Based on the size of the explosion, it is quite likely that the unburnt propellent in the rocket caused a fire that killed many.
Does anyone believe that Al-Ahli Arab Hospital was hit by the HAMAs?
- Thread starter dirtydaveiii
- Start date
so the us, French. Uk and most other western intelligence agencies are unanimous in their assessments but that is not god enough for you because Hamas with no evidence at all sat it was Israel.
As I said, you support bombing hospitals, as does every other Israeli supporter her.
Right, you and every Israeli support thinks everyone in Gaza is Hamas and you're going to kill them all.
We know.
Don't forget, they'll grow up to be Hamas now too, so you have to kill 1 million kids.
one of the more absurd attempt to shift blame for this terrible tragedy. To even create doubt when there is none is to excuse this atrocity which Hamas has used to fan the flames of hate against Jews worldwide.
No. You support whoever Israel kills if they say 'terrorist' afterwards.
So Israel kills 2000 children, you're there backing them.
Kill 1,000 women, you got their back.
Bomb a hospital, you're there.
No matter what they do, you'll go along now.
Enjoy the genocide.
Its the occupation.
75 years of settler colonial occupation and land theft.
Israel has killed 2000 children, not Hamas.
deal with it Frank. They are and do. It’s also why most civilized societies are supporting Israel. The people you clearly support are barbaric. You can’t grasp many differences. From one side giving warnings and one side not. To one side flat out murdering innocents intentionally and one side more often than not, not. To one wearing wearing body cams while they rape and torture commit indignities on human bodies, murder innocents, including young children, so they can jerk off to the recording once home.
Your head is so deeply in the sand and drinking their Koolaid you’ve had be shown repeatedly it most likely wasn’t Israel that hit the hospital, but Hamas or IJ. Not only is every credible intelligence service saying that. Your own eyes should be able to compute just how small the explosive charge was….but nope, not you..A blast area that’s obviously been sanitized and swept clean… nope, not you…Upto and including Doctors who have been up all night, saving lives, looking like they just walked out from a Spa to a staged photo op.
You’ve ignored the actual history, all the broken peace agreements and by whom/how and why. Right up to and including it was the UN who you love so much, that divided the land. And that one too, not lasting one day.
War sucks Frank. Innocent people die in them. Always have, always will. Civilized societies have learned its best not to start them.
Last edited:
As a cock-sure non Koolaid drinker, can you please clarify which of the three missile strikes on that hospital that week you have irrefutable evidence for being from Hamas? Do you have credible intelligence that the first two missle strikes were also "misfires" or were those classic IDF roof knocks followed by the third payload ? Or did the IDF roof knock them, then forget to follow up, but luckily hamas had a misfire to help out the IDF?
Hamas took upon itself to investigate it. They haven’t allowed anyone else onto the site. As a result they claimed that munition disappeared. No shrapnel or anything. Onus was on them and they haven’t delivered any proof. Case of a dumpster fire in a parking lot is now closed.
So you have problems with English?
Which part of “most likely not Israel” are you struggling with.
Which part of not finding any fragments are you struggling with? Anyone with part of a functioning brain knows, such things survive, and if there were any, Hamas would have A) made finding them a priority and B) paraded them to the world…..
Last edited:
No, the people you support are barbaric. They want to do a 'Dresden' on 2 million people.
Why would anyone back doing this to an indigenous people in this day and age?
AP erases Israeli pledge to attack Gaza like ‘Axis Power’ as officials threaten Palestinians with ‘Dresden’ doctrine
As Israeli officials proudly compare their bombardment of the Gaza Strip to the Allied firebombing of Dresden, the Associated Press has quietly removed a section noting US alarm over the historical comparison.
Hamas hasn't let anyone investigate?
They live in a death camp, Israel won't let anyone in.
No food, no water, no power.
Its a fucking death camp.
I am a partisan but your false logic and attempt to create doubt where none exists and then continue to quote or rely upon non-existent doubt was the same strategy used to promote the big lie in the US.
denying facts is assuming that thUS, French and British intelligence agencies may be lying is not balance. It is attempting to excuse Hamas atrocities and propaganda lies.
Or you could support genocide and claim that every single child of the 2420 that Israel has killed so far deserved to die.
Israel-Palestine war: Israel is caught lying time and again. And yet we never learn
and hamas said that israeli rocket disappeared without a trace leaving only 500 dead people (again, never confirmed or demonstrated) and not a shred of shrapnel. Just based on that can't we call bullshit?
and France and the uk etc. I would rather believe any one of them rather than Hamas.
There are UN inspectors based in GAZA.
In an interview with CNN a UN inspector in GAZA said " The local authorities did not give me free access to the area or were very unhappy that I was trying to investigate something that had clearly gone wrong from their point of view.”
Marc Garlasco, the former defense intelligence analyst and UN war crimes investigator, says there are signs of a lack of evidence at the Al-Ahli Hospital site.
He was allowed in but had a "guided tour" the day after.
He then went on to say “When I investigate a site of a potential war crime the first thing I do is locate and identify parts of the weapon. The weapon tells you who did it and how. I’ve never seen such a lack of physical evidence for a weapon at a site. Ever. There’s always a piece of a bomb after the fact. In 20 years of investigating war crimes this is the first time I haven’t seen any weapon remnants. And I’ve worked three wars in Gaza.”
https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/21/midd...nsic-analysis-gaza-hospital-blast?cid=ios_app
Has one ever landed in a courtyard packed with, as reported, a thousand people?
I have read conflicting statements on this as well, that it was hit a week before with 2 warning bombs, then 2 days before, now 1 day.
If they were warning shots, why did they hit the hospital directly insted of the parking lot first then hit the main building?
