Conrad Black gets pardoned

gary-clement-1.png
 
The non-compete agreements were a structured tax dodge that was reflected in the valuation of what was (ultimately) paid for the companies. The use of "Restrictive Covenants" was a common tactic when selling companies as the payment was not considered taxable income. That loophole was closed some years ago. Around 2013 but there are retroactive provisions going back many years. :-(

https://mcmillan.ca/will-work-for-free-employers-beware-of-offers-of-free-work-by-unpaid-interns


The first draft of section 56.4 of the Act was released by the Department of Finance in February of 2004. The new provision was largely introduced in response to two decisions of the Federal Court of Appeal, which had held that certain amounts paid to shareholders in connection with the sale of their companies' shares, as consideration for non-competition agreements, were not subject to income tax (which inevitably led to an increase in share sale transactions containing a non-compete component).

However, the scope of the version of section 56.4 of the Act that was finally enacted by Parliament continues to extend well beyond non-competition payments made to a vendor of corporate shares.

Furthermore, new section 56.4 generally applies retroactively to amounts received or receivable after October 7, 2003, subject to certain limited exceptions.
The new rules encapsulated in section 56.4 are lengthy and complex. Below is a summary of certain key features of new section 56.4:

  • by default, most payments received by a taxpayer in consideration for the taxpayer making a "restrictive covenant" must now be fully included in the income of the taxpayer for the purposes of the Act, subject to certain limited exceptions;

  • a "restrictive covenant" is broadly defined to include more than just conventional non-compete agreements; non-solicitation and non-disclosure covenants are also captured by the applicable definition of a "restrictive covenant";

The tax free non-compete fees (The Fortino Brothers rule) was legit. However, Conrad Black sold the newspapers to himself and collected a non-compete fee.
 
Trump was getting massive pushback with his China tariff war, think we got lucky on this one.
Still, credit to Trudeau for getting it done.

Trump would have had no chance of having his new NAFTA deal approved in the House without an agreeable deal with Canada. Have to give Trudeau and Freeland credit for not caving in too early, in spite of that Baby Scheer wanting the deal to be accepted very early on in the negotiations. The resilience of the Trudeau Government paid off, but that jealous Scheer who is all over the place now says that he is "disappointed" that the deal did not get done early on. I think that someone has to give him his feeding bottle and put him to bed in the early hours of the evening, as he is coming up with more and more BS by the minute!!
 
Regardless of the optics, I applaud this decision.

Once the case had worked its way up and down the court system, the only charges that remained was the charge of "mail fraud" (nothing more than a technicality about paperwork) and a dubious charge of "obstruction of justice."

There was no real crime. While some Hollinger board members may have wished in hindsight that they had read the paperwork more closely, no crime was committed.
 
I was never comfortable with the shotgun prosecution of Black, those can never result in a fair trial IMHO. How can you really try someone for dozens of charges. It should be law that there is a max 3 charges per trial and a judge must sort though the charges carefully to ensure there is no mistrial. These types of prosecutions are IMHO an abuse of state power.