Collective Punishment

…
The next question is what are your legal and/or moral obligations if you actually witness (not hearsay) a teammate or co-worker committing a crime? Let say in the post Bill C-36 period you witness one of your co-workers getting a BBBJ from a young lady and then slips her a $100 bill. Is this a payment for a "sexual service"? Do you do nothing or call the police?
In your example, the most one can say is that there might have been a crime that they witnessed; there is no evidence and no certainty in the story that the co-worker bought sex. The most the witness could take to the authorities is a suspicion that prostitution accounted for what they saw.

Everyone sees offences all the time, littering, improper driving, bits of shoplifting, minor frauds and misappropriations, and mostly they go unreported with society functioning adequately. But everyone also has some threshold where their morality and ethical code says, "I cannot stand silently by and allow this harm to go unchecked". In your example, as a TERBian, you'd likely think any 'harm' had more to do with the harm of being seen, and perhaps arrested than 'harming' society. But someone else might feel moved to protect the community and/or the shared workplace by reporting the 'crime' to some authority for action. We all have those internal dialogues from time to time, and always will. And your example might have read rather differently had you seen two strangers, or if one was in a uniform. Or taught your children.

A couple of aspects make the university sports team context somewhat different: There is no way for the players on a team trip to separate themselves and their actions from the university; they are its representatives, officially and unofficially. That is a status they accepted voluntarily, and my experience is that it is constantly reiterated and restated. The consequences of their actions both good and bad must be real, or there is no such relationship between team and school. It can't be all glory. So bad acts must be dealt with for the sake of the institution as well as morality, and for that to happen, they cannot be covered up or ignored.

The other aspect is the nature of a team: It functions as, and is trained to be a collective that is stronger and more effective than the sum of its parts. It isn's some arbitrary happenstance group unassociated with the activities of individual members. In fact the essence of the team is 'one for all', and it is commonplace for any individual failing to be sanctioned (even punished) as letting down the team. Sadly the flip-side 'all for one' seems to have operated to conceal wrongdoing, so what happened is all were sanctioned, because no one put team, and what the team represents ahead of matey-ness, as they should have. When we let a team collaborate in wrongful actions, we call it a criminal gang.

That road trip was an inning in the game of life, and no matter how individuals played, ultimately the team as a whole didn't play the game they needed to; they lost. But apparently needed the University to get that across to them.
 
The article also said that sexual problems were rampant. I don't think there could be those without any knowledge and therefore it is tacit complicity which is just as bad. Who reports it would have to be a witness but it sounds like the school was infected and the team needed to be shut down. Let's face it. For years to come there won't be anymore hazing as a result of this punishment where as if the 7 were kicked off of the team who is to say the incidents wouldn't keep occurring. It is tough love for those who weren't participating but it won't happen again. There will be too much peer pressure from thos who aren't actively involved.

It may even cause vigilante behavior from those not involved and straighten everyone out.
What does rampant mean?
Does it mean many perpetrators, does it mean a few repeatedly committing offenses? Do you know?
It wouldn't matter would it, everyone pays the same price.

You make the assumption that no one could not have known, and therefore = tacit complicity and therefore = just as bad.
Really? A guy knows about something, keeps his mouth shut, and that is just as bad as the original act.
According to that logic, the victims are just as guilty or even guiltier, since
they are the ones who actually subjected themselves to the abuse, and said nothing about it.

You just want easy answers and easy solutions to quell your own disgust and anger over the situation.
And it's easy dispensing convenient justice when they're kids.
I don't see the problem with just severely punishing the guilty ones, and escalating to some degree if things don't change for the positive.
If this kind of punishment were administered in the grown up world, everything would be shut down and the majority of the population would be in prison.

BTW, that's not tough love. Tough love is being tough with those who do something wrong, not indiscriminately punishing all those around.
 
From the first article posted.

Stuart Green, founder of the New Jersey Coalition for Bullying Awareness and Prevention, praised Superintendent Richard Labbe's decision as one that could change the conversation on the issue of bullying.

Though he sympathized with those who feel it unfair to punish an entire team, Green said responsibility for such conduct generally extends beyond the individual players.

"When these problems arise they're never primarily a function of the individual kids or players," he said. "These problems primarily arise because of the behaviors of the adults and leaders who manage these environments."


What a thing to say. What an assumption to make about a specific situation or group of people.
This statement basically says that none of the individuals would have done any of this or thought of doing it unless encouraged
at some level by the coaching staff .
I don't know for a fact whether the coaches were aware or were culpable of nurturing this kind of environment,
but to make a sweeping statement like that is salacious and undermines the credibility of an organization that strives for
positive values.
 
From the first article posted.

Stuart Green, founder of the New Jersey Coalition for Bullying Awareness and Prevention, praised Superintendent Richard Labbe's decision as one that could change the conversation on the issue of bullying.

Though he sympathized with those who feel it unfair to punish an entire team, Green said responsibility for such conduct generally extends beyond the individual players.

"When these problems arise they're never primarily a function of the individual kids or players," he said. "These problems primarily arise because of the behaviors of the adults and leaders who manage these environments."


What a thing to say. What an assumption to make about a specific situation or group of people.
This statement basically says that none of the individuals would have done any of this or thought of doing it unless encouraged
at some level by the coaching staff .
I don't know for a fact whether the coaches were aware or were culpable of nurturing this kind of environment,
but to make a sweeping statement like that is salacious and undermines the credibility of an organization that strives for
positive values.

I agree with your concerns. Using another example, let say a man and his wife have 3 children living at home. One of them is 19 years old and is caught viewing child porn in the basement of the house. The police haul the 19 year old off to jail. The Internet provider cuts off Internet access forever to the rest of the family because "they should have known better".