Deadbeat dad in Ontario? Genius solution devised....

do you guys ever READ my posts about the legal system? Even if they interfere with your good times ranting about politics?

Have a good thread, fellows. I've done my duty and shall depart.

Must be nice to be so awesome.
 
An endearing comment. Actually, my shyster-ism covers over 2 decades and every other family court lawyer - oops, I mean "shyster" - would echo my position. But we're all shysters and you clearly know more than we do.

Actually my response was directed to Colt.
I did not care to be told that the true scenario I described is "fantasy"
Are you & he of one mind ?

Let me make it very clear for you
I recognize that Deadbeat Dads are a huge issue and there are many kids who are denied the the basics (food, clothing, shelter) and there is no excuses for that
I have zero respect for any man who does not take care of his family.

However, there are many cases where the father is financial crippled based upon a decision by his wife to end the marriage.
She wins big and he pays big until the kids mature (15 to 20 years)
I know of several examples and there are posters here who are living this nightmare.
Fortunately I am personally not aware of any deadbeat dads.
I suspect I will know some in the future given a 50% divorce rate

As a lawyer you should no better than anyone that your objective in these cases is to minimize your clients liability or maximize your clients payout

So it often comes down to who has the better lawyer rather than what is the best thing for the kids.

Do I know more about the subject than you ?
Probably not

Can you 100% guarantee that not one father got screwed over royally in the thousands of divorces that have take place?
No

Can you speak for every single family court lawyer?
No

Did you need to respond with a smart ass remark dripping with sarcasm?
No

BTW , do the legal fees for these proceeding impact the kids at all by making the pie smaller?
 
Let me make it very clear for you
I recognize that Deadbeat Dads are a huge issue and there are many kids who are denied the the basics (food, clothing, shelter) and there is no excuses for that
I have zero respect for any man who does not take care of his family.

The problem with chasing deadbeats and expecting to make money is that it makes everyone a loser. How often do you see cops chasing down criminals and making them productive members of society?

You simply have to change the equation. If someone wants to be a deadbeat loser, they will succeed. Make the system so it is in the father's interests to pay for the education of as many kids as possible. Make it simple like the income tax system, and not so incredibly punative.

Fundamentally, the Common-Law system is set up to address an inequity by transferring funds from any deep-pocket to a victim. The best solutions to this is to either (a) minimize income so you are not a deep pocket, and/or (b) don't have kids. We have declining birth rates. We have fathers who don't work overtime to be with their kids. We have single stay-at-home Moms. Everyone in the system is poor. This solution minimizes the aggregate risk of having kids.

Alternatively, the child support system could be so straightforward. Every kid you father is an extra 10% income tax. Every kid you help raise, in your own home, is 10% less income tax. Make it so it is in a man's best interest to be supporting kids.
 
Again, strict penalties on deadbeat dads not only force deadbeats to cough up funds, but also deter guys from fathering kids they have no intention to support. Spend some time talking to single mothers in countries that have no legal apparatus to force support payment and hear about their life experiences.

It is just fucking incredible what some guys will do if they can get away with it with impunity.

right. as people are having sex they think of the consequences.

i know plenty of single moms, single dads- divorced/widowed/never married. and yes there are plenty of people who will not do what they should. - though all of that has nothing to do with whether criminalizing someone over a civil dispute makes sense or taking away their car which they may need to make a living.
 
Child support is really alimony.. lets face it.. it is often grossly in exess of what is really required for care of a child. Especially if you happen to be a high income earner.

Yeah, a dollar a day for food and a roll of garbage bags for clothes and shelter'll keep any kid alive. On the other hand, what's wrong with dividing the entire family income stream by the number of folks in the family and saying, 'there, that determines the available support per child, pay up your share' ? Just as a f'rinstance.

People who quibble about the amount of child support should be sterilized. I know it's a bit late, but better than never.

The car things perhaps a foolish way to wake up someone who's proven he doesn't think first or live up to his responsibilities, but you gotta start somewhere, and seizing something he cares about is a start.
 
I hate to say it, but I regard divorced parents as TRASH. Maybe one person is not to blame for the split up, but even then it was THEY that made a bad choice of partner to have kids with. And it's a fair bet both sides showed selfishness and inability to PUT THEIR CHILDREN FIRST.

The result is the kids grow up in a fragmented family, and are more likely to repeat the cycle in the next generation.



Agreed.


Did you consider that by splitting up they may just be putting the children first. Many stay together "for the sake of the children" an only end up doing more harm to the children that if they had gone their separate ways.
 
True enough, but still the mistake was made to have kids in the first place without being totally sure of a stable relationship.
 
There's no 'sure' in the future, or relationships, only commitment. Whatever you feel against/for your ex should have nothing to do with you and your kids. You owe them everything they need to grow up healthy, happy and educated. You made that committment when you didn't use birth control.

Whatever your ex is or is not paying. Whatever someone else might or might not pay is also beside the point. Whatever has happened to your situation, good or bad, you still owe them.

Once a court's gotten in there, those various balances have supposedly been weighed and adjusted, and either party can go back to readjust.

So you pay.
 
though all of that has nothing to do with whether criminalizing someone over a civil dispute makes sense or taking away their car which they may need to make a living.

Maybe we should make it explicitly criminal to fail to support your children.
 
Maybe we should make it explicitly criminal to fail to support your children.

A good friend of mine is going through a divorce. It isn't finalized yet, but because his soon-to-be-ex wife decided to spend a few extra hours with a mediator on her own, he was forced to pay for that mediator. And his salary was garnisheed because he didn't want to pay for something he didn't agree to nor participate in (he had agreed to participate as long as his insurance through work covered the sessions; that ran out earlier this year).

He didn't get so much as a hearing before his salary was garnisheed.

And now you want him thrown in jail because of a bill he didn't receive benefit from, didn't agree to, and therefore didn't pay in advance?

Get your head out of your a**.
 
I've had some experience with people in a country where women have absolutely no legal recourse of any kind to collect anything at all from men who father children and then walk away. It's sickening what happens there.

Before you knock the system we have, go look what happens in countries that have nothing like it. Truly awful things happen.
 
A good friend of mine is going through a divorce. It isn't finalized yet, but because his soon-to-be-ex wife decided to spend a few extra hours with a mediator on her own, he was forced to pay for that mediator. And his salary was garnisheed because he didn't want to pay for something he didn't agree to nor participate in (he had agreed to participate as long as his insurance through work covered the sessions; that ran out earlier this year).

He didn't get so much as a hearing before his salary was garnisheed.


And now you want him thrown in jail because of a bill he didn't receive benefit from, didn't agree to, and therefore didn't pay in advance?

Get your head out of your a**.
How is this a reply to?:
Maybe we should make it explicitly criminal to fail to support your children.
Were there even children involved? If there were, I'd have thought mediation would have been the first resort after they realized they couldn't communicate.

Whatever the stupidities and injustices iof the Family Law system here, it is the system. In the end—and your friend isn't there yet—it comes up with an amount that must be paid for the kid's support.

They're your kids. You pay, and if you're worthy of the title 'parent', you wish you could pay more.
 
A good friend of mine is going through a divorce. It isn't finalized yet, but because his soon-to-be-ex wife decided to spend a few extra hours with a mediator on her own, he was forced to pay for that mediator. And his salary was garnisheed because he didn't want to pay for something he didn't agree to nor participate in (he had agreed to participate as long as his insurance through work covered the sessions; that ran out earlier this year).

He didn't get so much as a hearing before his salary was garnisheed.

And now you want him thrown in jail because of a bill he didn't receive benefit from, didn't agree to, and therefore didn't pay in advance?

Get your head out of your a**.

Anynym, how can your friend be made to pay for a process he didn't agree to? I'm sure that his lawyer agreed with the other lawyer on a split of the mediation expenses or the judge made an order as to how the expenses were to be split. The issue for your friend is that the bill was left-open ended and he ended up paying for more hours than he expected. Maybe his lawyer should have anticipated what would happen.

In any event and given the massive upside of litigation expenses, an extra $500 or so in mediation costs isn't really that much if it saved the couple $5,000.00 in extra legal fees. It's just a sticking point that your friend is annoyed over as a focus for his general frustration with having to go to court and fight his ex wife.

And he doesn't get a hearing on a garnishment. It's just an execution of something the judge has already ordered and not a new step in the proceedings.
 
Must be nice to be so awesome.

I'm the only family law lawyer participating in this thread and my experiential advantage over everybody else is exponential. Thus, my awesome-ness.

If I was a nuclear physicist and this was a thread about splitting the atom, I would be awesome in that thread instead.

This is an interesting point. No one figures that lawyers really KNOW anything. right? I mean, everyone admits that doctors know more about open heart surgery than the average joe and that structural engineers know more about making a suspension bridge than Mr Average. But lawyers, fuck 'em! Anyone can figure out law. Lawyers just exist to rip good people off.

So maybe you want to tell me what your legal qualifications are to get in my face?
 
BTW , do the legal fees for these proceeding impact the kids at all by making the pie smaller?

Not like they used to. Now that we have child support guidelines that are fairly standard, many thousands of dollars are being saved by doing less extensive financial statements and much shorter or no examinations under oath on support issues. And that is on a per case basis.

A significant part of the problem with the "common wisdom" about what happens in our legal system is that people don't understand what is happening (a communications problem) and they tell a friend who tells a friends and you end up with some poor information being shuttled through a really bad game of chinese telephone. Almost every study I have read (particularly about criminal law) shows the public really misunderstands what the legal system is doing.

By the by, I prefer "mouthpiece" to "shyster" but do have a serious bit of ambulance chaser thrown in for good measure.
 
Like Oagre, I am a family law lawyer.

The judge who is the head of the family law courts wrote an article saying very clearly that when men don't pay, they go to jail and when women deny access, they get asked politely to grant access. That was a judge who said that. His reasoning was that the mother can't be put in jail because they have to look after the children. I just hope this mentality doesn't spread so mothers can commit any crime and not be put in jail.

Any man who wants to have children should move to one of those horrible countries where the role of the father is given some respect. There are only a few countries like that left.

As for me, I am going to hire a surrogate mother when I have children.

I can assure you that marriage is nothing more than a transfer of wealth from men to women.
 
Last edited:
True enough, but still the mistake was made to have kids in the first place without being totally sure of a stable relationship.

Some couples split or drift apart because one of them may grow emotionally, spiritually or intellectually and grow new interests (One friends wife grew an interest in the neighbors cock), while the other does not grow emotionally, spiritually or intellectually and is content with the way things are.
Others breakups may also be the result of one person in the relationship who develops behavior problems eg gambling, excessive drinking , spousal violence, spending problems or starts whoring around........
And then there are the problems the husbands cause..... (kidding)

The point is there may have a strong commitment and a lot of love when the kids were born, and both were envisioning a long life together, but people can and do change and now they are no longer a good fit for each other

With a 50% divorce rate it happens a lot and while the kids suffer, sometimes its not real cut and dry who is too blame or even if blame should be allocated at all
 
I'm the only family law lawyer participating in this thread and my experiential advantage over everybody else is exponential. Thus, my awesome-ness.

If I was a nuclear physicist and this was a thread about splitting the atom, I would be awesome in that thread instead.

This is an interesting point. No one figures that lawyers really KNOW anything. right? I mean, everyone admits that doctors know more about open heart surgery than the average joe and that structural engineers know more about making a suspension bridge than Mr Average. But lawyers, fuck 'em! Anyone can figure out law. Lawyers just exist to rip good people off.

So maybe you want to tell me what your legal qualifications are to get in my face?

Don't need to. You were out of the thread, and I pulled you back in. That makes you a small man with such low self-esteem that he has to be seen to be a winner on the internet!!! Guess what the giant "L" stands for?!? You rock.