Economics Question re: Taxation

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
Lately it's been in the news that the federal government could receive a windfall if they made the GST applicable to everything (i.e., removed the exemptions for food, books, etc.). My question is related but not specifically about that.

If the government chose to completely eliminate income tax and instead moved to a consumption based taxation system (i.e., you pay higher GST, or whatever it will be called, on everything but you pay zero income tax), while that provides an incentive for people to earn more, does that necessarily translate into higher (or at least offsetting) consumption tax revenue?

What I'm getting at is that I suspect a significant chunk of people (or, at least a significant chunk of people that have lots of disposable income) will put more money towards savings/investments rather than spend it. Sure many people will spend more, but will they spend enough to offset the loss in government revenue from income tax? This would be especially problematic if the wealthier part of the population invested their money offshore.

Or does the Investment component of the economic equation plus the (expected) increase in Consumption more than make up for the lost income taxes?

At it's simplest I would be worried (if I was the government) that people would say thanks for my income taxes back but I'm not going to spend 100% of that so in the end the government loses (which means we all lose when it comes to services, or we face greater deficits/debt).

Thoughts?

(p.s., this isn't a thread about how we shouldn't pay taxes at all, or how government wastes our tax money, or how we should have a flat income tax, it's about the idea of moving to a consumption-based tax system)
 
There are a few nations that have no income tax. Costa Rica is one. There it is import taxes, property taxes. CR is now debating whether or not to impose income taxes because of a shortfall of income for the gov't.

I would think that a GST only tax would lead to the most improvished suffering the most, as they have no choice in consumption. This would probably lead to an even greater have/have not society. As it stands now we are probably paying close to 50% of our income going to taxes (income, GST, gov't fees ect.) in one way or another.

With the demands we as a society make on government I can't see how anything less than 50% of our income going to gov't will change.
 
Such a move would make the govt revenue stream far more unpredictable and may impact the govts ability to raise funds

Consumers would have the discretion to spend less and impact the govt revenues

Investors buy govt bonds at the risk free rate because they know the govt can raise taxes if needed
They also have several venues to apply increases as needed. Personal, Corp and consumption taxes
If there was only consumption taxes a 100bp change would be very significant and politically difficult to manage
Also what is the rate 40% , 45%, 65% on top or every sale ?

Since Canada's economy is export driven, the govt would lose all the payroll taxes related to producing a barrel of oil, pound of copper or bushel of wheat, yet not be able to collect the consumption tax if that commodity is sold into an export market

Finally the current system of payroll taxes ensure the govt obtains their cut at the source
While there is lots of underground employment, the lost revenue as a result of undisclosed sales is far more difficult to monitor.
The payroll system is probably also easier to administer as it is
There has been wide spread dissatisfaction with the GST process
 
You'd see a more cash based world. You'd see a lot more black market goods and services. Part of the economic issue in Greece is this exact situation. First off, to eliminate income taxes, which are roughly putting 30-40% of your salary in the government coffers every paycheque, the user based tax would have to be.. 30-40%, just to be equal.

How many times have you gone to a mechanic, a service provider, a construction guy and had them say 'It's $1000 but if you pay cash, you can save the tax.' Do you honestly think this transaction is on the books? They aren't paying tax on it, they're pocketing the $1000.

Have you ever gone into a mom and pop convenience store, bought some gum and had the guy punch some number so the display on the cash register says the price, but when you leave he clears the amount and throws the cash in the machine? I see it every single day. They're collecting the 'price plus tax' but not paying that tax to the government. They're using it as 'profit'.

This style 'underground' economy is already taking billions of dollars out of the real world economy every year.

Right now they're willing to do this for 13%. Can you imagine how widespread this would be if they were able to now put 40% into their own profits?

The government would be in ruin in under a year. Unless the penalties imposed for 'catching' someone doing this were just so substantial that there was no benefit.. but collecting that penalty would probably put your local garage, handyman and convenience store out of business.
 
All the government would have to do to go to a consumption tax is to allow you to deduct all the income you save from your income tax return (and adding what you take out of your savings to spend). If the government did this, you would end up only paying tax on the income you spent on consumption. However, the advantage it would have over other consumption taxes like the GST is that you could make it progressive if you wanted to.

Generally, taxing consumption is better for economic growth than taxing income. However, the timing of the revenue is different. You collect income tax during a person’s working life (particularly their peak earning years). Consumption taxes are collected throughout a person’s life. As long as you treat bequests between generations in an equivalent way in both systems, a person should end up paying the same tax over their lifetime (assuming you pick revenue neutral tax rates and ignoring indirect differences in tax collected due to economic growth, etc.)
 
A specifically Canadian aspect of the 'all-consumption tax' model is how close most of us live to an international border that's still relatively open.