Does changing the oil, air filter improve emission test?

Twister

Well-known member
Aug 24, 2002
4,985
696
113
GTA
Use to be that when you did the muffler emission test, you changed your oil, air filter, and a few other things to improve your chances of passing. Is that still the case with the OBD? I was told by someone that as long as I don't have a check engine light I'm good.
 
Both are wrong.

Changing your oil, air filter and "a few other things" will do 0 to improve your chances of passing the emissions test.

And a check engine light on is usually not good, however, a Check Engine light being out is by no means a guarantee you will pass. The testing system measures pollutants in the exhaust.
 
Both are wrong.

Changing your oil, air filter and "a few other things" will do 0 to improve your chances of passing the emissions test.

And a check engine light on is usually not good, however, a Check Engine light being out is by no means a guarantee you will pass. The testing system measures pollutants in the exhaust.

WRONG, in Ontario anyway.
The testing system hasn’t tested emissions from the exhaust in years. Unless your car is 1996 or before.

If you don’t have a check engine light it will pass.
 
Oil and filter will do nothing. I should qualify what others have said - you will pass as long as you no check engine light and the car has been driven enough for the computer to perform all of its regular diagnostics. What this means is that for e.g., if had a light previously and disconnected the battery and the light goes away it will not pass unless you have driven it enough to allow the computer to complete the tests.
 
Oil and filter will do nothing. I should qualify what others have said - you will pass as long as you no check engine light and the car has been driven enough for the computer to perform all of its regular diagnostics. What this means is that for e.g., if had a light previously and disconnected the battery and the light goes away it will not pass unless you have driven it enough to allow the computer to complete the tests.
Forget your post. That's a great gif.
 
Oil and filter will do nothing. I should qualify what others have said - you will pass as long as you no check engine light and the car has been driven enough for the computer to perform all of its regular diagnostics. What this means is that for e.g., if had a light previously and disconnected the battery and the light goes away it will not pass unless you have driven it enough to allow the computer to complete the tests.

^^^This. You may even still pass if you have a check engine light on.

I have a check engine light that comes on from time to time due to a dodgy sensor that doesn't really affect anything to do with emissions... I still haven't gotten to fixing it yet. I was looking at it with my OBDII code reader and cleared the code on it not thinking it would affect anything. Shortly after I took the car in for an emissions test and got turned away because not enough time for the computer to do all the checks. They told me drive a ton for two days then come back. Went back, light was on, I still passed.
 
^ http://www.ontla.on.ca/library/repository/mon/25001/307198.pdf (see Table 9.0.1B in page 7)

If the inspection tech goes by the book, then a check engine light with stored fault code should be an automatic fail. There's no reason for the check engine light to exist except to indicate an emissions-related malfunction, whether it's tailpipe emissions or evaporative emissions (fuel system). What sensor was dodgy in your car?
 
Use to be that when you did the muffler emission test, you changed your oil, air filter, and a few other things to improve your chances of passing. Is that still the case with the OBD? I was told by someone that as long as I don't have a check engine light I'm good.
Check with your dealer and make sure your car has the latest PCM software. Occasionally carmakers release updated PCM software with more relaxed monitor thresholds.
 
If the inspection tech goes by the book, then a check engine light with stored fault code should be an automatic fail. There's no reason for the check engine light to exist except to indicate an emissions-related malfunction, whether it's tailpipe emissions or evaporative emissions (fuel system). What sensor was dodgy in your car?
Crank position sensor. If it was actually faulty the car wouldn't run.
 
^For an outright failure, no. However, the sensor can fail intermittently, or something else like a stretched timing chain can push the timing out of range (and trip a cam-crank correlation code), which hurts emissions. Was your car a GM?
 
Its the lounge Buddy, we ask all kinds of questions because there's a wealth of information. Escort reviews are in the review section

I’m thought this was/is an escort review Board...lounge and all....
 
yes, if you've driven your car over 100k without an oil change, then you'll improve your emission results

giphy.gif
 
^For an outright failure, no. However, the sensor can fail intermittently, or something else like a stretched timing chain can push the timing out of range (and trip a cam-crank correlation code), which hurts emissions. Was your car a GM?

It is an intermittent problem. The light comes on a few days then goes off again for a few days. From what I've read the computer will clear the code after three consecutive starts with no errors. It started not too long after I had to have some work done that would have required removing the transmission so they might have damaged it slightly or maybe there's some junk in the wiring harness. It's not a difficult part to replace and not expensive either, I really should just get the part and get under the car and do it. It's been like that for a couple years and the car runs fine so it's hard finding the motivation. Oh and no, not a GM.