copyright/ all rights reserved

yoniluvrca

Member
Sep 16, 2002
787
0
0
www.angusmagee.com
I have a legal question here.

A friend of mine is producing a CD of a speaker and is currently designing the cover. We were looking at it today and she was asking me if I knew about the copyright laws and what needed to be printed upon the back cover in order to protect the material.

When looking at other CDs I saw that there was often a copyright symbol(a small 'c' inside a circle ⓒ ), followed by the date and then the name of the company that holds the copyright.

Sometimes I have also seen the statement 'all rights reserved'. Is it needed to have all of this on order for the material to be protected legally?

ⓒ 2006, all rights reserved, xxxx ltd. is how it would look.

Thanks in advance.

YL
 
yoniluvrca said:
I have a legal question here. A friend of mine is producing a CD of a speaker and is currently designing the cover. We were looking at it today and she was asking me if I knew about the copyright laws and what needed to be printed upon the back cover in order to protect the material. When looking at other CDs I saw that there was often a copyright symbol(a small 'c' inside a circle ⓒ ), followed by the date and then the name of the company that holds the copyright.
Sometimes I have also seen the statement 'all rights reserved'. Is it needed to have all of this on order for the material to be protected legally? ⓒ 2006, all rights reserved, xxxx ltd. is how it would look. Thanks in advance.
YL

Placing a (c) on the back cover only protects the cover, not the music. You want to put a (p) on the actual CD to protect the music and it only protects the audio on that CD. A (c) on the CD itself would protect anything written on the CD, and/or a picture by a photographer embedded on the CD. In the USA, you have to send a copy (dreaded word) of the work to the US Library of Congress and file the correct form for audio works (not literary). You can also copyright the words of the music, and the written form of the music as well using seperate correct forms. Each one costs $30.00 USD (an illegal inflationary raise, IMHO, that the US Government did to discourage the arts, because it used to cost $10.00). As for Canada, the laws are similar, however please consult the area of government that deals with copyrights.

An owner/creator has the right to their work at the time it was created. However, many just "for the sake of writing" place a (c) on their work and consider it protected. It is not. A work is copywritten if and only if the proof of copyright exists in the LOC. Writing it and doing nothing does not protect it. Many news organizations and TV shows do it, but one has to assume that a copy of the show is in the LOC. Many times it is not, but it can be submitted when needed, in which the date of the creation is then protected from day one by making submission even years later. Companies with huge income and lawyers up the ying-yang can afford to do that. Individuals that assume their work will have value if stolen, should file the copyright petition right away.

Make note that (TM) and (r) are not copyrights, but trademarks, a seperate issue and much more expensive (last time I checked that 15 years ago, it was around $525.00). (TM) is a trademark in the process of being registered, whilst (r) is an actual registered trademark. Many US businesses register trademarks in the weirdest of places, almost abusing their capital. Examples of ridiculous registrered trademarks are: American Airlines registering "snack attack". The US Postal Service registering "zipcode", etc. Everyday thoughts that are registered trademarks. United cannot have a 'snack attack" now. FedEx canot create a delivery system based on a "zipcode". Get the idea?

Oh yes, and the copyright is ONLY protected inside the country in which it was submitted/filed. There's NO SUCH THING as an "international copyright". However, countries like China that rip off the world are getting hammered because, like it or not, they too have a copyright office (one office vs 1.5 billion people so you can understand why there is rampant copyright issues there) and companies like Microsoft can afford to sue and file later on.

Hope that helps! More info is here:

http://www.copyright.gov/

Gyaos.
 
Thanks Gyaos,

Lots of info and it makes me think that perhaps we should check here with a lawyer to be sure. In actual fact I am in Europe (Germany) so I gather from your info that these laws differ from country to country and do not cover you in all countries.

In any case, your response was very helpful and I thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed answer.

Regards

YL
 
In Canada, the US, and other countries that adopted the Berne Convention on copyright, you do not need the little (c) or the year anymore--it automatically belongs to you, whether or not you declare it. However putting it there doesn't hurt, and there are still some countries in which it actually matters.

What is much more important is the grant of rights to the recipient--what do you allow? What do you disallow? The best thing here is to copy something from an existing album, as they have hired lawyers to work out the right language.

Making it up off the top of my head, I would think you would want to write something like this in the fine print: "This work, including all music and artwork, is the copyrighted property of XYZ and has been made available for your private enjoyment only. Any broadcast, public performance, distribution in any form or by any means, or other copying of this work is strictly prohibited. All rights reserved."

There are actually more than one "copy right" that you own, and by selling/giving your music to someone else you are implicitly giving up at least some rights to them, to permit them to listen to the music. A statement like this is important to make it clear that you are giving up only the minimum rights necessary for them to enjoy it--that you are not giving up ALL your rights to the work. "All rights reserved" is short form for "I do not want to give up any of my rights to this work, I am giving you only the minimum", but it is often better to actually spell out what rights you are giving up and what rights you are keeping--which is what the text just before that does. The recipient can't claim, "Hey I thought I was getting a broadcast right", for example.

If you are REALLY concerned about this you can also actually take the step of registering your copyrights with the copyright office. If you do this step, you are saved from ever having to prove that you own the work if there is a dispute later on, so more of the burden of proof shifts to the infringer in the event that you sue someone. This doesn't change your legal standing at all, you own your work either way, it just saves you from having prove that you own it--someone else might later claim that you copied them, for example, and you would then have to prove who was first.
 
Gyaos said:
A work is copywritten if and only if the proof of copyright exists in the LOC.

I don't think you know what you are talking about. A work is your copyrighted property the moment you write it. Period. Full stop.

Putting a copy in the LOC is useful for proving that you are the author, and, if you go to court, it will save you from having to prove that point. However, in terms of whether your work is protected, it is protected if you can prove you own it, and LOC registration is just one way (though plainly the best way) of proving you own it.

Oh yes, and the copyright is ONLY protected inside the country in which it was submitted/filed. There's NO SUCH THING as an "international copyright".

You are just plain wrong. Look up "Berne Convention". Not all countries are signatories to this convention, but it effectively establishes an international system of copyrights for those countries that are.
 
Doesn't matter what you put on it, it will be on torrents and limewire 12 seconds before you release it to the market anyways :D
 
Its not even released yet and they are already selling " authentic originals" at Pacific Mall. :eek:
 
fuji said:
I don't think you know what you are talking about. A work is your copyrighted property the moment you write it. Period. Full stop.

Not true in a court of law. If your work is stolen, you have to show proof of copyright. Your statement is valid, so long as you show the proof. Writing a (p) on the work and not filing a copyright is different than writing a (p) and filing a copyright in which you present the document as proof of copyright. The filing of the form is the proof. Look at blackberry, who forgot to file a form.

You can file your form, fuji, at kazaa.

Gyaos.

P.S.: "Berne Convention" is just a bogus argument for those who copy works to get away with it. Holds no water in any court, like Canon Law does. The OP wants their work protected. The word is "protected". Your way is speculative and you really don't know much about it. You know, I signed up with the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Convention and made plenty of nukes.
 
Both Gyaos and Fuji are essentially correct, providing essentially similar arguments. However, Gyaos has made some false statements, as the link provided points out. What it essentially comes down to is burden of proof. As an artist and designer I took several contract and intellectual property courses at university and from DPIC (design professionals insurance co.).

From link provided by Gyaos:

"Copyright is secured automatically when the work is created, and a work is "created" when it is fixed in a copy or phonorecord for the first time.

...

"In general, copyright registration is a legal formality intended to make a public record of the basic facts of a particular copyright. However, registration is not a condition of copyright protection. Even though registration is not a requirement for protection, the copyright law provides several inducements or advantages to encourage copyright owners to make registration."


Copyright disputes always come down to burden of proof of valid copyright ownership. DPIC fairly clearly states a dated/signed original in possession of the creator is substantially good enough burden of proof. An undated/unsigned original is weak. Method by which you strengthen the establishment of that copyright are various. As Gyaos' link describes, or the LOC registration is one way, in America. The oft mentioned mailing yourself a copy is another method. Multiple copies in public domain carry the ©, date and authors name, as Fuji describes.

So, back to original question. If you do what Fuji describes you're protected or if you do what Gyaos describes you're protected, or if you do what I've described you're protected. Essentially all the same.

By the way, I date all my original designs and have had cause to provide dated sketches and they were good enough to establish copyright ownership of that design in a Minnesota court in my company's favour.
 
Ya, we all agree you need to have proof that you have the original. Registering with the copyright office is an excellent way to establish that proof, by far and away, the best way. Mailing it to yourself or getting it notarized or some other verifiable way to prove creation date or something similar is probably "good enough" most of the time but certainly registering it is better.
 
I am in the process of copywriting all of my posts at Terb because they are so cerebral.
 
antaeus said:
Both Gyaos and Fuji are essentially correct, providing essentially similar arguments. However, Gyaos has made some false statements, as the link provided points out. What it essentially comes down to is burden of proof.

My statements aren't false. The link and I agree. Registration is proof of copyright. Also once a creation is made can be considered copywritten, but there has to exist a burden of proof. However, registration, although not required, secures the copyright.

Maybe what I wrote appeared false to you, but since we are all correct, fabulous.

Now time to do some illegal downloading. :D