Do Cats Recognize Their Own Reflection in the Mirror?

Pleezerwell

Member
May 25, 2003
131
0
16
Wherever I'm At
One theory...

http://www.sirc.org/publik/mirror.html

An excerpt:

If you were a dog or a cat or a horse you wouldn't realise that the image was a reflection of yourself. Most animals in this situation think that they are face to face with another member of their species.

The exception is the great apes – chimps, gorillas and orang-utans are capable of recognising themselves in the mirror – and of course the Naked Apes: us.

What's interesting is what the other apes do when presented with a mirror: they use mirrors to groom themselves, pick food out of their teeth and make faces at themselves for entertainment – i.e. more or less the same reactions as us Naked Apes.

Another theory...

http://en.allexperts.com/q/Cats-1606/2009/12/cats-mirrors.htm

An excerpt:

Question

Why is it that some cats cannot see themselves in the mirror, and other cats do., or is our cat who is oblivious to the mirror just being ornery when it is walking by it and no indication that he can see himself in the mirror. thanks

Answer

Each cat's behavior will differ when they see a reflection in the mirror due to their individual intelligence and understanding. Some cats immediately recognize that reflections in a mirror are two-dimensional and will usually pay them no further mind. Most cats perceive depth (volume) in mirrors and see the reflected objects as ACTUAL objects when they are first introduced to mirrors. This is when you see cats who react to their reflections as if they are another cat, often with hissing and hair-raising. Kittens usually go about this for the longest, because their intelligence is not yet fully developed. With some investigation, most adult cats quickly develop an understanding that mirrors are reflective, not clear glass, and that there is no object or cat on the other side of the glass. The mirror loses much of its entertainment value after this point. However, some very intelligent cats can use the reflections in mirrors to see what's going on behind themselves.

The jury is still out as to whether cats can recognize that it's THEIR reflection that they're seeing in the mirror. Scientists use mirrors to try to determine whether or not animals are self-aware, aware that they are unique, individual beings. The test records animals' reactions when they see their reflection, and then again after a change has been made to their appearance - for instance, a dot placed on the animal's head. An animal who tries to remove the dot from his own head rather than the dot on his reflection is considered self-aware. Cats have failed this self-awareness test, but there is a lot of criticism against this test when used on species such as cats and dogs. They may fail simply because their visual accuity is not as great as other species' for the purposes of the test, or they don't have the intelligence level to use the mirror to help them remove the spot on their head.

Most likely, your cat has recognized that his reflection is only a reflection and is not really interested in it anymore.


PW
 

demien2k5

Banned
Aug 3, 2006
3,658
0
0
On the Edge
I am constantly amazed at this board's knowledge base! The last few posts really begin to frame the real deal where cats are concerned, and have shattered my pre-existing misconceptions that cats have phenomenal vision as a whole, not just night vision, and that sight was their primary sense. The mystery is quickly dissolving after 10 years of frustration and consternation on the matter! I thank you all! Enjoy a safe and happy long weekend, hosers!
 

someone

Active member
Jun 7, 2003
4,307
1
36
Earth
...or do they think it's some other cat? I swear, everytime I pick up my little dude and show him his reflection in the mirror, he is completely non-plussed, but if he sees another cat out by the pool in our yard through the patio window, he goes absolutely ape-shit! If he does recognize his own image, who told him it was him in the first place? Me? Another Cat? The cleaning lady? I'm very confused....

Thoughts, people?

(Where the hell is Ceiling Cat when you need an informed opinion?)
I read somewhere that since cats can see their own nose without a mirror they should know it is their reflection when they see the same nose in the mirror.
 

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,500
4,906
113
I think it is clear that cats, being solitary hunters, see the world very different than we do, and also different than dogs do. I believe that cats eyes are optimized for movement, such they will not see something being completely still. Also, cats seem to shut out any prediction, maybe because they can react extremely fast. Have you noticed, when you make a throwing movement with a ball in your hand, a dog will run to where the ball would go if thrown, while a cat will keep his eyes on the ball in your hand. Same, if you let a ball bounce in front of a cat; his head will bounce up and down with the ball.

cats are wondrous creatures. Good to have as friends.
 

genintoronto

Retired
Feb 25, 2008
3,226
3
0
Downtown TO
renteddesign.com
I suspect there will be dumb cats and smart cats. Dumb people and smart people. Snetches with stars and those without.
Why is it that some cats cannot see themselves in the mirror, and other cats do., or is our cat who is oblivious to the mirror just being ornery when it is walking by it and no indication that he can see himself in the mirror. thanks

Answer

Each cat's behavior will differ when they see a reflection in the mirror due to their individual intelligence and understanding. Some cats immediately recognize that reflections in a mirror are two-dimensional and will usually pay them no further mind. Most cats perceive depth (volume) in mirrors and see the reflected objects as ACTUAL objects when they are first introduced to mirrors. This is when you see cats who react to their reflections as if they are another cat, often with hissing and hair-raising. Kittens usually go about this for the longest, because their intelligence is not yet fully developed. With some investigation, most adult cats quickly develop an understanding that mirrors are reflective, not clear glass, and that there is no object or cat on the other side of the glass. The mirror loses much of its entertainment value after this point. However, some very intelligent cats can use the reflections in mirrors to see what's going on behind themselves.
I would tend to agree with the above theory, as well as with the idea that there are dumb cats and smart cats, just like humans.

My oldest (now gone) cat was really smart, and while completely unphased by his own reflection, he did use the reflections in the mirror to see what was going on behind him. He actually used to lay down in that very specific spot in my appartment, facing the mirror on an angle, which gave him a perfect view of the space around him.

My other cat is super cute, but dumb as bricks (actually, I think he's suffering from a learning disability). He is now 10 years old, but still hasn't figured out it's him in the mirror, and like a kitten, he is often surprised by his reflection in the mirror and will start hissing and hair-raising at his reflection.
 
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts