Dwyane Wade vs. Kobe

zydeco

Active member
Aug 16, 2003
1,493
1
38
Who would you take in a straight up trade? Both phenomenal athletes - at this point I think I'd take Wade.
 
Until Wade wins the big one, Kobe has the nod.
 
Both are out-of-this-world good but Wade has the mental make-up to work with other great players. Kobe couldn't get along with Shaq. End of story.

Toronto could of got Wade in the draft but chose Bosh instead. At the moment, Bosh is good but Wade is something else.

zydeco said:
Who would you take in a straight up trade? Both phenomenal athletes - at this point I think I'd take Wade.
 
It does seem like there is a serious potential upside with Wade - a gifted young player who is both coachable and whose game is team oriented.
 
Wade is definitely a special playa and in time he’ll be one of the best in the league but IMO he sure turns the ball over allot when he gets to fancy. I guess it’s alright cause he is still learning the game.

I also think that Kobe lost a step after the trial. He looks like he tried to bulk-up again and I don’t think his style of game works when he’s 20lbs heavier.

They are both amazing players but I think I’d go with Kobe if I had to choose. Besides the fact that he cant play with other great players…. F&^%, I guess that sums it up, if he cant play with other players I don’t want him…. I’ll take wade
 
zydeco said:
It does seem like there is a serious potential upside with Wade - a gifted young player who is both coachable and whose game is team oriented.

I think the key words here are "potential upside" and "coachable". I know it seems Kobe has been in the league for a long time, but he is still only 27, 4 years older than Wade. He's a great player, but I don't see him getting demonstrably better. Wade, on the other hand, is a very good player, and I can certainly see him getting even better.

My biggest knock on Kobe was his inability to get along with Shaq and Phil Jackson. I know everyone has an ego, but it just seems incomprehensible that someone could be so insecure and selfish, as to not be able to see that he is better off playing with the game's best big man, and with arguably, the game's best coach, than not.
 
Very true homonger - the Lakers could have had a reasonable shot at 2 or 3 more titles.
 
John_E_Depth said:
Wade is definitely a special playa and in time he’ll be one of the best in the league but IMO he sure turns the ball over allot when he gets to fancy. I guess it’s alright cause he is still learning the game.

I also think that Kobe lost a step after the trial. He looks like he tried to bulk-up again and I don’t think his style of game works when he’s 20lbs heavier.

They are both amazing players but I think I’d go with Kobe if I had to choose. Besides the fact that he cant play with other great players…. F&^%, I guess that sums it up, if he cant play with other players I don’t want him…. I’ll take wade

Right on. Kobe was DEADLY when he was a skinny player. I have never seen a player can score so quick like Kobe does (well let's not bring young MJ or AI in the picture here..).

I think that Kobe is better player than Wade. Wade has to accomplish lot more to gain Kobe level of respect. Wade is coachable and Kobe is not. But lot of ballers respect Kobe's game and skill. But if I was GM of Raptors and both players are willing to play for us and I have enough $ for only one of them, then I'll choose Kobe. Kobe will bring lot of marketing power. At the same time, we need someone who can score 30+ points nightly basis.
 
Wade no doubt.

stang5 said:
Both are out-of-this-world good but Wade has the mental make-up to work with other great players. Kobe couldn't get along with Shaq. End of story.

Toronto could of got Wade in the draft but chose Bosh instead. At the moment, Bosh is good but Wade is something else.

When Bosh and Wade were available for the draft Toronto didn't need Wade, they were a somewhat guard heavy team. They picked the player they needed at the time.

Always in the Groove...
 
close call...

But I'd take Wade. Even though Kobe is only 27- he's been in the L for 9 yrs. I think here's pretty much reached his peak as far as his personal game is concerned. If anything, his game has declined the past year. Part of the reason was due to the stress and distraction of the trial, and part of it was Shaq's departure. He's still a superstar player, but I wonder how much more his game will improve...if at all.

As for Wade, he's shown that he can also dominate a game (w/ or w/out Shaq in the line-up) by scoring, rebounding, dishing, steals and blocking shots(best shot blocking guard in the L) .In terms of accumalated total production per game, Wade had a higher score this past yr than Kobe. Wade is also equally as athletic as Kobe. And for such a young player, Wade makes alot of big time clutch shots. He does commit alot of turnover's though, but that's partly due to lack of experience- they will go down as he plays more games. As for Kobe winning more championships, I personally don't hold too much weight into that statistic when talking about a player's game. Kobe hasn't even shown that he can lead his team to the playoff's w/ out Shaq yet, so that right there tells me who was more important to the Laker's 3peat.

Bottom line- they both give you about the same kind of production right now, but Wade's game has alot more upside. And he doesn't trip over his own ego when he walks. Take Dwayne.
 
Wade gets the nod in my books. Younger, coachable, teamplayer and cheaper since he's been in the league for a shorter period of time. As for marketability he really just needs to string two good seasons together and he will be considered a star/real deal.
 
Wade is only "coachable" because he doesn't have the big contract yet. Bosh is coachable for the same reason. Big question is if Bosh will stay with the Raptors after his 3 year contract is over. Will he be coachable then? Kobe was coachable in his first coupla years in the league. Other recent examples, Vince and McGrady. Once they got the big contract, not coachable anymore.

I like Wade and enjoy watching him play. Wait & see if he's still coachable 2-3 years from now.
 
I agreed with most your pro-Wade comments. He looks very coachable, tough(both physically and mentally) and has all the neccessary skills to be an elite star. I love his demeanor and his overall balance to the game....so you know who I prefer.

In saying that, I doubt Wade would this good had the Raps taken him. I think his development would be a little slower playing in the Raps losing environment. Plus we don't have a center like Shaq who would make his teammates better at their game.

Speaking of Raps...anyone has any thoughts on who they'll pick at 7th? I just hope they don't pull another Araujo.
 
Wow...this is close...really close...

In my mind it is closer than some of you pro Wade guys are making it.

Wade is one hell of a player. Amazing. Unbelieveable.

Kobe is...Kobe.

Hmmm....

Kobe is taller, the better outside shooter, and when he is in the mood, the better defender.

Wade appears to be the better person and teammate, and probably could become as good a defender as Kobe from a technique and effort stand point. But there is no substitue for height / length / wingspan

Hmmm....

If Kobe weren't such an ass, it wouldn't be as close. He's the better shooter, defender, is taller, and has won championships.

Hmmm....

If the question is "which would you want to build a team"..as in everyone who mentioned the Raptors, I think I take Wade.

But if the question is "who would you take right now to win a championship"...adding one more player to a team that is already a 45 - 50 win contender...and it is a situation where Kobe would be the man, no question...I'd take Kobe. All else being equal, he is the (marginally) better player, with more experience, and maybe...just maybe if I am a lucky GM...a chip on his shoulder and something to prove.

Wade for the future.

Kobe to win it all right now.

Of course, if Miami wins it all this time it is Wade, period...LOL
 
Last edited:
Interesting points MLAM - but keep in mind that the Lakers had Shaq and Kobe last year and failed to "win it all right now".
 
Sure...

zydeco said:
Interesting points MLAM - but keep in mind that the Lakers had Shaq and Kobe last year and failed to "win it all right now".

...but Kobe wasn't the man last year in LA, Malone was hurt, and Payton's expiry date had passed during the off season without him telling anyone.

Really, if Malone is healthy, the Lakers win it last season. They just do.

I'll stick with my pick - if I have a good but not great team that needs someone to come in, be the man (that is key - Kobe has to be the man...)and TAKE US THERE...I'm taking Kobe, and betting that he is a man on a mission with something to prove.

It might be just me, but I think it says something about Kobe (who IS intelligent if nothing else...not every NBA player can say that) that he is prepared to have Phil Jackson come back and coach the lakers, even after Phil ripped him in his book. it says that Kobe might be capable of saying "I want to win, and I will do whatever it takes - including play for a man I don't like because he knows how to best coach both me and other NBA talent".

I've seen Wade when he is on, and he is amazing, but I've seen Kobe when he is on, and that is an act of God...
 
I'm not sure about all that "the man" stuff - but I think Jackson left largely because of Kobe in the first place.