Do You Max Out Your RRSP's??

Do You Max Out Your RRSP??

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 56.6%
  • No

    Votes: 36 43.4%

  • Total voters
    83
I do but that's because I contribute to the company pension and the company matches a fair portion of it. (Free $$$!)

On the whole though, if you do it right an RSP won't really generate any tax savings. If you start young, contribute the max and get a decent (5% - 8%) return, retire around 70 and die around 95, you'll still be drawing down over $100K per year and therefore pay 50% taxes anyhow.
 
Thats why you use the RRSP for the interest type securities and work any cap gains outside. If you get a cap gain inside the RRSP all it does is make it treatable as ordinary income when you withdraw. Sure you get some tax deferral but gov't gets the permanent tax rate differential bump up.
 
xarir said:
I do but that's because I contribute to the company pension and the company matches a fair portion of it. (Free $$$!)

I hear you! Isn't it great?? :)
 
I heard on the radio that the NFL chips in $2 for every $1 that players contribute, yet the plan isnt viable because not enough players take advantage of it!!!! :eek:
 
Apart from RRSPs bringing your income and tax bracket down (which is great), they were mainly introduced by the government to collect tax from seniors. They looked at all the baby boomers who will be paying little or no tax when they retire and figured out that that's not a good thing.

There is no guarantee that you will be in a lower tax bracket when you retire and you will pay tax on the whole amount of the RRSP investment. Many have also had their Old Age Security amount clawed back. Others have a company pension...their income when combined with the "forced" withdrawal of the RRSP funds will stagger people with how much tax they will pay if they have managed to accumulate a sizeable portfolio.

Yes, you don't get any tax refunds from non-RRSP investments, and you do pay tax yearly on the growth, but you don't pay full tax (most were capital gains so 50% is tax-free).

In summary, while they have some value, they are also not all that they are hyped to be either.
 
True enough. I max out every year, and then put the rest into non registered funds. Anything else I should invest in, besides real estate??
 
Paying off your mortgage first will save you a lot more in the long run.
 
xarir said:
I do but that's because I contribute to the company pension and the company matches a fair portion of it. (Free $$$!)

On the whole though, if you do it right an RSP won't really generate any tax savings. If you start young, contribute the max and get a decent (5% - 8%) return, retire around 70 and die around 95, you'll still be drawing down over $100K per year and therefore pay 50% taxes anyhow.

Correct, however you pay those taxes much later. up to 50 years later.
The present value of a dollar paid 25 years from now is about $0.30 with a discount rate of 5 %,
If you can average a better return than 5% on the holdings within a RRSP it is even less.
What would you prefer paying the govt a $1 now or a $1 in 25 years ?
It is the only tax shelter left to the average Canadian
Even if you cannot max out contibute something every year
 
Always. Like shaving everyday :)

Also, that's before spending time with the SP/MPA.
 
hinz said:
Do not want to spoil the fun but is this DB or DC plan?


Oooo, you're a real spoil sport. Most people don't know the difference and when I tell them the true traits of a DC plan (which many people have nowadays since DBs are falling out of favour) many get extremely freaked out. I'm glad that more people are taking interest in thier financial health and are educating themselves.
 
toughb said:
Paying off your mortgage first will save you a lot more in the long run.

Agree as long as you don't get greedy and "flip" to a bigger house-start the whole process again and omit any contribution.
 
gdurham said:
Oooo, you're a real spoil sport. Most people don't know the difference and when I tell them the true traits of a DC plan (which many people have nowadays since DBs are falling out of favour) many get extremely freaked out.

Most people don't know or should I say do not want to know the difference or for that matter saving for retirement. They would rather spend time enjoying "life" say following OC, Grey's Anatomy and American Idol, or shopping new gadgets on credit like IPhone or luxury goods like a bimmer, designer brand shoes and clothings, thinking these are therapy :eek: and deserved every bit of it.

Or mortgaging their future by financing their kids to private schools and living in "posh" neighborhood to keep up the Jones.

Nothing is wrong with that and people should enjoy life but question is who would remember and care those 30 years from now?

Regarding the pension plan, DB is going to be like well dinnosaurs, unless you are a lucky few working for banks (not insurance companies), governments or professionals like teachers. Many CFOs are simply too "optimistic" when it comes to market returns, both stock and bonds while they are chronically underfund the contributions. And you get a perfect storm when the industries in question have no pricing power and their workers are greying fast.

Ask those working in aviation, automobile manufacturing, steel, metals and lumber industries, especially those emerge from bankrupcy. They and the pensioners are lucky to have some monthly payments down the road.

And to live up the name as "spoil sport". I am not ever dwelling on how much nickled and dimed by the financial services and their salespeople aka advisers when people invest their hard earn money for retirements.

gdurham said:
I'm glad that more people are taking interest in thier financial health and are educating themselves.

Better than in denial, doing nothin at all and expect the government to bail out and fund their retirements. I am not that optimistic as it may be too late to a sizeable numbers of the Baby boomers a decade down the road. Maybe, just maybe the generation X has a better chance only if many of them can pay all of their student loans asap before juggling 1st down payment and funding retirement by the early 30s.

Count yourself lucky as for the time being the Canadians are not as dire as say the Americans.
 
I tend to agree with this, rrsps are great for the wealthy or middle class but not for those who are better off depending on the government in their old age.
====

RRSPs a poor choice for low-income Canadians: experts
By BRUCE CHEADLE

OTTAWA (CP) - At age 63 and facing a very modest retirement income, Greta Doucet is cashing out what's left of her meager nest-egg as fast as she can.

"I have a little bit left, but if you don't have a fairly large amount, you're just shooting yourself in the foot," said the part-time nurse and seniors advocate from New Brunswick. "You don't have enough to get yourself anywhere."

Converting her last $15,000 in RRSPs into cash and pumping the money into the mortgage of her Moncton home may sound like financial heresy in this season of wall-to-wall investment ads, when Canadians are being implored by financial institutions to max out their registered retirement savings.

But Doucet is simply following the best advice of experts who fully understand Canada's complex public pension system.

For modest income Canadians approaching retirement, RRSPs mainly benefit governments that claw back and tax their returns almost dollar-for-dollar after retirement.

"There are lambs off to slaughter as we speak," Richard Shillington, a freelance statistician, consultant and author from Ottawa says of the annual RRSP buying spree.

"The retirement planning that you're likely to get from the person in the cubicle at your bank, or from reading those articles about people who have incomes of $200,000, is wrong if you're among the half of us who don't have a pension plan.

"And nobody's going to tell you."

Shillington has been banging this drum since 1999, when he first laid out the huge tax hit on retirement savings in a study for the C.D. Howe Institute.

Looking at Statistics Canada data, he found that low-income retirees had squirreled away about $12 billion in RRSPs and $5 billion in registered retirement income funds (RRIFs).

"The greatest impact of these funds is to reduce the cost of government programs, rather than to improve seniors' standard of living," Shillington wrote.

Here's how it works.

Low-income Canadians - say, below $30,000 annually - get a relatively modest tax break on their initial RRSP purchase because of their low income tax bracket.

When they go to cash in after retirement, their RRSP income counts against their Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS), which is clawed back 50 cents for every dollar of retirement income.

The pension income is also taxed, meaning the senior sees only 25 cents of each dollar saved.

Not only that, but many seniors programs - think meals on wheels, subsidized retirement homes, prescription drugs and home care - may also be income-based, depending on the province.

So the effective tax rate on RRSP income in some cases is more than 100 per cent, says Shillington.

And while low-income people get the worst deal, Shillington argues that even middle income Canadians who don't have a company pension plan may hold what he calls "futile savings."

"What I've said to people is, if you don't have an employer pension plan then you want to have more than $100,000 in your RRSP at retirement - or nothing. The worst thing you could have is $30,000 in your RRSP."

Some 38 per cent of seniors - about 1.5 million - qualify for the GIS at retirement. Those who hold less than $100,000 in RRSPs are saving for the public treasury as much as for themselves.

Shillington has called the current RRSP mantra fraudulent.

"I will defend the use of the word fraud," says Shillington, who does not sell financial services or advice but has a website (www.shillington.ca) and hopes to publish a book this spring entitled Retirement Planning for the Rest of Us geared to low-income households.

"People are being encouraged to save money in an RRSP on the belief that they will benefit from it at retirement. The government knows that for many of them, that's not true."

The Conservatives under Stephen Harper said as much in their 2004 election platform, when the party pitched a new registered lifetime savings plan that would be tax-free upon withdrawal.

"When retirees withdraw their RRSPs," said the 2004 Tory platform, "they not only pay tax, but often have significant portions of their old age security benefits clawed back. The RLSP would particularly benefit low-and middle-income Canadians."

The savings plan promise was dropped from the party's 2006 election platform.

Officials in two federal government departments, Finance and Human Resources and Social Development, would not comment on whether the policy issue is still actively being considered.

Shillington uses the example of a 50-year-old earning $25,000 a year with no savings.

By common financial industry calculations, he'll need 70 per cent of that income in retirement, or $17,000 annually. Using simple RRSP calculators offered on banking websites, the individual might be told he needs to save up to $392,000 over the next 15 years.

"In fact, that person has to save almost nothing to get a $17,000-a-year income at retirement, because OAS (Old Age Security), GIS and CPP just about gets them there," said Shillington.

"It's just basically wrong."

Malcolm Hamilton, an actuary with Mercer Human Resource Consulting in Toronto, is one of Canada's leading pension experts.

He believes governments have done a poor job of setting retirement policy for the poorest and the wealthiest Canadians. The difference is that wealthy people can pay advisors to help arrange their retirement finances.

"The way they've designed the system it doesn't pay low-income people to use RRSPs," Hamiltion said in an interview.

"The rational thing to do is to yank the money in its entirety before 65. You don't need to spend it, but you do need to get it out of the tax shelter before the clawbacks kick in."

Even after taking the tax hit from cashing out RRSPs, people are further ahead, especially if they use the funds to pay off credit cards or mortgages.

David Perry of the Canadian Tax Foundation, an independent public policy research forum, joked in an interview that given the tax hit and clawbacks, low-income Canadians approaching retirement would be better off buying a case of beer than an RRSP.

"Better to invest in something that you or your soul needs in retirement," said Perry, turning serious.

"Why not take that trip home to England or Latvia or China?"

Shillington says he's been accused of advising people to "scam" the system. But when wealthy people arrange their finances to minimize their tax load and maximize tax breaks, it is considered sound financial management.

Hamilton agrees.

"You really need to tell low-income people how to protect themselves from their government, so I don't see the moral qualm here," said the actuary.

For Greta Doucet, she's just making the best of a poor retirement income situation after a career spent raising three kids, working part-time and being active in the community while nursing two failed relationships.

"I guess it's just admitting that I didn't really take good care of myself, which I suppose a lot of 60-year-old women didn't do," she said with good-natured charm.

"To get my house in order and keep my house as long as I can, that's the goal I'm aiming for. The RRSPs are gone."

Government retirement programs will provide Doucet between $16,000 and $17,000 a year, which is poverty level in Moncton.

"I'll have to do with that, and I'm not the only one."

http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Canada/2007/01/28/3467437-cp.html
 
I automatically put in $50 a month to my RRSP its at my bank at 600$ a year 4.20% then when my savings account reaches $500.00 that goes into my RRSP. I put in as much as I can and when things are tight I always put in 50$ a month.
 
hinz said:
Regarding the pension plan, DB is going to be like well dinnosaurs, unless you are a lucky few working for banks (not insurance companies), governments or professionals like teachers. Many CFOs are simply too "optimistic" when it comes to market returns, both stock and bonds while they are chronically underfund the contributions. And you get a perfect storm when the industries in question have no pricing power and their workers are greying fast.
Senior management of many big corp get DB as bonus incentives. They just don't publize it unless you're at part of the elite.
 
mmm_go said:
I max out my RRSP every year. I do contract work so I am Incorporated so I try to also leave as much as possible in the business as retained earnings.

Not knowing what you do, however, I would be careful with that. Leaving large sums of money in your operating company is a bit of a gamble as unforseen events could evaporate that cash. Specifically lawsuits, tax changes, business downturn. If it is a large sum, ie.: > 300k I would set up a holding company that owns your operating company and declare dividends to the holding company to get the cash out of the operating company. If you are ever being sued for a large amount you just go bankrupt as the operating company will have little assets and you still keep your cash.;)
 
Some interesting RRSP stats.

While the growth in RRSP contributions was strong, only 38 per cent of Canadians aged 25 to 64 contributed to RRSPs in the 2005 tax year, it said. And nearly 90 per cent hadn’t contributed all they were allowed, with their unused RRSP room averaging $23,700, up from $15,000 in 1999.
Further, and despite the growth in incomes, the size of RRSP contributions has hardly increased at all, it said. The median household contribution in 2005 -- with as many contributing more as less -- was $2,030, roughly the same as in each of the previous two years, meaning when adjusted for inflation Canadians are actually contributing relatively less.

http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/...=5030c177-8e20-4a92-8363-05d03658ca2b&k=53941