Do Cats Recognize Their Own Reflection in the Mirror?

Previous Thread Next Thread
D

demien2k5

Banned
Aug 3, 2006
3,658
0
0
On the Edge
...or do they think it's some other cat? I swear, everytime I pick up my little dude and show him his reflection in the mirror, he is completely non-plussed, but if he sees another cat out by the pool in our yard through the patio window, he goes absolutely ape-shit! If he does recognize his own image, who told him it was him in the first place? Me? Another Cat? The cleaning lady? I'm very confused....

Thoughts, people?

(Where the hell is Ceiling Cat when you need an informed opinion?)
 
D

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,500
4,906
113
demien2k5 said:
...or do they think it's some other cat? I swear, everytime I pick up my little dude and show him his reflection in the mirror, he is completely non-plussed, but if he sees another cat out by the pool in our yard through the patio window, he goes absolutely ape-shit! If he does recognize his own image, who told him it was him in the first place? Me? Another Cat? The cleaning lady? I'm very confused....

Thoughts, people?


(Where the hell is Ceiling Cat when you need an informed opinion?)
Click to expand...
My opinion is that cats not recognize anything in the mirror
 
D

demien2k5

Banned
Aug 3, 2006
3,658
0
0
On the Edge
danmand said:
My opinion is that cats not recognize anything in the mirror
Click to expand...
Then why doesn't he ever react when he sees his reflection...shouldn't he just think it's another real cat and go bananas like he does when he looks out the window?
 
R

red

you must be fk'n kid'g me
Nov 13, 2001
17,572
8
38
cats cannot see their own reflection in the mirror
 
D

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,500
4,906
113
demien2k5 said:
Then why doesn't he ever react when he sees his reflection...shouldn't he just think it's another real cat and go bananas like he does when he looks out the window?
Click to expand...
My theory is that he does not "see" a cat. Not himself, not another cat.
 
J

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,039
3,893
113
They figure it out pretty quick. I've seen kittens go after mirror images, but not grown cats. (No smell?)

My one cat definitely knows who is who. She doesn't like women at all, especially brunette women. She will run away from women, or his and growl at them if they try to pick her up. So obviously they can differentiate between the sexes. One time I was out on the porch roof and I saw her laying on the bed and I came up to the window and she started hissing at me and assuming the cat attack posture, but the second I called out to her she immediately relaxed, stopped hissing and eventually laid back down. Clearly she recognizes me by voice as well as apperance.
 
D

demien2k5

Banned
Aug 3, 2006
3,658
0
0
On the Edge
SillyGirl said:
Maybe because there's no smell, he knows it's not real?
Click to expand...
But looking through the closed patio window in the house, he certainly can't smell another cat out in the yard either, unless he has some form of "cat super powers" I'm not aware of....
 
D

demien2k5

Banned
Aug 3, 2006
3,658
0
0
On the Edge
james t kirk said:
She doesn't like women at all, especially brunette women. She will run away from women, or his and growl at them if they try to pick her up.
Click to expand...
...it's a proven fact that too many "pussies" in the same room will inevitably wind up in conflict, so no surprises there...
 
S

SillyGirl

Can't Touch This
Apr 9, 2010
502
1
0
Wandering Aimlessly
demien2k5 said:
But looking through the closed patio window in the house, he certainly can't smell another cat out in the yard either, unless he has some form of "cat super powers" I'm not aware of....
Click to expand...
hmmm...well, I don't know then.

I adopted my adult cat, and I've not held her in front of a mirror yet. I will when she wakes up and see what she does.

I have seen puppies react as though it's another dog, and it's the funniest thing! :p
 
D

demien2k5

Banned
Aug 3, 2006
3,658
0
0
On the Edge
eurotrash1970 said:
Do we really care if they realize it's not another cat?
Click to expand...
I'm just trying to get an answer to a puzzling riddle that's bugged me for about 9 years; it's not so much that I care if he recognizes himself, I just want to understand the mechanics of it...that, and if he's actually been mind fucking me for the past decade every time I hold him in front of the mirror. If so, he should win the Cat Academy Award, 'cause he's got that stone faced look down cold. No emotion or reaction whatsover. He's really a cool cat, man.
 
B

browsing

New member
May 28, 2009
83
0
0
It's the same answer of why don't most dogs and cats react to other animals on television... animals don't use just vision to identify other critters. It's a combination of sight, smell and sound that make it real to an animal. Some might argue that their dog or cat will watch television, but for most of them, it might just be an amusing changing of shapes that captures them. They are smart enough to know it's not real, though they might not fully understand exactly what it is they're looking at.
 
C

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
28,615
1,380
113
Cats have a very keen sense of smell. One time a outside cat got into the basement from an open window. When my kitty went down with me, she started to hiss. The most that cat could have done was walk around a bit, but that was enough to spread his smell.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Previous Thread Next Thread
Toronto Escorts
Top Bottom