Conservative attack adds

Ref said:
Hehehehe, thanks for the laugh.
I don't see the humour.

Ref said:
Who do you think paid down the debt? The mighty Liberal party? It was the people who were overtaxed doing it.
I understand that taxes are paid by the people.

However, the Federal Liberals could have decided to allocate more money to program spending and less money to debt payment. I'm glad that they chose the latter.

The Federal Conservatives provided a %1 GST cut. That's not necessarily a savings of %1 to the consumer because the provider of goods and services can increase prices to keep the %1. Personally, I don't feel %1 better off, but I will feel worse if the debt payment comes in at less than $10B this year.

Ref said:
As for the Liberals downloading expenses, this again was another way to pay down the debt. Pass it on to the next level of government and let them figure out how to pay for it! Talk about mismanagement. But thank god Mike Harris was there, the sheep of Ontario were led to believe the evils of the country were because of him!

As I stated before, I don't see it as downloading. Both the Federal Liberals and the Ontario Tories made cuts to services that were no longer affordable, and both levels of government were correct. The Ontario Tories made the mistake of cutting tax revenue, and so they continued with deficits. The Ontario Liberals are also continuing with deficits despite raising taxes, not good.

Ref said:
All the while the silent abuse of funds continued, the accountability of federal government controls was forgotten due to the spin-doctoring of the Liberal machine.

Sadly, spin-doctoring is a problem with every party. Just last November, Conservative Finance Minister Jim Flaherty tried to spin me on how he planned to pay off "net" debt in 15 years. I'm not interested in the net debt; I'm interested in the acutal debt (Like the one the Alberta Tories paid off). $10B/year pays off the actual debt in about 50 years. At less than $5B/year, the debt will not be paid off in my lifetime.

Ref said:
I have seen the inner workings of the massive accounting mechanism in the federal government and it is a nasty mix of bullshit and creative accounting. It will never be held accountable due to the multitude of programs and departments that have no internal controls.

Are the conservatives any better? Only time will tell, but at least we have rid ourselves of a Liberal government that had become corrupt and used to feeding at the trough of public expense. Change was needed because the "Old Guard" was content on ruling the roost and pointing fingers at everyone but themselves for the problems in the country.

Because if you step back and look at the big picture, the federal Liberals may have looked good from a federal standpoint, but their actions certainly fucked up most all provincial and municpal governmental operations. And that my friend, was not a good deal for the taxpayer and for the country!

Federal Liberals = Reduce the federal debt, but increase the provincial and municpal debts. Thanks for the ass fucking!

The Federal Liberals did not increase provincial and municipal debts. The Federal Liberals stopped paying out more than it took in, and it's time that the Ontario Liberals followed suit.
 
Last edited:
bbking said:
... will see who's dim. A majority Liberal Gov. is far more likely than a Conservative one.

Not according to the latest polls......lmao

It looks like Dion's convention bump is quickly evaporating with each unintelligible word he utters.

Don't wait too long boys or the Bloc will form the opposition.

bbking said:
Unfortunately, many of the old reform fools like yourself like to think Ontario will possibly go for Harper and his crowd. You Harper types are so out of step, you honestly believe that Ontario - or more importantly GTA will fall for the old Nixon campaign on crime, that it might actually work here - while I understand that Harper and most Albertans view Toronto as a crime ridden City akin to New Orleans, the reality is not there. The guestion then becomes Quebec and BC and one wonders if you guys actually feel lucky - the polls say no, but I do understand that false bravado seems to get you suckers to believe any ole lie Harper wishes to tell.

Like you, I have no idea what you're talking about.
 
markvee said:
The Federal Liberals did not increase provincial and municipal debts. The Federal Liberals stopped paying out more than it took in, and it's time that the Ontario Liberals followed suit.

Hehehehe, you are quite the funny guy.

I guess the elimination of provincial payments from the Federal government had no effect on the governments below them.

Please read up on transfer payments, specifically the lack of payments to Ontario and update me on that situation

Also, what would happen if Ontario decided to say "Fuck Canada", let's become our own country. How would things change from a federal perspective?

As nice as it is from that long lost hippie percieved liberal utopia, reality states that we need to be more conservative in our approach to living life from a realistic point of view. If having a minorty conservative government gives us that protection, then lets embrace it and be self assured that the silent majority is finally being heard.

Unfortunatley, the corrupt liberal governments of the past have worn out it's welcome and even the hippies of today acknowlege the bullshit they have been spoonsped by the Chretian and Martin governments these past few years.
 
bbking said:
... will see who's dim. A majority Liberal Gov. is far more likely than a Conservative one. Unfortunately, many of the old reform fools like yourself like to think Ontario will possibly go for Harper and his crowd. You Harper types are so out of step, you honestly believe that Ontario - or more importantly GTA will fall for the old Nixon campaign on crime, that it might actually work here - while I understand that Harper and most Albertans view Toronto as a crime ridden City akin to New Orleans, the reality is not there. The guestion then becomes Quebec and BC and one wonders if you guys actually feel lucky - the polls say no, but I do understand that false bravado seems to get you suckers to believe any ole lie Harper wishes to tell.

Good luck with thatfoolish notion though - you'll need it.


bbk

I'm a swing voter who is currently a Harper type and who doesn't think he has a chance in the GTA the next time around. But the landscape is changing. The children of new immigrants are somewhat more savy than their parents. They will not always vote in a block as they do now once they understand they are not indebted for their immigration to Canada. More importantly, the Liberals have suceeded in alienating many of their Jewish supporters who despite their smallish numbers had a huge impact on party coffers. If the Liberals were flush, they would be matching these ads but they can't. Instead, they're trying to spin it like their taking the high road.

What amazes me most is the selection of Dion as leader. With only 13% of first ballot supprt, he was hardly anyone's first choice. A very atypical Liberal move that has many of my Liberal colleagues shaking their heads. Although the election debate is probably less important than it was twenty years ago when Mulroney exposed Turner, I'm sure you're looking forward to seeing Dion tear a strip out of Harper on the environment. lol
 
tip said:
What amazes me most is the selection of Dion as leader. With only 13% of first ballot supprt, he was hardly anyone's first choice. A very atypical Liberal move that has many of my Liberal colleagues shaking their heads.

Most of the delegates favoured him as their second choice. Unless the front runner gets the nod on the first ballot, the candidate who is a strong second choice will often times come out as the winner. This was why I was fairly certain he would win back in October, when the polls showed most delegates placed Dion as their second choice and Iggy had no chance of winning on the first ballot.

Also, it's an unwritten law within the Liberal party, they rotate their leaders French/English.
 
Ref said:
Hehehehe, you are quite the funny guy.

I guess the elimination of provincial payments from the Federal government had no effect on the governments below them.

Please read up on transfer payments, specifically the lack of payments to Ontario and update me on that situation

Also, what would happen if Ontario decided to say "Fuck Canada", let's become our own country. How would things change from a federal perspective?

As nice as it is from that long lost hippie percieved liberal utopia, reality states that we need to be more conservative in our approach to living life from a realistic point of view. If having a minorty conservative government gives us that protection, then lets embrace it and be self assured that the silent majority is finally being heard.

Unfortunatley, the corrupt liberal governments of the past have worn out it's welcome and even the hippies of today acknowlege the bullshit they have been spoonsped by the Chretian and Martin governments these past few years.

Again, I don't see the humour.
I understand Federal payments to the provinces.
Do you think it was wrong for the Liberal Federal government to reduce these payments?
Would a conservative approach maintain these payments at the former levels?
Should Harper restore the payments?

I would have decreased the payments while allowing the provinces to increase provincial taxes (the provinces collect income tax and sales tax just like the feds). If the provinces wish to maintain unaffordable programs, the provinces should take the financial hit.

I think that financial conservatism entails not spending more than you have.
The Federal Liberals were right to cut provincial spending because there was no money. Similarly, Mike Harris was right to make cuts when the money wasn't there. Even Rae Days were an example of fiscal conservatism by trying to hold the line on public service employee pay.

An easy measure of the financial conservatism of a government is it's yearly debt payment. If the payment is a negative number then the government may as well call itself financially liberal (which would include the provincial governments of Rae, Harris, and McQuinty). If the Federal Liberals could make about a $10B payment every year, but the Federal Conservatives make a payment of less than $5B, then the Conservatives are less than half as financially conservative (with respect to debt management) as the Liberals.

Remember that the Federal Conservatives have not restored payments to Ontario. The decreased Federal surplus will be attributable to the GST cut, not restoration of spending on the provinces.
 
markvee said:
I think that financial conservatism entails not spending more than you have.
trying to hold the line on public service employee pay.

True

An easy measure of the financial conservatism of a government is it's yearly debt payment.

.

This is way oversimplifying. You are missing half of the equation. Taxation.
 
train said:
This is way oversimplifying. You are missing half of the equation. Taxation.
Given that I argued in this forum that measuring health care quality by wait times is oversimplifying, I concede it may be oversimplifying to measure fiscal conservatism by yearly debt payment alone.

However, I'm going to argue for my single measure of fiscal conservatism until someone provides a better method.

The question, as I see it, is what is more fiscally conservative, reducing taxes or paying debt?

I call reduce-your-taxes-while-you're-still-in-the-debt-hole fiscal conseratives yellow-bellied-weak-kneed-lily-livered conservatives.

I say be a manly fiscal conservative, like Ralph Klein, when he held up that paid in full statement for Alberta's provincial debt. Don't give any yellow-bellied, "but he has all those oil revenues." In my book, real fiscal conservatives want to pay debt the hard way, without natural resource revenues.

To keep this thread on topic, I'm going to add another single measure, this time for enviornmentalism. Why don't we treat today's emissions like a kind of envirnomental debt. This way, reducing emissions by 1% is like paying back $5B of debt. Fifty years of reducing emissions by 1% per year would put Canada at a 50% reduction in emissions in 50 years, an excellent achievement. I like this measure more than the current, how much meaningless paper can be signed, i.e. Kyoto Accord or Clean Air Act.

The Federal politicians can start tomorrow, by cancelling their Parliamentary shuttle bus service from the parking lot.
 
Last edited:
lookingforitallthetime said:
Most of the delegates favoured him as their second choice. Unless the front runner gets the nod on the first ballot, the candidate who is a strong second choice will often times come out as the winner. This was why I was fairly certain he would win back in October, when the polls showed most delegates placed Dion as their second choice and Iggy had no chance of winning on the first ballot.

Also, it's an unwritten law within the Liberal party, they rotate their leaders French/English.

Your correct about the unwritten law; however the Liberals I spoke to said Martin wasn't in long enough to count as an English leader. That's why most of the French Liberal heavyweights like Coderre did not run.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20061204.wgagnon04/BNStory/LiberalBackgrounder
 
tip said:
Your correct about the unwritten law; however the Liberals I spoke to said Martin wasn't in long enough to count as an English leader. That's why most of the French Liberal heavyweights like Coderre did not run.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20061204.wgagnon04/BNStory/LiberalBackgrounder

Except, Paul Martin was in longer than John Turner and they still gave the nod to Chretien after Turner.

The previous leadership battle between Turner and Chretien was extremely bitter and after losing, Chretien was almost inconsolable. He felt betrayed because the party machine (and many who he thought were his friends) backed Turner over him. Their argument was it's Turner's time because he's English.

A book by Lawrence Martin (Chretien, the Will to Win) covers this. If you get a chance, it's a good read.
 
bbking said:
Martin gets a pass on the rule because of his birthplace - weak I know but that was the spin. The Chretien/Martin war was a battle between two powerful Montreal factions within the Liberal Party which has it's roots in the Turner/Chretien fight. This splilled over into the last leadership contest with Iggy supported by the Martin camp and Rae supported by the Chetien camp. Coderre didn't run because he couldn't unite the two camps behind himself and saw what Kennedy was doing in English Canada. Coderre thought enough Quebecers would pass on Dion and support Kennedy, giving Coderre a shot at the leadership if Harper did well in Quebec in the next election and Kennedy wasn't able to return Liberals to Government. That didn't happen so I'm not sure what Coderre does in the next leadership race and with Kennedy building power riding by riding, I'm not so sure he (Kennedy) can be stopped if Dion falters in the next election.

I thought Kennedy was the best candidate in the last leadership race.

It's starting to look like you may need him sooner than you had hoped.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I thought Kennedy was the best candidate in the last leadership race.

It's starting to look like you may need him sooner than you had hoped.
So did I, which isn't saying much. I will give him credit he has swung a bit more to the centre in his political career.
Dion will get crucified in the English debates and we'll end up with another Tory minority thanks in large part to the blind and deaf Torontonians.
 
bbking said:
... but you haven't seen the real Dion - he is very good on the stump trail. One on one he is much better than the PM. Unfortuntaly, the PM and Dion's styles are polar opposite - and Liberals are trying to decide do you play fire with fire and negate Dion's natural strengths or do you go with Dion's ability to take his time to devolpe sound policy
Dion couldn't fight his way out of a wet paper bag, even if there were holes in it allready.
 
pussylicker said:
Dion couldn't fight his way out of a wet paper bag, even if there were holes in it allready.

I don't get it. BB was talking about Dion's strengths on the campaign trail and how he's good at dealing with people one on one etc. So now you've responded with some insane comment about Dion not being able to fight??? It sounds like you're talking about physical fighting as in fistcuffs or some other such nonsense. WTF??? Who cares if Dion is a good fighter or not? We're not asking him to go out there and physically assault anyone. So what is your point? BTW, Harper doesn't look like much of a fighter either but you can't tell just by looking so I don't see how you'd know whether Dion is a good scrapper or not. That whole fighting thing is just plain nonsense.
 
newinottawa said:
Attack ads always seem like an act of desperation to me. I didn't like when the Liberals used them in the last election and I don't like to Conservatives using even before an election is called now. It reeks of American mudslinging. Canadians should be above this crass behaviour.

It's not mudslinging, it's 'american' mudslinging. Like we're above all that, not to mention being 'above' those base americans. Reality check: about the only thing we canadians are above americans is in our capacity for being sanctimonious prigs. I happen to like the ads 'cause they hoist those holier-than-thou hypocrite Liberals on their own petards. Harper may be scary but Dion strikes me as someone who'd be prepared to break a few eggs (namely the golden ones in Alberta that's paying for his government and Quebec's) in order to achieve his environmental wet dream. What a creep.
 
FOOTSNIFFER said:
Harper may be scary but Dion strikes me as someone who'd be prepared to break a few eggs (namely the golden ones in Alberta that's paying for his government and Quebec's) in order to achieve his environmental wet dream. What a creep.

You are really superficial to the extreme. To call someone a creep because he "strikes you as someone who'd be prepared ....." is pretty silly. At least wait untill he does something bad.
 
slowpoke said:
I don't get it. BB was talking about Dion's strengths on the campaign trail and how he's good at dealing with people one on one etc.
So what is your point? BTW, Harper doesn't look like much of a fighter either but you can't tell just by looking so I don't see how you'd know whether Dion is a good scrapper or not.
Nothing was said about a fistacuff. Dion isn't a statesman, and never will be. He has no poise, no charisma, and no self restraint. Iggy didn't get upset, Dryden didn't get upset, Kennedy didn't get upset, Bob Rae didn't get upset. Only Stephanie got upset. He showed he can't deal with pressure without whining. The truth hurts, and he can't handle the truth. He couldn't debate with the others, so how can he perform one on one?

I haven't seen Harper lose his cool, and cry like a baby.
 
pussylicker said:
Nothing was said about a fistacuff. Dion isn't a statesman, and never will be. He has no poise, no charisma, and no self restraint. Iggy didn't get upset, Dryden didn't get upset, Kennedy didn't get upset, Bob Rae didn't get upset. Only Stephanie got upset. He showed he can't deal with pressure without whining. The truth hurts, and he can't handle the truth. He couldn't debate with the others, so how can he perform one on one?

I haven't seen Harper lose his cool, and cry like a baby.

Harper would kick Dion's scrawny ass in a fist fight. :D
 
pussylicker said:
Nothing was said about a fistacuff. Dion isn't a statesman, and never will be. He has no poise, no charisma, and no self restraint. Iggy didn't get upset, Dryden didn't get upset, Kennedy didn't get upset, Bob Rae didn't get upset. Only Stephanie got upset. He showed he can't deal with pressure without whining. The truth hurts, and he can't handle the truth. He couldn't debate with the others, so how can he perform one on one?

I haven't seen Harper lose his cool, and cry like a baby.

I think Dion got angry at Iggy's cheap shot remark and, BTW, he didn't cry like a baby. He was frustrated by Iggy's tactics and his heated response in English wasn't particularly coherent. English is not his native tongue so, IMHO, it was understandable that he couldn't find the right words quickly enough. I'd like to see how you handled yourself (arguing in French) under the same circumstances.

Dion inherited Kyoto quite late in the game and worked his tail off to make it happen so it pissed him off when Iggy, the siver spoon academic, pretended that it was Dion's fault that "we didn't get it done". Iggy had no idea what Dion went through as the environment minister - trying to sell Kyoto while the gov't sank under the weight of sponsorship. I honestly don't think it was possible for Dion to succeed under those circumstances and Iggy was out of line for exploiting that. I'd have been pissed too.