Contract out the TTC

I am in favor of privatizing but the employees need to be protected. If contractor A looses the bid to contractor B when the tender is up then all of employees from A are out of a job. If they are union contractor, B does not have to hire them or pay them the wage they had. The employee will have to start from ground zero at the starting hourly rate. In essence, an employee can find themselves out of a job every time the contract is awarded to a new operator. Don't believe me...check out whats happening in york region right now. And the union has been totally fucking useless protecting the rights of the employees. Worse yet, the region doesn't seem to give a shit about them either. Sad, and this scenario is playing out right now.
 
"“I think the TTC is quite efficient and accountable to its public. It’s actually pretty good, certainly for North America: high levels of service; frequent service, integration of subway is very good. It would be crazy to throw all that away.”

the guy's on crack whoever wrote that...accountable to WHO?

As for no competition: I don't know about that. Every year or so when the contracts come due you can actually hold the company responsible and if they don't improve, changes can be made. Now? The union has the city by the balls and even if the city has no money, they can strike for more. With a private company? If there's no money, the contract will stand.

It is widely known that anything run by government is inefficient. They have an endless supply of cash so where's the incentive to be cost efficient?

Just think of the savings in cleaning bills. I know of NO cleaner who makes $30.00 per hour and up. Mostly they make $12.00 and up. On that alone there'd be millions saved......
 
It is widely known that anything run by government is inefficient. They have an endless supply of cash so where's the incentive to be cost efficient?......

When is the next election?

Just think of the savings in cleaning bills. I know of NO cleaner who makes $30.00 per hour and up. Mostly they make $12.00 and up. On that alone there'd be millions saved......

If a cleaner was driving the bus, no-one could take any dirty photo's . . .
 
Privatization is useless unless they make some effort to get benefits from it. The driving test centres in Ontario are "private", but they still went on strike for many months. How did that happen? The contract was given to one company, that was unionized, and they went on strike. So there was no benefit to having privatized, a union was still in control. If they had given the contract for each office to a different company, then they would have to compete, which would benefit the consumers.

The real problem is labour laws that give unions too much power, combined with public sector managers who care more about pleasing the union than they do about operating efficiently. And both those problems are because voters vote for politicians that favour unions. So I do not see it changing, because voters essentially do not want it to change, it is the Canadian way. You could run for office saying you would eliminate all unions, because they are obsolete and harmful, but you would not win, because most Canadians do not agree. I think unions are obsolete, but it is not a majority view.
 
"“
It is widely known that anything run by government is inefficient. They have an endless supply of cash so where's the incentive to be cost efficient?

Just think of the savings in cleaning bills. I know of NO cleaner who makes $30.00 per hour and up. Mostly they make $12.00 and up. On that alone there'd be millions saved......

I love blanket statements like that. How about health care, run by the government it seems to be more efficient then the American, privatized model.

As for the wages, why are people always trying to lower the bar on themselves? Why, tboy, are you trying to make all government wages lower, shouldn't we be trying to make all other wages higher?
 
While any operation can be changed and many improved, surely the trouble of Toyota, GM and Chrysler—to say nothing of Nortel and Enron or most airlines—demonstrate that the private sector can be just as, or even more inefficient than the public. Simplistic 'solutions' like privatizing are not answers.

Breaking the big slow dinosaur into quick little responsive mammals may sound good. Competitiveness and all that. Until the little company managers realize they must grow, and that monopoly means money. Look how competitive our cable TV, telecom and bank sectors are. There's a reason all cars look and behave like all the others in their price range.

Transit is a necessary civic utility, like roads, sidewalks, sewers and a supply of water. It's gotta be cheap and available even where it can't 'pay for itself', otherwise the city clogs up with less efficient, more expensive ways of moving people around. That means it will always be an extreme planning, funding and management task, that will defeat formulas. And it will never be glamourous or pay enough to easily attract the visionary leadership that can boost it out of the stagnation any utility is prone to.

Privatization may have attractive features and may be peripherally useful, but I can't see it as the answer. Remember the public sector TTC was once the answer to the chaotic, inefficient and expensive mess of private operators that didn't meet the city's needs.
 
I am in favor of privatizing but the employees need to be protected. If contractor A looses the bid to contractor B when the tender is up then all of employees from A are out of a job. If they are union contractor, B does not have to hire them or pay them the wage they had. The employee will have to start from ground zero at the starting hourly rate. In essence, an employee can find themselves out of a job every time the contract is awarded to a new operator. Don't believe me...check out whats happening in york region right now. And the union has been totally fucking useless protecting the rights of the employees. Worse yet, the region doesn't seem to give a shit about them either. Sad, and this scenario is playing out right now.

What is happening up there ?????

VIVA is under the same union as TTC and the employees get more than York drivers but less than TTC

I asked the drivers last time I was there

So the private companies workers - VIVA - is protected by the Local 113 TTC union and get more than the public employees who work for York so are not the private workers better off ??
 
Just remember in the end you will pay more, private company MUST make a profit!!!! that's why they are in business. If the new company is cheap to employess it will become unionized so quick it won't know what happened to it.
 
The police budget is the highest cost by far - 24% of the total.

Nobody dares mention freezing this cost or contracting out more of their duties, they are untouchable.

I've made a similar point in many posts in this forum. The police and firefighter budgets are the most egregious of sacred cows at city hall. Cops are even defended when they extort legitimate businesses into paying for outrageous fees for routine monitoring of job sights, public celebrations, etc. I've often seen these welfare cases walking around when attending some public performance, or some the community events and frankly felt offended that they would feel that their calming presence was needed to quell any potential for trouble.

The sheeple in this city deserve the government they get.
 
Just remember in the end you will pay more, private company MUST make a profit!!!! that's why they are in business. If the new company is cheap to employess it will become unionized so quick it won't know what happened to it.

BW1, you've been so good lately, so I'll be gentle. You're just wrong on both counts, but when you've lived, eaten and breathed not much else than what the union gives you, and 'you' have, these points make sense, but they're not necessarily so.
 
The union would not sign any contract that reduced its barganing power, contracts with different expiry dates would do that.

Even with the same expiry date it doesn't matter. They will be bargaining with different management units. They can't hold up the bargaining with company A over a dispute in the terms they have with company B.

At the end of the day if you break up the operation into different companies the union might not WANT to sign a contract that reduces its bargaining power, but it's hard to see what choice the have. The structure itself weakens them.

In the unlikely event that one company goes on strike when another does not, piquet lines at transit entrances would appear and the union brothers would not cross them.

If the picketers from company A are blockading company B then the police can be called in to remove them. They have no right to picket other companies.

There might be work slow downs as a result, but they would not have the absolute ability to shut down the entire city they have today. Some level of service would continue, and that weakens their bargaining position.
 
What is happening up there ?????

VIVA is under the same union as TTC and the employees get more than York drivers but less than TTC

I asked the drivers last time I was there

So the private companies workers - VIVA - is protected by the Local 113 TTC union and get more than the public employees who work for York so are not the private workers better off ??

YRT is operated by a division of Miller Corporation ( nott the mayor) . It provides all sorts of contracted services to teh region, garbage,snow services, construction. They are union members but in a different union. The transit union went on strike against the operator of VIVA another private company. Unfortunatly for them the other companis contract ran on a different schedule and they still worked. It caused some aggravation and some confrontations. The strike lasted about a month and the union signed a contract worth less than the one they had refuse initially. That is the power of separate companies and contracts, which is why the Toronto local would never allow it to happen. The VIVA drivers are reportedly looking to jump unions because the ATU has basically abandoned them because of the hard feelings following the strike
 
Even with the same expiry date it doesn't matter. They will be bargaining with different management units. They can't hold up the bargaining with company A over a dispute in the terms they have with company B.

At the end of the day if you break up the operation into different companies the union might not WANT to sign a contract that reduces its bargaining power, but it's hard to see what choice the have. The structure itself weakens them.



If the picketers from company A are blockading company B then the police can be called in to remove them. They have no right to picket other companies.

There might be work slow downs as a result, but they would not have the absolute ability to shut down the entire city they have today. Some level of service would continue, and that weakens their bargaining position.

In a perfect world like the one you appear to want to live in that would be true, however in the world the rest of us use, the piquets would appear and the city would try to have them removed. The police would do what they alsways do negotiate a " fair" delay time so tehy can appear to be doing their job. The union brothers would initially refuse to cross the line and then each would cross individually after the requirted "fair" dealy time.

Now remember that his is taking place on public property and a piquet line properly done for information purposes is perfectly legal . Just look at the garbage strike last summer for an example .

They could effectivly tie up the city as they do now , throw in rotating piquets at unannounced sites during rushhour, and add in the prospect of this happening with each individual contract as it comes up and you have what would actually be a worse situation from a service point of view.

What the actuall solution is I really don't know , the city of toronto has made this particular bed and now lieing in it is a bit painfull.
 
Just remember in the end you will pay more, private company MUST make a profit!!!! that's why they are in business. If the new company is cheap to employess it will become unionized so quick it won't know what happened to it.

Private companies earn profits, units extort them. I don't see a difference other than by having MULTIPLE partners the TTC will be in a better bargaining position.

Whether it's a union that holds a monopoly or a private company that holds a monopoly the taxpayer gets screwed--you have to break the monopoly to get a good deal.
 
=however in the world the rest of us use, the piquets would appear and the city would try to have them removed

I think you missed something here: It's not the city that would have them removed. The private operator would do so. Unlike the city where the union lobby makes the city gutless, the private operators can afford to play hardball, and would, because the pickets would be eating into their profit margin.

A picket line for information purposes is only legal if it relates to the strike action. A strike in one section of the city can't block off routes in an unrelated region legally. Not under the employment law we have today anyway, the unions would have to get the law changed if they wanted to do that.

Ford workers cannot legally picket a GM plant, not even for "information purposes", even though they have the same union.

The operator unfairly picketed by a union it has no grievance with would sue the union for a lot of money and win.
 
Lets be honest here all are complaining about $$$$ money here cost of running the city. Does anyone here think if any of these services were privatized there taxes would go down???
 
I think you missed something here: It's not the city that would have them removed. The private operator would do so. Unlike the city where the union lobby makes the city gutless, the private operators can afford to play hardball, and would, because the pickets would be eating into their profit margin.

A picket line for information purposes is only legal if it relates to the strike action. A strike in one section of the city can't block off routes in an unrelated region legally. Not under the employment law we have today anyway, the unions would have to get the law changed if they wanted to do that.

Ford workers cannot legally picket a GM plant, not even for "information purposes", even though they have the same union.

The operator unfairly picketed by a union it has no grievance with would sue the union for a lot of money and win.

Piquets are for informatioon purposes they can be set up where ever they will serve the information distribution purpose, that would include subway entrances bus stops stations where ever. A private company can not stop somebody from using a public place ( sidewalk street ) for a legal purpose, that would require a court order and that would require proof of either damagesa or imminent harm. The city may not be the one doing the court appearances but they would have to be party to it as the city " owns " the property.

The operator ( company ) can not sue for damages resulting from a legal activity, an example would be the business who lose money due to the marathons ion Tornro for example . That would be a similar principle
 
BW1, you've been so good lately, so I'll be gentle. You're just wrong on both counts, but when you've lived, eaten and breathed not much else than what the union gives you, and 'you' have, these points make sense, but they're not necessarily so.
Yeah, we only have unions because overly generous and acommodating employers and the governments they controlled foolishly repealed the laws that made them criminal, thus allowing the thieving bastard organizers to take unfair advantage of kind benificent employers. Sadly that is the pattern that continues to this day.

No such thing as a bad employer or a need for workers to unite to speak with one voice. I was hearing things when that guy told me, "I'd love to give you what you're asking for, you're a good worker, but if I gave it to you, I'd have to give it to everyone." Wich was as clear an unspoken invite to organize as I've ever heard.

Unions were created by bad managers and unfair employment practices, like police were created by thieves (or are reformed thieves depending on your prejudices). If everyone had been honest and fair, we might have managed without them but they're here now. Deal with it.

Treat your workers honestly, fairly, and decently with openhanded and open minded communication and you can quite likely make a]paying uniondue unattractive. Bully and bullshit them, levae them insecure and resentful and the corner table conspiracy will find a union organizer looking for a comabt stripe. Private or public.

Not surprisingly, it's way more complicated than your glib dismissal blackrock13. But I'm sure you agree the virtues or vices of unions have zero to do with privatizing the TTC. Which is the topic you were probably trying to get back to.
 
It doesn't need splitting up or privatization. Just a real manager, a new charter and totally new deal with employees which includes a balance of improved compensation, security and work conditions but made conditional on high standars of performance, zero tolerance of poor service backed and far reaching oversight.
 
OJ;

Back in the day, unions did play their part and did some good, but in todays global economy they can fall down and are fast becoming secondary players. Some haven't figured that out soon enough and have ended up paying for it big time.