Kooky. Arguing against Nature is just punching yourself in the face. Your guy was rejected because his work wasn't sufficiently good quality and he's bitter.
All scientific experiments must be reproducible! When science experimental is not reproducible then it is garbage and must be retracted from the scientific journals!
Examples1: On March 23, 1989, Fleischmann (then one of the world's leading electrochemists) and Pons reported their work via a press release[2] from the University of Utah (who asserted ownership of the technology)[2] claiming that the table-top apparatus had produced anomalous heat (understood as "excess" heat) of a magnitude they asserted would defy explanation except in terms of nuclear processes, which later came to be referred to as "cold fusion".[3] In addition to the results from calorimetry, they further reported measuring small amounts of nuclear reaction byproducts, including neutrons and tritium.[4] The reported results received wide media attention,[1] and raised hopes of a cheap and abundant source of energy.[5]
Many scientists tried to replicate the experiment with the few details available. Hopes faded due to the large number of negative replications, the withdrawal of many reported positive replications, the discovery of flaws and sources of experimental error in the original experiment, and finally the discovery that Fleischmann and Pons had not actually detected nuclear reaction byproducts.[6] By late 1989, most scientists considered cold fusion claims dead.
So in example1 cold fusion experiments was proven not reproducible so base on core principle of science that experiments result must be reproducible since it wasn't reproducible it was scientists of cold fusion is dead!! Which is the correct result!!
Cold fusion experiments Fleischmann and Pons they claimed they created cold fusion. Later Hopes faded due to the large number of negative replications, the withdrawal of many reported positive replications, the discovery of flaws and sources of experimental error in the original experiment.
Examples 2: Mann hockey stick not reproducible ! Nature refused to retracted Mann Hockey stick from their journal!
Example 3: what I just posted on post # 421
So you can go punched yourself in your face!! Refusing to accept logic and then claim victory is typically Fuji crazy logic!!
