Dropped ceiling or drywall ceiling for the basement.

Dropped ceiling or drywall, which looks better

  • Use the drywall, dropped ceilings look like crap

    Votes: 23 59.0%
  • Dropped ceilings look better.

    Votes: 10 25.6%
  • They are both roughly the same looks wise

    Votes: 3 7.7%
  • I was promised cookies, me want cookie now!

    Votes: 3 7.7%

  • Total voters
    39

Anynym

Just a bit to the right
Dec 28, 2005
2,959
6
38
Sounds like the advice you want would be better provided by calling a residential real estate agent in your area and asking what a Drop Ceiling versus Drywall does to the resale value of homes in your area.

Personally, I can't see it affecting the valuation by more than a couple hundred bucks either way, but that's me.
 

FatOne

Banned
Nov 20, 2006
3,474
1
0
Sounds like the advice you want would be better provided by calling a residential real estate agent in your area and asking what a Drop Ceiling versus Drywall does to the resale value of homes in your area.

Personally, I can't see it affecting the valuation by more than a couple hundred bucks either way, but that's me.
That is also in the plans.
 

rgkv

old timer
Nov 14, 2005
4,117
1,680
113
What kind of aggravation are you talking about specifically? If the plumbing and electrical work is done correctly the first time, then there is nothing to fix later.
there's always somerthing to fix later, weather it be age, a bad plumbimg job, kids spilling water out the tub, men missing {not me though} all that sorta stuff......fixed lots and lots of these ceilings im my day, can be expensive repairs somethimes, especially if you get into stipple and stuff, just saying,,,,,,can save your self alot of aggravation with a BASEMENT ceiling
 

Moraff

Active member
Nov 14, 2003
3,648
0
36
Another consideration might be what the basement will be used for. If it's for a kids playroom, a teen's bedroom or even your entertainment room (big screen TV, stereo, etc.) you may want to consider the drywall as it is more soundproof than a dropped ceiling. There is a product out now called "Quiet Rock" which combines qualities of both drywall and a sound deadenng material together.
Good plan. In my case the master bedroom was over the basement recroom so I also installed a nice layer of Roxul's Safe-n-sound mineral fibre insulation in the ceiling. Now even if the tv is uncomfortably loud (for me anyways) you can hardly hear anything in the bedroom.
 

Moraff

Active member
Nov 14, 2003
3,648
0
36
The hardwired SD mount to a junction box.

I do agree though that it's best to do the job properly and eliminate junction boxes.

I was in a basement recently where a Contractor friend of mine is working. I've never seen a bigger electrical disaster in my life.

House is circa 1920, and it's got hot knob and tube, wiring from the 50's and 60's and a pile of Romex hanging everywhere. Totally shit job, terrible. The whole house needs to be rewired, but the owner thinks he's good to go. Some people amaze me with how stupid they are.
With live knob and tube I'm surprised his insurance company will insure him. My friend bought a house with it and the insurance company said you have x days to replace it or you're cut-off.
 

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,070
4,005
113
With live knob and tube I'm surprised his insurance company will insure him. My friend bought a house with it and the insurance company said you have x days to replace it or you're cut-off.
I live in High Park. I can ASSURE you that 80% or more of the houses around here are still utilizing some or all knob and tube.

I have a bit left, but it's in a room I'm going to tear down in the very near future, so no big problem.

Usually the problem with KnT is:

1. Crappy insulation that turns to charcoal over time and falls away.

2. No ground.

3. Not enough circuits

4. It's been fucked with.

5. Taped joints.

But the knobs and tubes are a great fucking idea.
 

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,070
4,005
113
Back then we had those stapled on 12"x12" ceiling tiles!
Yes they were.

Fake paneling, flourescent tube lighthing, 12 x 12 stapled ceiling tiles, shag or indoor / outdoor carpet with no underpad.

Yay, those were the days.

Oh, and a console 26" colour TV (that replaced the Admiral Black and White job)
 

Tangwhich

New member
Jan 26, 2004
2,261
0
0
I live in High Park. I can ASSURE you that 80% or more of the houses around here are still utilizing some or all knob and tube.

I have a bit left, but it's in a room I'm going to tear down in the very near future, so no big problem.
You're right that there's lots of houses with it, but from what I've seen when someone buys a place with it, the insurance makes the new owner upgrade. Same deal with 60A services. It may not be universal, but I know it's very common.
 

rgkv

old timer
Nov 14, 2005
4,117
1,680
113
Friend of mine just got a house through an inheritance, in the Main and Gerard area, home owners insurance came over, had a look and said, "no insurance till you change the knob and tube".


I have been trying to erase the second Main in the sentence about, on my message there is only one main, and when I erase one they both disappear
 

Bif_Butkiss

Active member
Apr 1, 2004
1,304
0
36
Toronto
Good plan. In my case the master bedroom was over the basement recroom so I also installed a nice layer of Roxul's Safe-n-sound mineral fibre insulation in the ceiling. Now even if the tv is uncomfortably loud (for me anyways) you can hardly hear anything in the bedroom.
Roxul has some great products. They are easier to use and more use specific over traditonal materials (pink fibreglass).
 

T.O.tourist

Just Me
Dec 5, 2008
1,732
0
36
Back to the original post
Strictly on a looks basis, which is better for a residential basement.
Strictly on a looks basis properly finished drywalled ceilings look much better. IMO drop ceilings look to industrial/office like.

I could add much more about properly installing and making sure your plumbing, HVAC and electrical have proper access points (yes this is possible even with drywall). I could further add ways to ensure that your plumbing/ electrical and HVAC should not need access points.
But you wanted to know which looks better, and esthetically drywall looks better.
However you could take the advice of other posts and believe that your place needs so much work (has anyone seen it), that you may as well tear the whole place down and hire Mike Holmes to build from new. LOL
 
Toronto Escorts