Contract out the TTC

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/you...ivate-transit-less-rare-than-you-d-think?bn=1

Contract the operation of the TTC out to different private operators. One company operating the subway. Another operating some bus lines. Another operating other bus lines. Another operating some street cars.

That way if any one operator faces a strike by its employees the rest of the transit system is not affected and only a small part of the system goes offline. If the subway operators are on strike people can still make due with street cars and busses. And so on.
 
Yes it should be done but there would be blood on the streets before the unions would lose this issue - well that is if they are awake.

Garbage would have been the esiest one to start with.
 
It won't happen in our lifetime.
 
The police budget is the highest cost by far - 24% of the total.

Nobody dares mention freezing this cost or contracting out more of their duties, they are untouchable.
 
In the long run, say even in about five years, the cost of contracting out will be higher than the cost of keeping it in-house.

The TTC is an essential service so the city and citizens have to pay whatever the new owners ask. There's no negotiation. Like in all cases where services are contracted out, the initial bids will be really low but actually they're too low in terms of estimated costs and over the years will rise because the new owners want to make a profit.

The real problem with the TTC is in 1.) How the organization is run; and 2.) Funding from the city.
 
In the long run, say even in about five years, the cost of contracting out will be higher than the cost of keeping it in-house.

The TTC is an essential service so the city and citizens have to pay whatever the new owners ask. There's no negotiation. Like in all cases where services are contracted out, the initial bids will be really low but actually they're too low in terms of estimated costs and over the years will rise because the new owners want to make a profit.

The real problem with the TTC is in 1.) How the organization is run; and 2.) Funding from the city.

I was told that there are 4000 staff and 5500 workers. That is a little top heavy to me,especially with what the staff are making.
 
http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/you...ivate-transit-less-rare-than-you-d-think?bn=1

Contract the operation of the TTC out to different private operators. One company operating the subway. Another operating some bus lines. Another operating other bus lines. Another operating some street cars.

That way if any one operator faces a strike by its employees the rest of the transit system is not affected and only a small part of the system goes offline. If the subway operators are on strike people can still make due with street cars and busses. And so on.
Would splitting rhe transit commission into different contracters result in different unions for the workers and operators? I doubt it. A strike will still take down the whole system.
 
it is an interesting concept, the problem is that you are assuming the contracts would be separate. The union at the TTC would have according ( i believe) to the law a succesor right to the unions at the new employers, regardless of whether the new companies are unionized or not. The union would refuse any contract to any of the other entities that did not run in concert with the others. The TTC nees a good pruning starting with the board room and working down.

They also need to be made an essential service, in concert with this the arbitration system needs to be reworked so that the affordability of the service is taken into account when the arbitrator makes his decision. This needs to be done regardless of the TTC . The example of the Toronto Police and Firefighters refusing any contract that does not make them the highest paid in their job in Canada has to stop.
 
In the long run, say even in about five years, the cost of contracting out will be higher than the cost of keeping it in-house.

The TTC is an essential service so the city and citizens have to pay whatever the new owners ask. There's no negotiation. Like in all cases where services are contracted out, the initial bids will be really low but actually they're too low in terms of estimated costs and over the years will rise because the new owners want to make a profit.

The real problem with the TTC is in 1.) How the organization is run; and 2.) Funding from the city.

There are lots of places that contract out garbage collection/disposal. It is very cost effective, and in places where I have lived it also provides much better service than municipal garbage service.
 
Not a good idea.

I'd be all for contracting out Garbage Collection, Emergency Services, including the police, but not the TTC and not the Sewer and Water (been tried by several municipalities (Hamilton) and it does not work well.

The problem would be the private guys cutting corners to improve their bottom line - count on it.
 
Would splitting rhe transit commission into different contracters result in different unions for the workers and operators? I doubt it. A strike will still take down the whole system.

That's illegal. Just because company A employees are in a legal strike position does not mean that company B employees will be. You can't go on strike against one employer just because you don't like what a totally different company has done.

Moreover in practice where it's been done that has not happened. When the VIVA bus drivers went on strike against the private operator of VIVA, the rest of that transit system kept running because the employees of those other contractors did not strike.
 
The union at the TTC would have according ( i believe) to the law a succesor right to the unions at the new employers

The union could presumably submit a bid for the work if it wanted the job, and might well come up with a competitive offer.
 
The TTC is an essential service so the city and citizens have to pay whatever the new owners ask.

No. You would not sell the TTC. You would privitize its *operation*. You could walk away from an operator and give the job to someone else. It would be stupid to outright privitize it because, as you say, the new owner could then hold the city over a barrel. The goal is to wind up with a situation in which nobody holds the city over a barrel, by tendering contracts to *operate* the service.

The city would continue to own the busses, streetcars, subways, and other infrastructure.

It is thus relatively easy to walk away from one operator and give their routes to someone else if the operator asked for too much money.
 
That's illegal. Just because company A employees are in a legal strike position does not mean that company B employees will be. You can't go on strike against one employer just because you don't like what a totally different company has done.

Moreover in practice where it's been done that has not happened. When the VIVA bus drivers went on strike against the private operator of VIVA, the rest of that transit system kept running because the employees of those other contractors did not strike.

The ViVA strike did indeed happen but the circumstances are different. YRT and VIVA are two entirly different companies set up at different times on separate contracts to the region . The VIVA service was done through a seal bid and they won the contract.

The TTC is an existing company that you propose to split minto separate operations/companies. The union would still represent the nbulk of the workers at all the divisions, they would also I expect refuse to sign any contract that allowed for the VIVA YRT situation.

Even if the contracts were separted you would still see piquets at all the locations that were up and running, the working employees would of course refuse to cross the lines and the police would do what they always do which is nothing.
 
The union could presumably submit a bid for the work if it wanted the job, and might well come up with a competitive offer.

My understanding of the succesor laws in the province guarentee the union the jobs that move to a new company , if the new company brought in all new employees aside from the bloodbath that would result I think those employees automatically enter the union. The law was enacted to stop companies from shutting down and opening up with a new name and non union employees.........
 
My understanding of the succesor laws in the province guarentee the union the jobs that move to a new company , if the new company brought in all new employees aside from the bloodbath that would result I think those employees automatically enter the union. The law was enacted to stop companies from shutting down and opening up with a new name and non union employees.........

That's fine, but a union still cannot strike against company A just because it has a gripe with company B. For example, the employees at Chrysler can't go on strike just because they are pissed off at the way Ford employees are being treated, even if they have the same union.

They may try an illegal wildcat strike but the lawyers for their employer would be able to go get an injunction to force them back to work, as they would not be in a legal strike position.
 
One of two companies contracted to maintain the London subway, Metronet, went bankrupt, leaving taxpayers on the hook for what some have estimated to be more than a billion pounds.

“Government had lulled themselves into the belief that the private sector is far more efficient than it is. Taking the huge amount of investment off the government books — it’s just creative accounting, and in the long run it costs the taxpayer more,” he said.

“I think the TTC is quite efficient and accountable to its public. It’s actually pretty good, certainly for North America: high levels of service; frequent service, integration of subway is very good. It would be crazy to throw all that away.”

 
That's fine, but a union still cannot strike against company A just because it has a gripe with company B. For example, the employees at Chrysler can't go on strike just because they are pissed off at the way Ford employees are being treated, even if they have the same union.

They may try an illegal wildcat strike but the lawyers for their employer would be able to go get an injunction to force them back to work, as they would not be in a legal strike position.
Wildcat strikes are in fact illegal, but my point is that all of the employees wold be represented by the ATU as they are now. The union would not sign any contract that reduced its barganing power, contracts with different expiry dates would do that. In the unlikely event that one company goes on strike when another does not, piquet lines at transit entrances would appear and the union brothers would not cross them. This would require provincial legislation to stop. Regardless it would result in massive problems
 
You would end up paying a higher fare...but it would be nice to get rid of all the lazy, complaining, Union bums.
 
We know no-one is going to privatize the TTC, because privatization is about using competition to improve services and efficiency and so on. There won't be competition after a sale, of course, just a private company with a shotgun to the city's head.

But privatizing the operation of the TTC, apart from the fact that public services gone private have a notorious history of heaping money into some company's pocket but then sticking taxpayers with a bill later on, poses all kinds of social justice problems (different profit margins on different routes) as well as coordinated growth and city planning issues. Though it would be cool if someone had a neat way of solving those...

Which might leave us with . . .

Consistently voting out of office anyone in Municipal or Provincial Government who doesn't have the political cojones to dethrone the Unions and put in a place a streamlined management.

Are the TTC troubles more a problem of political will-power, rather than being a problem solved by moving from the model of a public enterprise?