Christianity's Crisis

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
45,727
11,186
113
I'm surprised by how little is known about the Last Roman Civil War and how dire it was for Christianity.

It was a short and extremely violent episode in the middle of the 4th Century that left the Western Empire permanently in decline. After Constantine the Great legalized Christianity it wasn't all smooth sailing. With his passing the Empire was divided among his sons. Constantinus got Western Europe, Constans got Italy, what became Switzerland, Austria, Northern Yugoslavia and Africa, and Constantine II got the Eastern Empire. The peace didn't last long, the old Pagans revolted. In short order their champion Magnentius deposed both the brothers in the Western half, Paganism was restored to it's preeminence and religious cleansing began. The Pope fearing for his life fled to the island of Ponza.

Both the Western and Eastern Empires assembled huge armies and met at Mursa near present day Vukovar (ironic isn't it). It was utterly catastrophic, more Romans lost their lives in the battle than any other. Magnentius lost 2/3 of his army and was forced to withdraw, Constantine II lost half his army. The Eastern Roman Empire was under severe threat from the Persians, only a treaty with the Huns allowed them to survive. The Western Roman Empire was left permanently weakened, relying on German tribes to keep the Empire intact. Magnentius was deposed two years later in his power base of Gaul. It was the last stand of the Pagans and not long after Christianity became the official religion of Empire.

Christianity brought about the fall of the Western Roman Empire but it did survive. Had Magnentius won, Christianity would have ceased to exist and Western Europe today would, more than likely, be Muslim. In the East, it may have become a peripheral religion. If it survived at all, it's religious base would be Moscow today.
 
Don't claim to be an expert on the late Roman Empire, but I believe you over stress Magnentius support of paganism.

The revolt was more about the army's dislike of Constans, Magnentius himself wasn't that popular indeed the General Claudius Silvanus, and most of his men deserted Magnentius and joined Constantine II.
 
Never did.

My source was an old Italian encyclopedia that my parents managed to bring to Canada when we immigrated, it stressed the pagan element. I neglected to mention the Frankish General Silvanus. That source referred to the last Roman Civil War as Roman Armageddon. Lets face it, they didn't need much of an excuse to fight. According that source Rome remained almost totally pagan until the Byzantine Emperor Justinian reconquered, and destroyed, Italy from the Ostrogoths. The Catholic church became more assertive once it was abandoned following Justinian's death.

I don't know what happened to that old encyclopedia, it was a wonderful resource.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToOzA6kQvBE
 
Don't claim to be an expert on the late Roman Empire, but I believe you over stress Magnentius support of paganism. ...

And Constantine's support for Christianity.

Christianity was a growing movement which is why Constantine backed its rise and it would have survived regardless. In case you missed it, Christianity survived a couple hundred years of persecution so it would have survived another generation of it.
 
Constantine I was a ruthless politician and general, for most of his life he was not religious.

But he saw first hand Diocletian's persecution of Christians, he considered it a waste of talent. Then Diocletian passed him over as Emperor, he lifted the persecutions to solidify his power base. For most of his life Constantine was a devotee of Sol Invictus, the deity introduced by Emperor Aurelian, he was baptized months before his death. He ruled like Tony Soprano, legalizing Christianity fomented resentment from those devoted to paganism. By being baptized it was only a matter of time before Christianity became the official religion of the Roman Empire, it happened in 380. The pagans wanted to stop this at all cost.

Unlike Constantinople, Rome didn't become fully Christian until the end of the 6th century.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LLmjSMQMbQM
 
I guess if one was to be saddled with one of two religions,... we could have done a lot worst than Christianity.
 
Last edited:
There is a reason why I'm addicted to Roman history, in the earliest years of my life, I saw it every day. Here's a pic of Cicero's mountain villa (partially converted to a church), within walking distance from where I was born.

https://www.localidautore.com/images/dbimg/paesi/sora-5632.jpg

I'll eventually return to my birthplace. The old linen factory on the left has been converted to condos, I'll probably buy one.

https://www.world-of-waterfalls.com/images/xIsola_del_Liri_005L.jpg.pagespeed.ic.vSyZSAmGrP.jpg
 
The rise of Christianity was a catastrophe as it plunged Europe into the dark ages.
 
I'm surprised by how little is known about the Last Roman Civil War and how dire it was for Christianity.

It was a short and extremely violent episode in the middle of the 4th Century that left the Western Empire permanently in decline. After Constantine the Great legalized Christianity it wasn't all smooth sailing. With his passing the Empire was divided among his sons. Constantinus got Western Europe, Constans got Italy, what became Switzerland, Austria, Northern Yugoslavia and Africa, and Constantine II got the Eastern Empire. The peace didn't last long, the old Pagans revolted. In short order their champion Magnentius deposed both the brothers in the Western half, Paganism was restored to it's preeminence and religious cleansing began. The Pope fearing for his life fled to the island of Ponza.

Both the Western and Eastern Empires assembled huge armies and met at Mursa near present day Vukovar (ironic isn't it). It was utterly catastrophic, more Romans lost their lives in the battle than any other. Magnentius lost 2/3 of his army and was forced to withdraw, Constantine II lost half his army. The Eastern Roman Empire was under severe threat from the Persians, only a treaty with the Huns allowed them to survive. The Western Roman Empire was left permanently weakened, relying on German tribes to keep the Empire intact. Magnentius was deposed two years later in his power base of Gaul. It was the last stand of the Pagans and not long after Christianity became the official religion of Empire.

Christianity brought about the fall of the Western Roman Empire but it did survive. Had Magnentius won, Christianity would have ceased to exist and Western Europe today would, more than likely, be Muslim. In the East, it may have become a peripheral religion. If it survived at all, it's religious base would be Moscow today.

Not really. Rome rebounded quickly and routed the Alemanni at the Battle of Strasbourg in 357 AD - the last great victory. Succession struggles and civil wars were endemic in the Empire from 100 BC onwards until Rome fell. It took a combination of a major Visigoth invasion of Italy, yet another major Roman civil war and a major Frankish and Vandal invasion of Gaul to wreck Rome in the first decade of the 400's. Rome could cope with 1 or 2 military crises, but 3 mega-crises at once overstretched the military resources of Rome and snapped them. The Visigoths were bought off with first Boulogne and then Spain. With Spain, France and North Africa (to the Vandals) gone, the Western Empire could no longer raise and provision large enough armies to survive.

By Constantine, Christianity was the major religion in the Empire and adjoining barbarian powers - i.e the Visigoths - were also converting en masse. There was no realistic chance that Christianity would NOT have become the religion of Western Europe at that point. Constantine simply rode the most useful religious horse to bolster his own power.
 
^ Yet ironically in some ways Rome won (in terms of the Franks and Visigoths) since Latin remained the language of the Western Church and hence of statecraft and diplomacy and of course both French and Spanish are Romance Languages and indeed both Latin and French have influenced English.
 
^ Yet ironically in some ways Rome won (in terms of the Franks and Visigoths) since Latin remained the language of the Western Church and hence of statecraft and diplomacy and of course both French and Spanish are Romance Languages and indeed both Latin and French have influenced English.

The Franks and Visigoths wanted to be Romans so badly that they willingly learned Latin and "Romanized".

The clumsy Frankish attempt to speak Latin became a bastard language we call "French" - Latin grammar and bizarre German-ish pronunciation. The Goths were simply absorbed into the larger Spanish and Italian populations and their culture disappeared.