Denying Holocaust Will be Illegal

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't have an opinion on the Holocaust. It happened, just like I don't have an opinion on whether the sun rose this morning. It is a fact, not an opinion.

I do have an opinion on what to do with people who try to sow doubt regarding the Holocaust by denying it happened for the sole purpose of fomenting anti-Semitism.
Everything you think you know is only because someone else did some real investigation and research, and formulated conclusions from that research. However, knowledge and opinion evolves from continuing research. Are you opposed to continuing research into the Holocaust? What if that research were to support a change to any of the "facts" you accept today?
 
  • Like
Reactions: jacksparrow
LoL! I also don't celebrate the Lillehammer Afair nor the "incident " involving HMCS Trentonian and two other ships during Operation Pluto that was covered up or the attack on the Canadian troops in Afghanistan by the American plane. But, you go ahead.

I am going ahead. You are some kind of vile creature to be comparting what happened to the US Liberty to the Lillehammer affair or the bomb dropped on those Canadian kids in Afghanistan. Granted I shouldn't be shocked I have come across disgusting people considering the nature of this site, but still.
The benefit of the doubt you shall get and I really hope you are just ignorant.
Educate yourself, it's very well done and unless you are an ardent zionist will make you realize you were wrong.
 
I don't have an opinion on the Holocaust. It happened, just like I don't have an opinion on whether the sun rose this morning. It is a fact, not an opinion.

I do have an opinion on what to do with people who try to sow doubt regarding the Holocaust by denying it happened for the sole purpose of fomenting anti-Semitism.
You have an opinion that it is a fact.

'Merely asserting something over and over is the equivalent of saying "I'm right" continuously and somehow thinking that that actually has some kind of bearing on whether you actually are right or not.

But REGARDLESS - the point is, if you are so sure you are right, then what's the problem with hearing an alternative point of view?

Don't tell me because you KNOW this or that, just tell me what is wrong with hearing other people's opinions?
 
Last edited:
Everything you think you know is only because someone else did some real investigation and research, and formulated conclusions from that research. However, knowledge and opinion evolves from continuing research. Are you opposed to continuing research into the Holocaust? What if that research were to support a change to any of the "facts" you accept today?
Only if the tv and or gov tells him to will he change his mind.
 
Another person who dislikes democracy if people they don't like get elected.

Still waiting for either you or Jack to back your assertions that this potential law will prevent research.
What research are you talking about. Who is JAck.

When did you ask me a question I didn't answer? Please refer to the specific post. If I missed something I will respond, thank you.
 
I am going ahead. You are some kind of vile creature to be comparting what happened to the US Liberty to the Lillehammer affair or the bomb dropped on those Canadian kids in Afghanistan. Granted I shouldn't be shocked I have come across disgusting people considering the nature of this site, but still.
The benefit of the doubt you shall get and I really hope you are just ignorant.
Educate yourself, it's very well done and unless you are an ardent zionist will make you realize you were wrong.
Yes, anti Semites are especially fond of USS Liberty.
 
Yes, anti Semites are especially fond of USS Liberty.

So calling out a nation that was a supposed ally of and then went on to try and MURDER 294 American sailors and successfully MURDERED 34 of them is anti semitic?
Is mentioning LBJ's complicity in it anti semitic too?

You are revealing yourself.
 
Clearly some people don't accept them as fact.

Is your position weak?
No, it isn't.
so what's the problem?
Ah, you think they will FOOL too many people.
That is anti-democratic.
Shack is 100% correct. The facts are indisputable. The only people who dispute the Holocaust are neo nazis and white supremacists. They should be put in jail.

Anyway, it's an old argument. Holocaust denial has been prosecuted as a hate crime in this country since 1990. The neo nazis made the same spurious argument you make and were crushed quickly by the courts like the rancid vermin they truly are.

And our democracy didn't falter an iota. In fact, most people didn't even realize that it had happened.
 
Shack is 100% correct. The facts are indisputable. The only people who dispute the Holocaust are neo nazis and white supremacists. They should be put in jail.

Anyway, it's an old argument. Holocaust denial has been prosecuted as a hate crime in this country since 1990. The neo nazis made the same spurious argument you make and were crushed quickly by the courts like the rancid vermin they truly are.

And our democracy didn't falter an iota. In fact, most people didn't even realize that it had happened.

Sure, but so should support for apartheid as well.
 
Everything you think you know is only because someone else did some real investigation and research,
You mean like my mother who was in Auschwitz? That kind of research?

The only people who want to question the Holocaust are anti-Semitic and don't give a damn about truth or free speech of which they lie as their motivation. it's a red herring.
 
You mean like my mother who was in Auschwitz? That kind of research?

The only people who want to question the Holocaust are anti-Semitic and don't give a damn about truth or free speech of which they lie as their motivation. it's a red herring.
So can I get this from you?

If you are SURE you are right, whatever that means, then you want to stop anyone from saying anything to the contrary?

On which issues?

What is the principle you wish to establsih into law here?

PAY ATTENTION, not talking about any specific issues here, what principle governs what can no longer be discussed, and what cannot, and (all importantly) -
WHO DECIDES THIS?
 
  • Like
Reactions: jacksparrow
You mean like my mother who was in Auschwitz? That kind of research?

The only people who want to question the Holocaust are anti-Semitic and don't give a damn about truth or free speech of which they lie as their motivation. it's a red herring.
Shack is 100% correct. The facts are indisputable. The only people who dispute the Holocaust are neo nazis and white supremacists. They should be put in jail.

Anyway, it's an old argument. Holocaust denial has been prosecuted as a hate crime in this country since 1990. The neo nazis made the same spurious argument you make and were crushed quickly by the courts like the rancid vermin they truly are.

And our democracy didn't falter an iota. In fact, most people didn't even realize that it had happened.

What facts are indisputable? That is the point of this argument? What constitutes holocaust denial? People keep shifting the goalposts here to change the argument to did this happen or not? Yes something happened and that is indisputable. Saying it was a good thing is offensive and should not be allowed, but same with many other genocidal horrors throughout history.
Anything else should be up for questioning. The truth should never fear questions, quite the opposite, should make it stronger.

From a 1990 Chicago tribune article. https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1992-05-07-9202100662-story.html

"Beyond the Death Wall and the prisoners` barracks, past the ruined gas chambers and crematoriums, at the edge of the Auschwitz death camp, is a row of 19 concrete memorials.

The memorials are dedicated to the victims of the Nazi killing machine that operated here with such horrific efficiency. But gone now from the memorials are the 19 inscriptions that said in 19 languages that four million people died here.

The memorials are blank because they were wrong.

Jewish and Polish scholars of the Holocaust now agree that the Auschwitz death toll was less than half the four million cited here for four decades. The actual number was probably between 1.1 million and 1.5 million-and at least 90 percent of the victims were Jews."


Should that author go to jail? Is he a holocaust denier?







On a side note are the people who profit off of the suffering of holocaust victims equally rancid vermin?
 
What facts are indisputable? That is the point of this argument? What constitutes holocaust denial? People keep shifting the goalposts here to change the argument to did this happen or not? Yes something happened and that is indisputable. Saying it was a good thing is offensive and should not be allowed, but same with many other genocidal horrors throughout history.
Anything else should be up for questioning. The truth should never fear questions, quite the opposite, should make it stronger.

From a 1990 Chicago tribune article. https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1992-05-07-9202100662-story.html

"Beyond the Death Wall and the prisoners` barracks, past the ruined gas chambers and crematoriums, at the edge of the Auschwitz death camp, is a row of 19 concrete memorials.

The memorials are dedicated to the victims of the Nazi killing machine that operated here with such horrific efficiency. But gone now from the memorials are the 19 inscriptions that said in 19 languages that four million people died here.

The memorials are blank because they were wrong.

Jewish and Polish scholars of the Holocaust now agree that the Auschwitz death toll was less than half the four million cited here for four decades. The actual number was probably between 1.1 million and 1.5 million-and at least 90 percent of the victims were Jews."


Should that author go to jail? Is he a holocaust denier?







On a side note are the people who profit off of the suffering of holocaust victims equally rancid vermin?
Only one type of person, with only one motivation wants to discuss the possibility that the Holocaust did not occur as millions of pieces evidence have proven.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
What facts are indisputable? That is the point of this argument? What constitutes holocaust denial? People keep shifting the goalposts here to change the argument to did this happen or not? Yes something happened and that is indisputable. Saying it was a good thing is offensive and should not be allowed, but same with many other genocidal horrors throughout history.
Anything else should be up for questioning. The truth should never fear questions, quite the opposite, should make it stronger.
From a 1990 Chicago tribune article. https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1992-05-07-9202100662-story.html
"Beyond the Death Wall and the prisoners` barracks, past the ruined gas chambers and crematoriums, at the edge of the Auschwitz death camp, is a row of 19 concrete memorials.
The memorials are dedicated to the victims of the Nazi killing machine that operated here with such horrific efficiency. But gone now from the memorials are the 19 inscriptions that said in 19 languages that four million people died here.
The memorials are blank because they were wrong.
Jewish and Polish scholars of the Holocaust now agree that the Auschwitz death toll was less than half the four million cited here for four decades. The actual number was probably between 1.1 million and 1.5 million-and at least 90 percent of the victims were Jews."
Should that author go to jail? Is he a holocaust denier?

On a side note are the people who profit off of the suffering of holocaust victims equally rancid vermin?
Considering the author didn't deny the Holocaust and just said the total deaths were miscounted, it sounds like he's a legit historian.

The folks who got prosecuted were neo nazis who said the Holocaust was a myth created by the "International Zionist Conspiracy".

And who are the "people who profit off of the suffering of holocaust victims and are equally rancid vermin"?.... I'm not sure those exist.
 
Considering the author didn't deny the Holocaust and just said the total deaths were miscounted, it sounds like he's a legit historian.

The folks who got prosecuted were neo nazis who said the Holocaust was a myth created by the "International Zionist Conspiracy".

And who are the "people who profit off of the suffering of holocaust victims and are equally rancid vermin"?.... I'm not sure those exist.

There is a book called the Holocaust Industry by Norman Finkelstein. Interesting read. He risked a lot authoring it. Ballsy man. Check it out.
 
Only one type of person, with only one motivation wants to discuss the possibility that the Holocaust did not occur as millions of pieces evidence have proven.

Weak cowardly reply. Only one type of person rather than answer legitimate criticisms and questions simply replies by accusing everyone of being a nazi. You are not one of the chosen people Shack, we are all equal, no special privileges for you. Learn to deal with criticism like a man and stop kvetching.
 
Weak cowardly reply. Only one type of person rather than answer legitimate criticisms and questions simply replies by accusing everyone of being a nazi. You are not one of the chosen people Shack, we are all equal, no special privileges for you. Learn to deal with criticism like a man and stop kvetching.
You've previously asked. It's been answered numerous times. No need to answer again because the answer doesn't change.

What privileges did I ask for?

I never said that everyone is a nazi. Show me a quote where I said that. If not you can publicly apologize or shut up. I'll wait for that quote.
 
You've previously asked. It's been answered numerous times. No need to answer again because the answer doesn't change.

What privileges did I ask for?

I never said that everyone is a nazi. Show me a quote where I said that. If not you can publicly apologize or shut up. I'll wait for that quote.
He never answers, he just repeats that he has already answered it.

LOL, and yet HE is the one saying that the facts are indisputable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.