Colts Lose!

Seattle seahawks all the way


Whoot!


And this is the first time I see a Superbowl in a cold city like Detroit!
every other place was warm which is much better
 
I remember the last time Detriot held the Super Bowl the league said they would never have a Super Bowl in a cold weather city again. There where ppl getting to the game late because of the weather and all that. It was horrible.
I personaly dont think it should matter if it is a cold weather city, If they have the ablity to host they should be giving the chance. I would love to see Buffalo host a Super Bowl.
 
iluvbtca said:
BTW ... I wish I had a DVR but I still don't see how Manning avoided getting saftied in the 3rd quarter. It looked like his knee hit the goal line when he was taken down. Did anyone look at that again?
The momentum of the sackers took him down in the endzone but he was outside when they first grasped him. They replayed it on TV and the announcers agreed with the call.
 
MojoRisin' said:
Also WTF was with Peyton telling Dungy that they were going for it on 4th down. I mean it worked out and lead to a TD but the QB over ruling the head coach and the coach letting that happen? Holy shit i was surprised. Even if it might be the wrong call Dungy looked like a pussy in letting Manning take over and make the call on that one. You could see Dungy throwing up his hands and saying whatever...I thought that was a big deal. Dungy lost alot of respect on that play in my books (just a side note)

My thoughts also. I was stunned by that. A part of me respects Payton for having the balls to do that, knowing they need a score but I hope Tony gave him a good tongue lashing after the game (even though they converted).

On the other hand, I bet this happens often in sports. We noticed this one because it was so obvious (Peyton waving the punt team off). But I'll bet Michael Jordan has ignored Phil's play calls and did his own thing more than once. And remember Pippen refusing to go into a game? I can bet Iverson or Kobe have not always followed the coach's plans. And how many pitchers have argued with their managers to leave them in when they are tiring? Rumor has it that Jack Morris threatened Tom Kelly that he better not take him out in that famous 10-inning shutout game 7 win he had vs Atlanta.

It was still shocking to see.
 
According to ESPN, on Polamalu interception,

Morelli said: "I had the defender catching the ball. Before he got up, he hit it with his leg with his other leg still on the ground. Therefore, he did not complete the catch. And then he lost the ball. It came out, and so we made the play an incomplete pass."

Since when do we have to get up for a catch to be considered a catch? That was bullshit and that's what made the game closer than what it would have been. Sure, it made the game exciting but it almost decided the game.

Don't forget, the original ruling on the field was an interception. They need undisputable evidence to overrule the ruling on the field.
 
Don said:
My thoughts also. I was stunned by that. A part of me respects Payton for having the balls to do that, knowing they need a score but I hope Tony gave him a good tongue lashing after the game (even though they converted).

On the other hand, I bet this happens often in sports. We noticed this one because it was so obvious (Peyton waving the punt team off). But I'll bet Michael Jordan has ignored Phil's play calls and did his own thing more than once. And remember Pippen refusing to go into a game? I can bet Iverson or Kobe have not always followed the coach's plans. And how many pitchers have argued with their managers to leave them in when they are tiring? Rumor has it that Jack Morris threatened Tom Kelly that he better not take him out in that famous 10-inning shutout game 7 win he had vs Atlanta.

It was still shocking to see.

yeah i agree but the big difference with basketball is that its sort of a reactive game somewhat based on what the defense gives you but in the Manning/Dungy case it was just Peyton taking control during a stopage in play and overuling his head coach. Its more like Kobe ripping the whiteboard out of Phil Jacksons hand and writing up a play..lol can you imagine? Peyton was right i believe in that he wanted to go for it but Dungy looked bad in not doing anything, he needed to take control and do what he believed in. He's the coach
 
I'm no fan of Vanderjact either, but for the Colts to score so few points is inexcusable and Payton, Edge and the 4 receivers are all too blame along with him. And give credit where credit is due, the Steelers came in and kicked ass.
 
I think in thisa case it's more correct to say that the Steelers didn't allow the Colts to do what the Colts wanted to do. Not that the Colts blew it (apart from the missed FG)
 
shack said:
The momentum of the sackers took him down in the endzone but he was outside when they first grasped him. They replayed it on TV and the announcers agreed with the call.

I thought Dierdorf didn't make any sense with his agreement with the officials since I didn't notice any knee being down before Peyton hit the goal line. The only thing that would make sense is if the ref's blew the play dead early to protect the QB which would have been BS and too early.

Cheaters never win.

As a note, a couple of things have changed since the last Super Bowl in Detroit since 1982. First off, the NFL has turned into the ultimate psycho hosebag beast and its control freak intensity will not allow things to go wrong now a days. Also, becoming a big business, I'm sure the VIPs and essential to the NFL people will have no problems getting to the game. Judging by the piss poor way the lottery was held for Joe Schmo season ticket holders like myself, the NFL still doesn't give a crap about the average public.

However, the biggest reason why things will be different is where the stadium is. Ford Field is downtown where as the Silverdome is 45 min from the Detroit-Windsor border. Those who have hotels outside metro will probably be screwed in having to use shuttles. I expect the city and NFL to lockdown the downtown perimeter like a traffic DMZ and only allow certain amount of traffic on gameday.

Even Pontiac has grown into quite a bar area but Detroit is a downtown and should improve the outside the game atmosphere. They've been saying abandoned buildings, which are many, have been rented out for the week at 6-digit dollar values for parties.

It wouldn't suprise me if Detroit becomes a model for cold weather cities who have a shot at the Bowl. Roger Penske is the chairman for the Detroit SB committee so at least he knows about going fast, doing logistics and winning stuff. If he would only take the Lions president job ...
 
Hoagie on the Fan590 is talking about the Dungy/Manning punt thing now and its being reported that Dungy said that the punt team ran out on the field themselves without being told to go out by him. Manning was saying to the punt team to get back and not to Dungy. Ummm yeah sure. As if the punt team would do that. They'd be looking at Dungy for instructions. Dungys face said it all with his hands thrown up and even the announcer said that he mouthed to Manning "You take responsibility for this". Nice cover Dungy but sorry.
 
I thought that the officiating in all the games on the weekend that I watched was brutal. Even more puzzling was when there's a challenge and they still got the call wrong!
 
ottawasub said:
Appartently he made some comments in a post-game interview that the O-line didn`t give him much protection. Bradshaw really ripped into him on Fox for saying that in public.

I missed this. What did Peyton say? As the team leader, you can't be saying stuff like this and he should know better.

In any case, it doesn't take a genius to know that the Steelers were going to study film from the Colts/Chargers game, and that their game plan was going to be all about putting pressure on Manning. How the Colts couldn't have been prepared for this, I don't quite understand.
 
can we declare Manning this generations Dan Marino just yet? awesome stats and season but just cant but it together in the playoffs
 
scouser1 said:
can we declare Manning this generations Dan Marino just yet? awesome stats and season but just cant but it together in the playoffs

Marino at least played in one SB.
 
iluvbtca said:
I thought Dierdorf didn't make any sense with his agreement with the officials since I didn't notice any knee being down before Peyton hit the goal line. The only thing that would make sense is if the ref's blew the play dead early to protect the QB which would have been BS and too early.

It was exciting as all heck... and the officiating was HORRIBLE in this game.... but this call was actually correct (possibly the only one). In the case where a player is "driven backward" by a tackle, the "forward progess" rule places him at the spot where he was where he was first HIT (i.e. how close he got on his own momentum). Even though Manning was eventually "down" in the endzone, he was driven back into the endzone from about the one yard line (where he put himself)... he never went into the endzone on his own.

It was the right call.

Now that overturn of the Polamalu interception, however, is completely unjustifiable... and the explanation given by the ref was incomprehensible....
 
Armen Kitaen (sp?) at CBS interviewed a subdued Tony Dungy about 10min after the game on Sunday and asked him about Payton's decision to 'go for it' on fourth down. He said that was the play all along, as most of these plays are sent in through his earpiece in the helmet - and the punt team was just over-enthusiastic and ran on to the field.

I watched the game from beginning to end, and Tony Dungy never threw his hands up in that air - especially on that play. Actually Dungy is a very subdued coach himself, and rarely shows emotion on the field
 
CSTAD said:
Armen Kitaen (sp?) at CBS interviewed a subdued Tony Dungy about 10min after the game on Sunday and asked him about Payton's decision to 'go for it' on fourth down. He said that was the play all along, as most of these plays are sent in through his earpiece in the helmet - and the punt team was just over-enthusiastic and ran on to the field.

I watched the game from beginning to end, and Tony Dungy never threw his hands up in that air - especially on that play. Actually Dungy is a very subdued coach himself, and rarely shows emotion on the field

Thanks we've already pretty much covered that now but Dungy was seen and I saw him wave (maybe a better word) his hand in frustration as well as lip the phrase ("you take responsibility for this") as stated by the announcers on TV as well. Dungy was visably distraught by Manning doing this. As visibly distraught as he gets anyway. There was disention in the ranks there for sure
 
Mojo...

You aren't Dan Dierdorf, are you? (LOL!)

Most of what you said (in this entire thread actually) is exactly what the CBS announcers (ie.Dierdorf) said durning the game.

Usually he is wrong, which is probably why he was fired from MNF a few years back...
 
CSTAD said:
Mojo...

You aren't Dan Dierdorf, are you? (LOL!)

Most of what you said (in this entire thread actually) is exactly what the CBS announcers (ie.Dierdorf) said durning the game.

Usually he is wrong, which is probably why he was fired from MNF a few years back...

No its not but as i stated in my post i did watch some of the game and listen to the announcers, thats where we get info from isnt it? I have also been listening to the Fan today and got the information I posted prior that you felt the need for some reason to repost (and thank you)And i did see Dungy myself visibly frustrated. Didnt you? Are you Tony Dungy? everything you say is in support of this guy that looked foolish and didnt have his team prepared for the game the way he should have. BTW im tempted to believe an ex Pro and not you. cant blame me can you? LOL Good luck next year Tony
 
and it takes a Colts loss

and Dungy's screw up for your first post since signing up 6 months ago? lol Glad you could make it. anytime you feel the need to repost info and make goofy comments, you're more than welcome