Dating someone with herpes

You're kind of obsessed with this aren't you?
Herpes sucks, but it's not as much of social suicide as some are claiming. Not to say it doesn't put a severe cramp (if you chose to disclose) your game, and the OP is right, for people in their 20s or younger (eek!) it's definitely a major stigma. But to compare these guys to lepers and zombies is too much. Most people never have any symptoms anyway.
Now AIDS, yeah, that's zombie-hood for sure
there are pics of people with AIDS there as well
AIDS I kinda can understand because it's too big to keep a secret plus you can gain some benefit from disclosing it
herpes however seems to carry nothing but stigma
 
there are pics of people with AIDS there as well
AIDS I kinda can understand because it's too big to keep a secret plus you can gain some benefit from disclosing it
herpes however seems to carry nothing but stigma

It is pretty stupid that in some circles herpes has more of a stigma than AIDS. I think it's because people assume that all people with herpes have blatant symptoms all the time, and if you catch it, you must have been sucking down a herpes sore or something. Whereas AIDS you can't tell who has it. Stupid, but I think that's the assumption

Then again, I'm sure some people with AIDS would gladly disagree with me on the stigma question
 
It is pretty stupid that in some circles herpes has more of a stigma than AIDS. I think it's because people assume that all people with herpes have blatant symptoms all the time, and if you catch it, you must have been sucking down a herpes sore or something. Whereas AIDS you can't tell who has it. Stupid, but I think that's the assumption

Then again, I'm sure some people with AIDS would gladly disagree with me on the stigma question

I am mainly concerned about anal, nasal, and ocular HSV 2 myself. I was taught that although anal was common, the nasal and ocular were rare. But after seeing a 14 year old boy present with nasal Herpes and hearing the specialist tell me it and ocular were becoming common........ well it is not pleasant to have it, or be seen with it.
 
I am mainly concerned about anal, nasal, and ocular HSV 2 myself. I was taught that although anal was common, the nasal and ocular were rare. But after seeing a 14 year old boy present with nasal Herpes and hearing the specialist tell me it and ocular were becoming common........ well it is not pleasant to have it, or be seen with it.

How would you even get nasal herpes?
That sounds so ridiculous to be not even plausible
 
It is pretty stupid that in some circles herpes has more of a stigma than AIDS. I think it's because people assume that all people with herpes have blatant symptoms all the time, and if you catch it, you must have been sucking down a herpes sore or something. Whereas AIDS you can't tell who has it. Stupid, but I think that's the assumption

Then again, I'm sure some people with AIDS would gladly disagree with me on the stigma question
AIDS gets sympathy while herpes gets none
 
How would you even get nasal herpes?
That sounds so ridiculous to be not even plausible

You put your nose where HSV 2 is shedding. For a guy, DATY is an easy way to do it. I do not care what it sounds like. HSV 2 can infect skin. It easily infects ANY boundary area between skin and mucous membranes. Look it up. Oh it also can other areas. :). If you cannot find it ask nicely and I will give you some links.
 
I am sorry that you do not like the information from the Journal for the American Medical Association and from the CDC. Most people consider them the cold standard for medical information.

I am sorry you dislike statistics and averages. I am sorry you do not understand that if you have 1 chance in 25 of something happening, for some it will happen the first time, for some the 100 time. If you do not understand means, averages, and standard deviations you should not try to talk about them. It makes your arguments sound foolish.

I am sorry that a man seeing a random woman has about 1 chance in 16 to 1 chance in 25 that she is infectious (HSV 2) when he sees her.

I am sorry you insist on going on about condoms and refusing to accept all the research that shows only reduce the risk by 25 to 50%.

I am sorry the Durex survey is not considered a scientific study and is more of a Penthouse letter than an item to be quoted. The average North American man has 9 lovers in his life. ANd the number that have HSV 2 is a published documented fact.

I am sorry but get a grip and stop making up your own statistics. What you think and what seems to be is really not considered proof in scientific terms.

I have not seen a study comparing the number of SPs who have HSV 2 vs. the general population in Canada or in North America. I have seen MANY studies proving that somewhere between 1/4 and 1/5 women in North America have it. Until I see a documented peer reviewed study telling me it is more or less prevalent in SPs I will continue to assume the numbers are valid for SPs.

Maybe it is best you just get tested (ask for the DNA test :) and if you are infected you can stop worrying about it and making up justifications?

I am sorry that your math still doesn't add up, despite how much you try to use all the facts you have layed out nicely. It is odd that put another way, all of your stats point to the "on average" claim you have made that "every single SP on Cupids, Mirage, Dreammakers, etc etc" all have HSV2 (because most of them have seen 50 clients or more).
 
I am sorry that your math still doesn't add up, despite how much you try to use all the facts you have layed out nicely. It is odd that put another way, all of your stats point to the "on average" claim you have made that "every single SP on Cupids, Mirage, Dreammakers, etc etc" all have HSV2 (because most of them have seen 50 clients or more).

On average the house always wins in Vegas. Some people come back with more money than they left with when they take a trip to Vegas. Both statements are true.

GO TO SCHOOL AND TAKE BASIC STATS AND PROBABILITIES. Until you understand probabilities talking to you about this topic is like trying to explain colors to a blind man. You lack the basic skills to discuss this.
 
The notion that Herpes is difficult to transmit is laughable. We're all careful about protected FS but most of us prefer (even insist upon) BBBJ.

If the male is a carrier the female in BBBJ is at significant risk. Once an SP catches it in this way, she's a distribution centre to all the clients she goes down upon.
 
A real doctor would automatically understand that exposure does not mean you will get the disease. A stupid attention whoring troll pretending to be a doctor and looking stuff up on the internet probably won`t.
You can get fucking in the ass by someone with Aids and you still only have a 1/3000 chance of getting Aids.
http://www.sfcityclinic.org/stdbasics/stdchart.asp

As for Herpes

http://www.healthassist.net/conditions/herpes.shtml
Only about 25% of people with genital HSV- 1 shed virus at all in the absence of symptoms,
yet
Let`s say you have an infected male and an uninfected female. If they avoid sex during outbreaks, don`t use condoms regularly, and don`t take antiviral therapy every day, the risk of transmission is about 10% per year.
Even though the person is shedding 1 in 4 times, and using no other precautions, if two people fuck continuously for a year that would be a 100 times yet there is only 10% chance of transmission.
If we assume they fuck twice a week and keep in mind one partner does have it and with those rates, your 1/25 chances of getting Herpes per act of coitus is pretty much full of shit.

From Webmd
http://blogs.webmd.com/genital-herpes-intimate-conversations/2005/12/herpes-transmission-facts.html

Lots of people ask me how likely it is that they will either contract or transmit a genital herpes (HSV 2) infection to a sexual partner, so I thought I would address that in today’s blog.

The first tool in reducing transmission rates is knowing whether herpes is even in a relationship! If two people have no idea that one of them is infected, they can’t begin to reduce the risk of transmitting the infection because they don’t know there is anything to be concerned about! So testing for genital herpes is the first step – finding out who is infected and who is not.

Let’s say you have an infected male and an uninfected female. If they avoid sex during outbreaks, don’t use condoms regularly, and don’t take antiviral therapy every day, the risk of tranmission is about 10% per year. But if you add condoms, it reduces transmission about about 50%, if he takes Valtrex 500 mg once a day, he can reduce transmission also by about 50%. So you can see that the numbers get very low!

If it is a woman infected with HSV 2 having sex with an uninfected male, given the circumstances listed above again, then the transmission rate is about 4% prior to the interventions of condoms and Valtrex.






From
http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/285/24/3100.full

Our study revealed several new findings about the frequency and prevention of transmission of HSV-2 infection to sexual partners. Among monogamous couples with 1 partner who had known symptomatic genital herpes and 1 who was susceptible, we showed that the rate of transmission from men to women is 8.9/10 000 sex acts.

I`m sorry you like to pretend to me a doctor when you obviously are not
I`m sorry that the Journal of the American Medical Associations says you don`t have a fucking clue what you are talking about.


I find it hilarious when you go around talking down to people when in fact you are not only a troll, but a rather dumb misinformed one. Not that you won`t stop trying.
You go on about about all these fictional patients of yours and your medical school and your posting this from a boat in the Bermuda Triangle, please do shut the fuck up.

Because again, exposure does not mean infection. Fuck, I am not a Doctor but even I know that, anyone who has ever caught a cold knows that.
Although to be fair I read about transmission rates within relationships on a threat in https://merb.cc years ago.
I believe on Merb a fucker like you would get banned for passing fake medical credentials and false medical information.
 
GO TO SCHOOL AND TAKE BASIC STATS AND PROBABILITIES. Until you understand probabilities talking to you about this topic is like trying to explain colors to a blind man. You lack the basic skills to discuss this.

A bit rich from someone whom I've proved does not know anything about how disease transmits and yet claims to have gone to medical school and has patients.
 
A real doctor would automatically understand that exposure does not mean you will get the disease. A stupid attention whoring troll pretending to be a doctor and looking stuff up on the internet probably won't.

I had typed in an answer but you changed your post, so it became a lot of work to re address the issues.

It seems you have trouble understanding simple concepts :) Perhaps if you read post 58 you will discover I did mention that exposure/inoculation does not equal infection. You might want to re-read that post.

How infectious is it? AMA, WHO, and CDC all rate it as highly infectious. Who am I to argue? If 1 in 4 or 1 in 5 women have it, IT IS FUCKING INFECTIOUS (pun intended).

Why do your papers seem to contradict some of my statements? Because I am referring to the 21st century :) And in the 70s, 80s, and 90s there was no effective method of measuring shedding. I think the first papers referring to using DNA tests for swabs was in 2002. I wonder if you can find references telling us the world is flat. I bet you can :)

YOU are the only idiot who seems to insist that exposure equals infection. I know I did not.

Banning? Well I think someone who is to careless to read what is typed, and cannot understand that in the medical field 1985 references are a little past their prime, deserves to be a candidate for a stupid fat guy award :)

What part of 1 in 4 or 1 in 5 woman are already infected do you not understand? Without a high transfer rate that is impossible.

I am glad you have opinions and want to express them. Pity you do not have the necessary skills for the opinions to be informed.
 
A bit rich from someone whom I've proved does not know anything about how disease transmits and yet claims to have gone to medical school and has patients.

Actually your he did not understand probabilities and proved that.

You have proven you like to put words in peoples mouths they never said. You also have proven you do research at a high school level and do not bother checking if a refrence has been updated.

Surprise surprise, some things on the internet are outdated; some are wrong.
 
The notion that Herpes is difficult to transmit is laughable.

I just felt like quoting you ;)

I think it was Stanberry LR, Spruance SL, Cunningham AL, et al. Glycoprotein-D-adjuvant vaccine to prevent genital herpes. N Engl J Med 2002; 347:1652-61. Whose sample for the vacine reported in part.......

"showed efficacy in females who were seronegative for both HSV-1 and HSV-2 (efficacy=74%; 95% CI, 9 to 93). In this subgroup, the transfer rate of genital herpes was 3.5% in the treatment group and 13.3% in the placebo group"

Of course that is based on seronegative / positive DNA testing, not the far less effective methodology used in the last century. 13.3 % transfer rate during a short term test...... Oh my!
 
How infectious is it? AMA, WHO, and CDC all rate it as highly infectious. Who am I to argue? If 1 in 4 or 1 in 5 women have it, IT IS FUCKING INFECTIOUS (pun intended).

Why do your papers seem to contradict some of my statements? Because I am referring to the 21st century :) And in the 70s, 80s, and 90s there was no effective method of measuring shedding. I think the first papers referring to using DNA tests for swabs was in 2002. I wonder if you can find references telling us the world is flat. I bet you can :)

YOU are the only idiot who seems to insist that exposure equals infection. I know I did not.

Banning? Well I think someone who is to careless to read what is typed, and cannot understand that in the medical field 1985 references are a little past their prime, deserves to be a candidate for a stupid fat guy award :)

What part of 1 in 4 or 1 in 5 woman are already infected do you not understand? Without a high transfer rate that is impossible.

I am glad you have opinions and want to express them. Pity you do not have the necessary skills for the opinions to be informed.

The study I quoted is from the mid 90's. Not 1985. What was that about not being able to do research and who is being careless with the reading.
The jama study ALSO gave the same shedding numbers you do and similar population levels.
I never said anything about Herpes not being infectious, just that your numbers are horrible removed from reality. I guess a strawman is easier for you to deal with.
But the average guy is not taking those things into account. He is not doing them. Risk of being exposed to the HSV 2 virus during a sex act with an untested partner is about 1 /25. Probability of HSV 2 taking hold and showing symptoms, harder to predict, but in the 1 / 2 range fits the the transfer rate. It can be argued that on the average if you see 50 women, you will be infected.


I've shown this to be utterly and completely wrong. You can take your attitude and go fuck yourself because you are an inferior. You have not earned the right to talk down to me or to anyone else on terb. You have a lot of nerve tossing around those accusations on that other thread when you are the queen of tossing around insults, granted they are usually really ironic coming from you but still.

Actually your he did not understand probabilities and proved that.

You have proven you like to put words in peoples mouths they never said. You also have proven you do research at a high school level and do not bother checking if a refrence has been updated.

Surprise surprise, some things on the internet are outdated; some are wrong.

Putting things into peoples mouths, you mean like how you claimed that I said Herpes was not all that infectious vs saying your numbers are wrong. That you can't tell the difference between those two statements.

Yes because we all know the Herpes of today is completely different from the herpes of the 1970's The modern Herpes years hoodies and eats skittles and transmits so much easier because it is Ghetto yo, not like those hippie herpes from the 70's Really from around 1/1000 to 1/50? I don't think so Tim. Never mind that the Jama article is from the mid 90's. Nice job with the internet comment. We all know the Journal of the American Medical association is just one of those shady internet sites. That is cheap rhetoric.

You are clown shoes. You will keep coming back with more blah blah blah, but anyone else with half a clue [like just about anyone on Terb who has paid attention and isn't a white knight] has your number and knows you are full of shit.

If just about everyone has no respect for you... maybe it is you.



Oh and remember when you were getting all holier then thou when I had some missed words and typos. Payback is a bitch. WTF is that stuff in bold supposed to be.


And as I said elsewhere, I am not actually arguing with you, I am just warning the others who don't know about you.
I am done with this thread. I knew you would come back with some lame response that would fail and miss the point although I didn't expect it to set you up for more ridicule. Any response you might have is just not worth reading.
 
The study I quoted is from the mid 90's. Not 1985. What was that about not being able to do research and who is being careless with the reading.

You spout so much misinformation I hardly know where to start. You are more into arguing and proving me wrong than seeking any semblance of truth.

You quoted 3 web sites. All of them were based on information collected in the last century. One of them is based on papers published in 1985. This is important because there were major changes in the ability to detect and recognize HSV 1 and 2 in the early years of the 21 st century. Those changes made it possible to detect infections while still dormant, and to use swabs to determine if shedding was present. Before that shedding studies were more or less guesses. After it became possible to detect HSV shedding using simple swab tests on the skin huge progress was made and many old belief had to be re-evaluated.

Always look at when the tests are conducted, or in "review" documents look at what studies it is quoting. :)
 
I never said anything about Herpes not being infectious, just that your numbers are horrible removed from reality. I guess a strawman is easier for you to deal with.


Originally Posted by mrsCALoki

From Mrs CALoki "the average guy is not taking those things into account. He is not doing them. Risk of being exposed to the HSV 2 virus during a sex act with an untested partner is about 1 /25. Probability of HSV 2 taking hold and showing symptoms, harder to predict, but in the 1 / 2 range fits the the transfer rate. It can be argued that on the average if you see 50 women, you will be infected."

I've shown this to be utterly and completely wrong. You can take your attitude and go fuck yourself because you are an inferior.


Oh. I am so horrified at that. Let me get this straight in my tiny little blond head :). Most research in Canada (other than Playmate type unscientific poles) tells me that the average guy has sex with 5 to 10 women during his entire life. WHO, CDC etc tell us 1 in 6 to 1 in 10 guys already have HSV 2. I am allowing for the wide range since different studies use different criteria. So arguably (notice I used that word again), if you see 10 women on average 1 guy in 6 will catch / get / become infected with HSV 2. If that did not happen we would not have the infection levels in the world population.

It could be argued (note use of that standard phrase) that on the average if a guy sees approximately 50 women th odds are very high that he will have caught / gotten / have HSV .

Gee the over all stats and the stats developed working it from the other end are close. Who could have guessed?
 
Oh. I am so horrified at that. Let me get this straight in my tiny little blond head :). Most research in Canada (other than Playmate type unscientific poles) tells me that the average guy has sex with 5 to 10 women during his entire life. WHO, CDC etc tell us 1 in 6 to 1 in 10 guys already have HSV 2. I am allowing for the wide range since different studies use different criteria. So arguably (notice I used that word again), if you see 10 women on average 1 guy in 6 will catch / get / become infected with HSV 2. If that did not happen we would not have the infection levels in the world population.

It could be argued (note use of that standard phrase) that on the average if a guy sees approximately 50 women th odds are very high that he will have caught / gotten / have HSV .

Gee the over all stats and the stats developed working it from the other end are close. Who could have guessed?

images
 
You have not earned the right to talk down to me or to anyone else on terb. You have a lot of nerve tossing around those accusations on that other thread when you are the queen of tossing around insults, granted they are usually really ironic coming from you but still.

Well hun, the problem is when someone proves beyond a reasonable doubt, like a previous poster did, that they do not understand a normal distribution, or standard deviations, it makes it exceptionally hard to discuss statistic analysis with them.

Anyone who cannot cope with mathematics is not fully human. At best he is a tolerable subhuman who has learned to wear shoes, bathe and not make messes in the house.
--Lazarus Long,

I am not a good teacher. I refuse to go back to prime principals to bring a person with Junior High math skills up to Epidemiology 101. :).

In your case, I am treating you the same way I treat anyone in extreme denial when exposed to information they do not like :).
 
Yes because we all know the Herpes of today is completely different from the herpes of the 1970's The modern Herpes years hoodies and eats skittles and transmits so much easier because it is Ghetto yo, not like those hippie herpes from the 70's Really from around ...... .

Pointing out the obvious is starting to get boring :)

Once upon a time, disease came from evil sprites etc. Then someone invented a microscope and people could see little squirmy animals that they soon discovered caused many of the most problematic diseases. SURPRISE a new toothl made what came before it seem much less "true".

Once upon a time people had to use crude ineffective tools to detect and classify HSV. Once DNA serum and swab testing were discovered and became available to scientist the world changed. The view from ovaries is not great so I cannot comment first hand on the Seventies, but is at not a time when free sex was safe? where asbestos and PCBs were are friends? Did they even know the link between HSV and HIV in those days? Oh wait, did they know about HIV at all?

Woops am I being condesending towards some poor guy who is poking fun at me and trying to be clever and being an uniformed ass? Yes I guess I am :).