Consent or No Consent?


Yeah but a judge who tells a rape victim they should keep their knees together has crossed a line that they should have known better.

I don't think anyone is surprised that a comment like that would get you in trouble.

After reading some more comments I think there must have been a communication break down as it seems people are more in agreement than in disagreement.
 
Just s hypothetical situation: what if the driver asked this women "Do you want to fuck", she said "yes" and passed out right after? Is it a consent? Or anottehr one:
 
Or another possibility: what if this women, who, at the time of getting into the taxi, were clearly able to walk and talk, went in, see the taxi driver and say "Hi sexy, I want to fuck you" and then, given the higher temperature inside the cab, passed out. Is it a consent? If yes, the driver simply followed her desire to have sex, drove to a place where they can do it, and proceeds. Why did she ever wanted to fuck a stranger? Who knows, maybe because she was drunk and simply wanted to have sex?

In any case, these are possible scenarios, and, IMHO, they are likely probable, so, unless there is an evidence that this is not what has happened, there is no proof beyond the reasonable doubt that it was a rape.
 
Just s hypothetical situation: what if the driver asked this women "Do you want to fuck", she said "yes" and passed out right after? Is it a consent?
Seemingly the Judge in Nova Scotia forgot that according to the Supreme Court of Canada a person must provide “actual active consent.”

I should add that is the standard where I am as well. At the point when she says no or is so intoxicated that the "average person" would believe that she is intoxicated - there is no longer consent.
 
Just s hypothetical situation: what if the driver asked this women "Do you want to fuck", she said "yes" and passed out right after? Is it a consent? Or anottehr one:

No it's not, in my opinion, because

1. Even before she passed out she's too intoxicated to consent, and

2. An unconscious person cannot consent

I'm amazed the judge didn't agree with 1. As for 2 he gave the benefit of the doubt that she may have passed out only after the sexual activity.
 
"according to the Supreme Court of Canada a person must provide “actual active consent.”

So, if my GF wakes me up with a nice BJ, she is actually raping me? Surely I am not able to give her consent while I am sleeping. How about if I woke up in the same bed with her and I "inappropriately" touched her while she was still sleeping? What is the definition of "active consent". It was my understanding that after it is given it stays active until it is withdrawn.

And in the specific case of these drunk lady she may, as well, provide a continuous confirmation of her consent but does not remember it. And the driver is not the doctor to distinguish the drunk blubbering or whatever other sounds she was making from the moaning of pleasure. and when she passed out, maybe she was just wanted to relax after a nice orgasm. And maybe she is a squirted, this can explain wet pants. So, basically, there is not enough information to prove that the consent was not given and that at any point the driver knew for sure that this woman withdraws her consent. I believe, the judge's ruling was right based on the evidences provided.
 
"according to the Supreme Court of Canada a person must provide “actual active consent.”

So, if my GF wakes me up with a nice BJ, she is actually raping me. . .So, basically, there is not enough information to prove that the consent was not given and that at any point the driver knew for sure that this woman withdraws her consent. I believe, the judge's ruling was right based on the evidences provided. . .
A few points:

If you want to take the risk of 'hey I don't really need consent do I' go right ahead. Needless to say it is common sense that there is a huge difference between a drunk in a taxi, a one night stand, and a couple in a loving caring long term relationship where suddenly one of them "whigs out and calls police" and judges and juries do take that into account.

Further as Oagre posted way back in #47 "The judge is clearly toast and his career is over." That is also the feeling of friends in the Nova Scotia Bar.
 
There is a huge difference between "common sense" and "the rule of law" as well as "feeling of friends in the Nova Scotia Bar" and what is the right thing to do based on the facts and not an opinion
 
"according to the Supreme Court of Canada a person must provide “actual active consent.”

So, if my GF wakes me up with a nice BJ, she is actually raping me? Surely I am not able to give her consent while I am sleeping. How about if I woke up in the same bed with her and I "inappropriately" touched her while she was still sleeping? What is the definition of "active consent". It was my understanding that after it is given it stays active until it is withdrawn.

And in the specific case of these drunk lady she may, as well, provide a continuous confirmation of her consent but does not remember it. And the driver is not the doctor to distinguish the drunk blubbering or whatever other sounds she was making from the moaning of pleasure. and when she passed out, maybe she was just wanted to relax after a nice orgasm. And maybe she is a squirted, this can explain wet pants. So, basically, there is not enough information to prove that the consent was not given and that at any point the driver knew for sure that this woman withdraws her consent. I believe, the judge's ruling was right based on the evidences provided.

She was so drunk she pissed herself and passed out. Seriously, you don't need to be a doctor to know somebody that drunk is too far gone to consent. Also she pissed herself BEFORE the sex since her underwear and jeans were soaked in urine which means her clothes were still on when she pissed herself.

You are just making excuses for rape.
 
No, you do need a doctor to say so. You may make a guess, but you do not have a diploma to make your "guess" to be an official statement. There is a difference between what "it is so clear what had happened" and "there is a proof that it is what had happened". I agree, that, most probably, it was a rape, but the legal evidence base is not there. But if we low the bar for the required proof, than my BJ example become a rape, which is even worse.
 
No, you do need a doctor to say so. You may make a guess, but you do not have a diploma to make your "guess" to be an official statement. There is a difference between what "it is so clear what had happened" and "there is a proof that it is what had happened". I agree, that, most probably, it was a rape, but the legal evidence base is not there. But if we low the bar for the required proof, than my BJ example become a rape, which is even worse.

A woman who pisses herself and passes out is clearly too drunk too consent.
 
I think drivers should be held to the same standard as lawyer-client, teacher-student, doctor-patient, boss-subordinate, etc.
 
You are always responsible for your decisions. You are sloppily trying to overload the word responsible to cover two very different concepts: capacity to know right from wrong (criminal liability) versus capacity to consent.

If she is too intoxicated to make a rational decision about having sex, then why should she be able to make a rational decision about driving?

You are getting a little bit too hung up ion the LEGALITY of what occurs AFTER she makes (or doesn't make) this decision. That is immaterial to the issue of the functioning of a person's brain.

The point is that this idea that you under conditions of extreme intoxication are not responsible for your decisions has to apply across the board. You can't cherry pick which circumstances you want it to apply under. So making the decision to drive at some point while drunk is beyond your control because you are too drunk to make a rational decision.

You must be implying that there is a part of your brain related to criminal liability that REMAINS rational even as the part of your brain related to informed consent becomes IRRATIONAL.

I would love to see evidence for that.
 
With what the Crown charged him with. If you are intoxicated you have an inability to consent.



this is not true - intoxicated people have the ability to consent and are not complete blithering morons. We've all been pretty darn drunk and clearly been able to call a cab, buy cigarettes, goto the ATM, hell even talk to random strangers about all kinds of shit. and we've all been drunk where we left the bar and felt a little buzz, but by the time we got home we were done - like to hell with the bed done, i'm sleeping on the porch. So the drunk to incapacitated time line is not a clear or precise one.

There's a huge divide between drunk and incapacitated and even unconscious.

But the cabbie is a real loser for having sex with a passenger that was in a questionable state - regardless if she wanted it.
 
^ Great the SCC and I believe every state Supreme Court as well as Provincial Courts of Appeal have gotten it all wrong, now you tell us.
 
It depends on how drunk. The limit to me is can she commit an act of drunk driving. If she could have gotten into a car, started and driven drunk then she can consent, because she can be held to account for drunk driving. If she is incapable of drunk driving even, too drunk to have the ability to commit the act, then there is no way to she or he can consent. If I was a cabbie I'd have a dash cam.
 
It depends on how drunk. The limit to me is can she commit an act of drunk driving. If she could have gotten into a car, started and driven drunk then she can consent, because she can be held to account for drunk driving. If she is incapable of drunk driving even, too drunk to have the ability to commit the act, then there is no way to she or he can consent. If I was a cabbie I'd have a dash cam.
Needless to say it does. Merely having had a drink does not make you intoxicated. Your unofficial standard of if you shouldn't be driving or feel you shouldn't be driving, then you can't validly sign contracts or give consent is a good and prudent one.
 
this is not true - intoxicated people have the ability to consent and are not complete blithering morons. We've all been pretty darn drunk and clearly been able to call a cab, buy cigarettes, goto the ATM, hell even talk to random strangers about all kinds of shit. and we've all been drunk where we left the bar and felt a little buzz, but by the time we got home we were done - like to hell with the bed done, i'm sleeping on the porch. So the drunk to incapacitated time line is not a clear or precise one.

There's a huge divide between drunk and incapacitated and even unconscious.

But the cabbie is a real loser for having sex with a passenger that was in a questionable state - regardless if she wanted it.

Agreed.