Crosby being disrespected?

wazup

Well-known member
Jun 12, 2010
4,276
584
113
He's still performing at an elite level but hardly gets much mention anymore. The Penguins have emerged as cup contenders, I thought they were finished. Maybe covid has shone less spotlight on US teams. It's all about McDavid and Matthew's up here.

I thought he might end up in Montreal, but I don't see anyone going to that train wreck. The Habs are becoming the Knicks of the last 25 years, excluding this year.
 
He's still performing at an elite level but hardly gets much mention anymore. The Penguins have emerged as cup contenders, I thought they were finished. Maybe covid has shone less spotlight on US teams. It's all about McDavid and Matthew's up here.

I thought he might end up in Montreal, but I don't see anyone going to that train wreck. The Habs are becoming the Knicks of the last 25 years, excluding this year.

If there was an NHL team that was close tor the Knicks it was the post lockout Leafs for about a 10 year period. A period which I mocked their mismanagement. Until they smartly turned it around. And I praised their management as they did it.

For Montreal it would help if Bergevin was shown the door even if he had a solid off-season this year.

Since 2002 (20 years) the Habs have won 9 playoff rounds the Knicks have won two (both in one year).

Since 2002 the Knicks have been a 500 team just 4 times including this year. That includes a period of 3 in a row around 2010.

You want more recent? The Knicks will finally make the playoffs for the first time since the 2013 season. The Canadiens will make it for the fifth time in eight seasons.

Are the Canadiens in a great situation? Not going to say that. They are in a middling one but that could change. They are middle of the pack in young pieces, but not bottom either so player development over next 3 or 4 years could sway them to top third of league or other way as well. But they are not at the LOL Knicks level.

In a few years Shea Weber will very likely retire and his contract will become a major Issue for Nashville to deal with. Do you think Shea will play his last 4 years for 7 million total?

Rumblings out of Montreal are that in a few years they could find try to their way out of the Price situation via the LTIR rules. It could very well be controversial but given Toronto has abused the LTIR to their advantage as well will be amusing to see them get up in arms.

Montreal was able to get solid pieces this off-season who have performed well.
 
Last edited:
I said they look to be becoming the modern day Knicks, not the past. Players no longer want to play there and they are a storied franchise like the Knicks.

Looks like they are pinning their hopes on Caulfield, not sure how good he is. On the flip side, imagine if the leafs ended up with the disaster named Laine, how different they'd be now.
 
Remember that the Habs made the playoffs last year and the Leafs did not. There's an ebb and flow to these things. Toews, Kane and Keith brought 3 Cups to Chicago and nothing since even though all 3 are still on the team.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: gcostanza
He's still performing at an elite level but hardly gets much mention anymore. The Penguins have emerged as cup contenders, I thought they were finished. Maybe covid has shone less spotlight on US teams. It's all about McDavid and Matthew's up here.

I thought he might end up in Montreal, but I don't see anyone going to that train wreck. The Habs are becoming the Knicks of the last 25 years, excluding this year.
Why would you have thought Crosby would end up in Montreal?
 
If there was an NHL team that was close tor the Knicks it was the post lockout Leafs for about a 10 year period. A period which I mocked their mismanagement. Until they smartly turned it around. And I praised their management as they did it.

For Montreal it would help if Bergevin was shown the door even if he had a solid off-season this year.

Since 2002 (20 years) the Habs have won 9 playoff rounds the Knicks have won two (both in one year).

Since 2002 the Knicks have been a 500 team just 4 times including this year. That includes a period of 3 in a row around 2010.

You want more recent? The Knicks will finally make the playoffs for the first time since the 2013 season. The Canadiens will make it for the fifth time in eight seasons.

Are the Canadiens in a great situation? Not going to say that. They are in a middling one but that could change. They are middle of the pack in young pieces, but not bottom either so player development over next 3 or 4 years could sway them to top third of league or other way as well. But they are not at the LOL Knicks level.

In a few years Shea Weber will very likely retire and his contract will become a major Issue for Nashville to deal with. Do you think Shea will play his last 4 years for 7 million total?

Rumblings out of Montreal are that in a few years they could find try to their way out of the Price situation via the LTIR rules. It could very well be controversial but given Toronto has abused the LTIR to their advantage as well will be amusing to see them get up in arms.

Montreal was able to get solid pieces this off-season who have performed well.

Not aware of the Shea Weber contract details........What are they specifically?
 
Why would you have thought Crosby would end up in Montreal?
Earlier in the year I thought Pittsburgh were on the down swing and Montreal were headed up, the exact opposite happened. Didn't think Crosby wanted to go through a Pittsburgh rebuild.
 
Did Burke have anything to do with the turn-around of the Penguins? I feel since he joined they have been on the up and up. As for SC87 - it would be great if he went to Montreal for a feel good story vibe, but that man bleeds Black and Yellow in Pitts. I hope he ends it in Pitts, would be a great story - where he started, experienced winnings multiple Cups and retire on a high and start taking next steps in management related business for the Penguins.
 
I said they look to be becoming the modern day Knicks, not the past. Players no longer want to play there and they are a storied franchise like the Knicks.

Looks like they are pinning their hopes on Caulfield, not sure how good he is. On the flip side, imagine if the leafs ended up with the disaster named Laine, how different they'd be now.

Seems like they have been able to bring in players that helped this past year and are happy in Montreal. Toffoli, Allen, Edmundosn have all added value. Anderson as well (at least for the first year as well— the back end is a problem) I think your assessment is far too speculative over a longer period.

One could have argued the Leafs were in a similar situation around 2012 and they got out of the jam in 5 years. The Knicks have been a 20 year long shitshow.

If you want to speculate the Habs could have a tough 5 years it’s possible. But they could also just be a middle of the pack team. But to just call them the Knicks who have had 20 terrible years is sort of silly.

It’s not only caufield. Suzuki, Caufield, KK, Romanov, Primeau plus apparently an above average number of non elite prospects. It could be better but it could also be worse. They are going to need to find a way to get one home run somehow if they want to get to the top but they seem to be positioned to avoid the bottom .. which is not always optimal either. Sometimes it is better just to sink.
 
Last edited:
Not aware of the Shea Weber contract details........What are they specifically?

It’s hard for me to properly explain. Best thing to do would be to Google “Shea Weber Recapture”.

If I was not typing on my phone it would probably be easier to do quickly.

Shea gets paid I believe 3/1/1/1 million over his last 4 years so he has incentive to retire before his contract was up. His 14 year contract was done like this so his average cap hit against the cap would be less.

But at a high level if Shea Weber retires at any time before the end of his contract the Predators will be hit with a $24 million recapture cap hit. Goes back to the 2013 CBA where rules were done to punish teams that had given long deals out to circumvent the cap. In 2020 some relief was provided whereby the 24 million could be spread out longer — in Weber’s case at about 7 million a year.
 
Last edited:
It’s hard for me to properly explain. Best thing to do would be to Google “Shea Weber Recapture”.

If I was not typing on my phone it would probably be easier to do quickly.

Shea gets paid I believe 3/1/1/1 million over his last 4 years so he has incentive to retire before his contract was up. His 14 year contract was done like this so his average cap hit against the cap would be less.

But at a high level if Shea Weber retires at any time before the end of his contract the Predators will be hit with a $24 million recapture cap hit. Goes back to the 2013 CBA where rules were done to punish teams that had given long deals out to circumvent the cap. In 2020 some relief was provided whereby the 24 million could be spread out longer — in Weber’s case at about 7 million a year.

Thanks for taking the time. It's complicated for sure.
 
Earlier in the year I thought Pittsburgh were on the down swing and Montreal were headed up, the exact opposite happened. Didn't think Crosby wanted to go through a Pittsburgh rebuild.
There was never and never will be a chance Sidney Crosby will play for the Montreal Canadiens...
 
Just like there was never a chance that Gretzky would be traded.............
There was a chance Gretzky could be traded and it was no surprise it was to the Los Angeles Kings.

No credible source says Sidney Crosby is leaving the Penguins and it is even farther from reality that he’ll end up in Montreal.