Dear Americans....

You obviously do not understand my post, therefore I will help you understand it by providing details.
"Canada has been involved to some degree in every military conflict that the US has had" including the Iraq War

So, just to be clear, you are agreeing that I was correct in saying Canada hasn't fought in Iraq or Vietnam. You are pointing at non-combat contributions.

Just for the record then, how much money did Canada spend on the Iraq war, as a percentage of Canadian GDP?
 
So, just to be clear, you are agreeing that I was correct in saying Canada hasn't fought in Iraq or Vietnam. You are pointing at non-combat contributions.

Just for the record then, how much money did Canada spend on the Iraq war, as a percentage of Canadian GDP?

Given that the entire defense spend is 1% of GDP you don't spend much of anything on any engagement.....

OTB
 
Given that the entire defense spend is 1% of GDP you don't spend much of anything on any engagement.....

OTB

And the USA spends more than every country in the world combined, with almost 400 military bases across the globe. Last check, US Defence spending (up front costs) was somewhere around 750 billion. Total US budget is around 3.5 Trillion. Truth be told, the total cost of the US military is probably closer to a trillion dollars now (if you add in all the hidden money that goes to finance various R n D associated with the Industrial Military complex.

The US can't afford it's defence wish list anymore.

You laugh at the Euro-weenies and their gov't spending, but you'd better take a hard look at your own lifestyle that you can't afford anymore.
 
You laugh at the Euro-weenies and their gov't spending, but you'd better take a hard look at your own lifestyle that you can't afford anymore.
Which means Canada and other states are either going to have to increase their defence budgets or be willing to suffer the potential consequences up to losing national sovereignty.

When there is no longer a benign uncle or godfather to depend upon - life can be rough out there in the real world where there are muggers and worse.
 
Last edited:
Just for the record, you don't understand the complexity of war.

Let me summarize where we are at:

-- Canada has not committed the lives of any Canadian forces soldiers to the Iraq war

-- Canada has not committed any significant money or other resources to the Iraq war

But, because we have some minor engagements, token in both quantity and quality, you think that I do not understand the "complexities" of war.

I understand the "complexities" of this: We have essentially nothing on the line in Iraq.
 
Given that the entire defense spend is 1% of GDP you don't spend much of anything on any engagement.....

OTB

That's true. Unlike the United States, Canada is not a warlike nation.

However, even by the small standards of a Canadian military deployment, we have nothing invested in Iraq.
 
And the USA spends more than every country in the world combined, with almost 400 military bases across the globe. Last check, US Defence spending (up front costs) was somewhere around 750 billion. Total US budget is around 3.5 Trillion. Truth be told, the total cost of the US military is probably closer to a trillion dollars now (if you add in all the hidden money that goes to finance various R n D associated with the Industrial Military complex.

The US can't afford it's defence wish list anymore.

You laugh at the Euro-weenies and their gov't spending, but you'd better take a hard look at your own lifestyle that you can't afford anymore.

To some extent we agree here. I've argued for a while now that we should close our bases in Europe and bring the troops home (I think we have more boots on the ground in Europe than we do in Afghanistan and Iraq), I'd do the same in Japan and South Korea. I don't see Russia as a credible threat to the US - to the extent they are a credible threat to Europe, so what. Same is true for China and North Korea - so what.

We're blessed with two neighbors that are both militarily incapable and who only want to come here to work, not invade. Build a few more Carriers and project power from home....

OTB
 
To some extent we agree here. I've argued for a while now that we should close our bases in Europe and bring the troops home (I think we have more boots on the ground in Europe than we do in Afghanistan and Iraq), I'd do the same in Japan and South Korea. I don't see Russia as a credible threat to the US - to the extent they are a credible threat to Europe, so what. Same is true for China and North Korea - so what.

We're blessed with two neighbors that are both militarily incapable and who only want to come here to work, not invade. Build a few more Carriers and project power from home....

OTB

The way the debt is now in the states, I think a hard rain is gonna fall.

There is going to have to be some very tough choices in the future in terms of cost cutting. There will be no sacred cows - including the military.

Americans really love all the military toys don't they. Things that go boom.
 
The way the debt is now in the states, I think a hard rain is gonna fall.

There is going to have to be some very tough choices in the future in terms of cost cutting. There will be no sacred cows - including the military.

Americans really love all the military toys don't they. Things that go boom.

It's the only department in the Federal government that does what it's supposed to better than anyone else.....

OTB
 
Given that the entire defense spend is 1% of GDP you don't spend much of anything on any engagement.....

OTB

Looks like they have their priories right!
Since YOU support 'war mongering', of course you would disagree here...:rolleyes:
 
It's the only department in the Federal government that does what it's supposed to better than anyone else.....

OTB

Ha, are you really that naive? I would bet both my balls that if you let our Auditor General loose in the Pentagon she would find corruption, incompetence, greed, empire building, and graft beyond your WILDEST dreams.
 
It's the only department in the Federal government that does what it's supposed to better than anyone else.....

OTB

Really! Using your 'fuzzy math' again....
Seem to recall they LOST how many BILLIONS in Iraq not to mention their untold number of cost over-runs on just about EVERY weapons system in the last 50 or more years.....:rolleyes:
 
Yeah that one, based on falsified information.

However I'm not convinced by the "grab the oil" explanation. I am just baffled honestly. Saddam was quite happy to sell oil to Americans at the fair market price. The new Iraq government does exactly the same thing.

If you take the cost of this war, what is it $700 billion dollars now, and divide it by the number of barrels of oil that Iraq has produced since (about 2.4 mil barrels per day) then that is some spectacularly expensive oil: The war cost SEVENTEEN YEARS of total Iraqi oil output, plus the US still pays the market rate for that oil on top of the cost of the war. And that's just the cost to date... the cost is still rising.

Even if the US were to get all Iraq's oil for free, which they don't, the war would not have been cost effective.
 
Yeah that one, based on falsified information.

However I'm not convinced by the "grab the oil" explanation. I am just baffled honestly. Saddam was quite happy to sell oil to Americans at the fair market price.

Even if the US were to get all Iraq's oil for free, which they don't, the war would not have been cost effective.

Dubya and his DICK thought it could be a simple OIL grab.

Their plan was swoop in and be greeted as heroes being welcomed with rose petals by Iraqis glad the evil ally of Team 'w', Saddam, is removed. Then KBR would roll in to make a fortune rebuilding all that we destroyed, paid for with Iraqi OIL so it wouldn't cost Team 'w' and the USA a penny. Then an ever grateful 'new' Iraq puppet gov Dubya created, would extend long term OIL deals to the USA BIG OIL Interests for the next 100 yrs!

Brilliant Idea, looked great on paper to oilman DICK!
What could possibly go wrong?....:p