Eglinton Stabbing

  • Like
Reactions: Dragon77
This one doesn't concern me as much as the other random attacks and killings. Maybe the two knew each other, maybe they didn't. If you want to lessen your chances of getting hurt, don't punch someone in the head. This however doesn't change the fact that it erodes public confidence with regard to safety on the TTC and makes more people want to drive.

don’t mistake me, but um.
Have they considered that the chances of creamed in the city roads/highways, still greatly outweigh the chances of getting attacked on the TTC

One gets headlines, the other doesn’t.
 
Looks like the only way to defend yourself these days is to just to keep your mouth shut and leave the scene, because who knows what the guy may do. Or wear a stab vest or something.



The fact that he even produced a knife would probably nullify his self defence claims. BTW isn't pepper spray illegal to carry in Canada?

Yea it is. It’s considered a restricted weapon or some such nonsense. I think the fine print depends on “where”. I carry it when in the bush up north. Which for city people means well north of cottage country. Around people, in Public n the city. You’re likely in a world of trouble.
 
I'm not a lawyer but I think once you have a prohibited weapon on you and use it regardless if he didn't hunt the guy down to add in some more knife wounds, your self defense claim goes out the window. I believe the victim in this case did throw the first haymakers and enraged the stabber who looked like he was about to get a beatdown.

The victim probably has been training in the local dojo and wanted to try out his moves but paid the price.

Um no.
legally we are allowed to use as much force as is necessary to remove the threat. Killing someone slapping you is hardly self defence.

You can shoot someone that breaks into your house. The implied threat of coming into your home…….warrants more force. But if dead body is at the bottom of the stairs and you are upstairs. Hope you have $1,000,000 to fight the charges. And no how the crime scene looks. In almost all cases you have the book thrown at you…years later charges dropped or acquitted. But your still broke.

As much force as is necessary to remove the the threat.

Right/wrong I have no bone. But that is how police read it, and crowns prosecute it.
 
Last edited:
Canadian self defense law,

Canadians have a right to defend their property or themselves as long as their defensive actions are reasonable under the circumstances. This means that if you injure an intruder entering your home or property, you would need to show that the circumstances gave you no other reasonable choice.

Kind of wishy washy and very open to interpretation to what someone deems "reasonable"
 
Canadian self defense law,

Canadians have a right to defend their property or themselves as long as their defensive actions are reasonable under the circumstances. This means that if you injure an intruder entering your home or property, you would need to show that the circumstances gave you no other reasonable choice.

Kind of wishy washy and very open to interpretation to what someone deems "reasonable"
Yeah, still very grey. Open to a ton of interpretation. It’s also been changed fairly recently. Last I read it ( handful of years ago) it was the old “as much force as necessary”

Old
Reasonable in the circumstances"
Under the old laws, the measure for acceptable defensive force was articulated in various ways. In some versions of the defence it was framed as "no more force than necessary" or "as much force as is necessary"

If I had to guess too many cases were being lost, charges dropped and homeowners being broke. Police will still throw the book if a gun isinvolved. But a small woman at home bs a man in the house. Well charges might be dropped faster.

However, under the new law, the nature and degree of the threat may impact differently upon the determination of whether the accused genuinely responded with a defensive purpose (under paragraph 34(1)(b) [/b]

.
 
Canadian self defense law,

Canadians have a right to defend their property or themselves as long as their defensive actions are reasonable under the circumstances. This means that if you injure an intruder entering your home or property, you would need to show that the circumstances gave you no other reasonable choice.

Kind of wishy washy and very open to interpretation to what someone deems "reasonable"

There's almost no other way to write it though.
You can't make an exhaustive list because eventually something that isn't on the list will come up and people will have to make a judgment call anyway.

"The community finds it reasonable under the circumstances" is about all you can hope for.
 
There's almost no other way to write it though.
You can't make an exhaustive list because eventually something that isn't on the list will come up and people will have to make a judgment call anyway.

"The community finds it reasonable under the circumstances" is about all you can hope for.

Agreed
There are a number of laws where I like the fact it’s grey. As opposed to blackwhite, rule of the law. It gives cops some discretion whether or not to proceed.

Too often though in Canada, when someone defends themselves or their property (houses). They just have the book thrown at them. When some common sense might have prevailed.

Don’t have to search hard on Google to find way too many. I think there was one in NB or NB last year. Certainly one I recall out West where the judge finally tore strips out the crowns. Blasted them.

And some years ago in Hamilton a guy that had his house firebombed. I think he fired twice. Cops lost their minds. Acted like apes. In the end charges dropped some years later. The guy spent a fortune having to defend himself twice.
 
They’re lucky they can run away on line 1. If this happened on line 2, everyone is fucked in the train car
He was stabbing one person, no evidence he was stabbing random people. Most homeless have knives and will use them. They don't care about a criminal record or doing some time.
 
There's almost no other way to write it though.
You can't make an exhaustive list because eventually something that isn't on the list will come up and people will have to make a judgment call anyway.

"The community finds it reasonable under the circumstances" is about all you can hope for.

Not asking for a list. Just saying what I might find justified, others may not.
It's unfortunate that a person would have to spend lots of $$$ to prove his/her point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
This is correct. Spot on Phil.
If he stabbed the dude who attacked him - total self defense. Once the assailant fled...he no longer had that right to chase and stab. Attempted murder is right.
Plea to "aggravated assault". 8 to 10 years Pen. That's my guess. Guy will be arrested in a day or two.