person is not guilty of an offence if
- (a) they believe on reasonable grounds that force is being used against them or another person or that a threat of force is being made against them or another person;
- (b) the act that constitutes the offence is committed for the purpose of defending or protecting themselves or the other person from that use or threat of force; and
- (c) the act committed is reasonable in the circumstances.
- Marginal note:Factors
(2) In determining whether the act committed is reasonable in the circumstances, the court shall consider the relevant circumstances of the person, the other parties and the act, including, but not limited to, the following factors:
- (a) the nature of the force or threat;
- (b) the extent to which the use of force was imminent and whether there were other means available to respond to the potential use of force;
- (c) the person’s role in the incident;
- (d) whether any party to the incident used or threatened to use a weapon;
- (e) the size, age, gender and physical capabilities of the parties to the incident;
- (f) the nature, duration and history of any relationship between the parties to the incident, including any prior use or threat of force and the nature of that force or threat;
- (f.1) any history of interaction or communication between the parties to the incident;
- (g) the nature and proportionality of the person’s response to the use or threat of force; and
- (h) whether the act committed was in response to a use or threat of force that the person knew was lawful.
- Marginal note:No defence
(3) Subsection (1) does not apply if the force is used or threatened by another person for the purpose of doing something that they are required or authorized by law to do in the administration or enforcement of the law, unless the person who commits the act that constitutes the offence believes on reasonable grounds that the other person is acting unlawfully.
If you read any actual court judgments on self defence, you will note lots of phrases like "defensive force cannot be measured to a nicety" and "the fact that the accused was also angry does not affect whether he was genuinely attempting to defend himself". In other words, judges and lawyers know that the situation is messy and chaotic and the participants are on adrenaline and emotional over drive and they give every benefit of the doubt to the one attempting to defend himself. But there are common sense limits to how far anyone can stretch a self defence claim.I have been trying very hard to stay away, step gingerly around any wording that might cross over into gun debates. For someone, if I’m not mistaken ( if I am my bad, right now) who thinks banning guns is the answer. I’m surprised you’re now nonplussed about violent attacks on public transit…the two don’t add up….Make up your mind???? If I’m mistaken about your stance on guns…my bad.
With respect to your post I’m “replying to” and some one stabbing a guy 13 times. In a flight or fight life or death situation.
I will bet your life has never actually been in danger. Because it seems to me, you don’t have any actual experience. With what adrenaline and cortisone do, what the tunnel vision is like. It’s you or the person against you that walks away. You might also beat the front of the line chirping about a cop, who puts 3 or 6 rounds into someone’s torso. And before you say it, yeah I’ve been there…have you?
Then too. I have zero interest in digging up the coroners report from that. Of the 13 stabs. How many were superficial? Not really going to put an end to it?
If you read any actual court judgments on self defence, you will note lots of phrases like "defensive force cannot be measured to a nicety" and "the fact that the accused was also angry does not affect whether he was genuinely attempting to defend himself". In other words, judges and lawyers know that the situation is messy and chaotic and the participants are on adrenaline and emotional over drive and they give every benefit of the doubt to the one attempting to defend himself. But there are common sense limits to how far anyone can stretch a self defence claim.
And regarding my "inconsistent" stance on gun availability and public violence?.... Nah, I'm realistic, not inconsistent.
Tell me how you'd protect the TTC from any incidents of this type and make it cost effective and not massively inconvenient to the ordinary, peaceful 99.9999999999999999999999% of passengers and I'll listen.
I said "cost effective". A couple of security guards at each subway station won't do much and putting them on every subway train is expensive and won't deter a determined assailant. The stabber in yesterday's incident wouldn't care if a security guard was on board.Did you not read? I did say how it would help. It’s called visible presence and show of force.it works…I guess you also believe having cops patrol neighborhoods, being present at concerts, festivals, etc. Also ineffective…you must…Because now your just blowing smoke out your ass because you have a bone to pick.. Or can you just not make up your mind?
And if nothing else.
Trained in CPR. Nah having people like that around might not help…and so much more.
“realistic”
Or just someone that tries to suck and blow at the same time. Can’t really decide where they actually stand?
It’s going to take a decade or two and a few dozen very high profile, with lots of headlines and controversy incidents. We can hope that police and crowns find their common sense again. The one I linked from this past winter a perfect example of how they should apply the new law.
Elderly man vs home invader. There’s a nuance ( contributing factor ) there. Some or similar situation say you…a big strapping man in his prime vs a scrawny teen that’s drunk or high and enters the wrong house. Green light to pull the trigger?
Presently, many Canadians are under the misconception they can’t defend themselves. Largely because cops and crowns haven’t used common sense for decades. Or the judge that sentenced a guy to 5 years for taking a knife off an armed invader and stabbing him 13,times. Obviously the cops involved, the crown involved and that judge. Have never, ever been in a situation when their lives were in danger and on the table…would have probably pissed themselves in fright instead of fight.
That should change, and hopefully people will have a sense of what is “acceptable” and what isn’t….So long as cops and crowns use their brains instead of just throwing the book at people.
People won't like this answer but...... in the scenario you mention, yes I pull the trigger. You trespass on my property be prepared to pay the consequences.
I hate when people start making excuses. Oh he was high on drugs, he has a mental illness. I don't give a fuck. You are responsible for you.
I have no kids or other people living here.You do know I hope there are dozens. If not hundreds of such instances out of the states.
I seriously feel bad for you, and your daughter when you kill her BF late one night.
When homeowners are scared of things that go bump in the night.
I have no kids or other people living here.
What would give a BF the right to enter my home without knocking and waiting for an answer?