Contract out the TTC

Most of the people who are bitching are above the pay scale of a TTC worker and are upset that they make almost as much as them.
 
Yes, what we need is more downward pressure on incomes. Its those pesky, almost middle class but really poor and pretending, TTC workers dragging the economy down.

Quite right. More right than you realize. When money is spent inefficiently like this we produce less than we should, and that drags the entire economy down. It is, in the long run, a body blow to our productivity, and over the decades that adds up to a lower standard of living for everyone.

Policies like free trade, where all of sudden workers here have to compete with workers in Mexico or China.

What's your alternative? An insular economy, where we lag behind the rest of the world for generations? That's what we tried, and it resulted in a wage gap between us and other countries. The pain we feel today is the resolution of that wage gap. Had we not allowed the wage gap to form in the first place it would not nearly be so painful now.

Protectionist policies are like borrowing money you don't have: Feels good in the short-run, but in the long run you are screwing yourself over.
 
WE, Canada have a much higher standard of living not just in wages, health care education ect, Lets not forget it was the rich that created the big recession Banks, Insurance companys, Ceo's ect not the little guy or middle class guy the rich got greedy, so leave the TTC people alone.
 
What's your alternative? An insular economy, where we lag behind the rest of the world for generations? That's what we tried, and it resulted in a wage gap between us and other countries. The pain we feel today is the resolution of that wage gap. Had we not allowed the wage gap to form in the first place it would not nearly be so painful now.

Free trade just means that a Canadian working at some widget factory for $20/hr is now competing with someone in China making the same thing for 50 cents/hr, without unemployment insurance, environmental protection.....

It wasn't workers clamouring for free trade, it wasn't even consumers, it was CEO's who wanted to pay Chinese wages to Canadian workers. Without some form of insulation from external economies we never would have developed universal health care, 40hr work weeks and most of the social services we now have.

My alternative would be to fund Canadian unions to start up Chinese trade unions, to exert upwards pressure on their wages.
Only problem, is if the Chinese were to gain the wealth of North Americans the world would run out of resources too quick. One quick example, if Chinese owned cars and drove at the same rates as Americans, it would take all of the oil in production right now just to keep them gased up.
 
Free trade just means that a Canadian working at some widget factory for $20/hr is now competing with someone in China making the same thing for 50 cents/hr, without unemployment insurance, environmental protection.....

If it can be made by someone who is worth only 50 cents an hour, then it was NEVER worth paying $20/hr for. That's a loss of productivity, that $20/hr person, if they are honestly worth $20/hr, should have been doing something more productive instead of wasting their skills and education making a 50 cent per hour product.

It was years of distorted protectionist policies that led to a $20/hr person making a $0.50/hr product. The problems we have now with the readjustment back to an economically sensible world is the hangover of our idiotic policies of the past. Had we NEVER had protectionist policies we would not now have all these workers having to switch careers in mid life--they would have chosen sensible careers from the get go.

Note that we in Canada, especially the poor among us, have benefited enormously from access to cheaply produced goods. I can afford many more things than I used to be able to buy as a result of being able to buy low priced imported goods.
 
If wealth was equally distributed we would all be making three times as much as we are

That was tried in a few countries, starting around 1917, but after about 72 years of trying it people realized that instead of everyone being three times richer, everyone was instead around ten times poorer. It turns out when you distribute income equally nobody works and then there are no goods and no services available and so what really happens is that everybody gets much, much less.
 
That was tried in a few countries, starting around 1917, but after about 72 years of trying it people realized that instead of everyone being three times richer, everyone was instead around ten times poorer. It turns out when you distribute income equally nobody works and then there are no goods and no services available and so what really happens is that everybody gets much, much less.

I am not going to pretend I am an economist but I do believe the policies of today are the policies of the rich.

I suspect the Fed, for example, is honest in its policies but the alternative thinkers are not allowed into power positions, such as chairman of the Fed, by the rich

I just cannot accept that extremely unbalanced wealth is essential for a democracy and freedom and that any alternative will always lead to social ruin


Right now a lot of worker ants are suffering to the point of suicide while the wealthy, non productive workers, buy up bargains to own even more

This is wrong on all levels conceivable and yet ignored by those who criticize unions as though worker ants giving up what small power they have will benefit the whole
 
WE, Canada have a much higher standard of living not just in wages, health care education ect, Lets not forget it was the rich that created the big recession Banks, Insurance companys, Ceo's ect not the little guy or middle class guy the rich got greedy, so leave the TTC people alone.

You're sounding a little like long gone but not forgotten Mr Big 1942. At least thankfully, you didn't say that unions gave us everything worthwhile and aren't responsible for the bad stuff that happens.
 
FUJI - cheaply produced goods generally equals lower quality in a product. Here in Canada we have a high standard of living
higher then most countries in the world and that's why many people want to come live in this country. We just need to spread the wealth around. We once again have big business making record profits off of whom? EG: banks, Walmart to list a few, sure there are some who aren't making as much as they once did but big business is still doing ok while the poor guy gets poorer.
 
FUJI - cheaply produced goods generally equals lower quality in a product. Here in Canada we have a high standard of living
higher then most countries in the world and that's why many people want to come live in this country. We just need to spread the wealth around. We once again have big business making record profits off of whom? EG: banks, Walmart to list a few, sure there are some who aren't making as much as they once did but big business is still doing ok while the poor guy gets poorer.

Easy BW1, what are the record profits you speak of. The profits are higher than last year but they aren't the biggest ever. Please, ease up on the sound bit rhetoric. The last 2 year for most countries, companies, and people, blew chunks big time. It's not a bad thing that companies are now making profit or we'd be in deep doodoo. If they're making profits that you see as too big, how much profit would you allow them to make? 10%, 5%, 2%, 1/2%? Now would that be ROI, ROA, or ROE? I''m just asking these questions to see what your idea of too much is.
 
Well 5 banks making 5.1 billion in one quarter sounds a little to me considering there getting more tax cuts come July 2010
and that's only 1 quarter, sure they lost some during the last 18-24 months but tehre were making billions in the late 1990's and early to mid 2000's, don't you think it would be a good idea to share some of that with their employees (lower end paid) and cut back on some of the user fees?.
 
Well 5 banks making 5.1 billion in one quarter sounds a little to me considering there getting more tax cuts come July 2010
and that's only 1 quarter, sure they lost some during the last 18-24 months but tehre were making billions in the late 1990's and early to mid 2000's, don't you think it would be a good idea to share some of that with their employees (lower end paid) and cut back on some of the user fees?.

You miss my point or ignored it all together. How much, in terms of percentage, would you feel was a good return for your money, 1%, 2%, 5%, 1/2%. Historically Canadian banks have made approximately 4%. A few years back you would have laughed at someone who told you they could give you 4% return. Now you might accept it. Canadian banks are seen as big companies, the term is large cap. There are other companies in the world and some banks who make RBC look tiny. Canadian banks make lots of money measured in dollars, but their return is, as I stated, about 4%. If you want to reap the benefits go for the ride and buy some stock.
 
If it can be made by someone who is worth only 50 cents an hour, then it was NEVER worth paying $20/hr for. That's a loss of productivity, that $20/hr person, if they are honestly worth $20/hr, should have been doing something more productive instead of wasting their skills and education making a 50 cent per hour product.

Fuji, I don't know what you do, but can you honestly say that you could not be replaced by someone else who would do the work for cheaper? I'm sure one of the billions in China could do your job for far less, so should your boss fire you and hire them?

Lets see, we've lost lots of manufacturing (as if we had much to begin with), high tech jobs, telemarketing/support......
Down in the States, I think the only thing that they produce more of is now guns and maybe movies. Otherwise get your job at Starbucks or Walmart. Cars, computers (maybe not all the software), food, oil, clothes, appliances.....all those are outsources and I guess none of thoes jobs were worth $20/hr.

Oh, and by the way Fuji, I'd be willing to cheat on your wife for less money, too.
 
Fuji, I don't know what you do, but can you honestly say that you could not be replaced by someone else who would do the work for cheaper? I'm sure one of the billions in China could do your job for far less, so should your boss fire you and hire them?

No, if I worked overseas in China doing what I do, I would earn the same money, perhaps even more than I do now. In fact my standard of living would rise because I would be able to purchase services more cheaply in China, whereas I overpay for services in Canada due to artificially inflated wages here. If I weren't so connected to friends and family here in Toronto moving overseas would be a great career move for me in terms of the cost of living savings.

That's a point that is lost on the people who are opposed to free trade: If your skills are truly marketable on a global scale they are valued in every country. Trade protections create the illusion of a globally marketable skill where no such skill exists.

Our goal as a nation should be to raise up the level of skill and education of our workforce so that it is globally competitive--so that a $20/hr worker in Canada is worth $20/hr in China as well. We want our $20/hr workers to have skills and training that a $2/hr worker simply does not have. When that is true there is no fear of global competition.
 
To all those "rich people" haters. If you were to kill all the rich people in Canada (I know you won't), would you believe that to-day's poor people will be even poorer? Think about that for a moment.
 
No, if I worked overseas in China doing what I do, I would earn the same money, perhaps even more than I do now.

I have been offered twice my salary to work overseas. Twice the salary and half the taxes (think about that for a moment). But, money is not everything to me. I am an unrepentent proud Canadian and I prefer to live here and make half the money and pay twice the taxes.

Does anybody think that a TTC bus driver would be offered twice the salary overseas (well, maybe in Afghanistan but you might get killed)?
 
Look, 20% own 80% of the wealth

Let's be frank. Even that last great bastion of communism, the PRC, has rich people (more billionaires than any country except the U.S.). You cannot have a great society without rich people (ever heard of a great society with just poor people?).
 
To all those "rich people" haters. If you were to kill all the rich people in Canada (I know you won't), would you believe that to-day's poor people will be even poorer? Think about that for a moment.

Who said anything about killing rich people?
I'd just like a gentle tipping of the graduated tax system, so that the rich pay a higher rate, maybe not as high as the 70's but more than now.
 
Let's be frank. Even that last great bastion of communism, the PRC, has rich people (more billionaires than any country except the U.S.). You cannot have a great society without rich people (ever heard of a great society with just poor people?).

Because China is a dictatorship, so was USSR , not a true democracy where wealth is distributed fairly not owned by a few like here

True peoples state has never been created because Stalins and Chairmen Maos take over and or crushed by Imperialism although a few have been established and have worked

Just A THOUGHT that is not as niave as you think it is IMHO