CUPE, TTC who's next?

cyrus said:
Yet every year TTC budget has been going up and still they keep howling for more! They don't care if the city has to cut the police budget or raise taxes. Now even with part of the gas tax, they are still predicting deficit in their budget!
Why? To pay for their bus drivers’ exuberating salaries (52 to 67K+ range depending on seniority!)

Wow, has the media got you snowed. The TTC budget goes up every year b/c gov't had ignored maintenance for decades, resulting in sky-rocketing costs of maintaining infrastructure. Labour costs are a drop in the bucket (of the last $0.25 increase on TTC fares, the current union proposals would amount to $0.02 of that total).

The TTC is a well-paying job. If you're jealous of that fact, then go apply for a position; they're hiring all the time. Of course, you wouldn't want to be a bus driver now would you? Having to deal with all those griping commuters, limited future job prospects, working weekends and odd-shifts. No, you wouldn't want to work it but you have no problem begrudging TTC workers the compensation they are paid to do the job few other people want...
 
healer677 said:
I say contract it all out to real companies - companies that can not only provide the service but remove all this griping and threats of strikes from union employees. Best offer wins. The city will probably save money this way.

That's what most people think. Heck, I would think that way too if I didn't know any better.

The empirical evidence is, at best, no change or minimal change in costs and, at worst, poorer levels of service provision and higher costs overall. The classic example is a study done of garbage collection in New Jersey. The work was privatized and costs went up!

The problems with contracting out are many, but they aren't obvious to joe-average who doesn't know any better. It's only after the change has been made and costs go up that people realize what a mistake they've made.

So how do costs go up? Well, to begin with, management costs rise b/c there needs to be a mechanism to ensure the contracted party is doing the job that it said it would do. This is very expensive to do. It's much easier to have supervisors overseeing the job on a daily basis then it is to somehow monitor what another company is doing and how they are doing it when you don't have anyone overseeing them on a daily basis. Usually you don't know something's gone wrong until well after the fact.

Second, private companies have more interest in profit and less interest in service provision. I've seen it before and I'll see it again; as soon as something gets contracted out the third party cuts every corner it can to do only the bare minimum that it must. And there's no mechanism for the payer (e.g. gov't) to supervise/reprimand the third-party employees who are making lacklustre efforts for lacklustre pay.

Third, service levels that go down end up costing even more in the long run. Mistakes, when they ultimately get discovered, must get fixed and that often ends up costing a bundle.

The problem with contracting out is that it appears to save so much costs upfront that everyone falls for it. But they don't see all the hidden costs that end up making the whole endeavour more costly than it was to begin with, usually with less service to show for it.

As for "the best offer wins", try renovating your house with that logic and see what you end up with :rolleyes:
 
KEEBLER

Is there ever a time when any level of gov.
can say that is in the tax payers best intrests
to try and find another way of providing the service a union does.
To me C.U.P.E. is a bit different because it's employer is not a private
company.
 
someone said:
I take it that you have no problems with the firm hiring other nonunionized workers if they don't like the price your union president offers. After all, in most markets you are not restricted in terms of who you can buy from. Otherwise, you can't really claim it is a market at work.

Don't know much about labour law, do ya? ;)

Scab labour is legal in Ontario (except during the life of an existing collective agreement).

If you agree to a contract that says you won't hire non-union workers, then hell yeah I would expect you to abide by the terms that you agreed upon. That is the market at work in that you agreed to those terms. That was part of the deal you struck.

Now, if it comes time to renegotiate your contract and you don't like the terms being presented to you, then you have the right to hire replacement workers and try to continue operations without your fully trained, experienced, knowledgeable staff. And we'll see how long you can compete in the free market with those other employers who begin to strip you of your market share.
 
"Private companies have more intrest in profit"
I thought that was the idea to make a profit
but maybe i am just an average-joe who does not know better

Look i am for unions and their rights but the tax payers has a right
to get the most out of their $$

You can't say with a wide brush that the private sector would not
provide a better value to any service.

The gov. has a responsiblity to deliver all services to the tax base
at the best value .
 
chd said:
KEEBLER

Is there ever a time when any level of gov.
can say that is in the tax payers best intrests
to try and find another way of providing the service a union does.
To me C.U.P.E. is a bit different because it's employer is not a private
company.

Well, first off, a union doesn't offer any service to the gov't; it's members do. A union merely represents the workers.

I'm sure there are situations when outsourcing may be in the best interests of the gov't and taxpayers of Ontario. But the TTC isn't it. You privatize the TTC and you'll see fares skyrocket; you cap the fares and you'll see no interest from private enterprise in running the TTC. Firms are in business to make profit; you limit that profit too much and no firm will enter the business. The TTC cannot survive as an independent company; it requires gov't funding to make it feasible. That whole fiasco played out in the energy sector when the Conservatives tried privatizing it and the whole plan blew up in their face as prices jumped.

The problem with your question is that you assume the end product from unionized workers is worse than the end product done by non-unionized workers. Whether that's true or not is highly contested; what is known is that the answer is not as black-and-white as people think it is. Yes, unions tend to lower productivity and profit. But unions also tend to increase output (on the whole), improve the workforce capital of a company (thru training, for example), and give employees "voice" that they probably would not otherwise have.

The problem with talking about the context of gov't is two-fold. First, gov't believes (and I agree with it) that it has a role to play as a leader for other employers to follow. That's part of the reason why gov't is the first to adopt progressive employment laws. It's very hard to ask employers to pay more to employees or give more benefits when the gov't isn't doing that itself. The other problem is that gov't isn't a business; it's not about making a profit. Gov't is about providing services and often those services cost much more than they can possibly take in. So to treat gov't like a business is a fundamental mistake from the outset. The aim should be providing a certain level of service for a certain level of cost. We can argue over what those levels should be, but simply going for lower costs ignores the service part of the equation.

Finally, did you know that the Ontario gov't has one of the most qualified, best trained workforces in Canada? Same with the federal gov't. The average gov't employee has at least a university degree; the same cannot be said for the average private-sector employee. The problem is peoples' perception that gov't employees all sit behind a counter and renew your driver's license. They don't. But one of the benefits and aims of unions is to raise the wages for ALL workers, not just those at the top. So low-level gov't employees are usually paid more than their private sector equivalent; but high level employees are usually paid less.
 
chd said:
"Private companies have more intrest in profit"
I thought that was the idea to make a profit
but maybe i am just an average-joe who does not know better

Look i am for unions and there rights but the tax payers has a right
to get the most out of their $$

You can't say with a wide brush that the private sector would not
provide a better value to any service.

The gov. has a responsiblity to deliver all services to the tax base
at the best value .

I agree with most of what you say, but I don't agree with the idea that the point of gov't is to make a profit. And if you think you're going to get better service from a third-party contractor, you are dreaming.

The city of Toronto has one of the best transportation services throughout North America in the TTC. It's just that people like to think that the grass is greener on the other side. For the money that is put into the TTC by gov't, the service we receive is very good. But that's not to say that the service we receive is everything we expect it to be; it's just that's the level of service we can expect for the amount that is being put into it.

And, no, I don't think that gov't is some kind of monolithic entity that can do no wrong and is the answer to all of our problems. But until I see a feasible alternative that takes more into account that just the immediate reduction in labour costs, I'll stick with what we've got.
 
I Am Not Saying The Non Union Work Would Be Better
In The Ttc Case It Would Make Sence To Keep A Union Labour
Force
But If There Are Other Areas Were You Could Get Non Union
Work Even If The Quality Was Less But The Cost To The Tax Payer
Was Reduced And The Ratio Made Sence I See Nothing Wrong
With That
There Are Cupe Jobs That Even Thou They Were Neg. In Good Faith
The Time Has Come To Look At Another Way Of Providing The
Service

Elf I Respect Your View Points But I Think The Time Has Come
For The Whole Way In Which Gov. Delivers The Service To The Tax Payer To Be Looked At
 
I Never Said The Point Of Gov, Is To Make A Profit
I Just Took It As A Slight That Private Companys Make Profit
If That Was Not You Point
I Stand Corrected
 
Keebler Elf said:
Don't know much about labour law, do ya? ;)

Scab labour is legal in Ontario (except during the life of an existing collective agreement).
I would say that I know more about labour law than you do as you have clearly never heard of the Rand formula.

Keebler Elf said:
If you agree to a contract that says you won't hire non-union workers, then hell yeah I would expect you to abide by the terms that you agreed upon. That is the market at work in that you agreed to those terms. That was part of the deal you struck.
Under the Rand formula there is no choice. Even if nonunion workers can be hired, they must still pay union dues. For better or worse, this effectively rules out mixed union/nonunion work places.

Keebler Elf said:
Now, if it comes time to renegotiate your contract and you don't like the terms being presented to you, then you have the right to hire replacement workers and try to continue operations without your fully trained, experienced, knowledgeable staff. And we'll see how long you can compete in the free market with those other employers who begin to strip you of your market share.
I have worked in jurisdictions with both the Rand formula and ones with voluntary unionism. I doubt if you have as all you seem to know is the Ontario system. The point of my post is that, good or bad, you can’t say compulsory unionism is the market in action.
 
someone said:
I take it that you have no problems with the firm hiring other nonunionized workers if they don't like the price your union president offers. After all, in most markets you are not restricted in terms of who you can buy from. Otherwise, you can't really claim it is a market at work.
Depends on the contract terms, and the supply of and demand for the services of the workers, doesn't it?

Most companies are too aware of their own best interests to try to start all over with an entirely new labour force. It's obviously easier to replace WalMart workers than star hockey players. But it has been done.

Most folks setting up a contract to supply or buy something, be it widgets or workers are smart enought to protect their position when the contract ends and it's time to renew or cancel, and it's usually a lot harder to cancel than to re-negociate. Why would labour contracts be much different?

In what way are union contracts not part of ordinary market economics? If you insist on being on the worst terms possible with your client/supplier you'll have a hell of a time in all your dealings. If you understand that your arrangement benefits you both, you'll see your best interests are served by working together. Pretty basic stuff I'da thought. Labour-management relations aren't much different. Except for the silly rhetoric.
 
Winston said:
…edit…But I have to admit, after hearing what goes on at Ontario Power Generation, I think all the "Brothers and Sisters" should get a job in the private sector and see just how the other half lives.
As long as the CEO sits in traffic on the 400 instead of using the 'copter that's supposed to be checking powerlines as his limo to the cottage. Speaking of how the other half lives.
 
oldjones said:
In what way are union contracts not part of ordinary market economics? [...] Pretty basic stuff I'da thought. Labour-management relations aren't much different. Except for the silly rhetoric.

And the use of violence ;)
 
oldjones said:
Depends on the contract terms, and the supply of and demand for the services of the workers, doesn't it?

Most companies are too aware of their own best interests to try to start all over with an entirely new labour force. It's obviously easier to replace WalMart workers than star hockey players. But it has been done.

Most folks setting up a contract to supply or buy something, be it widgets or workers are smart enought to protect their position when the contract ends and it's time to renew or cancel, and it's usually a lot harder to cancel than to re-negociate. Why would labour contracts be much different?

In what way are union contracts not part of ordinary market economics? If you insist on being on the worst terms possible with your client/supplier you'll have a hell of a time in all your dealings. If you understand that your arrangement benefits you both, you'll see your best interests are served by working together. Pretty basic stuff I'da thought. Labour-management relations aren't much different. Except for the silly rhetoric.
My post was not meant to past judgment on whether unions are positive or negative. I have worked in different environments where either argument could be made and I don’t think there is a universal answer to this question (although in the province I’m in, I think that in many ways the balance has shifted to far towards unions). I agree with you regarding hockey players versus Walmart workers (or bus drivers and CUPE members to keep things on topic). However, arguments that markets produce efficient results (e.g. where benefits to trade have been exhausted) usually involve the assumption of many buyers and sellers who are price takers. Situations such as you describe involve bargaining which generally do not produce the same efficient results as markets. For this reason anti competition laws usually outlaw suppliers from combining in cartels. In fact anti competition laws were originally used against unions until they were exempted from them. Thus, I don’t understand why you argue that unions represent functioning markets but not the same situation in other markets (unless you are arguing that anti competition laws are wrong, in which case I agree that you are being consistent). It seems to me that regardless of whether unions are good or bad, they are modifications (at the very least) to the workings of labour markets. If you disagree with me that's fine. I'm just trying to understand your position.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Wow, has the media got you snowed. The TTC budget goes up every year b/c gov't had ignored maintenance for decades, resulting in sky-rocketing costs of maintaining infrastructure. Labour costs are a drop in the bucket (of the last $0.25 increase on TTC fares, the current union proposals would amount to $0.02 of that total).

The TTC is a well-paying job. If you're jealous of that fact, then go apply for a position; they're hiring all the time. Of course, you wouldn't want to be a bus driver now would you? Having to deal with all those griping commuters, limited future job prospects, working weekends and odd-shifts. No, you wouldn't want to work it but you have no problem begrudging TTC workers the compensation they are paid to do the job few other people want...
Hmmm . . . . It seems you are the one with out a clue and a lot of preconceived notions,
first of all salaries have always been the major cost of running any kind of organization, in private sector any thing in the range of 40 to 60% and much higher in the Public sector, second of all maintenance is an operational issue thus it is TTC’s job to look after it not the government, just line TTC drivers who drive the buses not the government!
When the increase in total salaries exceed the salary projection/allocation in the budget it always gets compensated by cutting into other expenses then it may have to go red (into deficit), i.e., purchase of new buses, maintenance . . . . etc gets sacrificed.
As for driving a bus for TTC being a good paying job, hell it is and I wonder why would that be the case when you don't even need even a high scool diploma for it never mind a collage education! ummmm it is a hard work! right . . . let me think. . . . Gee let’s join a union!!! ( did you know to become a TTC driver, one needs to be on the waiting list for almost 5 year!)
Now, those who know the history of unions (19Th century, Coal miners, UK etc. . . . lalalala) would appreciate their usefulness but extortion is not one of them!
 
someone said:
My post was not meant to past judgment on whether unions are positive or negative. I have worked in different environments where either argument could be made and I don’t think there is a universal answer to this question (although in the province I’m in, I think that in many ways the balance has shifted to far towards unions). I agree with you regarding hockey players versus Walmart workers (or bus drivers and CUPE members to keep things on topic). However, arguments that markets produce efficient results (e.g. where benefits to trade have been exhausted) usually involve the assumption of many buyers and sellers who are price takers. Situations such as you describe involve bargaining which generally do not produce the same efficient results as markets. For this reason anti competition laws usually outlaw suppliers from combining in cartels. In fact anti competition laws were originally used against unions until they were exempted from them. Thus, I don’t understand why you argue that unions represent functioning markets but not the same situation in other markets (unless you are arguing that anti competition laws are wrong, in which case I agree that you are being consistent). It seems to me that regardless of whether unions are good or bad, they are modifications (at the very least) to the workings of labour markets. If you disagree with me that's fine. I'm just trying to understand your position.
I think what you are saying is that unions have a monopoly of some sort, so the bargaining isn't the same as in an open market. One might as well say the employer has a monopoly on members' jobs. Neither is really true. After fulfilling whatever obligations they may still have to each other due to their expiring contract, and remaining within the law, either side's free to find someone else to play with. As free as any other market.

There are lots of sectors with more than one union representing/supplying the desired labour, and there's no special impediment to founding yet another. Some managements have been known to encourage such sweetheart setups. Film and TV technicians used to have their pick of three unions, a lovely situation for producers, until the major American union bulldozed the upstart Canadian organization and hoovered up its members. But producers can and do still whipsaw NABET against IATSE.

The only way I'd buy the position that a union is a "modification of a normal labour market" would be if you could show me it's abnormal for people to get together in their common interest. I think that's the most normal thing in the world. Still, if that's the deal you want: You give up the legal fiction that a corporation (a group of individuals sharing ownership of an enterprise, but without responsibility for its operation) exists as a person does, and make every shareholder liable and responsible, and I'll give up unions. But if the workers must each negociate and sign individually, obviously so must those owners.
 
oldjones said:
I think what you are saying is that unions have a monopoly of some sort, so the bargaining isn't the same as in an open market. One might as well say the employer has a monopoly on members' jobs.
In some situation like a small mining town that would be true but in Toronto, except for specialized occupations, it would not be true.
oldjones said:
Neither is really true. After fulfilling whatever obligations they may still have to each other due to their expiring contract, and remaining within the law, either side's free to find someone else to play with. As free as any other market.
Not really, once a union is certified, it is the official representatives of those in the bargaining unit. Even when replacement workers are hired, I believe the employer is still supposed to make “good faith” attempts to come to an agreement with the union. Moreover, in some provinces, replacement workers are not an option (unless, the have changed the law, Quebec would be an example)

oldjones said:
There are lots of sectors with more than one union representing/supplying the desired labour, and there's no special impediment to founding yet another. Some managements have been known to encourage such sweetheart setups. Film and TV technicians used to have their pick of three unions, a lovely situation for producers, until the major American union bulldozed the upstart Canadian organization and hoovered up its members. But producers can and do still whipsaw NABET against IATSE.
True, I was not thinking in terms of craft unions.

oldjones said:
The only way I'd buy the position that a union is a "modification of a normal labour market" would be if you could show me it's abnormal for people to get together in their common interest.
Adam Smith would agree. The fact that it is normal is why we have a Competition Act to try to prevent such behavior in most markets. In the case of union, the Rand formula actually has the opposite effect and encourages such behaviour.
Anyway, I think I see where your coming from which was all I was interested in. Thanks.
 
someone said:
…edit…Adam Smith would agree [that joining together in the common interest is normal]. The fact that it is normal is why we have a Competition Act to try to prevent such behavior in most markets. In the case of union, the Rand formula actually has the opposite effect and encourages such behaviour.
Anyway, I think I see where your coming from which was all I was interested in. Thanks.
Perhaps I could persuade you to amplify your last point. I just can't make the leap to Adam Smith, who I always thought abhorred state intervention in the marketplace. Surely it's not the joining, but the monopoly that may result, that distorts the market. And it seems we agree unions are not monolpolies.

My understanding of Rand is that it requires those benefiting from/covered by a union-negociated collective agreement to pay union dues to finance that negociation irrespective of whether they want membership in the union. As a quid pro quo I believe the 'closed shop' is not legal—you can make her pay, you can't make her join. Middle ground I'd have thought and no members-only monopoly.

Employers have always treated workers as a collective—"the wage for weavers is tuppence a day take it or leave it"—rather than bargaining one on one. One-on-one would be that free market, would it not? So is a refusal to bargain individually restraint of trade?

Surely the employer's insistance on dealing on a group basis entitles the workers to form their own group to negociate with them. I just don't see the applicability of anti-trust laws at all, and I had thought that they'd failed in court when applied to unions.
 
oldjones said:
Perhaps I could persuade you to amplify your last point. I just can't make the leap to Adam Smith, who I always thought abhorred state intervention in the marketplace. .
No problem. The most common quote that Smith did not think it was "abnormal for people to get together in their common interest" is:

“People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for
merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a
conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise
prices.”

Although he did not think government regulation would be effective in preventing this, he nonetheless did not think government regulation should encourage it:

“But though the law cannot hinder people of
the same trade from sometimes assembling together, it ought to do
nothing to facilitate such assemblies, much less to render them
necessary."

For more details see http://socserv2.socsci.mcmaster.ca/~econ/ugcm/3ll3/smith/wealth/

oldjones said:
Surely it's not the joining, but the monopoly that may result, that distorts the market. And it seems we agree unions are not monolpolies. .
No, we don’t agree on that. My comment was with regard to your claim that it could also be said that employers have monopoly power. Unions would not have bargaining power if they did not have some monopoly power.

oldjones said:
My understanding of Rand is that it requires those benefiting from/covered by a union-negociated collective agreement to pay union dues to finance that negociation irrespective of whether they want membership in the union. As a quid pro quo I believe the 'closed shop' is not legal—you can make her pay, you can't make her join. Middle ground I'd have thought and no members-only monopoly.

Employers have always treated workers as a collective—"the wage for weavers is tuppence a day take it or leave it"—rather than bargaining one on one. One-on-one would be that free market, would it not? So is a refusal to bargain individually restraint of trade?

Surely the employer's insistance on dealing on a group basis entitles the workers to form their own group to negociate with them. I just don't see the applicability of anti-trust laws at all, and I had thought that they'd failed in court when applied to unions.

That depends on the work involved. In my line of work, even when there is a union, there is a lot of individual negotiation about where on the pay scale you are as factors such as "market differential" are taken into account (e.g. usually economics professors get some market differentials automatically but English professors have a tougher time unless they have exceptional publication records).

Without a union, employers are forced to raise (and when feasible) lower wage rates in response to market conditions. Indeed for occupations like the CUPE workers in Toronto, the employer would likely be what are called “price takers” (I should say that I have not lived in Toronto for a few years so I have not been following the details). Given that many other employers higher the same type of workers, both employers and workers would likely have to take the market wage as given, if it where not for unions in.

As far as anti trust laws, I believe that orginally courts upheld them until they were changed. However, I'm too lazy to find a link supporting this.
 
cyrus said:
first of all salaries have always been the major cost of running any kind of organization, in private sector any thing in the range of 40 to 60% and much higher in the Public sector, second of all maintenance is an operational issue thus it is TTC’s job to look after it not the government, just line TTC drivers who drive the buses not the government!

Buddy, you really, really, really don't know what you're talking about. Labour costs are nowhere near 40-60% of total costs. Maybe in the NHL, but that's about it.

Labour costs are higher in the public sector than the private b/c the public sector tends to pay more and has a greater ratio of "knowledge" work vs. capital infrastructure than most private firms.

Infrastucture costs are one of the largest, if not the largest, costs for the TTC. So when gov't chronically underfunds for decades, there's not a whole heck of a lot the TTC can do about it.

To be honest, I'm still flabbergasted that you think labour costs are 40-60% of total labour costs. You are obviously well out of your league in this discussion, so I'll leave you to your, um, "thoughts"...