Consent or No Consent?

Yeah, even in the ridiculously unlikely scenario that this girl, who was proven wasted by her blood alcohol test and was so drunk she was refused club entry, got in a cab and would have had to immediately asked a random cab driver to fuck her, the fact that she was passed out and had pants soaked in her own urine only 10 minutes later makes me feel like that consent is no longer valid.
 
Here's the controversy, the crux of the article and why this judge should censured , fined and removed from the bench;

"A Nova Scotia judge is facing a firestorm of criticism after declaring “clearly, a drunk can consent” as he acquitted a Halifax taxi driver of sexually assaulting a female passenger who was so intoxicated that she urinated on herself and passed out in the back of his cab.

Justice Gregory Lenehan told the court that while it was obvious the woman was drunk at the time of the incident, and that the accused was “not somebody I would want my daughter driving with,” the Crown had failed to provide any evidence that the complainant did not agree to sexual activity.

The woman, who prior to getting in the cab had been denied entry to a downtown bar because of her level of intoxication, could not remember any details of the incident. Her blood alcohol level was found to be three times the legal limit for driving, or as high as 244 milligrams per 100 millilitres of blood.

“A lack of memory does not equate to a lack of consent … Clearly, a drunk can consent,” Justice Lenehan told the Halifax provincial courtroom in declaring 40-year-old Bassam Al-Rawi not guilty.
"
 
Two things.

On the issue of consent. Saying a severely drunk person can consent is like saying a minor can consent. Both lack the mental capacity. In my mind, it's okay if two people in similar conditions get into it (two drunk people or two minors), but having someone of higher mental function take advantage of someone with lower mental function is just wrong. Very difficult to prove in most circumstances (though in this particular case I don't think it's that difficult given the facts). It also calls into question how drunk is too drunk to consent and legally why would the onus be on the sober person to determine that line?

On the issue of trust. A cab driver is absolutely in a position of trust and therefore should be held to high standards. Same goes for that officer in St. John's who gave a drunk woman a ride home, then had "consensual" sex with her. Moral of the story: don't bang strangers while you're on duty!
 
The inability of intoxicated persons to give consent was I thought as much a matter of Black Letter Law in Canada as the inability of Minors to give consent.
Indeed the Supreme Court of Canada has held that a person must provide “actual active consent.”

I suspect that this Judge will be facing discipline.
 
Wow. so if she cant remember what happened then the guy can invent whatever story he likes.

Sorry but i doubt the woman would fuck a cabbie she just met.

Lets say she was drunk and horny she could have pucked up a guy are made a booty call.

Sure there are probably some women who would do it but rare.

I would say if a girl was fall down drunk i would make sure she got home safe and left it alone.
 
while no one deserves to be sexually assaulted use some common sense lady! Don't get so frickin' hammered you pee your own pants.
Hardly any more relevant than what she might have been wearing, or how inviting she looked: either is an excuse to victim-blame and shift responsibility from the accused.
 
“A lack of memory does not equate to a lack of consent … Clearly, a drunk can consent,” Justice Lenehan told the Halifax provincial courtroom in declaring 40-year-old Bassam Al-Rawi not guilty.

Maybe we could deport him? I'm sure Sweden would gladly accommodate his cultural values.
 
The woman was very drunk, enough that she peed in her underwear and pants. That tells me that she was out of control and the guy took advantage of her. (I think) The problem is the judge has no proof that she didn't want to have sex and she remembers nothing. What are you going to charge the guy? For not being ethical? Was she too drunk to even consent and he took advantage?
With what the Crown charged him with. If you are intoxicated you have an inability to consent.
 
Who, exactly?? The defendant was already found not guilty; there is nothing to appeal.
Unlike many other Common Law jurisdictions including the United States in Canada the Crown can appeal. However, appeals by the Crown are quite rare, and generally confined to errors in law.
 
This is extremely disturbing. IMHO I don't think a drunk can give consent, especially one that cant remember any details of what happened that night. In the article it says the cab driver went to the citys south end and parked the car. That is where the sexual activities took place. What the driver should have done is made sure she had got home safely instead of thinking with his little head. The fact that the judge does not see anything wrong with this is extremely disturbing.
Although this case appears to be rape and totally inappropriate , you can't just make a blanket statement that " a drunk can't give consent". If I am drunk and decide to drive, am I responsible for that bad decision? Yes, I am. If a couple are drinking in a bar and both are moderately drunk and decide to have sex, can the woman wake up the next day, feel guilty and turn around and charge the guy with rape even though she may have said, "Fuck me now" ?

Each case needs to be considered on it's own merit and the blanket statement is not applicable, IMHO
 
The Crown has just appealed the case...
Good thing. More clarity would be very desirable. The ruling as reported change nothing in the law but certainly produced a maximum of confusion in those who want to be law-abiding.
 
I'm sorry a woman who is so drunk that she can not even make it to the bathroom and possibly has no idea of whats happening can not give consent IMO.I as a woman and I'm sure many other women on here will agree that when I/ we get into a cab and I/ we are drunk my intentions are NOT to have sex with the driver. The article says that instead of taking her home he took her to opposite side of town where he parked up. He seen that she was drunk, the first thing he should have done was taken her home.



Although this case appears to be rape and totally inappropriate , you can't just make a blanket statement that " a drunk can't give consent". If I am drunk and decide to drive, am I responsible for that bad decision? Yes, I am. If a couple are drinking in a bar and both are moderately drunk and decide to have sex, can the woman wake up the next day, feel guilty and turn around and charge the guy with rape even though she may have said, "Fuck me now" ?

Each case needs to be considered on it's own merit and the blanket statement is not applicable, IMHO
 
With what the Crown charged him with. If you are intoxicated you have an inability to consent.

Presumably the issue is the extent of intoxication. Lots of people happily have sex while drunk, stoned, or otherwise high. "Rape" drugs like GHB or MDMA/extasy are often taken by both partners to make sex more fun.
It's not as black and white as with minors. In fact even with the minors the line may quickly become fuzzy if the minor presented herself as an adult.