Denying Holocaust Will be Illegal

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't start thinking like a right wingnut. Anyone who wants to tell me how to think can go fuck themselfđź–•...
this is not about what you think, it's about whether to allow you poisoning others with your toxic "thoughts" and how far reaching can it be. As I understand you will still be allowed to deny holocaust in PRIVATE conversations. So you can still poison your friends and family, but not the general public.
 
Just more pandering in anticipation of an election

No election anytime soon AFIK. But I feel this is not necessary. I would like to see how the data that indicates Jews are the victims of 62% of hate crimes is gathered. I would have thought that muslims are more likely to be targeted just based on the homicides targeted against Muslims in the last several years.
 
...

And who decides? And what if they are wrong? And what if they use this to create a totalitarian regime?

...
That slippery slope argument seems more than a little unrealistic.

I don't think that a law like this will make any impact on antisemitism in Canada (it hasn't in Germany) but it is a long way from criminalizing people who use hateful motivations to deny the Nazis intentionally murdered millions of Jews and other minorities simply because of their religious/ethnic identity and believing it is a sign of coming totalitarianism.


And I feel that the current Q belief about liberals really trying to control the world in a totalitarian state has a lot in common with the beliefs that allowed the Nazis to justify their attempted extermination.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poker and Valcazar
No election anytime soon AFIK. But I feel this is not necessary. I would like to see how the data that indicates Jews are the victims of 62% of hate crimes is gathered. I would have thought that muslims are more likely to be targeted just based on the homicides targeted against Muslims in the last several years.
Our government has clearly condemned both antisemitism and anti-Islamic hatred. There were also Muslims targeted by the Holocaust simply because they were Muslim.


p.s. Your thoughts aren't matched by the stats.
1649545440508.png
 
Our government has clearly condemned both antisemitism and anti-Islamic hatred. There were also Muslims targeted by the Holocaust simply because they were Muslim.


p.s. Your thoughts aren't matched by the stats.
View attachment 137049

As I said I was interested in how they were gathered .I can see from the stats that its more likely muslims have given up on reporting hate crimes vs the hate crimes actually suddenly and miraculously stopped.
 
Question: How can any intelligent and rational person person deny the Holocaust happened?

I agree, but how long until it's a criminal offense to, say, deny there's more than two genders? This is literal policing of language. I'm not willing to let the government decide which opinions are criminal and which aren't. It's the same thing Putin's doing with his "special military operation" by outlawing the ability to call it an invasion. His purported motivation is de-nazification, so in his eyes, it's completely justified to police language in this respect.
 
This is outrageous in an open society that deems itself free and democratic- exactly what the likes of Putin would do. And I'm happily and proudly Jewish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jolly_Penguin
This is outrageous in an open society that deems itself free and democratic- exactly what the likes of Putin would do. And I'm happily and proudly Jewish.
You are happily and proudly ultra right, it’s more important for you guys to be able to spew out modern lies and propaganda than to defend dead Jews from lies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bver_hunter
You are happily and proudly ultra right, it’s more important for you guys to be able to spew out modern lies and propaganda than to defend dead Jews from lies.
and you are for censorship. Like Putin.
 
Since the reports all say it is essentially the same text as Waugh's bill (C-250), we can look at that.
If you want to see the part it would be modifying, it is here: https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/section-319.html


Criminal Code



1 (1) Section 319 of the Criminal Code is amended by adding the following after subsection (2):



Wilful promotion of antisemitism



(2.‍1) Everyone who, by communicating statements, other than in private conversation, wilfully promotes antisemitism by condoning, denying or downplaying the Holocaust is

(a) guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years; or

(b) guilty of an offence punishable on summary conviction.





(2) The portion of subsection 319(3) of the Act before paragraph (a) is replaced by the following:



Defences



(3) No person shall be convicted of an offence under subsection (2) or (2.‍1)



(3) Subsections 319(4) to (6) of the Act are replaced by the following:


Forfeiture



(4)  If a person is convicted of an offence under section 318 or subsection (1), (2) or (2.‍1) of this section, anything by means of or in relation to which the offence was committed, on conviction, may, in addition to any other punishment imposed, be ordered by the presiding provincial court judge or judge to be forfeited to Her Majesty in right of the province in which that person is convicted, for disposal as the Attorney General may direct.



Exemption from seizure of communication facilities



(5) Subsections 199(6) and (7) apply with any modifications that the circumstances require to section 318 or subsection (1), (2) or (2.‍1) of this section.



Consent



(6) No proceeding for an offence under subsection (2) or (2.‍1) shall be instituted without the consent of the Attorney General.



(4) Subsection 319(7) of the Act is amended by adding the following in alphabetical order:


Holocaust means the planned and deliberate state-sponsored persecution and annihilation of European Jewry by the Nazis and their collaborators from 1933 to 1945; (Holocauste)
 
I agree, but how long until it's a criminal offense to, say, deny there's more than two genders? This is literal policing of language. I'm not willing to let the government decide which opinions are criminal and which aren't.
This is an excellent observation.

Language is the key to just about anything. So you make hate speech illegal.

Then, what happens to the definition of hate speech? What constitutes hate? Eventually, a DIFFERENCE OF OPINION WITH WHAT THE GOVERNMENT WANTS is considered hate.

The gender thing is an excellent example.

Right now, we are seeing that people who disagree with the transgender narrative are considered hateful.

What is the transgender narrative? That in the area of gender, what a person Thinks or Wants to be - they are. and we must agree.

What a scary concept that is! Because if they force others to recognize what THEY consider to be reality, they can and will extend that to other things.

The insanely ironic thing is that at the same time transgender people and women are protected vigorously, "toxic masculinity", and "white privilege" is tossed about casually with no thought of IT being considered hateful. At the very time they are preaching anti-hate, inclusive messages, they are doing the exact thing they are attacking.

We actually have people (often in academia) saying that a black person can't be racist to a white person, and they get away with it!
 
Who cares how a person can come to that conclusion? There are zillions of patently wrong beliefs out there.

Ironically, the instigators of the holocaust, the Nazis, certainly did not believe in free speech.

"When the Nazis came to power in 1933, the German constitution guaranteed freedom of speech and freedom of the press. Through decrees and laws, the Nazis abolished these civil rights and destroyed German democracy. Starting in 1934, it was illegal to criticize the Nazi government. Even telling a joke about Hitler was considered treachery."

Once you allow this kind of censorship, good luck restraining it, once a ruthless ruler gets in power.

And one eventually always does.
Again, virtually the same provisions have been in force for decades and have been used to prosecute nazis and Holocaust deniers. Not only have the provisions not been 'misused by a ruthless dictator", but you were not even aware that they were in existence.
 
Again, virtually the same provisions have been in force for decades and have been used to prosecute nazis and Holocaust deniers. Not only have the provisions not been 'misused by a ruthless dictator", but you were not even aware that they were in existence.

Same provisions used against Zundel, aren't they?

The only difference in discussion is a proposal by Israel supporters to try to get the IHRA definition of antisemitism into legislation. That definition tries to tar criticism of Israel itself as antisemitism.

Hate speech laws are good, they work in Canada but that would be over reach in an attempt to shut down the growing reports of Israeli apartheid.
 
A lot of good and valid comments so far. I'll add a couple of comments.

I do agree within reason that we don't want government to dictate, within reason, what we can or can't say. I do emphasize within reason. At least with a democratically elected government we have, at least in theory, a voice and vote in what that government does.

What I find more concerning is cancel culture. Say or do something that is not in tune with some social group, they can "cancel" you. Try and get you fired from your job so you lose your means to earn a living. These social activist groups are not elected by you but they still have some/much power over your life.
 
In this particular case are they wrong that the Holocaust occurred?

What is considered denial is often wrong. Revisionism or asking questions shouldn't be labeled as outright denial.
Celebrating what happened or hoping for another event like that to occur is a different story.
 
this is not about what you think, it's about whether to allow you poisoning others with your toxic "thoughts" and how far reaching can it be. As I understand you will still be allowed to deny holocaust in PRIVATE conversations. So you can still poison your friends and family, but not the general public.
They are trying to pass a law now where an anonymous accuser can say they feel like you might tweet something mean in the future and you face up to a 20k fine split between the gov and the accuser.
 
That slippery slope argument seems more than a little unrealistic.

I don't think that a law like this will make any impact on antisemitism in Canada (it hasn't in Germany) but it is a long way from criminalizing people who use hateful motivations to deny the Nazis intentionally murdered millions of Jews and other minorities simply because of their religious/ethnic identity and believing it is a sign of coming totalitarianism.


And I feel that the current Q belief about liberals really trying to control the world in a totalitarian state has a lot in common with the beliefs that allowed the Nazis to justify their attempted extermination.

Because commies didn't murder more. Authoritarianism in all forms is bad and should be called out as such.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.