Conservative attack adds

lookingforitallthetime said:
You're right, I should have said using loopholes. That was what I meant.

Blow it our your arse anyway :p


that still implys some wrongdoing. but not necessarily illegal. yes if you had said that originally it would be a little bit different. I still find it fascinating to find a right wing individual (i assume you are right wing based on your comments) that does not believe in minimizing their taxes payable and structuring their affairs to pay the least amount possible.

thanks for paying so much in taxes. I appreciate it.
 
red said:
where have I gone wrong? you have read the treaty? you didn't get it second hand? your opinion is more valuable than the average canadian? or you don't despise the opinions of the average canadian? if I am wrong, then I will gladly admit it.

You stated in an earlier post that you disapproved of the way I discuss opinions. Putting words in my mouth is a substantially weaker method of discussion IMO.

Show me where I said my opinion "is more valuable than the average Canadian" or I "despise the opinions of the average Canadian" and I will gladly admit I'm wrong.
 
red said:
that still implys some wrongdoing. but not necessarily illegal. yes if you had said that originally it would be a little bit different. I still find it fascinating to find a right wing individual (i assume you are right wing based on your comments) that does not believe in minimizing their taxes payable and structuring their affairs to pay the least amount possible.

thanks for paying so much in taxes. I appreciate it.

I wonder what your stance on the issue would be if Harper owned a shipping company and registered the vessels in a different country to take advantage of tax loopholes.

Decidedly different I'm sure.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I wonder what your stance on the issue would be if Harper owned a shipping company and registered the vessels in a different country to take advantage of tax loopholes.

Decidedly different I'm sure.


no it wouldn't. but there is no danger of this happening as he has never run a business. he has worked either in politics or as a policy wonk is wholelife, I believe.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
You stated in an earlier post that you disapproved of the way I discuss opinions. Putting words in my mouth is a substantially weaker method of discussion IMO.

Show me where I said my opinion "is more valuable than the average Canadian" or I "despise the opinions of the average Canadian" and I will gladly admit I'm wrong.

I based that on the quote below. I will acknowledge that my comment "despise the opinions of the average Canadian" was over the top.

lookingforitallthetime said:
I'm always amazed at how little people know about Kyoto. Generally speaking, the ones who know the least are the most supportive.
I will acknowledge that my comment "despise the opinions of the average Canadian" was probably going too far. my apologies.
 
red said:
no it wouldn't. but there is no danger of this happening as he has never run a business. he has worked either in politics or as a policy wonk is wholelife, I believe.

I'm not convinced you would be as lenient on Harper as you appear to be on Martin, but I will have to take your word for it.

That aside, there is no reason to believe Harper would be any less successful in business than he is in politics. I would be happy to have him run my company, but prefer him in the position he now holds.
 
Given that Dion never ran a business either, I’m sure that Red does not mean his post as a criticism of Harper, as he would also have to make the same criticism of Dion (OK, Dion came from a less demanding academic discipline but otherwise he would suffer from the same criticism if Red had meant it as a criticism).

Edit: BTW, according to Wikipedia, Harper did work as a computer programer in the oil and gas sector before going back to school (university), although I'm not sure what any of this has to do with his being a PM. Dion seems to have never been in the private sector.
 
Harper was also President of the National Citizens Coalition for a number of years. You don't get any more Private sector than that since it is entirely funded by members donations none of which are tax receiptable.


Gotta love Capitalism.
 
Dion looks like too much of a nerd not to care about the environment, and Harper just looks like a shrewd chubby guy trying to figure out which is the best way to play his cards... its pretty obvious Harper doesn't give a shit about Kyoto, but its just as obvious he will pretend he does if he feels thats what he's got to do to get elected.
 
someone said:
Given that Dion never ran a business either, I’m sure that Red does not mean his post as a criticism of Harper, as he would also have to make the same criticism of Dion (OK, Dion came from a less demanding academic discipline but otherwise he would suffer from the same criticism if Red had meant it as a criticism).

Edit: BTW, according to Wikipedia, Harper did work as a computer programer in the oil and gas sector before going back to school (university), although I'm not sure what any of this has to do with his being a PM. Dion seems to have never been in the private sector.

Just for ineterest, what exactly did Dion study?
 
red said:
no it wouldn't. but there is no danger of this happening as he has never run a business. he has worked either in politics or as a policy wonk is wholelife, I believe.
He wa sin the middle of a Ph.D. in economics when Preston Manning, the founder of the Reform Party asked him for help. Interestingly, Harper was once a card carrying Liberal, while at U of T, if memory serves me correctly.
 
red said:
you are interesting right winger. not many want to pay taxes.
What does that make you? I pay my taxes, but it makes me sick to see our money wasted, unless of course you don't care where or how it's spent, so then that would exclude you from commenting here when most Canadians see waste and mismanagement coming from Lieberals. Unfortunately, Jack would hand out to anyone who is a special interest group without asking for justification or for good stewardship. Fortunately, Jack isn't running the country.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
So you find no problem with the Prime Minister of Canada using tax loopholes? Nothing about this causes you to reflect, even for a second, on what kind of message this sends?

I often wish corporations would worry less about their bottom line and more about Canada. But I know very little about the shipping business or how much of that decision was Martin's alone. I do know that you can't run a business on sentiment and that shareholder's have certain expectations etc. If most other shipping cos are saving taxes this way, it may have been irresponsible or even reckless to stay the course and not follow suit. I simply don't know so I refuse to pretend that I do. Unlike some....

Furthermore, I'll be seeing my accountant in the next month or so. I'll deduct everything I possibly can. If my accountant suggested I could legally save even more by somehow registering my assets offshore, I'd probably say "let's do it". The point is companies and individuals all try to save taxes. It is normal behaviour.
 
slowpoke said:
I often wish corporations would worry less about their bottom line and more about Canada. But I know very little about the shipping business or how much of that decision was Martin's alone. I do know that you can't run a business on sentiment and that shareholder's have certain expectations etc. If most other shipping cos are saving taxes this way, it may have been irresponsible or even reckless to stay the course and not follow suit. I simply don't know so I refuse to pretend that I do. Unlike some....

If this were true, there would be no ships in the industry registered in Canada. I doubt very much this is the case, but like you, I don't pretend to know the shipping industry either. I guess it's possible that other shipping companies have a greater sense of civic duty than Paul Martin's.

I have no problem with companies trying to save money and getting the best tax breaks possible. However, when a company owned by the Prime Minister disavows his country in order to save taxes, I have a problem with that.

As a Canadian tax payer, I find this insulting. I can assure you I would never register my company's assets in another country to reduce taxes. I expect no less from our Prime Minister.

slowpoke said:
Furthermore, I'll be seeing my accountant in the next month or so. I'll deduct everything I possibly can. If my accountant suggested I could legally save even more by somehow registering my assets offshore, I'd probably say "let's do it". The point is companies and individuals all try to save taxes. It is normal behaviour.

Again, if disavowing your country to reduce taxes is considered normal behavior, I'm glad I'm not normal.
 
shakenbake said:
Just for ineterest, what exactly did Dion study?
Apparently his undergraduate degree was in political science and then he went on to sociology. In my opinion, both are pretty Mickey Mouse (especially in Canada where I think I have only ever meet one political scientist that could even take a derivative and the sociology types I have meet have just been out to lunch).
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
If this were true, there would be no ships in the industry registered in Canada. I doubt very much this is the case, but like you, I don't pretend to know the shipping industry either. I guess it's possible that other shipping companies have a greater sense of civic duty than Paul Martin's.

I have no problem with companies trying to save money and getting the best tax breaks possible. However, when a company owned by the Prime Minister disavows his country in order to save taxes, I have a problem with that.

As a Canadian tax payer, I find this insulting. I can assure you I would never register my company's assets in another country to reduce taxes. I expect no less from our Prime Minister.

Again, if disavowing your country to reduce taxes is considered normal behavior, I'm glad I'm not normal.

If Martin's corporate behaviour at his "other" job was of even the slightest importance, I'd probably go and google up all kinds of relevant info about flags of convenience in the shipping industry, how common or uncommon it is, what the other options are, are there any large steamship lines that have not done so etc. But, apart from your irrational desire to take pot shots at the departed leader of the Liberals, who cares? Martin is now just another ex PM. Everything he did as owner of CSL was perfectly legal. If you're trying to establish the unlikely theory that only Liberals are unpatriotic enough to use legal means to reduce their taxes, you've got your work cut out for you. Good luck!!!
 
slowpoke said:
If you're trying to establish the unlikely theory that only Liberals are unpatriotic enough to use legal means to reduce their taxes, you've got your work cut out for you. Good luck!!!

Why do all you Liberal weenies argue by putting words in people's mouths?

Show me where I said or implied that "only Liberals are unpatriotic enough to use legal means to reduce their taxes"

Good Luck!!!
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Why do all you Liberal weenies argue by putting words in people's mouths?

Show me where I said or implied that "only Liberals are unpatriotic enough to use legal means to reduce their taxes"

Good Luck!!!

You didn't actually say it, nor did I accuse you of saying that or implying it. I said: "If you're trying to establish the unlikely theory that only Liberals are unpatriotic enough to use legal means to reduce their taxes, you've got your work cut out for you". Since we both know that you're not really trying to sell us such an idiotic load of utter hogwash, you've got nothing to worry about. Right?

BTW, just out of curiosity, why ARE you making an issue about how Martin ran his business. Just asking.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
....Again, if disavowing your country to reduce taxes is considered normal behavior, I'm glad I'm not normal.

Show me where I said or implied anything about disavowing my country or that I consider that normal. I said: "If my accountant suggested I could legally save even more [taxes] by somehow registering my assets offshore, I'd probably say "let's do it".

Since I qualified my statement with "legally", that would mean that the laws of my beloved Canada allow all citizens to avail themselves of this particular tax benefit (loophole to you). Who am I to argue with the wise and honourable bright lights at Revenue Canada? And since when does legally registering one's ASSETS offshore become disavowing one's country. Did I say I would abandon Canada? Well....DID I?
 
slowpoke said:
BTW, just out of curiosity, why ARE you making an issue about how Martin ran his business. Just asking.
He didn't. I started the attack on Mr Dithers recently, and Red got involved. So flame me if you want.

It's nice to see that are others passionate enough to take up the ball and run with it.