Lately it's been in the news that the federal government could receive a windfall if they made the GST applicable to everything (i.e., removed the exemptions for food, books, etc.). My question is related but not specifically about that.
If the government chose to completely eliminate income tax and instead moved to a consumption based taxation system (i.e., you pay higher GST, or whatever it will be called, on everything but you pay zero income tax), while that provides an incentive for people to earn more, does that necessarily translate into higher (or at least offsetting) consumption tax revenue?
What I'm getting at is that I suspect a significant chunk of people (or, at least a significant chunk of people that have lots of disposable income) will put more money towards savings/investments rather than spend it. Sure many people will spend more, but will they spend enough to offset the loss in government revenue from income tax? This would be especially problematic if the wealthier part of the population invested their money offshore.
Or does the Investment component of the economic equation plus the (expected) increase in Consumption more than make up for the lost income taxes?
At it's simplest I would be worried (if I was the government) that people would say thanks for my income taxes back but I'm not going to spend 100% of that so in the end the government loses (which means we all lose when it comes to services, or we face greater deficits/debt).
Thoughts?
(p.s., this isn't a thread about how we shouldn't pay taxes at all, or how government wastes our tax money, or how we should have a flat income tax, it's about the idea of moving to a consumption-based tax system)
If the government chose to completely eliminate income tax and instead moved to a consumption based taxation system (i.e., you pay higher GST, or whatever it will be called, on everything but you pay zero income tax), while that provides an incentive for people to earn more, does that necessarily translate into higher (or at least offsetting) consumption tax revenue?
What I'm getting at is that I suspect a significant chunk of people (or, at least a significant chunk of people that have lots of disposable income) will put more money towards savings/investments rather than spend it. Sure many people will spend more, but will they spend enough to offset the loss in government revenue from income tax? This would be especially problematic if the wealthier part of the population invested their money offshore.
Or does the Investment component of the economic equation plus the (expected) increase in Consumption more than make up for the lost income taxes?
At it's simplest I would be worried (if I was the government) that people would say thanks for my income taxes back but I'm not going to spend 100% of that so in the end the government loses (which means we all lose when it comes to services, or we face greater deficits/debt).
Thoughts?
(p.s., this isn't a thread about how we shouldn't pay taxes at all, or how government wastes our tax money, or how we should have a flat income tax, it's about the idea of moving to a consumption-based tax system)

