Charlottesville Car Death

Status
Not open for further replies.
If those are not the factual accounts of what occurred, then nothing will seem to please those trying to understand this whole terrorist incident.
But the extreme right wing were also chanting that Dylann Roof was a hero?? This guy was a terrorist who killed 9 church goers purely because they were black. These disgusting racist groups should be condemned by all, as they support terrorism.

I take it that you either didn't read my OP or these news stories. Neither story contains the information I'm looking for.

Have a look at these stills in connection with the video on the CNN story link. There is a woman with a green shirt who is propelled onto the roof of the white vehicle. That person is not identified as Heyer, and appears to have survived her injuries. There doesn't appear to have been anyone else struck by the front of the vehicle.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/42333...woman-killed-car-heather-heyer-first-picture/

So the question remains, where was Heyer?
 
I did see a video of some left wingnut loser hitting the car with a base ball bat, which was surrounded by more losers, ,... BEFORE the incident.
 
I take it that you either didn't read my OP or these news stories. Neither story contains the information I'm looking for.

Have a look at these stills in connection with the video on the CNN story link. There is a woman with a green shirt who is propelled onto the roof of the white vehicle. That person is not identified as Heyer, and appears to have survived her injuries. There doesn't appear to have been anyone else struck by the front of the vehicle.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/42333...woman-killed-car-heather-heyer-first-picture/

So the question remains, where was Heyer?

How do you know that she was not run over by the car. It was speeding when it approached the crowd. It then eventually reversed and struck some other pedestrians. The fact is that this terrorist is being held for murder with intent. Is there a reason that you want to know the exact details now? It will all be revealed during the trial of this right wing scumbag who deserves to be locked up for life.
 
How do you know that she was not run over by the car. It was speeding when it approached the crowd. It then eventually reversed and struck some other pedestrians. The fact is that this terrorist is being held for murder with intent. Is there a reason that you want to know the exact details now? It will all be revealed during the trial of this right wing scumbag who deserves to be locked up for life.

Your reading comprehension is very low. I don't "know" that Heyer wasn't: a) struck by the car as it reversed, b) struck by one of the other cars involved in the collision, c) struck by another person or object affected by the crash, etc. I didn't say that I did. The only thing I know is that she is not the person who was struck by the front of the car and propelled onto the top of the white car. How Heyer was struck is the information I'm trying to find out.

As to why I'm interested in it now, I guess it's the same reason that news networks covered the incident and are following up on the story. It's a potentially important incident that relates to a number of political issues being debated at the moment.

As to the facts, the fact is that someone is being held on charges of 2nd degree murder. His trial won't be held or completed for quite some time. However, the debates that the incident relates to will not wait for that trial. People like you will engage in those debates as if certain facts are established. You're already doing that. By contrast, I'm interested in understanding what the facts are that can be discerned from publicly available information. You may feel that certain facts will likely be established. I tend to put more stock in what evidence actually is available. The place that anyone would start in examining this potential murder is to understand how the victim was killed. That's likely to have a significant relationship to what criminal intent can be attributed to the accused.
 
There is video of the event happening but what is unclear is whether the vehicle hit Heather Heyer or not. There is a smashed windshield but no blood can be detected. Also on the pictures of Heather on the stretcher she is stripped down to shirt and panties but there is no blood visible on her body. Given the carnage I'm actually shocked that nobody else perished in this attack.

With all these details you are stating, it seems you believe this was just some conspiracy. Sounds rational.
 
...
There are some facts that pique my interest to want to know more. I've seen video showing some people being knocked over by the side of the car as it collided with the cars blocking the intersection. I haven't seen a clear video showing anyone being struck BETWEEN the cars. I've seen video of protesters attacking the car. It's not clear to me whether they attacked both before and after the collision. I have seen video of protesters who jumped on the car and/or blocked it from behind struck or thrown from the car as it reversed from the collision. I haven't seen clear reporting on Heyer's precise injuries leading to her death or as to how exactly she was impacted by the collision. I haven't seen a video (despite the existence of at least 5 different videos of the collision, a fact that, to me, is curious in itself) where Heyer's position in relation to the collision is identified.
...

...
At this point, there are several odd aspects of the incident (perhaps further facts will clear them up), but I won't bore you with that, as you're not that interested.
....


Nice. So either you are into snuff films or you want evidence that the 'good person' white supremacist driving the car was just an innocent patsy, attacked by protesters as he innocently drove his car, and the liberal elite have created this story to lay blame on him and the demonize the racist movement he was with.
 
If those are not the factual accounts of what occurred, then nothing will seem to please those trying to understand this whole terrorist incident.
But the extreme right wing were also chanting that Dylann Roof was a hero?? This guy was a terrorist who killed 9 church goers purely because they were black. These disgusting racist groups should be condemned by all, as they support terrorism.

I think bud is "looking into the facts" about Roof's attacks too.
 
Just for those who might be wondering why I never respond to Fuji or Frankfooter, it's because I have them both on ignore. They both know that, yet despite that knowledge they persist in responding to my posts as if we are engaged in a dialogue, or might exchange with one another. I'm not sure whether the better name for that behavior is trolling or stalking. Either way, it is odd behavior, and gives you a glimpse into their personalities.

While there is no telling what nonsense they are posting, I can be sure of one thing, it is sure to be unresponsive to my call for links to the information I'm looking for.

Whether or not bud plug responds to my posts doesn't interest me, I'm more concerned about outing behaviour that seems to be defending what most people have called an act of terrorism, committed by a ne-nazi. The act of terrorism killed one person and injured 19 and there is video to back this up, multiple eye witnesses, an arrest and charges laid. Trying to claim that because he can't see the murder committed on publicly released video so therefore he doubts it happen is one step worse then the Sandy Hook deniers.
http://www.salon.com/2013/01/09/the_worst_sandy_hook_conspiracy_theory_yet/
 
Whether or not bud plug responds to my posts doesn't interest me, I'm more concerned about outing behaviour that seems to be defending what most people have called an act of terrorism, committed by a ne-nazi. The act of terrorism killed one person and injured 19 and there is video to back this up, multiple eye witnesses, an arrest and charges laid. Trying to claim that because he can't see the murder committed on publicly released video so therefore he doubts it happen is one step worse then the Sandy Hook deniers.
http://www.salon.com/2013/01/09/the_worst_sandy_hook_conspiracy_theory_yet/

It's been said "It’s hard to win an argument with a smart person, but it’s damn near impossible to win an argument with a stupid person."

Being a Nazi, or supporting similar political or social (etc.) views/aims as Nazis is an abundantly obvious line in the sand which separates the stupid, from everyone else. It's better to know nothing than to side in any regard whatsoever with these muppets.

This isn't complicated: If you support something these Nazis support, STRONGLY reconsider your position on it, or don't get riled when you're aptly identified as Nazi by association. There is no "but" to this.
 
It's been said "It’s hard to win an argument with a smart person, but it’s damn near impossible to win an argument with a stupid person."

Being a Nazi, or supporting similar political or social (etc.) views/aims as Nazis is an abundantly obvious line in the sand which separates the stupid, from everyone else. It's better to know nothing than to side in any regard whatsoever with these muppets.

This isn't complicated: If you support something these Nazis support, STRONGLY reconsider your position on it, or don't get riled when you're aptly identified as Nazi by association. There is no "but" to this.

Just what the fuck did bud post that indicated he supported Nazi's,...???

Talk about stupid,...!!!
 
Your reading comprehension is very low. I don't "know" that Heyer wasn't: a) struck by the car as it reversed, b) struck by one of the other cars involved in the collision, c) struck by another person or object affected by the crash, etc. I didn't say that I did. The only thing I know is that she is not the person who was struck by the front of the car and propelled onto the top of the white car. How Heyer was struck is the information I'm trying to find out.

As to why I'm interested in it now, I guess it's the same reason that news networks covered the incident and are following up on the story. It's a potentially important incident that relates to a number of political issues being debated at the moment.

As to the facts, the fact is that someone is being held on charges of 2nd degree murder. His trial won't be held or completed for quite some time. However, the debates that the incident relates to will not wait for that trial. People like you will engage in those debates as if certain facts are established. You're already doing that. By contrast, I'm interested in understanding what the facts are that can be discerned from publicly available information. You may feel that certain facts will likely be established. I tend to put more stock in what evidence actually is available. The place that anyone would start in examining this potential murder is to understand how the victim was killed. That's likely to have a significant relationship to what criminal intent can be attributed to the accused.

My reading comprehension skills are way beyond yours. I know that there are conspiracy theories by right wing websites. I did not read anywhere that she was the lady that was struck and propelled to the top of the car. So far very little information has been put out describing exactly how she was killed i.e. front of the car or back of the car etc. All we know is that the car was responsible for her death and was considered to be second degree murder with intent. Now the right wing websites claim that she died from a coronary condition such as a heart attack, and some person being stretchered off without any blood flowing out of her was considered to be Heather Heyer. That is only a presumption. Fact of the matter is, this was a terrorist incident that involved the killing of Heather Heyer. By now if the police wanted to release the exact details of her death, they would have done so. Again, not too sure what difference it will make if you know the exact details of her death. Can you bring her back to life? If it was readily available, the main stream media would have disclosed it.

By the way I am just mentioning what has been disclosed by the MSM. All other sides of the story by mainly right wing websites are pure speculation. So good luck if you think that you will get to the bottom of it, unless the police or her family decide to disclose this information.
 
My reading comprehension skills are way beyond yours. I know that there are conspiracy theories by right wing websites. I did not read anywhere that she was the lady that was struck and propelled to the top of the car. So far very little information has been put out describing exactly how she was killed i.e. front of the car or back of the car etc. All we know is that the car was responsible for her death and was considered to be second degree murder with intent. Now the right wing websites claim that she died from a coronary condition such as a heart attack, and some person being stretchered off without any blood flowing out of her was considered to be Heather Heyer. That is only a presumption. Fact of the matter is, this was a terrorist incident that involved the killing of Heather Heyer. By now if the police wanted to release the exact details of her death, they would have done so. Again, not too sure what difference it will make if you know the exact details of her death. Can you bring her back to life? If it was readily available, the main stream media would have disclosed it.

By the way I am just mentioning what has been disclosed by the MSM. All other sides of the story by mainly right wing websites are pure speculation. So good luck if you think that you will get to the bottom of it, unless the police or her family decide to disclose this information.

Not to mention how ridiculous it is to 'investigate' a car driving into a crowd that also injured 19 people, aside from the one death that Bud isn't sure happened.
Its not like the neo-nazi driver would get off 'cuz he only injured 19 people and didn't kill anyone, if he was driving that car he's going to jail.
 
My reading comprehension skills are way beyond yours. I know that there are conspiracy theories by right wing websites. I did not read anywhere that she was the lady that was struck and propelled to the top of the car. So far very little information has been put out describing exactly how she was killed i.e. front of the car or back of the car etc. All we know is that the car was responsible for her death and was considered to be second degree murder with intent. Now the right wing websites claim that she died from a coronary condition such as a heart attack, and some person being stretchered off without any blood flowing out of her was considered to be Heather Heyer. That is only a presumption. Fact of the matter is, this was a terrorist incident that involved the killing of Heather Heyer. By now if the police wanted to release the exact details of her death, they would have done so. Again, not too sure what difference it will make if you know the exact details of her death. Can you bring her back to life? If it was readily available, the main stream media would have disclosed it.

By the way I am just mentioning what has been disclosed by the MSM. All other sides of the story by mainly right wing websites are pure speculation. So good luck if you think that you will get to the bottom of it, unless the police or her family decide to disclose this information.

See, there's your reading comprehension problem in a nutshell. You responded to me as if my post was what you read on some website. Try responding to what people actually post.

What has become clear through this thread is that, apparently, no one has links to more specific information about this incident. Posters who care about the accuracy of what they post (and we all know which TERBites don't care) should bear this in mind. Usually terrorists help us brand them as such by the statements they make in the course of their acts or afterward. Curiously, no such statements have been reported in this case. That doesn't mean the evidence won't prove the incident to be such an act, but it appears that evidence is not public yet.
 
See, there's your reading comprehension problem in a nutshell. You responded to me as if my post was what you read on some website. Try responding to what people actually post.

What has become clear through this thread is that, apparently, no one has links to more specific information about this incident. Posters who care about the accuracy of what they post (and we all know which TERBites don't care) should bear this in mind. Usually terrorists help us brand them as such by the statements they make in the course of their acts or afterward. Curiously, no such statements have been reported in this case. That doesn't mean the evidence won't prove the incident to be such an act, but it appears that evidence is not public yet.

That's because the terrorist is in custody, Bud. He's not uploading to the sites you frequent. He's in jail
 
Wow,... the sources of that stench has grown.
 
See, there's your reading comprehension problem in a nutshell. You responded to me as if my post was what you read on some website. Try responding to what people actually post.

What has become clear through this thread is that, apparently, no one has links to more specific information about this incident. Posters who care about the accuracy of what they post (and we all know which TERBites don't care) should bear this in mind. Usually terrorists help us brand them as such by the statements they make in the course of their acts or afterward. Curiously, no such statements have been reported in this case. That doesn't mean the evidence won't prove the incident to be such an act, but it appears that evidence is not public yet.
The only facts that matter are that James Fields, a guy who marched with white supremacists, drove his car into a crowd of protesters and Heather Heyer dies as a result. The courts will rule on exactly what happened and what punishment (if any) he deserves.

The rest of it is quite obviously bullshit attempts to pretend that there is some liberal conspiracy that faked he death to discredit the alt-right and their neo-nazi buddies.
 
See, there's your reading comprehension problem in a nutshell. You responded to me as if my post was what you read on some website. Try responding to what people actually post.

What has become clear through this thread is that, apparently, no one has links to more specific information about this incident. Posters who care about the accuracy of what they post (and we all know which TERBites don't care) should bear this in mind. Usually terrorists help us brand them as such by the statements they make in the course of their acts or afterward. Curiously, no such statements have been reported in this case. That doesn't mean the evidence won't prove the incident to be such an act, but it appears that evidence is not public yet.

Again you are not comprehending what I am saying. The police have probably got multiple eye witness accounts, that corroborate the fact that this was an act of terrorism. This was not a staged event and as there were hundreds of demonstrators within striking distance of that car, do you think that there should have been multiple cameras filming Heather Heyer in particular at the time of her killing? There well could have been a couple of videos that could be used as evidence. The newsmedia are going by the fact that this terrorist has been held in custody for 2nd degree murder as well as severe bodily harm. What other facts do you need? Your statement that "curiously no statements have been reported in this case", is implying that this terrorist may have been wrongly charged, or the case maybe thrown out in court due to the lack of evidence or as the right wing media are implying, is that Heather passed away due to a coronary issue??? Is this the reason why you are questioning the arrest of this terrorist?
 
The only facts that matter are that James Fields, a guy who marched with white supremacists, drove his car into a crowd of protesters and Heather Heyer dies as a result. The courts will rule on exactly what happened and what punishment (if any) he deserves.

The rest of it is quite obviously bullshit attempts to pretend that there is some liberal conspiracy that faked he death to discredit the alt-right and their neo-nazi buddies.

Wrong. Not arguably wrong, indisputably wrong.

White supremacist at the wheel or not, a lot more facts matter. The list is too long to bother with, but the first of those facts is - how did Heyer die?

Leaving aside the legal analysis (which appears to be beyond you anyway), it's going to matter politically whether this is a story of:

1. A premeditated act of terror, designed and executed as an act of violence, or
2. An act of murder (motivated by hatred against a group in general, an individual, or motivated by something else), or
3. An act intended to threaten/intimidate that ended up in an unintended death through intervening circumstances, or
4. A death that resulted from a driver panicking in reaction to a perceived threat or hostile circumstance, or
5. An accident, or
6. The act of an individual with bona fide mental illness, or
7. Take your pick of a myriad of other narratives.

These different characterizations of the event will make a world of difference to the political debates which reference Charlottesville. So, sorry, the facts matter.

Your interpretation that an inquiry into the facts must have the purpose of trying to show that Heyer's death was faked is well north of ridiculous.
 
Wrong. Not arguably wrong, indisputably wrong.

White supremacist at the wheel or not, a lot more facts matter. The list is too long to bother with, but the first of those facts is - how did Heyer die?

Leaving aside the legal analysis (which appears to be beyond you anyway), it's going to matter politically whether this is a story of:

1. A premeditated act of terror, designed and executed as an act of violence, or
2. An act of murder (motivated by hatred against a group in general, an individual, or motivated by something else), or
3. An act intended to threaten/intimidate that ended up in an unintended death through intervening circumstances, or
4. A death that resulted from a driver panicking in reaction to a perceived threat or hostile circumstance, or
5. An accident, or
6. The act of an individual with bona fide mental illness, or
7. Take your pick of a myriad of other narratives.

These different characterizations of the event will make a world of difference to the political debates which reference Charlottesville. So, sorry, the facts matter.

Your interpretation that an inquiry into the facts must have the purpose of trying to show that Heyer's death was faked is well north of ridiculous.
This is the person who visited a concentration camp in Germany and had this to say about this camp:
"This is where all the magic happened". Kind of kills of statement #4.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fqdy6EFl1js
If that does not debunk the notion that he was not attacked, then watch him deliberately speeding towards a crowded area. He was accelerating towards the crowd, and there was no one intimidating him.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kq-QlgVqou8
 
...
These different characterizations of the event will make a world of difference to the political debates which reference Charlottesville. So, sorry, the facts matter.

....

Bullshit. There is no political debate. There are criminal charges and a court case (which you don't seem interested in waiting for) and then there are conspiracy theorists.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.