Does Fuji speak for you?

Does Fuji speak for you?

  • Fuji Speaks for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%
  • Fuji does not speak for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%

  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
You must learn to read:

"The ICRC commentary on the Fourth Geneva Convention makes clear that Article 49 (6), like the convention as a whole, aims to protect the local population in the occupied territory and not the population of the occupying state. Furthermore, international humanitarian law prohibits any action by an occupying power aimed at altering the intrinsic characteristics of the occupied territory, including any measures that affect its demographic, cultural or social composition.

Contrary to what the Levy report maintains, from the viewpoint of international law the West Bank is occupied by Israel. This assertion, like the ICRC's position that the Israeli settlements in the West Bank are unlawful, is based entirely on the relevant provisions of international humanitarian law".[33]"

Hopefully, you won't continue to repeat what you know to be false.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levy_Repor

That is an allegation against the "occupying power". Note that saying the occupied population is not protected by the transfer rule does not mean they have lost their status as civilians or that they aren't protected from armed attack under the Geneva Convention.

You are just repeating yourself after having been thoroughly refuted.
 
That is an allegation against the "occupying power". Note that saying the occupied population is not protected by the transfer rule does not mean they have lost their status as civilians or that they aren't protected from armed attack under the Geneva Convention.

You are just repeating yourself after having been thoroughly refuted.

Oh....capitulation has begun. Looks like having the ICRC identify the settlements as illegal has got you back peddling. You always fold when challenged.
 
Back on topic:

The settlers are not accused of doing anything illegal, and in any case they are protected from attack under the Geneva Convention as civilians.

Attacks on settlers are grievous war crimes.
 
Back on topic:

The settlers are not accused of doing anything illegal, and in any case they are protected from attack under the Geneva Convention as civilians.

Attacks on settlers are grievous war crimes.

No, the settlements are illegal. The Geneva Convention does not protect the violation of the Geneva Convention.
 
No, the settlements are illegal. The Geneva Convention does not protect the violation of the Geneva Convention.

You can hold your breath until you are blue in the face, stamp your feet, and cry. It will still be a war crime to attack civilians.
 
You can hold your breath until you are blue in the face, stamp your feet, and cry. It will still be a war crime to attack civilians.

They are only civilians if they aren't involved in attacks.
And given that they are IDF armed and settlers regularly take part in IDF backed attacks on farms and civilians, that claim doesn't hold water.
 
They are only civilians if they aren't involved in attacks.
And given that they are IDF armed and settlers regularly take part in IDF backed attacks on farms and civilians, that claim doesn't hold water.

That is like saying that Palestinians aren't civilians because Iran armed them with missiles and they take part in attacks on Israel.

Only those few who take part in attacks lose their convention protection as civilians, and only while they are participating in the attacks.

Keep justifying terror and war crime, you claim to oppose it now and then but then you post things like this where you terrorist mentality comes through loud and clear.
 
You can hold your breath until you are blue in the face, stamp your feet, and cry. It will still be a war crime to attack civilians.

Why would I when the Geneva Convention does not protect those violating the a Geneva Convention?
 
Notes from the Freedom Bus movement in the Occupied Territories:
The minutiae of the occupation are even more frightening than the more gross realities. To cite one example, in Jiftik, the largest village in the Jordan Valley (which gained access to electricity only a few years ago), residents are prohibited from digging wells deeper than 80m, while settlements are allowed to dig 10 and even 20 times as deep. As a result of these long-term policies, the local water supply has become so brackish that it's unusable for most crops.

On the land they do farm, Palestinians are routinely prevented from using most modern fertilisers or pesticides. "This leads to poor crops," an activist explained. "Then the Israelis compare [our crops] to their well-watered, fertilised crops to show how modern they are." Even successful crops often face insurmountable obstacles to reach a market, as Israeli corporations establish monopolies on processing products such as local dates (Palestinians are prohibited from owning the machinery that would allow them to process it themselves) or watermelons and then import cheaper produce from abroad, effectively destroying local industry.

The situation is similar in the Hebron Hills region of southern West Bank. In just the few days of our stay in the village of Atwani, settlers twice attacked young children on the way to school with slingshots, an olive grove was uprooted, shepherds were harassed, a Palestinian worker died after falling while being chased by Israeli police, and settlers destroyed solar panels provided to unelectrified hamlets by an Israeli NGO.

In the central or northern West Bank, Israel has expropriated much of the best agricultural land for settlements such as Ma'on, located just metres from Atwani. In a familiar story, Israel has only recently allowed water and electricity to the village; their provision is still scant and expensive. And Atwani is relatively fortunate. Dozens of smaller surrounding communities remain unrecognised and are prohibited from being hooked up to the electricity grid or water lines, or building communal structures likes mosques or schools.

Whether or not one considers the West Bank to be occupied or sovereign Israeli territory is irrelevant. The actions we witnessed are not just illegal, they're war crimes. Practiced together and repeatedly, they constitute crimes against humanity.
http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2014/04/freedom-riders-move-palestine-sol-2014471003748159.html


The actions reported by settlers there are not the actions of civilians.

And the words of the Israeli government show that Zionism is active colonization, or a war crime. Which makes settlers part of an active policy of war criminals, hardly civilian.
Bennett said: "For years there was an attempt to block construction in Jerusalem by blasts and explosions, but it didn't happen. Construction in Jerusalem is not a 'poof', it is Zionism and we will never apologize for it."

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4508284,00.html
 
Why would I when the Geneva Convention does not protect those violating the a Geneva Convention?

You at just plain wrong on that to begin with, and the settlers themselves are not violating the convention anyway.

I see groggy too is trying to justify violence after bullshitting that he is against it. The convention binds occupying power, not the civilian population.

You are both supporters of terrorism. Fucking sick.
 
You at just plain wrong on that to begin with, and the settlers themselves are not violating the convention anyway.

I see groggy too is trying to justify violence after bullshitting that he is against it. The convention binds occupying power, not the civilian population.

You are both supporters of terrorism. Fucking sick.

Wrong again:

"the convention as a whole, aims to protect the local population in the occupied territory and not the population of the occupying state." You know what population that is, don't you? The illegal infiltrators who are violating international law.
 
Keep denying all you want, but the 4th Geneva convention affords the protection of ALL civilians and that means wether or not they are in illegal settlements or not. But considering you think it's okay to blow up a teenager on vacation on a beach in Tel Aviv, it doesn't surprise me that you misinterpret the conventions as well. Btw, I am very familiar with them seeing as I served 5 years in the Canadian Military and we had to learn them.
 
You at just plain wrong on that to begin with, and the settlers themselves are not violating the convention anyway.

I see groggy too is trying to justify violence after bullshitting that he is against it. The convention binds occupying power, not the civilian population.

You are both supporters of terrorism. Fucking sick.

Wrong again.
According to your HRW page settlers are only civilians if they aren't taking part in an active campaign.
And from those two reports its sounds like they are.
 
Wrong again.
According to your HRW page settlers are only civilians if they aren't taking part in an active campaign.
And from those two reports its sounds like they are.

Again, that is like saying every Palestinian is a legitimate target because a few thousand belong to Hamas. There are a half million settlers, only a handful of those are involved in belligerent activities and only those few loose their protection as civilians.
 
Keep denying all you want, but the 4th Geneva convention affords the protection of ALL civilians and that means wether or not they are in illegal settlements or not. But considering you think it's okay to blow up a teenager on vacation on a beach in Tel Aviv, it doesn't surprise me that you misinterpret the conventions as well. Btw, I am very familiar with them seeing as I served 5 years in the Canadian Military and we had to learn them.

The next thing you know you'll admit you were an occupation soldier as well.
 
Are you seriously that dense? When I arrived in Israel I was a tourist, since I had time before my enrolment in the military there. Try to discredit me all you want but you're a clown that has probably never stepped foot in either Israel, the West Bank or Gaza and never will. Keep your media driven hatred up :)
 
Are you seriously that dense? When I arrived in Israel I was a tourist, since I had time before my enrolment in the military there. Try to discredit me all you want but you're a clown that has probably never stepped foot in either Israel, the West Bank or Gaza and never will. Keep your media driven hatred up :)

You've got creep written all over you. You lied. You participated in an occupation army. You are just another racist zionist.