Chinese Head Tax

I guess the Federal gov't is smarter than we thought. But how do we know this new tax on head will be put to good use. They could have a sliding scale rate:
CBJ $10
BBBJ $20
BBBJCIM $30
BBBJCIMS $35
 
LancsLad said:
I guess the Federal gov't is smarter than we thought. But how do we know this new tax on head will be put to good use. They could have a sliding scale rate:
CBJ $10
BBBJ $20
BBBJCIM $30
BBBJCIMS $35
LMAO......now thats what I call an immigrant head tax!! :D
 
nathan_wong0 said:
I don't think Canadian gov't should apologizes for chinese head tax! This is ancient history ... the chineses should move on and stop harp over this situations! My great greatgrandfather paid the head tax . I'm second generation of Chinese Canadian and I 'm not even minutely upset over it! My great grandfather help built the railroad and suffered the racism but we grow to love this great country! The Japanese Canadian really suffered in World War II they desired the apologizes from the canadian gov't when their business was confiscated and sold for peanuts!
Wong, you're a cool guy dammit!!! :cool:

Wong, you are not wrong, you are Wong!!!
 
I think ultimately the Chinese head tax was the right decision. Sure it may have been discriminatory or maybe even racist, but the fact of life is that the Chinese have a very large population. If the head tax and immigration ban was not in place, what percentage of the Canadian population would be Chinese now? It's possible Canada's population could easily be 100 million now, 75% Chinese :) Can you blame the European nationality people who were in power at the time for protecting their own political and economic interests? At the time of immigration, those Chinese were foreigners, combined with "supply and demand" (more Chinese = more demand) then why not charge more?

Don't get me wrong, I like Chinese people and some of their culture, I have Chinese friends and girlfriends :) and have been to China, and they agree with me. I'm not anti-Chinese, I just feel the need to point some things out.
 
Respectfully, I disagree with ForkMaster. The head tax was wrong simply because it was applied only to Chinese people. It would be different if it was applied to all immigrants but it wasn't. Another aspect of the tax was that it was exorbitantly high given common wages of the time.

In any case, I too agree that it's ancient history. As a nation we've moved so far beyond that kind of behaviour. To me, it's something that should be taught in schools as a lesson of what not to do.

An official apology is a nice thing though so I suppose it does no harm in the end. It shouldn't be a big deal though - say "We're sorry", accept the apology graciously, then let's all move on to more important matters.
 
xarir said:
Respectfully, I disagree with ForkMaster. The head tax was wrong simply because it was applied only to Chinese people. It would be different if it was applied to all immigrants but it wasn't. Another aspect of the tax was that it was exorbitantly high given common wages of the time.

In any case, I too agree that it's ancient history. As a nation we've moved so far beyond that kind of behaviour. To me, it's something that should be taught in schools as a lesson of what not to do.

An official apology is a nice thing though so I suppose it does no harm in the end. It shouldn't be a big deal though - say "We're sorry", accept the apology graciously, then let's all move on to more important matters.

I agree. I understand there are few ppl alive today who was actually "affected" by the head tax, meaning they were around when the tax was in place. Those ppl, I think deserves little more than an apology, maybe a little compensation. But other than that, its just part of history. you cant blame ppl now for something that happens years ago before they were even born and have control over. I think its good they are issuing an official apology and acknowledging it, something Martin and Liberals never did. But after that, yes I agree things like this should be taught as lessons.

This is like last year i believe, when China wanted apology from Japan for something that happened years ago. There were lots of demos around Japanese related ppl, stores in China . And lots of Japanese ppl, stores etc, were being trashed, ppl being assaulted etc. Like they had anything to do with what happened before they were born.