Contract out the TTC

It doesn't need splitting up or privatization. Just a real manager, a new charter and totally new deal with employees which includes a balance of improved compensation, security and work conditions but made conditional on high standars of performance, zero tolerance of poor service backed and far reaching oversight.
The union will not allow any of the above because it would allow people who want to work hard to get ahead, while the clock punching drones would have to actually work.
 
LS, then why do striking york region employees not shut down the TTC? They could shut down the TTC and claim it is for "information purposes" but they don't because they would get sued for disrupting a business that has nothing to do with their strike.

There' s a simple concept here:

The current power of the city union derives from their having a monopoly. Break the monopoly, break their power. They will still be present to bargain on behalf of their members, but they will be forced to look for reasonable win-win bargaining outcomes rather than the extortion they currently engage in.
 
OJ;

Back in the day, unions did play their part and did some good, but in todays global economy they can fall down and are fast becoming secondary players. Some haven't figured that out soon enough and have ended up paying for it big time.
Ah, so what we need are global unions. How else can the sweated labourers influence the Wal*Marts?
 
LS, then why do striking york region employees not shut down the TTC? They could shut down the TTC and claim it is for "information purposes" but they don't because they would get sued for disrupting a business that has nothing to do with their strike.

There' s a simple concept here:

The current power of the city union derives from their having a monopoly. Break the monopoly, break their power. They will still be present to bargain on behalf of their members, but they will be forced to look for reasonable win-win bargaining outcomes rather than the extortion they currently engage in.

A strike in York region has nothing to do with the transit system in Toronto, it would serve no purpose to piquet the TTC centers, that is why it was not done there was no useful purpose. The VIVA staff did in fact piquet the YRT centers for a while and the cold weather and lack of interest in their cause stopped them.

The concept of sueing somebody or a company for carring on a perfectly legal activity is strange to say the least
 
Ah, so what we need are global unions. How else can the sweated labourers influence the Wal*Marts?

Are you suggesting that all Wal-Mart workers should make $100,000 like TTC fare collectors? If so, the cost of a litre of milk will be $25.
 
I fear that bully monopoly municipal unions and weak kneed and commie mayors and councilors have created a death spiral for the city. The cost of living and doing business in Toronto is simply getting too expensive. Here are a couple of examples:

1) During the 2009 garbage strike, I learned that volunteers are prohibited from picking up garbage. Apparently, there is a law/bylaw/regulation that states that "only professionally trained" garbage people are autorized to pick one garbage in the City of Toronto. You or I are not authorized to pick up garbage and could be fined (or jailed?) for doing so.

2) Paid duty police officers. Only "professionally trained" police officers are eligible to be hired as paid duty officers. I can sort of see some logic here because an "unprofessionally untrained" police officer might inadvertently taser someone to death.
 
What is happening up there ?????

VIVA is under the same union as TTC and the employees get more than York drivers but less than TTC

I asked the drivers last time I was there

So the private companies workers - VIVA - is protected by the Local 113 TTC union and get more than the public employees who work for York so are not the private workers better off ??


YRT is contracted out to Miller on one side and Tokmakjian on the other. Viva is run by foreign outfit called Violia. The Tokmakjian contact is up soon and went out for tender. It appears that Violia undercut the local outfit by being able to save on labour costs since all the drivers will be new hires at a starting rate. Problem is a lot of the local outfit's drivers who are unionized and earing top dollar for that transit will be out of a job and will need to reapply with Violia to get their old job back at a new reduced rate. The region knew about this but did not modify the language in the tender to protect the drivers or level the playing field. The current union knew about this but did sweet fuck all to pressure the change. The local contractor who had the contract for the better part of 30 years and was bound by the employees contract (and rightly so) lost out to a the foreign owned Violia because they can pay lower starting rates.. Some of these employess have over 25 years and will loose their current standard of living and signority. And this bullshit can happen every 5 years since York region seems to care less about the people who run their system.
I'm all in favor of contracting out to the most effecient operator but the employees cannot be treated like disposable rags. This one really stinks. Shame on the region and the union!
 
YRT is contracted out to Miller on one side and Tokmakjian on the other. Viva is run by foreign outfit called Violia. The Tokmakjian contact is up soon and went out for tender. It appears that Violia undercut the local outfit by being able to save on labour costs since all the drivers will be new hires at a starting rate. Problem is a lot of the local outfit's drivers who are unionized and earing top dollar for that transit will be out of a job and will need to reapply with Violia to get their old job back at a new reduced rate. The region knew about this but did not modify the language in the tender to protect the drivers or level the playing field. The current union knew about this but did sweet fuck all to pressure the change. The local contractor who had the contract for the better part of 30 years and was bound by the employees contract (and rightly so) lost out to a the foreign owned Violia because they can pay lower starting rates.. Some of these employees have over 25 years and will loose their current standard of living and signority. And this bullshit can happen every 5 years since York region seems to care less about the people who run their system.
I'm all in favor of contracting out to the most effecient operator but the employees cannot be treated like disposable rags. This one really stinks. Shame on the region and the union!

Thx for the explanation and I agree that the employees are getting fucked so Viola can get rich. It is called the merry dance of capitalism.

Viva just runs the express routes, has modern clean buses and is on the honor system where occasional police will come to check for tickets
 
The union at the TTC would have according ( i believe) to the law a succesor right to the unions at the new employers, regardless of whether the new companies are unionized or not.
.

Well that law definitely applies if one buys a company with a unionized workforce you are correct. I'm not sure it applies it situations that don't involve the purchase of the business. Whether the puchase of the rolling stock and/or subway line constitutes "buying the business" would probably end up in court. I'm guessing you may be right - then we would have accomplished nothing except to get better negotiaters on the employer side of the table.
 
I don't think the TTC should sell the rolling stock or the subway line. They should simply contract out the job of operating the infrastructure.

Selling the TTC off wholesale to a private company would not improve the situation. We would go from facing a union monopoly to a private company monopoly. Swapping one monopoly for another would not improve the city's bargaining position.

The goal would be to offer different contracts for different jobs: One contract to provide subway operators, another contract to provide fare collectors, another contract to provide bus drivers, another one for streetcar drivers. We would then have a variety of different companies providing services to the TTC. Any one of them could have their employees go on strike, but the other services would continue uninterrupted.

Since the city owns the infrastructure and the rolling stock it can swap to a different contracter when the contract expires, so the city would have substantial bargaining power.
 
Some of these employess have over 25 years and will loose their current standard of living and signority.

This will sound harsh but nobody owes anybody a living. Some of these employees were sucking on the public teat for over 25 years and now they join the real world where the rest of us live. Yes, reality sucks.
 
Since the city owns the infrastructure and the rolling stock it can swap to a different contracter when the contract expires, so the city would have substantial bargaining power.

Fuji, you do make sense sometimes. What the TTC and all City of Toronto bully monopoly unions need is a change in attitude and culture. Smiliar to the societal change in attitude on smoking, it will take education and time, but it is doable.
 
This will sound harsh but nobody owes anybody a living. Some of these employees were sucking on the public teat for over 25 years and now they join the real world where the rest of us live. Yes, reality sucks.

These employees were not public servants, they work for a private company. And the office staff from managers to trainers are also not public servants. The whole reason for contracting out is for efficiency. YRT has much lower operating costs per unit per hour for everything capared to the TTC. They also get paid less. The TTC is a huge elephant with run away expenses and top heavy with mgt. This is a case where your loosing a job because the next contractor can rehire you and pay you a starting rate for the next one to two years.
Your right, nobody owes you a living, but if your doing a good job, have been for 25 years, at a agreed upon rate, you shouldn't have to start over again at your same job for 30% less the next day because a new contractor has taken over. Efficiency should be gained by cutting waste and acquiring better managers to run the system, not on how you can cheat your current workforce.
Besides, how fair is a tender that favors new bidders who can pay a starting rate over an existing one that is bound by a collective agreement. Not a very level playing field!
 
Rather than contract out the operations. Just get rid of the unions.

Sure, but that's a tall order. That would require changes in law at likely both the federal and provincial level, if not a change to the charter of rights and freedoms.

Whereas contracting out the staffing of different elements of the TTC to different private operators is something the City of Toronto could do today, without any law needing to be changed.
 
That would require changes in law at likely both the federal and provincial level, if not a change to the charter of rights and freedoms.

Even changing the law might not be enough when the City of Toronto has a commie mayor supported by a bunch of commie councillors. Premier Harris changed the law to allow Toronto to bring in replacement workers when the garbage people went on strike but our commie mayor simply ignored the City's legal rights.

Then there is the very real threat of violence by union thugs and goons. Does anyone think that the bully unions and their members give a damn about complying with laws?
 
Get over your $100000 ticket taker!!! ask the question how many hours of OVERTIME did he have to work to make that amount of money???? Now as for Walmart the worlds largest sued employeer that says it all. Now look at teh banks making billions in profits getting tax cuts and more are coming for them July 1st 2010 and they pay there front line workers peanuts, while making billions, something wrong with the picture I'd say.
 
Even changing the law might not be enough when the City of Toronto has a commie mayor supported by a bunch of commie councillors. Premier Harris changed the law to allow Toronto to bring in replacement workers when the garbage people went on strike but our commie mayor simply ignored the City's legal rights.
?

Premier Harris is the one who put Toronto in all this financial mess in the first place. His amalgamation and offloading of services ensured that Toronto would get screwed, mostly for supporting those pinkoes, and never be able to afford to pay its own way again. Unless McGuinty fixes that up, and its not bloody likely with a $24 billion deficit, again largely thanks to the structural deficit put in place by Harris's tax cuts. Same thing that Flaherty is now doing again to Canada, as the federal budget officer, Kevin Page reports, Canada now faces a structural deficit due to Harper's unaffordable tax cuts.

Now compare the success of privatizing the 407, which runs fine, but costs too much and gives a private company the priviledge of revoking your license plate if you don't pay their fees, with the possibilities of a privatized TTC. All privatizing ever does is give some politician's friend the opportunity to rake the public over the coals and make them rich. Its not going to make service better or faster. What's screwed the TTC is the waste of resources in starting up the Sheppard line, where the poplulation density doesn't support a subway line, and never will.