Dropped ceiling or drywall ceiling for the basement.

Dropped ceiling or drywall, which looks better

  • Use the drywall, dropped ceilings look like crap

    Votes: 23 59.0%
  • Dropped ceilings look better.

    Votes: 10 25.6%
  • They are both roughly the same looks wise

    Votes: 3 7.7%
  • I was promised cookies, me want cookie now!

    Votes: 3 7.7%

  • Total voters
    39

FatOne

Banned
Nov 20, 2006
3,474
1
0
Strictly on a looks basis, which is better for a residential basement.

There is a bit of a difference of opinion in the household, and I am wondering if there is some consensus on the issue in the outside world.
 
Drywall - strictly for looks. I'm partial to flat ceilings, no stucco. I do my own Drywall. When I compound, I use the mesh tape, do a joint coat, then 2 top coats. Use a Troublelight when sanding holding it at different angles to highlight the imperfections in the compound. First sand with 80 grit, then a quick pass with 120.

Use 5/8" to avoid sagging.

The only advantage (and it's a fucking huge advantage) is that if you want to get to the underside of the floor - it's simple and easy. (To run cables, fix pipes, whatever.)

Strictly looks though - Drywall
 
Forget looks, drop ceilings are useful to get to the plumbing and wiring. I would not seal the basement ceiling up with drywall. Pipes leak, wiring gets old. How would you shut off the outside water in the fall? What happens if you want to blow out the ducts for the house? You should see all the dust that comes out of them.
 
Forget looks, drop ceilings are useful to get to the plumbing and wiring. I would not seal the basement ceiling up with drywall. Pipes leak, wiring gets old. How would you shut off the outside water in the fall? What happens if you want to blow out the ducts for the house? You should see all the dust that comes out of them.

By that argument we shouldn't bother putting drywall on the walls either then. Re shutting off water: You'd be an idiot if you drywalled over your valves w/o putting an access door in. Re cleaning ducts... don't think I've ever seen anyone who drywalled their mechanical room to the point of bulkheading around the ductwork. So there's your access for cleaning.

One thing to watch... if you have any electrical junction boxes in the ceiling you aren't allowed to hide them behind drywall.
 
^^^^ Sometimes you can put a 120 volt AC Smoke Detector there. (Cut a hole in the Drywall, then cover the hole with the SD, hooked to the 120v.

Should be legal then.
 
I have never had a drywall ceiling in the basement that I did not have to put holes in to fix a leak, or run wires. But it can be patched rather easily.
Most people can put up a dropped ceiling ,where putting up drywall so you can not see every seam, is difficult if your not a pro.
Drywall around low hanging ducts is nicer and I believe drywall can usually leave more head room.
So i am still in favour of drywall, just make sure the person doing it, is good. And do not bury any electrical boxes.
 
^^^^ Sometimes you can put a 120 volt AC Smoke Detector there. (Cut a hole in the Drywall, then cover the hole with the SD, hooked to the 120v.

Should be legal then.

Unless the SD is mounted to the junction box I do not believe so, unless - perhaps - the hole the SD covers is large enough to allow access to the junction box. And while that would be a great plan if you have only the one, I know when I renovated my rec. room I discovered the previous owner had drywalled over approximately a dozen junction boxes. (must have been a sale on - lol)

Another consideration would be what ceiling height you are working with. If you have a low basement, losing a few more inches to a drop ceiling may be unappealing.
 
The hardwired SD mount to a junction box.

I do agree though that it's best to do the job properly and eliminate junction boxes.

I was in a basement recently where a Contractor friend of mine is working. I've never seen a bigger electrical disaster in my life.

House is circa 1920, and it's got hot knob and tube, wiring from the 50's and 60's and a pile of Romex hanging everywhere. Totally shit job, terrible. The whole house needs to be rewired, but the owner thinks he's good to go. Some people amaze me with how stupid they are.
 
Another consideration might be what the basement will be used for. If it's for a kids playroom, a teen's bedroom or even your entertainment room (big screen TV, stereo, etc.) you may want to consider the drywall as it is more soundproof than a dropped ceiling. There is a product out now called "Quiet Rock" which combines qualities of both drywall and a sound deadenng material together.
 
Drywall by far looks better and gives more value for resale. If you do the plumbing and electrical right and don't cut corners and install to code, you should have no problems, I never have. Agree to use 5/8 in thick drywall to prevent rippling over time.
 
Drywall by far looks better and gives more value for resale.

We can go either way in terms of other considerations, but I am conserned about resale value. I happen to think dropped ceilings look cheap but I could live with it, however if it would hurt resale value of the house, I`d be more inclined to go drywall. However it isn`t 100% up to me, so I figure I`d poll the masses.
 
Cheap ceiling tiles look cheap, so does cheap drywall, especially after it was cheaply patched because someone wanted to hide speaker cables, or was poorly painted after the dishwasher leaked.

It's a basesement, no one will be fooled. It's the closest thing most homes have to a utility shaft/corridor/room. Someone will be digging into that ballroom quality surface, even if it isn't you. Because the services for the entire house are distributed across that ceiling. Drywalling it is a little like having your mechanic weld your hood shut. Choose what you want, but nmake sure you have figured out how to cope with that future digger. Drywal/plaster does repair easily in a lwo tech way, but finding the low tech guy with the skills to do it on a small job is an art

What's your ceiling clearance gonna be, and how are you intending to deal with the ducts and other things that drop below the average? There's real art to dealing with drops and interruptions so they don't look clumsy. The lower the ceiling, the worse anything but a really good drywall job will look. Tracks and tiles can be tweaked, as well as used for access.
 
There is one other possibility.....

If you have a laundry room in the basement (because that's where they belong and not on the main floor like so many gullible people today opt for) and a furnace room - you leave the furnace room ceiling bare, bringing the phone and cable and Cat 6 and alarms all into the furnace room.

Laundry room - install a drop ceiling, which gives you further acces. Try to position the furnace room / laundry room such that they pick up any plumbing stacks or pipe runs, etc.

But the main part of the basement - go drywall cause it looks much better, and adds value (if a finished basement even adds value to a house).

In this fashion, you will still have access to at least 20 to 30% of your basement ceiling for utilities should you need to.

You can also run empty electrical conduits in the drywalled ceiling cavity if you think you may need a wire here or there in the future.
 
Are you doing the work yourself, or hiring somebody? Drywall is heavy. It's a hard job, even with two people, and plastering can be tricky if you're not experienced.
 
Are you doing the work yourself, or hiring somebody? Drywall is heavy. It's a hard job, even with two people, and plastering can be tricky if you're not experienced.

We are aware of the other issues. It is probably one of the bigger reasons why the dropped ceiling is under consideration at all.
 
been in the business 40 years....wanna save aggravation later.....drop ceiling, there are nice tiles out there...its faster, clearner, cheaper, everythings accessable, and most can do themselves.....


sorry, should add, best in full or almost full height ceilings....you need about 2" from the bottom of your joist to the underside of the tile
 
Part of the appeal of drywall is you normally end up with a higher ceiling , so really before I'd answer your question with an opinion I'd want to know how high is your ceiling now ?
 
I have seen a few basements that are mostly drywalled ceilings but have high end tiles in a few sections in the centre of the room. Best of both worlds.
 
Your expensive finished basement will not look like just another part of your home, it will look like the set from Wayne's World!

wayne06.jpg

Me and everyone I grew up with in the 70's had a basement pretty much just like the above.

Sniff, brings back memories.