Deadbeat dad in Ontario? Genius solution devised....

wetnose

Gamahucher
Nov 14, 2006
2,442
0
36
They'll come and take your CAR

"Starting Dec. 1, someone (read “father”) in arrears on their support payments can have their car impounded. That’s about the stupidest punishment for non-payment one can imagine, since most people need their cars in order to work. As Lloyd Gorling, a father’s rights activist put it, “How are you going to make support payments if you can’t get to work? If you can’t make support payments, does the government really think you’re going to be taking a taxi every day to work?”"
 
They'll come and take your CAR

"Starting Dec. 1, someone (read “father”) in arrears on their support payments can have their car impounded. That’s about the stupidest punishment for non-payment one can imagine, since most people need their cars in order to work. As Lloyd Gorling, a father’s rights activist put it, “How are you going to make support payments if you can’t get to work? If you can’t make support payments, does the government really think you’re going to be taking a taxi every day to work?”"

The issue is that most of these guys work - under the table - and still don't pay support. The only thing that brings them to heel is having their licence suspended and even then, most of these scofflaws simply drive under suspensions. So the next step in the logical chain is to.....

If a guy loses his job - genuinely - he can apply to the court for relief and the judge will remove or reduce his child support until he is re employed.

The Men's Rights movement has a lot of catchy slogans and buzz phrases, but poke beneath the surface and it's 90% rhetoric.
 
You should check out what happens to women in countries that have lax or no government enforcement of child support. It becomes commonplace for guys get girls pregnant and then freely walk away from all their commitments without even a second thought about it. The women (and kids) end up absolutely in desperate straights, especially if they were in highschool when they got pregnant. It's really a fucked and very sad situation.

Tough support laws not only make sure that children get at least some of the support they need from the father, but also make sure that potential fathers think twice before pressuring their girl to fuck bareback.

There's a sure fire technology that's been invented that guarantees you will never have to pay child support, if used properly--it comes in a little wrapper and is lubricated or unlubricated at your preference. If on the other hand you make a conscious decision to bring a child into the world you really ought to be mentally prepared to support that child no matter what happens to your relationship.
 
Guys who don't pay their child support are dirt bags.....

OTB
 
Child support is really alimony.. lets face it.. it is often grossly in exess of what is really required for care of a child. Especially if you happen to be a high income earner.
 
Lots of situations where a guys income changes (down and up) and it takes months for FRO to catch up (or they may never change the situation) - this also applies to those who are paying and their time is up (ie kids no longer qualify) and it can be a few years before payments stop - in the meantime the money goes to the ex when the kids may be working and out of home - does the ex pass it along (highly unlikely in most cases).

It often takes the Ex to also stop the payments and you know how quickly some of these may take to do so.

Deatbeat Dads are an issue - can already lose your license, so taking the car is not a big step forward, however, the real problem lies within FRO.

Who even knows about FRO - who runs it? (ie staff), what accountability to they have? almost a 'secret' office that has no accountability or commitment to provide specific services.

BTW None of this is my personal experience - avoided having go through their office when divorcing and this is only form what I have read in divorce forums and some firends experiences - so will be ons sided to whomeever is complaining!
 
Child support is really alimony.. lets face it.. it is often grossly in exess of what is really required for care of a child. Especially if you happen to be a high income earner.

No. It is not grossly in excess of what is required for the care of a child. The figures are taken from a chart which is published by the government and is based on several months of research by a team of economists and social workers as to how much it genuinely takes to support a child.

Honestly, where do you get your information from?
 
Lots of situations where a guys income changes (down and up) and it takes months for FRO to catch up (or they may never change the situation) - this also applies to those who are paying and their time is up (ie kids no longer qualify) and it can be a few years before payments stop - in the meantime the money goes to the ex when the kids may be working and out of home - does the ex pass it along (highly unlikely in most cases).

It often takes the Ex to also stop the payments and you know how quickly some of these may take to do so.

Deatbeat Dads are an issue - can already lose your license, so taking the car is not a big step forward, however, the real problem lies within FRO.

Who even knows about FRO - who runs it? (ie staff), what accountability to they have? almost a 'secret' office that has no accountability or commitment to provide specific services.

BTW None of this is my personal experience - avoided having go through their office when divorcing and this is only form what I have read in divorce forums and some firends experiences - so will be ons sided to whomeever is complaining!

FRO is anonymous and their office is highly secure because of many threats and attempted assaults by deadbeat dads against staff. For the reason, the staff use first names and numbers and rarely meet dads in person. All FRO does is execute court judgments. They have little decision-making power. The courts and judges do all the work in setting amounts. In some instances, FRO will HELP the dad by not executing an out of date judgment when the ex agrees that the kids no longer qualify.

Yes, sometimes exes are bitches and play the system and keep the support running when the kids are working and out of the house. Moms scam the system too. The remedy is to go to court and the judge will make the mom present the kids school records and when she cannot show they are still in school, he will make her pay the money back.

Is this easy and convenient for the guy? No. But no court is. Court is the last resort of "shit happens" and is time consuming and sometimes expensive.

FRO doesn't "catch up" if a guy loses his job. It is the guy's responsibility to present papers to a judge proving his loss of income and then the judge will change the order. FRO just does what the judge tells it to.
 
Exactly the same thing if they have to pay child support.

good, often women are over looked and not even considered as dead beats. yes they don't leave as often as men but they do leave. anyone the leaves their kids should get chemically castrated and sent to prison.
 
Why not fine them, and if they don't pay, jail them for a bit. Taking away the car doesn't help matters really, especially if they just find another car and drive anyway. That whole relief process takes time and you can bet the nagging ex will be pushing and shoving for joe to get a tim hortons job so he can pay a cent or two.

I have heard that a lot of guys want to help their kids, but they do not want ANY of that money going into the "womans" pockets and often it does.

Sure, every prick dad and deadbeat dad I have ever talked to in 20 years of being a divorce lawyer tells me that Mom will just spend all the money on makeup and all the kids really need from him is a pack of diapers and a candy bar each month. In actual fact, the woman has to buy food and clothing for the kids and normally needs every penny of the support.

Losing your licence and car REALLY works with most deadbeat dads. For most of these dudes, driving around is a real status symbol of being a man and having to take TTC or beg for rides humiliates them and gets them paying. Judges will put these guys in jail as well; but that is seen as more drastic than suspending the driver's licence and is the next step along the trail.

Surprisingly, most of these deadbeats dads who have been telling a judge for years that they cannot pay, suddenly pay up within a day of being put in jail.
 
No. It is not grossly in excess of what is required for the care of a child. The figures are taken from a chart which is published by the government and is based on several months of research by a team of economists and social workers as to how much it genuinely takes to support a child.

Honestly, where do you get your information from?

You are assuming that government employees (probably mostly women) arrived at the correct figures ?????
When was the last time a government agency got things right?
When was the last time a government agency came in under budget?
Its inherent for government agencies to over spend and therefore over estimate true cost.

I have zero respect for any Dad (or Mom) who does not place the interest of their Kids first and foremost.

Some guys get royally screwed over
Wifey started fucking some other guy
She demands a divorce.
The lawyers tell him women win custody 90% of the time
He has to liquidate 50% of everything they owned. (Despite the fact he earned way more than she did- her talents were looking hot and spending)
He has to move out and pay for his new accommodations.
He then has to pay alimony (lump sum) and child support
I have heard from more than a few that it does not cost anywhere near the stated amount to support the kids
He gets to see his kids 1/2 as much as before and must rearrange his in order to do so
His kids arrive at his new (smaller) place needing new cloths.
His kids inadvertently tell Dad that Mom and the new guy are in the Caribbean on holiday, but have a new car and are getting a hot tub.
The kids also inadvertently Dad that the new guy shows next to zero interest in them and is a bit of a dick head

The guy sucks it up and continues to pay because he loves his kids, but he shakes his head and wonders
a) What the Fuck did he do to deserve this
b) How is this right?

I guess he is paying for the past sins of deadbeat dads
 
You are assuming that government employees (probably mostly women) arrived at the correct figures ?????
When was the last time a government agency got things right?
When was the last time a government agency came in under budget?
Its inherent for government agencies to over spend and therefore over estimate true cost.

I have zero respect for any Dad (or Mom) who does not place the interest of their Kids first and foremost.

Some guys get royally screwed over
Wifey started fucking some other guy
She demands a divorce.
The lawyers tell him women win custody 90% of the time
He has to liquidate 50% of everything they owned. (Despite the fact he earned way more than she did- her talents were looking hot and spending)
He has to move out and pay for his new accommodations.
He then has to pay alimony (lump sum) and child support
I have heard from more than a few that it does not cost anywhere near the stated amount to support the kids
He gets to see his kids 1/2 as much as before and must rearrange his in order to do so
His kids arrive at his new (smaller) place needing new cloths.
His kids inadvertently tell Dad that Mom and the new guy are in the Caribbean on holiday, but have a new car and are getting a hot tub.
The kids also inadvertently Dad that the new guy shows next to zero interest in them and is a bit of a dick head

The guy sucks it up and continues to pay because he loves his kids, but he shakes his head and wonders
a) What the Fuck did he do to deserve this
b) How is this right?

I guess he is paying for the past sins of deadbeat dads


I guarantee that you have spent zero time in any Family court. I also guarantee you that oagre has likely represented as many dads as he has mothers and he still has formed the opinions he has, which I share whole heartedly, based not on what "more than a few" have told me, but based on five years of practice. The scenario you have described above is nothing more than a fantasy that emerges from the bitterness that fuels the "men's rights" movement.
 
FRO is anonymous and their office is highly secure because of many threats and attempted assaults by deadbeat dads against staff. For the reason, the staff use first names and numbers and rarely meet dads in person. All FRO does is execute court judgments. They have little decision-making power. The courts and judges do all the work in setting amounts. In some instances, FRO will HELP the dad by not executing an out of date judgment when the ex agrees that the kids no longer qualify.

Yes, sometimes exes are bitches and play the system and keep the support running when the kids are working and out of the house. Moms scam the system too. The remedy is to go to court and the judge will make the mom present the kids school records and when she cannot show they are still in school, he will make her pay the money back.

Is this easy and convenient for the guy? No. But no court is. Court is the last resort of "shit happens" and is time consuming and sometimes expensive.

FRO doesn't "catch up" if a guy loses his job. It is the guy's responsibility to present papers to a judge proving his loss of income and then the judge will change the order. FRO just does what the judge tells it to.

Okay...that makes sense. I guess when I went through my court days, I was prepared and didn't give up anything I wasn't willing to - the problem then surfaces with the court system. On three occasions in court my ex brought up issues already documented and dealt with in prior sessions and I keep indicating that to the judge. The judge also missed some decisions in her documentation so I had to get that rectified (transcript and a motion) which is kind of tedious.

So part of the problem also lies with the courts and the documentation - so antiquated with how the process works. In theory the documents could be written up at the end of the court session, both parties sign and electronically submitted to the correct locations (ie FRO if required).
 
The mens rights movement so to speak got started becasue of the inequities of family court, when was the last time you heard about a mother being santioned for violating vistiation? It happens all the time, kids are sick, they are over at a friends, don't want to go... The list is endless.

Family court in respect to children is supposed to be about the best interest of the children, until equal rights under the law are given to both parents, actual rights not just lip service there wilalways be issues.
 
i hear what oagre says but I thinks it better to have the guy out of jail and in his car and working than the taking away his car and putting him in jail for what is really a civil dispute.
 
One other thing, by the time you are done with the impound towing and storage fees you will be out the better part of a grand if not more.... so how does that help the kids?
 
I agree.

Fathers should be pay child support but only 20% of income. I know a couple of guys who can't even pay rent because of they have to pay too much.
 
I guarantee that you have spent zero time in any Family court. I also guarantee you that oagre has likely represented as many dads as he has mothers and he still has formed the opinions he has, which I share whole heartedly, based not on what "more than a few" have told me, but based on five years of practice. The scenario you have described above is nothing more than a fantasy that emerges from the bitterness that fuels the "men's rights" movement.

As someone who has lived through (almost) precisely what JohnLarue discribes, I can tell you it's not based on fantasy. I fully agree with the need for child support, and certainly agree that there should be penalties, severe penalties, for those who don't pay. But, things are very much in the mother's favor these days.

For decades, fathers could just walk away from a marriage, paying all but nothing to help raise the kids. As often as not, they also walked out on the kids, leaving the mother doing the bulk of the child rearing, and earning money to support the children. Because of the magnitude of this problem, the courts pulled up their socks, and legislated more appropriate support requirements, so that mothers and children were no longer getting screwed by poor fathers. But, in the effort to "fix" the problem, they've gone too far.

Now, fathers are more involved with their kids than ever, and many of those of us who are divorced are very heavily involved in our childrens lives. We get them for 1/2 of the time, yet are required to pay large sums to the mother, with little to no no accountability on how she spends the money. I agree that the kids/mother should receive support to pay for food, home, clothes, etc.. but the amounts need to be realistic. There's absolutely no reason that I should have to live in a 2br apartment, have 2nd hand furniture, shop at discount stores, and drive a beat-up car, simply because our relationship didn't work and it is best for everyone that the marriage end.

In my case, she's rewarded with an extra $1500/mo child support for the next 15 years, which is almost 1/2 of my montly income.. makes it a bit hard to swallow when she goes on trips, has a new vehicle, a large house, and new clothes, while the kids come over and are wearing socks with holes and ripped jeans.