Death at The Derby

bestillmehard said:
Eight Belles broke down AFTER the race. She was gallopping out when she broke her ankles. She ran a damn good race and went out a super star! RIP lil fille


Well PETA thinks like me also that the horse must have been hurt BEFORE the race was over with.
http://customwire.ap.org/dynamic/st...ME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2008-05-04-18-33-43

NORFOLK, Va. (AP) -- People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals is seeking the suspension of Eight Belles' jockey after the filly had to be euthanized following her second-place finish in the Kentucky Derby on Saturday.

Gabriel Saez was riding Eight Belles when she broke both front ankles while galloping out a quarter of a mile past the wire. She was euthanized on the track.

PETA faxed a letter Sunday to Kentucky's racing authority claiming the filly was "doubtlessly injured before the finish" and asked that Saez be suspended while Eight Belles' death is investigated.

"What we really want to know, did he feel anything along the way?" PETA spokeswoman Kathy Guillermo said. "If he didn't then we can probably blame the fact that they're allowed to whip the horses mercilessly."

Guillermo said if Saez is found at fault, the group wants the second-place prize of $400,000 won by Eight Belles to be revoked.

Saez, a 20-year-old Panama native, was riding in his first Kentucky Derby. He frequently rides for Eight Belles trainer Larry Jones.

A call to the jockeys' room at Delaware Park, where Saez raced on Sunday, went unanswered.

Eight Belles, the first filly since 1999 to run in the Derby, appeared fine until collapsing while galloping out after the finish.

The letter to the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority also sought a ban on whipping, limits on races and the age of racehorses, and a move to softer, artificial surfaces for all courses.
 
Not sure if a replay of the race can be found-maybe Y-tube?-but I recall seeing that horse gaining on Big Brown but then it backed off. I watch many races before, it did seem strange. It was only for like 2-3 seconds that she was gaining on him. Most of the time it goes on for 10-20 seconds.

Thats why I think the horse got hurt before the race was over.
 
SC Joe....you are missing the point.

It's about "free will". The ability to make a choice. There is no way you can compare some kid playing football, and getting pressure from his parents to be sucessful, and exploiting a non-sentient life for your own pleasure.

I've quoted this before on here, but I believe it was Ghandi who said that the measure of a civilization will be judged on how "it" treats those of less fortunate circumstances. As the dominant life form on this planet, we may eat meat, and use animal hides for clothing, but do we have to make their deaths painful and their final moments full of fear and stress?

It's just not necessary to race horses and put them in mortal danger...except to provide us entertainment, and the thrill of "wagering" a sum of money on the outcome.
 
It's not unusual for horses to sustain an injury during a race, and still keep going. Often only a very small change in their stride will be noticable to the jock. These horses are bred to be competitive, and adrenlin can keep them going, except in a case of a catastrophic injury. By catastrophic injury, I mean a compound fracture, where the bone breaks through the skin.

Most likely, the initial break happened during the stretch drive, probably the sesamoid bone. When this bone gave way, and it's attachment to suspensory ligament, the full weight of the horse came bearing down on the ankle bone. We're talking about 1000's of pounds of force on an area about 4-5 inches across. And probably immature bone, not yet fully set, as horses grow well into their 4th year.

As far as the whipping aspect, it's been my experience you can't whip speed into a horse...very often it's the surprise aspect of a crack across the ass and the noise of the whip on the saddle pad that spurs horses on at critical times in the stretch drive. PETA needs to know that the horses are checked by the attending track vet for any mark made by the whip, and any rider or driver that brings back a horse that's been abused gets a big fine and a long suspension. PETA is just looking to score some political points and get their names in the paper.
 
The Cunning Linguist said:
It's very sad to see animals put in a position where they might die for our amusement and enjoyment.

Animals are used for our entertainment, food, and even as subservient slaves (the domesticated cat and dog). That's the way it is.
 
Don said:
Animals are used for our entertainment, food, and even as subservient slaves (the domesticated cat and dog). That's the way it is.

What century did you "teleport" in from? It may be the "way it is", but that doesn't make it right.

I'm not sure about the cat/slave concept though....I think it might be the other way around.

There's joke that when we provide food, shelter, and affection to a dog, he must think "what a powerful being to give this all to me...he must be a GOD."

A cat thinks..."I must be a GOD because this powerful being is giving me food, shelter, and affection (when I want it, BTW).:)
 
I admittedly know almost nothing about horse racing, but I've always wondered why a leg fracture would require the horse be killed. Is there no way they could be operated on and have the affected leg repaired?
 
its weird. the only female finishes second. Big Brown is the winner. was there a horse called "old white guy" in the race?
 
red said:
its weird. the only female finishes second. Big Brown is the winner. was there a horse called "old white guy" in the race?
Nope. That would be the owners.
 
Well Mexico has bull fighting, we have horse racing. Maybe its not right, it would not bother me much if horse racing was stop. But it won't happen. Too much money is made, theres Visa, Budweiser-Bud even uses horses in its ads.

The age should be raised from 3 years old to 4 but unless this keeps on happening-and it be "better" if 2-3 horses drop in 1 race-the rules won't change because thats just how the rules have been for 134 years.

It be nice if the horses could get like a brace on their legs before they break it but I am sure its been thought of and guess it can't be done.

As I get older it seems like less things get to me. Look at that Husband and Wife who were stab to death last week. They left behind a 19 and 21 year old kids. This coming week somebody else will most likely die a senseless death. Another horse will breakdown.

Sometimes I can understand these people who don't read a newspaper, watch TV, etc. They just block out the world and carry on with their daily life.
 
Asterix said:
I admittedly know almost nothing about horse racing, but I've always wondered why a leg fracture would require the horse be killed. Is there no way they could be operated on and have the affected leg repaired?


What I learn thanks to that other horse is that horses need to stand all the time-maybe they can lay down but only for a short while. As they stand, all their weight needs to be equal on all 4 legs. If not, they get sick-I am not a vet. Since that horse had 2 bad legs, there was no hope at all saving it.
 
Asterix said:
I admittedly know almost nothing about horse racing, but I've always wondered why a leg fracture would require the horse be killed. Is there no way they could be operated on and have the affected leg repaired?
http://www.wisegeek.com/why-are-broken-legs-so-dangerous-for-horses.htm

It's sad, but in in many cases it's the most humane thing to do.

Don said:
Animals are used for our entertainment, food, and even as subservient slaves (the domesticated cat and dog). That's the way it is.
So if I want to entertain myself by throwing cats off the roof of my building then I should be allowed to? Animals are used for our entertainment. That's the way it is.
 
Very sad :(

I wonder if the filly in question was pin fired? Does anyone know? Pin firing is used to alleviate chronic injury; in other words they re-injure the legs, generally below the cannon, by cauterizing nerve endings so that the horse can still run when there would otherwise be chronic swelling or pain..completely disgusting I know, but it may be an explanation as to why she kept running....

Steph
416-966-6966
www.torontovixens.com
 
First off........I think she put in a couple of "bad" strides about a sixteenth of a mile from the finish.....or about 6 or 7 seconds from the finish line.

As for what Steph said above, the top trainer in Florida was ruled off the track for having the leg of his horse cut off after it broke down a few years ago............they figured he had "denerved" the horse so that it wouldn't feel the pain of it's bad legs!!

But he carries on today........elsewhere..........still winning at 30 percent!!:eek:
 
It's a stupid barbaric "sport". Should be outlawed like cock-fighting.
 
Humans use animals for all kinds of reasons it's up to the individual to decide
if it's right for them as an individual.

Some kill wild animals for sport, some race horses, some ride Bulls, some run their dogs to pull a sled, and even some ride dolphins!!!!
 
stang said:
It's a stupid barbaric "sport". Should be outlawed like cock-fighting.

You come to my barnyard and punch my cock and I will promise you a fight. :eek:


Seriously, I agree with you on both accounts...........