Divorce Question - Matrimonial Home

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,059
4,068
113
Here's a question for the lawyers on the board (I know you're here!)

You know the rule that says when you get married she or he automatically owns half of your house, even if you owned it outright before you got married.

(Damn wierd rule)

Anyway, say you marry Jane, she then owns half YOUR house by law.

2 years later, it comes off the rails and you know it's coming off the rails.

Could you (the owner) go out and refinance the house TO THE HILT and take the cash and put it in an account where she couldn't get at it.

For example, your house is worth a million bucks (nice round number) and you know that she's going to deal you the nine of spades, so you take out a mortgage to the tune of 900 grand and put the money where she can't get it or find it.

Then, when it comes off the rails - sure honey, you can half of the house, take away the debt, the real estate fees, that's about 50 grand, so your half is 25 grand.

What is the pitfall that I'm not aware of here?
 
You have to sign an affidavit as to whether you are married and that the real estate is not a matrimonial home to get mortgage... if sign a false affidavit fraud for sure and may raise issues about validity of mortgage.
 
So how does one get around the "Matrimonial Home" Rule?

What about if you had a line of credit BEFORE you were married.

For example, I KNOW that RBC will give me a Line of Credit up to 80% of the worth of my home. If I had it set up before I was married, it would be easy to run the Line of Credit right up to the max while I was married, then when the divorce comes down, well, I spent the money at the Casino, I'm broke.
 
The reason I ask is I have a friend (seriously, I do) who is actually female, who owns her house outright. (No mortgage, place is probably worth 550 to 600 k)

She met a guy less than a year ago and he asked her to marry her in January 2008 and she said yes.

Now, she has a Teacher's Pension (which she says she can protect with a Marriage Contract, HOWEVER, she tells me that she can NOT do the same with her house. She claims she trusts her future hubby, but I'm not so sure.

I had thought that you could put the house into the Marriage Contract (Pre-nup) and that if you split up, he has no claim on the house.

I was sure of this.

But she tells me that she's asked and that NO, you can not put the matrimonial home into a Marriage Contract, it's the one exception.

Is that true?
 
Check your line of credit docs carefully.. i suspect that it is frozen at level on date of marriage and then needs her signature on any movement upward after. You need to have a lawyer review the docs.
 
My line of credit is easily accessable from any ABM.

I suppose they could say, "well, when you got married, your line of credit was at 20k, now it's at 800k when you want to get divorced - the 20k applies", however, I could just say, "no, she spent the money with me at the Casino"

Have a buddy open a safety deposit box and start making deposits.
 
Why doesn't she sell the house before the marriage and move into his? Or he can sell his home and buy a half interest in her house? Or they buy a new one together?

If he's not in a financial position to do this, that's a whole separate problem. I notice in spite of all the "trust", she's investigating her options to the nth degree, so she apparently realizes the situation has the potential to be a costly mistake.
 
Before marriage, can't she role the house into a company. her as sole shareholder, her private company can by contract be excluded from family assets. she and her new hubby lease the house from her company, that she runs as a business.

Sure she looses any potential upside capital fain free of tax, but she crystalizes at todays value and does not "own" the matrimonial home personally.


I'm no lawyer ( thank God) but throw out this idea to see how the crowd reacts.



.
 
Mikehorn said:
Why doesn't she sell the house before the marriage and move into his? Or he can sell his home and buy a half interest in her house? Or they buy a new one together?

If he's not in a financial position to do this, that's a whole separate problem. I notice in spite of all the "trust", she's investigating her options to the nth degree, so she apparently realizes the situation has the potential to be a costly mistake.

I suggested that she sell the place and they jointly buy a house together and pay the mortgage 50 50, however, he's not got any money to speak of. Makes an fair wage, but has no savings (he's 46) and there may be other issues.

She's not stupid, she even said to me, "What if I have an affair", but she's simply looking for a deal where if they split up, he leaves with what he came in with - basically nothing.

I suggested that they simply live together since the "matrimonial home" rule does not apply to common law unions, however, he very much wants to get married.
 
Are you sure...

"You know the rule that says when you get married she or he automatically owns half of your house, even if you owned it outright before you got married."

...this is the case?

I was under the impression (but i am not lawyer...however, I HAVE gone through and am in a divorce), that all assets own before the marriage remain in the ownership of their respective "owners"...so that as long as she doesn't put him on the title, it is still her house, and they are just living in it.

I could be wrong, but that was MY understanding.

Failing that, shit, given the nature of "common law" marriage here in Canada, there is no way in hell I'd be getting married...
 
Why not have her sell her house before they get married to her mom/dad and then rent from them? Or simple rent some other place to live in.

CP
 
MLAM said:
"You know the rule that says when you get married she or he automatically owns half of your house, even if you owned it outright before you got married."

...this is the case?

I was under the impression (but i am not lawyer...however, I HAVE gone through and am in a divorce), that all assets own before the marriage remain in the ownership of their respective "owners"...so that as long as she doesn't put him on the title, it is still her house, and they are just living in it.

I could be wrong, but that was MY understanding.

Failing that, shit, given the nature of "common law" marriage here in Canada, there is no way in hell I'd be getting married...

That was my understanding too, however, I am told that the "matrimonial home" is the one exception to that rule.

You own your house outright before your marriage, she or he automatically owns half the day you get married. (In fact, I am sure of that)

I, however, thought that the house could be put into a marriage contract - that it was hands off, however, she tells me no, the matrimonial home (in this case, her house that she has sweated to pay for) is automatically half his and can not be protected under any contract since by law, a contract can not operate outside the law and the laws says, he or she owns half.
 
chrispalen said:
Why not have her sell her house before they get married to her mom/dad and then rent from them? Or simple rent some other place to live in.

CP

Parents are dead, question is is how to protect the asset.

I suppose she could sell it to her brother, but then if his marriage goes south?
 
MLAM said:
"You know the rule that says when you get married she or he automatically owns half of your house, even if you owned it outright before you got married."

...this is the case?

I was under the impression (but i am not lawyer...however, I HAVE gone through and am in a divorce), that all assets own before the marriage remain in the ownership of their respective "owners"...so that as long as she doesn't put him on the title, it is still her house, and they are just living in it.

I could be wrong, but that was MY understanding.

Failing that, shit, given the nature of "common law" marriage here in Canada, there is no way in hell I'd be getting married...

Actually, that isn't the case. Once you are married, everything becomes joint property unless it is listed otherwise in a pre-nupt. (least that's how it was explained to the 9 guys who were raped by their wives when the wife filed for divorce)

As for mortgaging the house to the hilt, the money then becomes jointly owned and even if someone hides it, it will still be considered a family asset come divorce time.

For eg: if they have 2 million in assets. Her share will be 1 million. If he "hides" the $900K his "share" of the assets will be $100K. If all the other assets are like stocks, bonds, RRSPs, cars, boats, etc. She will get it all and he'll get the mortgage and the house.

Don't forget a couple doesn't have to be married for this to apply. Since Ontario is "common" law, if you live together for 2 yrs (I think it's 2 years) then that is the "equivalent to being married".

As for "hiding" assets prior to marriage. YOu can check with a lawyer on this but I think once you've entered into a marriage contract (by accepting his proposal) then you can't "hide" anything.

Funny though, this "friend" is worried about losing half her house and she isn't even married yet. If she's that worried, have him sign a pre-nupt.....(and no law protects any property or asset when entered into a contract agreed to by both parties but you can check on that via a lawyer). If that was the case then all these rich dudes would be losing their shirts if matrimonial homes were exempt from pre-nupts.

""What about my matrimonial home?"
The value of the matrimonial home is always divided equally, even if it was owned by one party at the beginning of the marriage."

from this link, 4th paragraph down.

http://www.ottawadivorce.com/propertydivision.htm

There you have it, he gets half if he divorces her and she doesn't protect her assets via a pre-nupt.
 
tboy said:
Don't forget a couple doesn't have to be married for this to apply. Since Ontario is "common" law, if you live together for 2 yrs (I think it's 2 years) then that is the "equivalent to being married"..

Not quite.

When you're living together, what you owned prior to shacking up, including your house, remains your property.

That's one huge difference. You're living together, she or he can't touch your house if you owned it prior to shacking up.

See page 7 of the Ontario Min. of the Attorney General's Guideline

http://www.attorneygeneral.jus.gov.on.ca/english/family/familyla.pdf
 
Cnd-Guy said:
Maybe she should re consider the marriage to the 46yr old who has nothing

No shit but finally a woman is thinking like a man: protect my ass(ets) lol before saying "I do" (agree to give her half of everything when she "needs to grow as a person" lol)
 
CP said:
Why not have her sell her house before they get married to her mom/dad and then rent from them?

JTK I'm not a lawyer but please hear me out. CP is on to something.


What your friend could do is to put a $400000 mortgage in her mother's or father's name. If the house is worth $500000 then there would only be $100000 of equity remaining as your friend's mother etc would own the first mtg and would have to be paid out before any assets could change hands if a divorce does occur:) .